2025 All-Section Five List Released
The Section V Lacrosse leadership has selected first, second and honorable mention lists of All-Section players. The 2025 first team lists fifteen players and includes the six All-Americans previously announced. "The first six athletes on the first team are easy" said Section Five Assistant Coordinator, Paul Wilson. "after that, it becomes more difficult as we have so many excellent players. With the six first spots taken, there are only nine more places on the first team."
To be nominated each player was required to be selected to their first team all-league team (except Independent teams). The lists were selected from a pool of ninety-two players. The selections were reviewed by Chairmen of each of the two leagues, three at-large coaches, the Lacrosse Coordinator and Assistant Coordinator. "It is a difficult task", Wilson continued. "There are so many talented players, so many different opinions, and so many elements to consider." Players are reviewed for their performances, the strength of their opponents and how their stats relate to the quality of their opponents. "Certainly, the strength of a team's schedule is a factor when reviewing a player" said Section V Coordinator Mike Simon.
Although grade and league were not major factors in selection, the list shows the skills that are found throughout the section. Ten Monroe County teams were represented on the lists, with the rest representing Finger Lakes (6), and Independents (3). Showing that the "Best of the Best" can come from any age group, there were 26 seniors, 11 juniors, 6 sophomores, and 2 freshmen listed. Distribution among the positions shows 13 midfielders, 12 attackmen, 7 defensemen, 5 FO specialists, 2 LSM, 1 ssdm, and 5 goalies.
First Team
Keegan Ahern - Pittsford senior - Hofstra *
Ryan Bremer Canandaigua senior - RIT
Braden Fingar - Penn Yan junior - Towson
Teagan Fingar - Penn Yan senior - Mt St. Mary *
Grady Goodberlet - HFL - sophomore
Grayson Hathway - Penn Yan freshman
Max Heick - Geneva senior - St John Fisher
Quinn Kailbourne - HFL senior - RIT
Carson Lich - Pal-Mac junior
Mitchell Monte - Fairport senior Dartmouth *
Cooper Moore - Irondequoit Junior - USMA *
Will Rheude - Canandaigua senior - Loyola *
Eli Ricci - Victor freshman
A.J. Theodorakakos - Penfield junior - USMA *
Will Thompson - Penn Yan senior
* All-Americans
Second Team
John Blair - Bloomfield-Honeoye - senior
Mike Belles - Canandaigua - senior - Canisius
Turker Fisher - Penn Yan - junior
Domenic Giangreco - McQuaid Jesuit - junior - Georgetown
Sven Habitzreuther - Irondequoit - senior
Jackson Dennie - Pal-Mac - sophomore
Brodie Joyce - Penfield - junior - Providence
Drew O`Buck - Hilton - senior Hobart
Noah Olbrich - Aquinas - senior
Gavin Parks - Brighton - senior
Luke Ryan - Fairport - senior - USMA
Kyle Saeger - Victor - senior - Jacksonville
Brady Secker - Victor - senior - Binghamton
Mason Schembri - Penfield - junior
Sam Thore - Irondequoit - junior
Honorable Mention
Reid Diehl - Pal-Mac - sophomore
Griffin Hilimire - Mynderse - senior
Brady Goetz - Pittsford - senior - Tampa
Drew Ikewood - Pal-Mac - sophomore
Brody Kaye - Spencerport - sophomore
Oliver Kowal - Victor - junior
Alex Pesante - Geneva - sophomore
AJ Quagrello - McQuaid Jesuit - senior - Tampa
Jase Smith - Gananda - senior - Alfred
Michael Thomas - Bloomfield-Honeoye - senior
Ryan Torrelli - Fairport - senior - Brockport
Zach Tortora - Spencerport - junior - Canisius
Conner Tripp - Midlakes - senior
Avery Valenti - Pittsford - junior
Drew Williamee - Canandaigua - senior