Aquinas at McQuaid Jesuit
| PLAYER | Team | GRAD YR | POS | COLLEGE |
| Aidan Abbott | Waterloo | 2023 | D | |
| Stas Abel | Brighton | 2011 | D | |
| Mattan Abittan | Brighton | 2018 | A | |
| Joe Abraham | Geneva | 2010 | M | |
| Corbin Abramson | Brighton | 2007 | A | |
| Odin Abril | Eastridge | 2012 | G | |
| Jack Acker | Wayne | 2021 | G | Brockport |
| Zach Ackerson | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | D | |
| Hunter Ackley | Mynderse | 2014 | D | |
| Andy Adam | Schroeder | 2008 | D | Buffalo |
| Ben Adams | Thomas | 2025 | D | |
| Ben Adams | Canandaigua | 2025 | D | |
| Craig Adams | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | D | |
| Eli Adams | Thomas | 2022 | D | Fairfield |
| Joe Adams | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | D | |
| Nate Adams | Livonia | 2018 | A/M | |
| Nate Adams | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | A/M | |
| Riley Adams | Thomas | 2024 | A | |
| Jacob Adkins | Livonia | 2018 | A/M | |
| Jacob Adkins | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | A/M | |
| Brian Adler | Waterloo | 2006 | M/A | |
| Keiron Adorno | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | A | |
| Ethan Adrid | Victor | 2023 | M | |
| Noah Affronti | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Zach Agliata | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | M | |
| Braylon Agnello | Wayne | 2024 | A | |
| Peter Agnello | Aquinas | 2024 | D | |
| Jonathan Agness | Spencerport | 2018 | A | |
| Sam Agostinelli | Aquinas | 2026 | M | |
| Keegan Ahern | Pittsford | 2025 | D | |
| Drew Ahlstrom | Gates Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Charles Aiello | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Cody Aikey | Canandaigua | 2021 | A | |
| Logan Airy | Gananda | 2027 | M | |
| Zachary Ajavananda | Spencerport | 2025 | M | |
| Josh Ake | Greece Arc_Oly | 2006 | D | |
| Jackson Akers | Spencerport | 2018 | M | |
| Kwabena Akuamoah-Boateng | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Tyler Alawi | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | LSM | |
| Alex Alayon | Brockport | 2020 | M | |
| Enrique Alayon | Brockport | 2018 | M | |
| Giordamo Albert | Gates Chili | 2018 | A/M | |
| Ross Albright | Canandaigua | 2007 | M | |
| Braydon Albro | Penfield | 2025 | D | |
| Jon Alcorn | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | M | |
| Devon Aldermann | Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Devon Aldermann | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Jacob Aldrich | Penfield | 2012 | M | |
| Matt Aldrich | Gananda | 2015 | A | |
| Joe Alello | Penfield | 2024 | D | |
| Aiden Alexander | Penfield | 2025 | M | |
| Erik Alexander | Avon | 2015 | D | |
| John Alexander | Fairport | 2023 | G | |
| Jon Alexander | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Michael Alexander | Geneva | 2015 | D | FLCC |
| Shawn Alexander | Pittsford | 2020 | M | |
| Evan Alfano | Schroeder | 2020 | G | Maryville |
| Dominic Alfieri | Pittsford | 2025 | M | |
| Nick Alfieri | Aquinas | 2012 | M | |
| Mickey Allan | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | A | |
| Joe Allegue | Batavia-Attica | 2017 | M | |
| Joe Allegue | Batavia | 2017 | A | |
| Cooper Allen | Penfield | 2017 | G | |
| J. Brian Allen | Penfield | 2010 | D | |
| Jacob Allen | Thomas | 2018 | A | Indianapolis |
| Jaypar Allen | Newark | 2024 | M | |
| JD Allen | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2022 | A | Lake Erie |
| Jeffrey Allen | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Joey Allen | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Jordan Allen | Fairport | 2023 | DM | |
| Mike Allen | Pal-Mac | 2014 | G | |
| Ricky Allen | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | D | |
| Ryan Allen | Pal-Mac | 2026 | A/M | |
| Sean Allen | Pal-Mac | 2027 | A/M | |
| Shawn Allen | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | A | |
| Stu Allen | Spencerport | 2011 | M | |
| Thomas Allen | Spencerport | 2014 | DM | |
| Trevor Allen | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | M | |
| Tyler Allen | Newark | 2016 | D | |
| Zach Allen | Thomas | 2023 | DM | |
| Michael Alley | Gates Chili | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Jeremy Allston | Livonia | 2006 | D | |
| Luis Aloma | Eastridge | 2005 | D | |
| Jagger Altieri | Thomas | 2024 | M | Geneseo |
| Jake Altman | East Rochester | 2012 | M | Keuka |
| Theodore Altman | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | A/M | |
| Jake Altmire | Thomas | 2012 | G | |
| Dennis Alton | Batavia | 2013 | A | |
| Isaac Alva | Pittsford | 2022 | A | |
| Luke Alva | Pittsford | 2024 | A | |
| Alex Alvarado | Hilton | 2012 | D | |
| Landon Alvarado | Newark | 2011 | M | |
| Teddy Alvarado | Hilton | 2014 | A | Alfred State |
| Jake Alvarez | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | A | Ithaca |
| Deven Alves | Canandaigua | 2010 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Jordan Alves | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Shane Alves | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | A | |
| Jake Alvord | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | A | |
| Lorenzo Amadio | Victor | 2024 | A | |
| Derek Amann | Thomas | 2015 | D | |
| Thomas Amato | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | D | |
| Seth Ambroz | Wayne | 2013 | D | |
| Kyle Amedo | Thomas | 2016 | D | |
| Logan Ameele | Pal-Mac | 2018 | M | |
| Brett Amen | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | A | |
| Brad Ames | Penn Yan | 2005 | M | |
| Corey Ames | Hilton | 2007 | D | |
| JP Ames | Midlakes | 2010 | M | |
| Joe Amico | Thomas | 2009 | D | |
| Dylan Amidon | Waterloo | 2021 | A | |
| Ethan Amidon | Brighton | 2023 | D | Wittenberg |
| Jordan Amorese | Irondequoit | 2007 | D | |
| Rich Amundson | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | D | Brockport |
| Alex Anderson | Waterloo | 2013 | M | |
| Brad Anderson | Avon | 2016 | A/M | |
| Chad Anderson | Penfield | 2017 | DM | |
| Eddie Anderson | Pal-Mac | 2007 | D | Alfred |
| Ethan Anderson | Schroeder | 2026 | D | |
| Ian Anderson | Mynderse | 2018 | A | |
| Jake Anderson | Brighton | 2007 | A | |
| Luke Anderson | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | A | |
| Ryan Anderson | Waterloo | 2015 | M/D | |
| Sean Anderson | Mynderse | 2013 | M | |
| Tommy Anderson | Pittsford | 2023 | D | |
| Tyshaum Anderson | Newark | 2017 | D | |
| James Andon | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | |
| Clark Andre | Victor | 2018 | M | |
| Will Andre | Victor | 2020 | D | |
| Alex Andreoli | Fairport | 2015 | A/M | |
| Devin Andrews | Canandaigua | 2017 | A | Le Moyne |
| Joe Andrews | Mynderse | 2022 | D | |
| Matt Andrews | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | D | |
| Nick Andrews | Geneva | 2013 | D | |
| Tyler Andrews | Spencerport | 2014 | D | Keuka |
| Dakoda Andross | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Shawn Andrus | Waterloo | 2007 | G | |
| Nicolas Ange | Thomas | 2024 | A | |
| Joe Angello | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | A | |
| Drew Angelo | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | M/FO | Syracuse |
| Nick Angelo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | G | |
| Jonathan Angelone | Brighton | 2005 | M | |
| Josh Anken | Gananda | 2013 | M | |
| Justin Anken | Gananda | 2015 | G | |
| William Ankenbauer | Gates Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Christoffer Ankersen | Midlakes | 2011 | M | |
| Matt Annechino | Thomas | 2017 | M | |
| Rick Antelli | Aquinas | 2008 | D | |
| Matt Anten | Hilton | 2013 | D | |
| Garcia Anthony | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | D | |
| Todd Anthony | Canandaigua | 2005 | M | |
| Alan Antinarelli | Aquinas | 2007 | G | Lycoming |
| Colin Antinelli | Penfield | 2024 | D | |
| David Antonini | Gates Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Bob Apgar | Mynderse | 2013 | D | |
| Jeremy Appell | Schroeder | 2005 | D | |
| Matt Appenowich | Haverling | 2008 | D | |
| Ethan Appleton | Brighton | 2014 | A/M | |
| James Appleton | Avon | 2013 | A | |
| Jake Apthorpe | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | |
| Fernando Aragon | Batavia | 2008 | A | |
| Thomas Arao | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Sam Arazoza | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Brayden Arber | Livonia-Avon | 2028 | A/M | |
| Joe Arcarese | Fairport | 2013 | D | Siena |
| Alex Archer | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | M/A | |
| Aiden Arena | Fairport | 2022 | D | |
| Jonathan Arieno | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Vincent Ariola | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Peter Armbruster | Schroeder | 2013 | DM | |
| Alex Armstrong | Thomas | 2013 | D | Potsdam |
| Chris Armstrong | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | D | |
| Jordan Armstrong | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | G | |
| Jordan Armstrong | Batavia | 2020 | G | |
| Luke Armstrong | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | M | |
| Matt Armstrong | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | A | |
| Quentin Armstrong | Gates Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Anthony Arner | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | D | |
| Anthony Arner | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | D | |
| Adam Arnold | Geneva | 2010 | M | |
| Grady Arnold | Pal-Mac | 2020 | A | Seton Hill |
| Nate Arnold | Pal-Mac | 2017 | D | Le Moyne |
| Sean Arnold | Fairport | 2013 | D | |
| James Arrend | Avon | 2016 | D | |
| Chris Arsenault | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Ivan Arsov | Gates Chili | 2019 | D | |
| Mike Arvan | Penfield | 2006 | M | Villanova |
| John Asbury | Waterloo | 2010 | M | |
| Joshua Ash | Brockport | 2011 | D | |
| Thomas Ashby | Wayne | 2025 | M | |
| Shane Ashe | Bishop Kearney | 2010 | A | |
| Adam Ashkar | Greece Storm | 2023 | D | |
| Yunis Ashkar | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | M | |
| Kyle Ashmead | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | M | |
| Jeremy Askin | Geneva | 2024 | M | St Bonaventure |
| Nate Askin | Geneva | 2021 | M | Brockport |
| Nick Askin | Geneva | 2020 | M | Brockport |
| Alexander Aspromgos | Gates Chili | 2023 | G | |
| Mike Asselin | Brighton | 2011 | M | |
| Robbie Asselin | Brighton | 2006 | M | |
| Christopher Atkinson | Fairport | 2007 | D | Cortland |
| Daniel Atkinson | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | G | |
| Andrew Atwood | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | G | |
| Andrew Atwood | Batavia | 2021 | G | |
| Riley Atwood | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | D | |
| Riley Atwood | Batavia | 2021 | D | |
| Robert Atwood | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | A/M | |
| Jack Auberger | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | M | |
| Alex Augsburger | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | A | |
| Matt Augustine | Geneva | 2007 | M | |
| Bergren Aunkst-Park | Waterloo | 2025 | G | |
| Gianluca Auriuso | Hilton | 2027 | A | |
| Tano Auriuso | Aquinas | 2026 | A | |
| Ethan Aust | Penfield | 2024 | A | |
| Alex Austin | Eastridge | 2008 | A | Brockport |
| Mike Austin | Schroeder | 2013 | M | |
| Riley Austin | Eastridge | 2009 | A | Brockport |
| Ryan Austin | Fairport | 2018 | D | |
| Wesley Austin | Eastridge | 2012 | D | |
| Griffin Avery | Pittsford | 2016 | A | Nazareth |
| John Avery | Pittsford | 2018 | A | Utica |
| Nolan Avery | Newark | 2012 | M | |
| Ryan Avery | Irondequoit | 2025 | A/M | |
| Jason Avezzato | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | D | |
| Najeeb Awad | Brighton | 2019 | M | Buffalo |
| Chris Aycock | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | M | Nazareth |
| Tyler Aycock | Pittsford | 2012 | A/M | SUNY Albany |
| Duncan Ayer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | A/M | |
| JD Ayer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | A | Bentley |
| Collin Ayers | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | D | |
| Dustin Ayers | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | |
| Jason Ayers | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | D | |
| Daniel Ayotte | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Owen Baader | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | M/A | |
| John Babcock | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | M | |
| Justin Babcock | Midlakes | 2019 | A/M | |
| Logan Babcock | Pal-Mac | 2022 | A/M | |
| Collin Bacher | Penn Yan | 2026 | A | |
| A.J. Bachman | Mynderse | 2009 | A | |
| Jake Bachner | Irondequoit | 2016 | A | |
| Bryan Backus | Midlakes | 2013 | A | |
| Tyler Badger | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | M | |
| Jaydes Baerga | Gananda | 2025 | M | |
| Jason Baetzhold | Gates Chili | 2009 | G | Brockport |
| Gary Baier | Fairport | 2006 | A | |
| Coty Bailey | Penn Yan | 2018 | D | |
| Ethan Bailey | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | A | |
| Isaac Bailey | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Jake Bailey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | D | North Carolina |
| Jonathan Bailey | Geneva | 2022 | D | |
| Josh Bailey | Waterloo | 2012 | G | |
| Josh Bailey | Brockport | 2014 | D | |
| Kevin Bailey | Gates Chili | 2006 | D | |
| Kiel Bailey | Geneva | 2024 | D | |
| Luc Bailey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | DM | Ohio State |
| Merritt Bailey | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | G | Seton Hill |
| Mitch Bailey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | D | St John Fisher |
| Paul Bailey | East United | 2020 | G | |
| R.J. Bailey | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | M | |
| Seth Bailey | Pal-Mac | 2012 | M | |
| Thomas Bailey | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | M | |
| Jeff Baily | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | D | |
| James Baiocchi | Brighton | 2021 | D | |
| Nick Baird | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | M | |
| Sean Baird | Spencerport | 2024 | D | |
| Troy Baird | Eastridge | 2015 | A | |
| John Baird-Gajdos | Bishop Kearney | 2024 | M | |
| Dakota Bajdas | Geneva | 2024 | G | |
| Xavier Bakari | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | M | |
| Andrew Baker | Mynderse | 2010 | D | |
| Erik Baker | Midlakes | 2011 | M | |
| Riley Baker | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | D | |
| Robert Baker | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Zach Baker | Pal-Mac | 2020 | A | Maryville |
| Gage Baker-Brownlie | Spencerport | 2020 | G/M | |
| Ethan Bakogiannis | Geneva | 2015 | M | FLCC |
| Ahmad Bakrin | Brighton | 2015 | M | |
| Blake Balcaen | Schroeder | 2016 | M | Pace |
| Jesse Balcarek | Aquinas | 2018 | D | |
| Stephen Balcerak | Spencerport | 2006 | D | |
| TJ Balch | Thomas | 2025 | A | |
| Mike Baldino | Spencerport | 2008 | M | |
| Aiden Baldwin | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | M | |
| Brendan Baldwin | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2026 | A/M | |
| Brody Baldwin | Haverling | 2022 | A/M | |
| Evan Baldwin | Greece Storm | 2026 | LSM | |
| Connor Ball | Schroeder | 2018 | M | |
| Justin Ball | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Michael Ball | Fairport | 2016 | M | |
| Alex Ballatori | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Keegan Balliet | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | D | FLCC |
| Iain Balsamo | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Will Banahene | Brighton | 2012 | M | |
| Kevin Bane | Fairport | 2012 | M | |
| Noah Banister | Penfield | 2025 | D | |
| Matt Barbaccia | Pittsford | 2012 | M | |
| Kristian Barbato | Spencerport | 2010 | A | |
| Nick Barbato | Spencerport | 2014 | A | |
| Charlie Barbay | Mynderse | 2009 | A/M | Alfred |
| Mike Barbay | Mynderse | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Barbay | Mynderse | 2012 | M | Keuka |
| Rob Barber | Midlakes | 2007 | M | |
| Mike Barbone | Hilton | 2010 | M | |
| Joey Barboza | Penfield | 2018 | A | |
| Will Barboza | Penfield | 2015 | M | |
| Jon Barclay | Pittsford | 2008 | M | |
| Noah Barclay | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | D | |
| Jared Bardeen | Canandaigua | 2017 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Thomas Barden | Penn Yan | 2022 | A | |
| Chris Barilla | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | A | |
| Matt Barilla | Midlakes | 2010 | A | |
| Mike Barilla | Schroeder | 2007 | M | RIT |
| Phil Barilla | Irondequoit | 2018 | A | |
| Vin Barilla | Schroeder | 2009 | A | MCC |
| Brandon Barker | Pittsford | 2015 | M | Ohio State |
| Colby Barker | Pittsford | 2017 | M | |
| Tad Barker | Greece | 2005 | M | |
| Zach Barker | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2021 | D | |
| Tom Barkolas | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Stephen Barlow | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Hunter Barnard | Greece Arc_Oly | 2019 | A/M | |
| Hunter Barnard | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| Chad Barnes | Newark | 2010 | M | |
| Mitchell Barnes | Greece Storm | 2026 | G | |
| Nate Barnes | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Nate Barnes | Newark | 2027 | 0 | |
| Zach Barnes | Newark | 2015 | M | |
| Brandon Barnhart | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | A/M | MCC |
| Peter Barraclaugh-Tan | Brighton | 2021 | M | |
| Andrew Barreca | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | G | SUNY Poly |
| Dan Barreca | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | A | |
| Emmett Barrese | Penfield | 2023 | D | |
| Jackson Barresse | Penfield | 2022 | D | |
| Christian Barrett | Hilton | 2006 | M | |
| Conrad Barrett | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Cory Barrett | Waterloo | 2014 | M | |
| John Barrett | Newark | 2007 | M | Marywood |
| Keaton Barrett | Fairport | 2023 | D | |
| Matthew Barrett | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | D | |
| Tom Barrett | Newark | 2010 | M/A | |
| Alvaro Luna Barrientos | Penfield | 2008 | M | |
| Alex Barrow | Victor | 2013 | M | |
| Dan Barrow | Victor | 2016 | M | |
| Patrick Barrow | Victor | 2016 | D | SUNY Albany |
| Pete Barry | Pal-Mac | 2007 | M | |
| Josh Barski | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | A | |
| Mark Bart | Haverling | 2010 | D | |
| David Barth | Greece Arc_Oly | 2006 | A | |
| Tim Barth | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | M | St John Fisher |
| Luke Bartkoski | Victor | 2014 | M | Le Moyne |
| Dylan Bartlett | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | M | |
| Kam Bartley | Gananda | 2023 | M | |
| John Bartolotto | Fairport | 2020 | LSM | Baldwin Wallace |
| Josh Barton | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Ricky Barton | Aquinas | 2013 | M | St John Fisher |
| Cale Bartosch | Pal-Mac | 2019 | D | |
| Alexander Bartz | Batavia | 2023 | M | |
| Alexander Bartz | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | M | |
| Dokota Bartz | Brighton | 2014 | D | |
| Lucas Basil | Spencerport | 2015 | A | |
| Steve Basil | Spencerport | 2008 | M/A | |
| Jacob Basile | Mynderse | 2013 | D | |
| Steve Basile | Victor | 2011 | G | |
| Noah Baskin | Brighton | 2016 | D | |
| Kyle Basmajian | Gates Chili | 2010 | D | |
| Brice Basset | Schroeder | 2010 | D | |
| Codie Bassett | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | D | |
| Mark Bassett | Pal-Mac | 2017 | M | |
| Steve Bassett | Pal-Mac | 2015 | G | |
| Yakoub Basta | Brighton | 2019 | A | |
| Steven Bastian | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Levi Basynnski | Spencerport | 2012 | M | |
| Jason Batcheller | Midlakes | 2009 | A | |
| Ryan Bates | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | D | |
| Frank Battaglia | Gates Chili | 2005 | G | |
| CJ Battiagila | Thomas | 2018 | LSM | Penn State |
| Derek Battin | Penn Yan | 2007 | D | |
| Quinten Battle | Mynderse | 2018 | A | Wells |
| George Bauer | Eastridge | 2014 | D | |
| Josh Bauer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Nick Bauer | Pal-Mac | 2010 | D | |
| Ryan Bauer | Spencerport | 2018 | M | |
| Xavier Bauer | Brockport | 2023 | D | Alfred |
| Connor Bauman | Canandaigua | 2020 | M | |
| Jaden Bauman | Canandaigua | 2016 | A | |
| Robert Bauman | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | |
| Chris Bausch | Livonia | 2010 | A | |
| Austin Baxendell | Gates Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Dylan Baxter | Brockport | 2027 | D | |
| Patrick Bay | Canandaigua | 2015 | A | Lake Erie |
| Tim Bay | Canandaigua | 2015 | A | Lake Erie |
| Dan Baylard | Newark | 2013 | M | |
| Alec Bazer | Gates Chili | 2007 | D | |
| Matt Beach | Batavia | 2020 | M | |
| Matt Beachel | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | G | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Colin Beadling | Brockport | 2018 | D | |
| Caleb Beadnell | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | A/M | |
| Tyler Beals | Pal-Mac | 2021 | A | |
| Joel Bean | Gananda | 2019 | M | |
| Kolby Bean | Gananda | 2014 | M | |
| Sam Bean | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | M | |
| Sean Beaney | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | MCC |
| Cole Beardsley | Brockport | 2021 | A | MCC |
| Chance Bears | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | M | |
| Re`Shaun Beason | Bishop Kearney | 2022 | M | |
| Henry Beaton | Pal-Mac | 2026 | D | |
| Johnathon Beattie | Waterloo | 2012 | A | |
| Curtis Beaty | Eastridge | 2015 | M | |
| Carl Beaver | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Christopher Bechle | Fairport | 2012 | D | SUNY Binghamton |
| John Bechtold | Bishop Kearney | 2015 | M | |
| Brendan Beck | Wayne | 2021 | M | |
| Mike Beck | Pal-Mac | 2005 | D | |
| Sam Beckenbach | Gananda | 2013 | D | |
| Dyllan Becker | Haverling | 2024 | G/D | |
| Justin Becker | Livonia | 2009 | G | Alfred |
| Richard Becker | East United | 2020 | A | |
| Nick Beckert | Midlakes | 2019 | D | |
| Austin Beckingham | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | A | |
| Mike Beckwith | Irondequoit | 2008 | M | |
| Ben Bednardz | Schroeder | 2007 | A | |
| Brad Beebe | Haverling | 2027 | M | |
| Cole Beebe | Haverling | 2009 | A | |
| Justin Beehler | Hilton | 2008 | D | |
| Bobby Beers | Brighton | 2015 | D | |
| Brendan Beh | Schroeder | 2022 | LSM | |
| Clay Behlok | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | D | |
| Matt Behlok | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Kyle Beikirch | Gates Chili | 2006 | M | |
| William Beikirch | Gates Chili | 2014 | D | |
| Will Beikrich | Midlakes | 2014 | M | |
| David Beiling | Pittsford | 2011 | A | |
| Jared Beiling | Schroeder | 2013 | D | |
| Nick Beitmair | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| Beka Bekauri | Geneva | 2019 | M | |
| Riley Belanger | Pal-Mac | 2021 | - | |
| Ben Beldner | Pittsford | 2018 | D | |
| Tyler Beldock | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | A | |
| Ben Belfield | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Jake Belias | Pittsford | 2017 | A/M | |
| Alex Bell | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | M | |
| Connor Bell | Newark | 2018 | M | |
| Dan Bell | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | D | |
| David Bell | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Dennis Bell | Penfield | 2004 | M | |
| Devin Bell | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | D | |
| Dimitrius Bell | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | M | |
| Jack Bell | Schroeder | 2023 | D | |
| Jack Bell | Aquinas | 2026 | A | |
| Jake Bell | Batavia | 2009 | D | |
| Kenneth Bell | Spencerport | 2007 | M | |
| Kevin Bell | Hilton | 2024 | A | |
| Mike Bell | Hilton | 2005 | M | |
| Ryan Bell | Penfield | 2019 | A | |
| Spencer Bell | Fairport | 2018 | A | RIT |
| Tommy Bell | Aquinas | 2015 | D | |
| Tommy Bell | Penfield | 2015 | LSM | |
| Zac Bell | Schroeder | 2015 | A | |
| Aiden Bellavia | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | D | |
| Mark Belles | Canandaigua | 2019 | A | St Bonaventure |
| Matt Belles | Canandaigua | 2022 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Mike Belles | Canandaigua | 2025 | A | |
| Aaron Bellinger | Wayne | 2017 | G | |
| Josh Bellis | Canandaigua | 2018 | M | |
| Nathan Bellis | Canandaigua | 2013 | D | Alfred |
| Nick Bellucco | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | G | MCC |
| Alexander Beltran | Eastridge | 2015 | M | |
| Julian Bement | Thomas | 2022 | A | |
| JW Bement | Newark | 2009 | A | |
| Scott Bement | Canandaigua | 2008 | G | Hartford |
| Matt Benamino | Geneva | 2015 | M | |
| John Bender | Brighton | 2013 | D | |
| Matt Bender | Pittsford | 2019 | M | Oswego |
| Will Bender | Brighton | 2015 | M | |
| Donald Benedict | Penn Yan | 2007 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Lee Benedict | Pal-Mac | 2005 | D | |
| Mike Benedict | Pal-Mac | 2011 | M | |
| Noah Benedict | Thomas | 2019 | D | |
| Seth Benedict | Marcus Whitman | 2020 | M | Le Moyne |
| Tom Benedict | Livonia | 2011 | D | |
| Kyle Benesh | Haverling | 2006 | M | |
| Nick Benetti | Victor | 2021 | A/M | Oswego |
| Ben Bengston | Midlakes | 2006 | D | |
| Grey Benham | Canandaigua | 2018 | M | |
| Kyle Benham | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | D | |
| Max Beniamino | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | G | |
| Mike Beniamino | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| Nick Beniamino | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | G | |
| Alejandro Benitez | Schroeder | 2017 | M | |
| Angel Benitez | UPrep | 2019 | A | |
| Cody Bennett | Victor | 2007 | G | |
| David Bennett | Pal-Mac | 2005 | M | Medaille |
| Dylan Bennett | Haverling | 2010 | LSM | |
| Jared Bennett | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | A | |
| Jason Bennett | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2027 | G | |
| Kain Bennett | Midlakes | 2020 | M | |
| Sam Bennett | Canandaigua | 2021 | A | RIT |
| Sean Bennett | Geneva | 2008 | M | Alfred |
| Zachary Bennett | Pittsford | 2024 | D | |
| Elliot Benson | East Rochester | 2012 | M | |
| Jerry Benson | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Jevon Benson | Pal-Mac | 2014 | D | |
| Brody Bentley | Mynderse | 2013 | LSM | |
| Kevin Bentley | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Cory Benulis | Victor | 2005 | A | |
| Kyle Benwitz | Victor | 2011 | A | |
| Chris Benza | Fairport | 2010 | M | Nazareth |
| Javier Benzan | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Javier Benzan | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Jason Berardicurti | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Isaac Berg | Brighton | 2015 | G | |
| Noah Berg | Brighton | 2007 | G | |
| Charlie Bergen | Livonia | 2010 | A | |
| Izzy Berger | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | D | |
| Zac Berger | Livonia | 2006 | G | |
| Marty Berke | Hilton | 2005 | M | |
| Nick Berkompas | Aquinas | 2007 | M | Pfeiffer |
| Alex Bernardi | Newark | 2024 | D | |
| Tyler Bernarduci | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | M | Indianapolis |
| George Bernat | Penfield | 2016 | M | |
| James Berndt | Newark | 2026 | M | |
| Casey Berns | Schroeder | 2024 | G | D`Youville |
| Jordan Bernstein | Thomas | 2008 | M | |
| Steve Bernsten | Hilton | 2009 | A | Canisius |
| Jeffrey Bero | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | A | |
| Tim Berry | Midlakes | 2014 | M | |
| Aiden Bertino | Brockport | 2019 | M | |
| Brent Bertrom | East Rochester | 2014 | M | |
| Christian Besaw | Victor | 2024 | A | Rollins |
| Tyler Best | Pal-Mac | 2010 | M | |
| Emanual Bestman | Mynderse | 2006 | M | |
| Aaron Bethmann | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | A | |
| Adam Bethmann | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | D | |
| Graysen Betts | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | D | |
| Kyle Betts | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | A | |
| Zach Bevilacqua | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | G | |
| Travis Bevins | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| John Bezek | Thomas | 2013 | G | Potsdam |
| Adam Bianchi | Eastridge | 2014 | M | |
| Alex Bianchi | Aquinas | 2014 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Anthony Bianchi | Aquinas | 2010 | M | Brockport |
| Joe Bianchi | Irondequoit | 2019 | D | |
| Nick Bianchi | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Tom Bianchi | Hilton | 2013 | D | |
| Tucker Bickel | Canandaigua | 2022 | D | |
| Andre Bigham | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | |
| Josh Bihrle | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | G | |
| Sean Bihrle | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | M | |
| Matt Bilak | Penfield | 2012 | M | Tampa |
| Zach Bilger | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | M | |
| Jared Bilinski | Spencerport | 2014 | D | |
| Beau Billinski | Spencerport | 2010 | D | |
| Jack Billitier | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | A | Bucknell |
| Nick Billitier | Spencerport | 2018 | D | |
| Ryan Bills | Pal-Mac | 2007 | A | |
| Brent Binder | Pittsford | 2013 | D | |
| Zach Binggeli | Gananda | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Binnert | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | A | |
| Nate Birch | Haverling | 2017 | G/M | FLCC |
| Trent Birch | Haverling | 2019 | LSM | |
| Davis Bird | Thomas | 2015 | G | |
| Ian Bird | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Jeff Bird | Hilton | 2006 | D | |
| Justin Bird | Thomas | 2013 | M | |
| Adam Birkbeck | Spencerport | 2021 | G | |
| Ryan Birkbeck | Spencerport | 2018 | M | |
| Josh Birle | Spencerport | 2009 | G | |
| Tommy Birmingham | Pittsford | 2020 | D | |
| Dan Biron | Fairport | 2014 | D | John Carroll |
| Joe Biscardi | Aquinas | 2014 | M | |
| Aristide Bishop | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Derrek Bishop | Livonia | 2013 | M | |
| Jason Bishop | Waterloo | 2012 | D | |
| Zack Bishop | Mynderse | 2014 | D | |
| Jim Bishoping | Hilton | 2012 | D | |
| Derek Bishopp | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | Alfred |
| Zach Bishopp | Livonia | 2015 | M | |
| Brennan Bitely | Schroeder | 2020 | A | |
| Dylan Bittlingmaier | Pittsford | 2005 | M | Geneseo |
| Sean Bittner | Brockport | 2008 | M | |
| Spencer Bjorling | Canandaigua | 2015 | D | |
| Hunter Black | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | M | |
| Lennon Black | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Lucas Black | Canandaigua | 2023 | D | |
| Trevor Black | Waterloo | 2012 | D | |
| Cory Blackburn | Hilton | 2006 | M | |
| Dan Blackburn | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | D | |
| Parker Blackburn | Spencerport | 2006 | D | |
| Myles Blackwood | Aquinas | 2022 | M | |
| Dan Blaessig | Thomas | 2015 | A | Keuka |
| Luke Blain | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | A | |
| Zach Blain | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | D | |
| Benjamin Blair | Penfield | 2023 | M/FO | |
| John Blair | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | A | |
| Nick Blair | Midlakes | 2014 | A/M | |
| Skyler Blair | Pal-Mac | 2024 | D | |
| Adam Blankenberg | Newark | 2007 | D | |
| Jake Blaszak | Fairport | 2022 | M/FO | |
| Nicholas Blaszak | Fairport | 2012 | D | |
| Jared Blaszyk | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Lucas Blaszyk | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | A | |
| Spin Blazak | Canandaigua | 2021 | M | |
| James Blazey | Pal-Mac | 2017 | M | |
| John Blazey | Pal-Mac | 2021 | M | |
| Dom Blechot | Thomas | 2024 | M/D | |
| Brendan Bleier | Eastridge | 2005 | D | |
| Cody Bleier | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Jacob Bleier | Pal-Mac | 2013 | M | |
| Andrew Blend | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| RJ Blessig | Thomas | 2011 | D | |
| Colin Blind | Thomas | 2013 | D | Brockport |
| Mitch Bliss | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | D | |
| Noah Blocher | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | A | |
| Justis Blocker | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Eric Blodgett | Newark | 2020 | D | |
| Jesse Blodgett | Haverling | 2021 | M | |
| Justin Blodgett | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Stu Blodgett | Newark | 2014 | D | |
| Forrest Blondell | Newark | 2017 | M | |
| Austin Blood | Avon | 2015 | A/M | |
| Mike Blood | Schroeder | 2010 | D | St John Fisher |
| Ryan Blood | Avon | 2016 | M | |
| Brian Bloom | Haverling | 2011 | M | |
| Josh Bloom | Geneva | 2006 | M | |
| Mark Bloom | Geneva | 2005 | M | |
| Mike Bloom | Penn Yan | 2014 | D | |
| Shane Bloom | Penn Yan | 2014 | M | |
| Jeff Bloomer | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | D | |
| Matt Bloomer | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | A | |
| Adam Blossom | Hilton | 2010 | D | |
| Nick Blossom | Hilton | 2014 | D | |
| DeCouteau Blueye | Marcus Whitman | 2020 | A | FLCC |
| Melkamu Blueye | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | M | |
| Tariku Blueye | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | M | |
| Austin Blumbergs | Penn Yan | 2018 | M | St Bonaventure |
| Chase Blumbergs | Penn Yan | 2020 | A/M | |
| Jackson Blythe | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | G | |
| Matt Blythe | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | A | Grove City |
| Ryan Boadway | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | D | MCC |
| Kaden Boardway | Penfield | 2017 | G | |
| Jordan Bobbo | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Jacob Bocianski | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Brady Bodamer | Hilton | 2020 | A | |
| Eric Bodine | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | M | |
| Jordan Bodine | Penn Yan | 2015 | A | |
| Michael Boe | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| Ryan Boe | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | |
| Seth Boesel | Pal-Mac | 2021 | A/M | |
| Michael Bogan | Newark | 2007 | G | |
| Ben Bogdan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Alexander Bogdanoff | Fairport | 2006 | D | |
| Jacob Bogert | Schroeder | 2015 | D | |
| Colin Boglione | Greece Arc_Oly | 2019 | A/M | |
| Colin Boglione | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| Mike Bohling | Waterloo | 2010 | M | |
| Alex Bohme | Aquinas | 2020 | M | |
| Michael Bohme | Aquinas | 2017 | D | |
| Jake Boice | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | |
| Eric Boike | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | A | |
| Jason Boike | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | A | |
| Cal Boily | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Josh Boily | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | D | |
| Joshua Boily | Greece Storm | 2019 | D | |
| Ryan Boily | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Aiden Bolam | Gates Chili | 2021 | M/FO | |
| Sutton Boland | Victor | 2019 | D | Penn State |
| Brendan Bolger | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Cameron Bollin | Schroeder | 2016 | A/M | |
| Cole Bollin | Schroeder | 2020 | A | Geneseo |
| Conor Bollin | Schroeder | 2018 | A | RIT |
| Marshall Bolster | Canandaigua | 2027 | A | |
| Mason Bolster | Canandaigua | 2022 | D | |
| Alex Bolt | Wayne | 2021 | A/M | |
| Gunnar Bolton | Schroeder | 2022 | D | |
| Van Bolton | Schroeder | 2027 | G | |
| Garrett Bonacci | Spencerport | 2020 | A | |
| Dan Bonafede | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Pat Bonafede | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | M | Potsdam |
| Andrew Bonalle | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Matt Bonancci | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | D | |
| Justin Bonanza | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | A | |
| Zach Bonazza | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Kyle Boncaro | Geneva | 2008 | A | Goucher |
| Jack Bond | Avon | 2020 | M | |
| Jack Bond | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | A/M | |
| Phil Bond | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | A | |
| Matt Bonferraro | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Sean Bonhag | Victor | 2023 | M | Marywood |
| Parker Bonis | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Adam Bonisteel | Brockport | 2015 | D | |
| Greg Bonney | Geneva | 2007 | A | |
| London Booker | Gates Chili | 2012 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Dylan Boone | Avon | 2016 | DM | |
| Dylan Boop | Avon | 2015 | A/M | |
| Matt Borcyk | Hilton | 2007 | M | |
| Ryan Borland | Waterloo | 2020 | G | |
| Jacob Borrelli | Midlakes | 2019 | G | |
| Joe Borrelli | Greece Ath_Ody | 2018 | D | |
| Joseph Borrelli | Greece Storm | 2018 | D | |
| Brian Borys | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| Merrick Bosch | Wayne | 2022 | A/M | |
| Matt Boseck | Canandaigua | 2015 | M | |
| Ty Boshers | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | |
| Curtis Boshnack | Irondequoit | 2005 | G | |
| Wyatt Boss | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M | |
| Parker Bossard | Geneva | 2020 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Cole Bossarte | Fairport | 2023 | G | |
| Connor Bostian | Pal-Mac | 2017 | D | |
| Brendon Bostley | Hilton | 2021 | M | |
| Cameron Bostley | Hilton | 2018 | A/M | |
| Gabe Botana | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | M | |
| Daniel Bothwell | Fairport | 2006 | D | |
| Sammy Botross-Greenlee | Thomas | 2015 | M | |
| Aaron Bottazzo | Irondequoit | 2005 | M | Robert Morris |
| Cory Bottiglier | Irondequoit | 2005 | M | Nazareth |
| Calvin Bouch | Geneva | 2010 | M | |
| Nick Bourji | Hilton | 2012 | D | |
| Aydan Bourne | Waterloo | 2023 | M | |
| Brackett Bourne | Brighton | 2011 | A | |
| Dan Bournival | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Christopher Bourque | Fairport | 2007 | A | |
| CT Bove | Fairport | 2013 | A | |
| Andrew Bovenzi | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | D | |
| Jack Bovenzi | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Adam Bowen | Waterloo | 2012 | D | |
| Mason Bowen | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Ryan Bowen | Fairport | 2014 | A | |
| Zachary Bowen | Waterloo | 2008 | G | |
| Kyle Bowerman | Fairport | 2011 | G | |
| Ryan Bowerman | Penfield | 2024 | D | Loyola |
| Andrew Bowes | Irondequoit | 2013 | D | Canton |
| John Bowes | Irondequoit | 2014 | D | |
| Collin Bowman | Midlakes | 2015 | D | |
| John Bowman | Wayne | 2015 | A | |
| Josh Bowman | Wayne | 2013 | A | |
| Michael Bowman | Fairport | 2014 | M | |
| Zach Boyatzies | Wayne | 2020 | A | |
| Zach Boyatzies | Hilton | 2020 | A | |
| Jake Boyce | Pittsford | 2005 | A | SUNY Binghamton |
| Kiernan Boyce | Victor | 2021 | D | |
| Nelson Boyd | Waterloo | 2007 | A/M | |
| Phil Boyd | Batavia | 2012 | A | |
| Winston Boyd | Waterloo | 2006 | M/A | |
| Cameron Boyer | Haverling | 2024 | A | |
| Conor Boyer | East Rochester | 2009 | M | |
| Miles Boyer | East Rochester | 2012 | D | |
| Luvon Boykins | Geneva | 2022 | G/D | |
| Dalton Boylan | Canandaigua | 2020 | D | |
| Nick Boylan | Canandaigua | 2005 | M | Belmont Abbey |
| Ronan Boyle | Penfield | 2026 | D | |
| Frazer Boyum | Fairport | 2023 | G | |
| Jake Brackett | Brockport | 2009 | M | |
| Cory Braden | Midlakes | 2018 | A | |
| Cameron Bradley | Batavia | 2018 | D | |
| Mike Bradley | Waterloo | 2010 | M | |
| Jonah Bradley-Guelzow | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | D | |
| Brikeal Brady | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| Jack Brady | Mynderse | 2025 | A | |
| Steven Brady | Victor | 2019 | M | |
| Tyler Brahm | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | D | |
| Cole Branach | Penn Yan | 2027 | A | |
| Avery Brandow | Haverling | 2013 | M | |
| Dylan Brannon | Brighton | 2008 | M | |
| Gabe Brassett | Geneva | 2014 | D | |
| Lukas Brassi | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | M | |
| David Brassie | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | M/A | |
| Mathew Brassie | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | A/M | |
| James Bratton | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | Mt Olive |
| Max Brauer | Brighton | 2011 | M | |
| Brandon Braun | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Erik Braun | Fairport | 2005 | M | |
| Tom Braun | Penfield | 2010 | M/D | |
| Alex Bravo | Hilton | 2015 | M | |
| Tyler Bray | Penn Yan | 2015 | D | |
| Kyle Breach | Spencerport | 2008 | A | |
| Jason Breau | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | A | Lycoming |
| Tim Breau | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | A/M | Western NE |
| Schuyler Bredesen | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | A | FLCC |
| Kyle Bree | Newark | 2008 | M/D | |
| James Breen | Pal-Mac | 2009 | M | |
| Trevor Breese | Waterloo | 2020 | D | |
| Rob Breeze | Brockport | 2008 | D | |
| TJ Brei | Victor | 2020 | A | |
| Greg Bremer | Newark | 2018 | D | |
| Keith Bremer | Newark | 2015 | M | |
| Ryan Bremer | Canandaigua | 2025 | M | |
| Andrew Brennan | Fairport | 2012 | M | Oswego |
| Jack Brennan | Irondequoit | 2019 | A | Maryland |
| Tyler Brennan | Thomas | 2016 | D | |
| Will Brennan | Geneva | 2011 | A | Goucher |
| Matt Brennessel | Midlakes | 2012 | G | |
| Liam Brett | Pittsford | 2024 | G | |
| AJ Brewer | Geneva | 2013 | M | |
| Ben Brewer | Pittsford | 2010 | D | |
| Ethan Brewer | Geneva | 2015 | A | |
| Patrick Brewer | Haverling | 2016 | M | |
| Josh Brewster | Penn Yan | 2015 | M | |
| Dan Brezinsky | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Josh Brickler | Irondequoit | 2019 | D | |
| Harrison Brickwood | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Brett Bridges | Pittsford | 2007 | M | |
| Robert Bridges | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | A | |
| Brian Briggs | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | D | |
| John Briggs | Pal-Mac | 2010 | DM | |
| Jon Briggs | Midlakes | 2006 | A | |
| Nick Briggs | Spencerport | 2017 | D | |
| Pete Brilla | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | |
| Colin Brillian | Gananda | 2014 | A | GCC |
| Kyle Brimm | Geneva | 2008 | G | Wells |
| Zach Brimmacomb | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | |
| Don Bringley | Aquinas | 2005 | D | |
| Dante Brinson | UPrep | 2018 | D | |
| Mike Brisbane | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | G | |
| Donovan Bristol | Newark | 2014 | M | |
| Chadd Britton | Livonia | 2006 | M | |
| Gavin Britton | Gananda | 2021 | G | |
| Logan Britton | Livonia | 2008 | M | |
| Angelo Brock | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | D | |
| Freddie Brock | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Andrew Brocklebank | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | D | |
| Cole Brockman | East United-Eastridge | 2026 | M | |
| Ethan Brodman | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | A | |
| Max Brodmann | Penn Yan | 2021 | A/M | Oswego |
| Josh Brodnicki | Batavia | 2014 | M | |
| Steve Brol | Pal-Mac | 2010 | D | Morrisville |
| Zac Bromley | Batavia | 2013 | M | |
| Marc Brondon | Aquinas | 2008 | M | |
| Tanner Brongo | Spencerport | 2013 | D | |
| Brad Broniman | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2018 | M | |
| Aaron Brooks | Geneva | 2020 | D | FLCC |
| Ben Brooks | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Ian Brooks | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Tyler Brooks | Livonia | 2015 | M | |
| Zachary Brooks | Marcus Whitman | 2019 | M | |
| Tyler Brooks-Lambert | Midlakes | 2010 | M | RIT |
| Coron Broomfield | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | |
| Curtis Brosius | Waterloo | 2008 | A/M | |
| Rhen Brover | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M/D | |
| Aiden Brown | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | G | |
| Alexx Brown | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | D | |
| Christian Brown | Penfield | 2024 | M | |
| Corey Brown | Livonia | 2013 | M | |
| Damon Brown | East United | 2023 | M | |
| Damon Brown | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | M | |
| Darius Brown | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | |
| Devon Brown | Newark | 2015 | G | |
| Dominic Brown | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| Dylan Brown | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Gavin Brown | Spencerport | 2028 | A | |
| Geoff Brown | Spencerport | 2011 | A | |
| Gunnar Brown | Thomas | 2018 | M/A | |
| Ian Brown | Canandaigua | 2015 | M | |
| Jacob Brown | Fairport | 2023 | A | |
| Jamison Brown | Spencerport | 2025 | M | |
| Jeremy Brown | Canandaigua | 2007 | A | Montana |
| Josh Brown | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | D | |
| Jream Brown | Newark | 2023 | A | |
| Keaton Brown | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2022 | G/M | |
| Kentrayl Brown | East United | 2018 | M | |
| Kevin Brown | Schroeder | 2024 | DM | |
| Kyler Brown | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | D | |
| Lane Brown | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | M | |
| Latoine Brown | East United-Eastridge | 2026 | M | |
| Mackenzie Brown | Fairport | 2013 | D | |
| Matt Brown | Haverling | 2020 | LSM | |
| Matthew Brown | Brockport | 2026 | A | |
| Mike Brown | Fairport | 2018 | D | |
| Nathaniel Brown | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Nick Brown | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Noah Brown | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | M | |
| Owen Brown | Irondequoit | 2020 | M | |
| Parker Brown | Schroeder | 2025 | M | |
| Ryan Brown | Geneva | 2023 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Stevie Brown | Newark | 2022 | M | |
| Taye Brown | East United-Eastridge | 2027 | D | |
| Tim Brown | Waterloo | 2013 | A | |
| Zach Brown | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | M | |
| Zachary Brown | Wayne | 2021 | A | |
| Chryron Brown-Wallace | Eastridge | 2013 | D | |
| Jared Brownell | Newark | 2023 | M | |
| Gavin Brownlie | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | D | |
| Gavin Brownlie | Aquinas | 2023 | LSM | |
| DeSean Bruce | Geneva | 2024 | M | |
| Dan Bruder | Mynderse | 2014 | D | |
| Tyler Bruder | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | M | |
| Doug Brummel | Schroeder | 2006 | D | |
| Anthony Brumsted | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Connor Brundage | Haverling | 2024 | A | |
| Tyler Brunea | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | G | |
| Mike Bruno | Mynderse | 2012 | D | Cazenovia |
| Nick Bruno | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | MCC |
| Thomas Bruno | Brockport | 2024 | A | |
| Lucas Brush | Irondequoit | 2021 | D | |
| Ben Bryan | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | M | |
| Nik Bryan | Fairport | 2004 | M | |
| Tyler Bryne | Victor | 2007 | D | |
| Jake Bucci | Fairport | 2017 | A | |
| Jonathan Bucciarelli | Greece Storm | 2024 | G | Jacksonville |
| Carl Bucella | Pittsford | 2009 | D | |
| Dylan Buchholtz | Batavia | 2012 | G | |
| Alex Buchko | Gananda | 2017 | D | |
| CJ Buchta | Brighton | 2020 | D | |
| Rob Buchwald | Midlakes | 2010 | M | |
| Aaron Buck | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | A | |
| Chad Buck | Canandaigua | 2004 | A | |
| Jacob Buck | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | A | Canisius |
| Justin Buck | Canandaigua | 2006 | M | |
| Lucas Buck | Canandaigua | 2025 | A | |
| Brodie Buckert | Pal-Mac | 2020 | D | |
| Mitchell Buckert | Hilton | 2019 | M | |
| Tyler Buckland | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | A | |
| Dan Buckley | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | |
| Mason Buckley | Mynderse | 2024 | A | |
| Noah Buckley | Mynderse | 2016 | A | |
| Ryan Buckley | Pal-Mac | 2007 | M | |
| Ian Bucklin | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | M | |
| Ben Budgar | Geneva | 2026 | A | |
| Andrew Budlong | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | M | |
| Jon Budnik | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Christopher Budzinack | Batavia | 2017 | M | |
| Tyler Budzinack | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | A/M | |
| Tyler Budzinack | Batavia | 2021 | M | |
| Avery Bueso | Newark | 2015 | M | |
| Carlos Bueso | Newark | 2023 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Jordan Bueso | Penfield | 2014 | A | MCC |
| Riley Bufton | Gananda | 2013 | A | |
| Justin Buick | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | |
| Ryan Buick | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | M | |
| Kyle Bullard | Thomas | 2018 | M | |
| Brandon Bulman | Pal-Mac | 2020 | M | |
| Devon Bulman | Newark | 2024 | A | |
| Carter Bumpus | Newark | 2025 | G | |
| Justin Bunce | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Chandler Bunn | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | M | |
| Jeremy Bunn | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Jeff Buono | Thomas | 2013 | D | |
| Giovanni Buonomo | Gates Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Justin Buonomo | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | |
| Dante Burandt | Brockport | 2020 | D | |
| Ian Burch | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | M | |
| James Burdette | Penn Yan | 2013 | D | |
| Austin Burdick | Gates Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Michael Burdick | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Zach Burdick | Schroeder | 2014 | DM | |
| Reese Burek | Fairport | 2018 | A/M | USMA |
| Jason Burg | Haverling | 2019 | D | |
| Connor Burgasser | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | M | Salisbury |
| Jim Burgasser | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | D | St John Fisher |
| Tyler Burgasser | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | D | Stevens |
| Brian Burger | Pal-Mac | 2017 | A | |
| Sam Burgess | Brighton | 2012 | M | |
| Michael Burgio | Greece Storm | 2023 | M | |
| Xavier Burgos | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | M | |
| David Burke | Fairport | 2006 | M | RIT |
| Ian Burke | Aquinas | 2016 | A | |
| James Burke | Pittsford | 2011 | M | Air Force |
| Michael Burke | Fairport | 2009 | M | |
| Noah Burke | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2021 | A/M | |
| Noah Burke | Batavia | 2022 | A | |
| Noah Burke | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | A | |
| Ryan Burke | Penfield | 2014 | LSM | |
| Thomas Burke | Mynderse | 2009 | M | |
| Peter Burkhardtt | Fairport | 2006 | A | |
| Christian Burkhart | Brighton | 2019 | M | |
| Fred Burkholder | Canandaigua | 2007 | D | |
| Luke Burkovich | Irondequoit | 2013 | A | |
| Mosi Burks | Aquinas | 2024 | D | |
| Alex Burley | Canandaigua | 2018 | M | |
| Brandon Burley | Eastridge | 2012 | M | |
| Evan Burley | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | RIT |
| Sam Burley | Canandaigua | 2018 | D | |
| Owen Burlingame | Haverling | 2027 | M | |
| Kyle Burm | Newark | 2005 | M | |
| Andrew Burnett | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Brian Burns | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | LSM | |
| Cody Burns | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Cody Burns | Batavia | 2020 | M | |
| Jack Burns | Brockport | 2011 | A | |
| Jack Burns | Thomas | 2023 | A | Clarkson |
| Jake Burns | Brockport | 2010 | M | Herkimer |
| Pal Burns | Hilton | 2015 | M | |
| Travis Burns | Brighton | 2013 | D | |
| Tristen Burns | Brockport | 2015 | D | |
| Tyler Burns | Batavia | 2022 | M | |
| Tyler Burns | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | A | |
| Mitchell Burrall | Geneva | 2020 | D | |
| Jordan Burrell | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | G | |
| Cal Burroughs | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2020 | D | |
| Damon Burton | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Dave Burton | Penfield | 2007 | G | |
| Henry Burton | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | |
| Frank Buscemi | Aquinas | 2010 | M | |
| Kevin Buschle | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | |
| Noah Buschner | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Brandon Buse | Penfield | 2016 | M | |
| Bobby Bush | Canandaigua | 2004 | M | |
| Henry Bush | Gananda | 2018 | A/M | |
| Zach Bushart | Newark | 2015 | A | |
| Isaa Bushen | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Tyler Bushnell | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2017 | D | Geneseo |
| Zak Bussey | Canandaigua | 2013 | D | St John Fisher |
| Avery Bustamante | Wayne | 2025 | M | |
| Alexander Butcher | Brighton | 2020 | G | |
| Carson Butcher | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | M | |
| Tom Butcher | Midlakes | 2005 | D | |
| John Butlak | Waterloo | 2011 | M/D | Cazenovia |
| Brayden Butler | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | M | |
| Josh Butler | Haverling | 2007 | M | |
| Mark Butler | Irondequoit | 2017 | A | |
| Isaiah Butskey | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| John Butt | Penfield | 2005 | D | |
| Joe Buttarazzi | Fairport | 2022 | DM | |
| John Buttarazzi | Fairport | 2020 | A/M | |
| Matt Buttarazzi | Fairport | 2023 | D | |
| Michael Buttarazzi | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Tyler Butterworth | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Mark Butto | Schroeder | 2009 | A | |
| Andy Button | Penn Yan | 2009 | M | Morrisville |
| Chris Button | Fairport | 2010 | A/M | Le Moyne |
| Ryan Butts | Hilton | 2019 | M | Clarkson |
| Sam Byassee | Victor | 2015 | M | |
| Jeremy Byrne | Aquinas | 2014 | D | |
| Kyle Byron | Irondequoit | 2005 | D | Geneseo |
| Joe Caccamise | Gates Chili | 2013 | A | |
| Gavin Cady | Hilton | 2024 | D/LSM | |
| Ben Cafolla | Mynderse | 2016 | D | Alfred |
| Tom Caggianelli | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | |
| Kevin Caggiano | Victor | 2018 | D | |
| Matt Caggiano | Victor | 2020 | M | |
| Colin Cahill | Pittsford | 2023 | M | Geneseo |
| Ryan Cahill | Wayne | 2019 | A/M | |
| Gio Caiazzo | Schroeder | 2023 | M | |
| Mitchell Cain | Victor | 2018 | M | Loyola |
| Nick Cain | Batavia | 2011 | D | |
| Ryan Cain | Fairport | 2025 | A | |
| Nick Caine | Wayne | 2026 | M | |
| Jack Cairns | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | D | |
| Noah Cakir | Fairport | 2020 | A | |
| Vinny Calcagno | Thomas | 2015 | A/M | |
| Jared Calderon | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Quinton Caleb | Brockport | 2015 | M | |
| Sam Calebi | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | M | |
| Michael Calianese | Victor | 2020 | G | |
| Jared Calice | Penn Yan | 2019 | M | |
| Koray Calik | Schroeder | 2011 | D | |
| Dallas Calkins | East United | 2018 | A | |
| Elijah Calkins | East United | 2020 | D | |
| Landon Calkins | Haverling | 2025 | M | |
| Alex Call | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | D | |
| Alex Callaghan | Pal-Mac | 2019 | D | |
| Garrett Callahan | Schroeder | 2025 | M | |
| Jack Callahan | Victor | 2016 | LSM | Bryant |
| Logan Callahan | Victor | 2021 | M/FO | Johns Hopkins |
| Spencer Callahan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Messiah Calloway | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Brent Calson | Schroeder | 2015 | D | |
| Cody Calvert | Penfield | 2017 | M | |
| Anthony Camarella | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | A | |
| Anthony Camarella | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | A | |
| Dominic Camblin | Newark | 2012 | G | |
| John Camblin | Newark | 2026 | A | |
| Robert Camblin | Newark | 2009 | D | |
| Bobby Cameron | Fairport | 2023 | M | |
| Jason Camilo | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | A | |
| Anthony Camiolo | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | D | |
| Steve Cammarata | Penfield | 2005 | M | |
| Gino Cammilleri | Gates Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Jack Camp | Wayne | 2016 | A | |
| Joe Camp | Wayne | 2019 | LSM | RIT |
| Tyler Camp | Brockport | 2021 | D | |
| Steven Campaniello | Gates Chili | 2010 | M | Lycoming |
| Zack Campaniello | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Devin Campbell | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | M | |
| Frank Campbell | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | D | |
| Jared Campbell | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | D | |
| Mark Campbell | Waterloo | 2015 | G | MCC |
| Matt Campbell | Bishop Kearney | 2025 | M | |
| Owen Campbell | Pal-Mac | 2005 | A | |
| Peter Campbell | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | |
| Kyle Campion | Spencerport | 2006 | M | |
| Mickey Campisi | Thomas | 2012 | A | |
| Tomas Campos | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Kevin Canales | Penn Yan | 2015 | M | |
| Ryan Canham | Thomas | 2016 | D | Clarkson |
| Kirtan Cannan | Schroeder | 2015 | G | |
| Tyler Cannan | Brighton | 2009 | D | |
| Francisco Canovas | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Ryan Cantrell | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | D | |
| Nick Canzoneri | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | M | |
| Cuan Cao | Mynderse | 2024 | D | |
| Loc Cao | Mynderse | 2025 | M | |
| Aidan Cap | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | G | |
| Mateo Capezzuto | Schroeder | 2021 | M | |
| Matt Capezzuto | Victor | 2014 | M | |
| Mike Capezzuto | Victor | 2012 | M | |
| Briele Caples | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | |
| Loren Caples | Irondequoit | 2012 | LSM | |
| Robert Capo | Brockport | 2011 | D | |
| Nick Capone | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | M | Morrisville |
| David Cappiello | East Rochester | 2012 | A | |
| Cole Cappon | Pal-Mac | 2015 | D | |
| Gerry Cappon | Gates Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Michael Cappuccio | Spencerport | 2026 | M | |
| Nick Caracci | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Anthony Caranci | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | G | |
| John Caranci | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | M | |
| Matt Caratazzolo | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Frank Caravita | Geneva | 2025 | D | |
| Benjamin Card | Newark | 2027 | D | |
| Dan Card | Thomas | 2021 | LSM | |
| Matt Card | Newark | 2019 | M | |
| Rich Cardarelli | Penfield | 2011 | A | |
| David Cardillo | Victor | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Cardillo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | M | Vassar |
| Jon Cardona | Penfield | 2009 | D | |
| Ambrose Carey | Canandaigua | 2019 | M | |
| Dylan Carey | Irondequoit | 2026 | A/M | |
| Gavin Carey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | D | |
| Jackson Carey | Thomas | 2022 | D | |
| Jacob Carey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | |
| Joe Carey | Thomas | 2017 | D | |
| Jordan Carey | Brighton | 2011 | G | |
| Matt Carey | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | M | |
| John Caricati | Schroeder | 2027 | M | |
| Shaquonn Carithers | Newark | 2027 | M | |
| Matt Carkner | Pal-Mac | 2011 | G | |
| Jack Carl | Brighton | 2020 | D | |
| Jamie Carl | Brighton | 2018 | D | |
| TJ Carl | Brighton | 2022 | A | Vassar |
| Aaron Carle | Geneva | 2023 | A | |
| Chris Carlson | Penn Yan | 2007 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Greg Carlson | Schroeder | 2009 | M | |
| Steven Carlson | Penn Yan | 2006 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Wes Carlson | Midlakes | 2006 | M | |
| Nathan Carmen | Mynderse | 2016 | D | |
| Dylan Carnavale | Brighton | 2006 | D | |
| Anthony Carnevale | Mynderse | 2004 | G | |
| Blair Carney | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | |
| Trevor Carney | Irondequoit | 2016 | M | |
| Dave Carpenter | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | M | |
| Ryan Carpenter | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | D | |
| Tom Carpenter | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Tyler Carpenter | Hilton | 2018 | D | |
| Tyler Carpenter | Brockport | 2020 | D | |
| Austin Carr | Brighton | 2016 | M | |
| Christopher Carr | Waterloo | 2007 | D | |
| Elijah Carr | Pal-Mac | 2016 | D | |
| Joey Carr | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | D | Alfred State |
| Kaiden Carr | Newark | 2026 | M | |
| Kenny Carr | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | LSM | Alfred State |
| Joe Carra | Schroeder | 2017 | A | Alfred |
| Michael Carrick | Avon | 2020 | M/D | |
| Michael Carrick | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | A/M | |
| Jamison Carrier | Irondequoit | 2022 | M | |
| Jonah Carrier | Irondequoit | 2024 | M | Maryland |
| Kevin Carris | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Joeseph Carroll | Eastridge | 2020 | M | |
| Joseph Carrozzi | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | G | |
| Patrick Carrozzi | Victor | 2019 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Collin Carson | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | St John Fisher |
| Kyle Carson | Canandaigua | 2007 | G | |
| Connor Carter | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2026 | A/M | |
| Daniel Caruso | Gates Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Eugene Carvin | Thomas | 2014 | D | Potsdam |
| Sam Casaverde | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | DM | |
| Kyle Casciani | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | M | |
| Cassidy Case | Haverling | 2019 | M | |
| Colin Case | Pittsford | 2015 | G/M | |
| Ethan Case | Schroeder | 2016 | M | |
| Evan Case | Newark | 2017 | A | |
| Jack Casey | Spencerport | 2019 | A | |
| Ben Cashman | Schroeder | 2026 | G | |
| Hunter Casper | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | D | |
| Cameron Casselman | Newark | 2014 | A | |
| Parker Casselman | Newark | 2018 | A | |
| Brian Cassidy | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | A | |
| Colin Cassidy | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Jack Cassidy | Penfield | 2016 | DM | |
| Mike Cassidy | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Dan Castaneda | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Tyler Castelli | East Rochester | 2012 | M | |
| Alan Caster | Newark | 2011 | M | |
| Jared Caster | Newark | 2018 | D | |
| Sam Castiglia | Victor | 2020 | G | |
| Enrique Castillo | Newark | 2018 | M | Keuka |
| Yaudi Castillo | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | M | |
| Yaudi Castillo | Batavia | 2021 | M | |
| Chris Castle | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Cole Castle | Penn Yan | 2009 | A | |
| Thomas Castle | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Roark Castner | Penn Yan | 2023 | D | |
| Austin Castre | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Patrick Castrechini | Pal-Mac | 2026 | G/D | |
| Manny Castro | Penfield | 2026 | 0 | |
| Chris Caswell | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Anthony Catalano | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Brecken Catalano | Pittsford | 2020 | G | |
| Gavin Catalano | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | G | |
| Gavin Catalano | Pittsford | 2017 | G | St John`s |
| Jon Catalano | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | D | |
| Mario Catalano | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | G | |
| Tyler Catalano | Wayne | 2020 | D | |
| Tyler Catalfano | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | G | Morrisville |
| Grant Catalino | Schroeder | 2007 | A | Maryland |
| Mike Catalino | Schroeder | 2005 | M | Duke |
| Josh Catanese | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | DM | |
| Giorgio Catanzaro | Gananda | 2023 | G | |
| Mike Catanzaro | Penfield | 2010 | D | |
| Mike Caternolo | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | D | Brockport |
| Geoff Catlin | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Quentin Cato | Gates Chili | 2024 | A | |
| Richard Cato | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | Maryville |
| Tim Cato | UPrep | 2017 | D | |
| Alex Caton | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | D | Hobart |
| Jonathan Caton | East Rochester | 2012 | G | |
| Nick Caton | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | M | Jacksonville |
| Tim Caton | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | D | Sacred Heart |
| Jon Catone | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | A | |
| Nick Catone | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | D | |
| Brendan Caufield | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | G | |
| Dan Caufield | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | G | Plattsburgh |
| Sean Caufield | Fairport | 2010 | D | |
| Jesse Caulkins | Schroeder | 2012 | A | |
| Keefer Caulkins | Haverling | 2022 | M | |
| Jayden Cauwels | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | M | |
| Jordan Cauwels | Livonia | 2014 | G | |
| Tim Cavagnaro | Greece Arc_Oly | 2006 | D | |
| Michael Cavallaro | Gates Chili | 2016 | G | |
| Travis Cavender | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | D | |
| Braeden Caviness | Gananda | 2025 | M | |
| Aiden Cawley | Hilton | 2023 | M | VMI |
| Matthew Ceballo | Gates Chili | 2023 | G | |
| Cameron Cecere | Aquinas | 2018 | M | John Carroll |
| Aiden Ceci | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | M | |
| Killian Ceci | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | M | Seton Hill |
| John Cedeno | Brockport | 2026 | D | |
| Julian Cenzi | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Michael Cerame | Aquinas | 2024 | G/D | |
| Craig Cercone | Greece | 2005 | M | |
| Christian Cerda | Penfield | 2021 | A | |
| Preston Cerda | Penfield | 2020 | A | |
| Tristian Cerda | Eastridge | 2018 | M | |
| Andrew Chadwick | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | A/M | |
| Jim Chaffer | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2017 | M | |
| Eli Chalmers | Aquinas | 2019 | A | |
| Eli Chalmers | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | A | |
| Ethan Chalmers | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Max Chamberlain | Hilton | 2018 | M | |
| Alex Chambers | Aquinas | 2008 | D | |
| Carter Chambers | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | D | |
| Chris Chambers | Pittsford | 2007 | M | |
| Carter Champion | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Jon Champion | Eastridge | 2007 | D | |
| Jordan Champion | Eastridge | 2008 | D | |
| Ross Champlin | Schroeder | 2025 | LSM | |
| Brandon Chan | Avon | 2014 | D | |
| Zachary Chang | Eastridge | 2014 | A | |
| Connor Chans | Penfield | 2018 | G | |
| Adam Chapman | Marcus Whitman | 2009 | A | |
| Brian Chapman | Victor | 2008 | M | |
| Chip Chapman | Batavia | 2010 | M | GCC |
| Dom Chapman | Pal-Mac | 2010 | M | |
| Ian Chapman | Batavia | 2008 | A | |
| James Chapman | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | LSM | |
| Jeff Chapman | Haverling | 2012 | M | |
| Jon Chapman | Canandaigua | 2016 | D | Oswego |
| Patrick Chapman | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Luke Charlesworth | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Joe Charnley | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Angus Chase | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | M | |
| Cam Chase | Thomas | 2025 | A | |
| Carter Chase | Thomas | 2027 | M | |
| Tim Chase | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | DM | |
| Brock Chasey | Gananda | 2022 | A/M | |
| Logan Chasey | Gananda | 2019 | D | Potsdam |
| Steven Chau | Bishop Kearney | 2027 | M | |
| Alvaro Chavez | Penn Yan | 2018 | D | |
| Jeremy Chavez | Waterloo | 2013 | D | |
| Eric Chavoustie | Schroeder | 2006 | A | |
| Christine Checo | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Brandon Cheeseman | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | D | |
| Alex Cheesin | Brighton | 2011 | D | |
| Alexander Chefalo | Gates Chili | 2012 | LSM | |
| Simon Chelebian | Brighton | 2005 | M | |
| Charlie Cheney | Canandaigua | 2021 | A | |
| Matt Cheney | Midlakes | 2018 | A | |
| Tom Cheney | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| Jimmy Cherry | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | G | |
| Jimmy Cherry | Batavia | 2016 | G | |
| Vic Cheruban | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | D | |
| John Cherwonik | Brockport | 2016 | M | |
| Samuel Cherwonik | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Andy Chester | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | D | |
| Alex Chiara | Livonia | 2012 | A | FLCC |
| Jake Chiarelli | Aquinas | 2021 | M | |
| Paul Chiariello | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | A | |
| Corey Chiccino | Gananda | 2018 | D | |
| Joey Chiccino | Gananda | 2021 | M | |
| Jake Chichester | Livonia | 2014 | M/A | |
| Nicholas Chilano | Greece Arc_Oly | 2019 | G | |
| Nicholas Chilano | Greece Storm | 2019 | G | |
| Andrew Chilbert | Geneva | 2017 | M | |
| Ben Chilbert | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Jake Chilbert | Geneva | 2017 | M | |
| Nate Chilbert | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Jeremiah Childs | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Justin Childs | Waterloo | 2010 | D | |
| Sasha Childs | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | M | |
| Sasha Childs | Batavia | 2021 | M | |
| Dylan Chilson | Waterloo | 2010 | M | |
| Colin Chimera | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | M | |
| John Peter Chinelly | Aquinas | 2018 | G | |
| Kyle Chipariano | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | M | |
| Dakoda Chirico | Pal-Mac | 2015 | D | |
| Derek Chisom | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | Keuka |
| Ben Chissom | Haverling | 2009 | D | |
| John Choate | Spencerport | 2023 | M | |
| Charles Chodack | Irondequoit | 2021 | G | |
| Luke Choffin | Geneva | 2022 | D | Brockport |
| Trevor Cholowsky | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | M | |
| Matt Christ | Pal-Mac | 2005 | A | |
| Mike Christ | Pal-Mac | 2007 | A | |
| Derek Christensen | Penn Yan | 2004 | D | Keuka |
| Nate Christensen | Penn Yan | 2014 | D | |
| Teddy Christensen-Cook | Geneva | 2020 | A | |
| Max Christiaansen | Midlakes | 2019 | A | |
| Travis Christine | Gates Chili | 2017 | D | |
| Mareck Christman | Schroeder | 2020 | M | |
| Mike Christman | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Payton Christman | Eastridge | 2015 | G | |
| Tim Christmas | East Rochester | 2010 | M | |
| Anthony Christopher | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | D | |
| Mike Chudyk | Schroeder | 2017 | LSM | |
| Pat Churchill | Mynderse | 2007 | M | |
| Cris Ciaccia | Hilton | 2005 | M | |
| Christian Cianflone | Pittsford | 2010 | D | |
| Cole Ciao | Spencerport | 2027 | M | |
| Brennan Cicchetti | Gates Chili | 2021 | G | |
| Jon Cicero | Midlakes | 2017 | M | |
| Michael Cichetti | Canandaigua | 2020 | D | |
| Zack Ciejek | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | A | |
| John Cifaratta | Mynderse | 2012 | M | |
| Frankie Ciliberto | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Thomas Cincebox | Pittsford | 2017 | D | Nazareth |
| Connor Cincotta | Penn Yan | 2011 | A | |
| Joey Cinquino | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | M/FO | |
| John Cintineo | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | M | |
| Mike Cintineo | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | A | Geneseo |
| Tyler Cippilone | Hilton | 2014 | LSM | |
| Nick Cira | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Cam Cirella | Schroeder | 2017 | A/M | |
| Eric Ciresi | Brockport | 2006 | D | |
| Cam Cirincione | Thomas | 2013 | DM | |
| Jason Cirulli | Schroeder | 2005 | M | St John Fisher |
| Caleb Cisco | Mynderse | 2017 | D | |
| Cody Cisco | Livonia | 2012 | A | |
| Chris Ciufo | Livonia | 2007 | D | |
| Aaron Civalier | Penfield | 2004 | M | Nazareth |
| Nolan Civiletti | Hilton | 2017 | A | |
| George Claery | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | |
| Beckham Clancy | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | G | |
| Ian Clancy | Waterloo | 2010 | D | |
| Alec Clanton | Aquinas | 2013 | M | |
| Brendon Clar | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | A | |
| Alex Clark | Penfield | 2021 | D | |
| Andrew Clark | Haverling | 2012 | G | |
| Anthony Clark | Mynderse | 2007 | A | |
| Ayden Clark | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | A | |
| Brandon Clark | Haverling | 2017 | D | Keuka |
| Brandon Clark | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | LSM | |
| Bret Clark | Hilton | 2007 | M | |
| Colby Clark | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | |
| Curtis Clark | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | D | |
| Dayshaun Clark | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Gavin Clark | Schroeder | 2006 | D | |
| Gavin Clark | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | LSM | |
| Ian Clark | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | M | |
| Jakari Clark | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Kyle Clark | Haverling | 2013 | A | |
| Leon Clark | Haverling | 2020 | D | |
| Liam Clark | Brighton | 2026 | DM | |
| Maddux Clark | Haverling | 2024 | M | |
| Matt Clark | Hilton | 2011 | M | |
| Mike Clark | Mynderse | 2011 | A | |
| Mitch Clark | Irondequoit | 2008 | DM | |
| Nayshaun Clark | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Steven Clark | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | |
| Tanner Clark | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | D | |
| Tyler Clark | Gates Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Chandler Clarke | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | A | |
| Gavin Clarke | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | LSM | |
| Noah Clarke | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | A | |
| Reverdy Clarke | Avon | 2019 | M | |
| Reverdy Clarke | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | M | |
| Andrew Clarkowski | Bishop Kearney | 2010 | G | |
| Chris Clasgens | Brighton | 2018 | D | |
| Ronan Class | Livonia-Avon | 2027 | D | |
| Juan Claudio | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M/A | |
| Jacob Claus | Pittsford | 2022 | D | Hartwick |
| Joe Clay | Penfield | 2006 | D | |
| Cody Clement | Pal-Mac | 2007 | A | |
| Jake Clement | Canandaigua | 2015 | D | |
| Matt Clement | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | |
| Liam Clements | Livonia | 2015 | D | |
| Matt Clements | Victor | 2016 | A | |
| Taylor Clements | Newark | 2018 | A | |
| Elliot Clemmons | Aquinas | 2016 | M | |
| Caden Clemons | Hilton | 2020 | M | |
| Matt Clemons | Newark | 2008 | A | MCC |
| Shane Cleveland | Penfield | 2009 | D | |
| Alex Cliff | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Aaron Clifford | Thomas | 2009 | M | |
| Bryan Clifford | Thomas | 2007 | D | Keuka |
| Jay Clifford | Hilton | 2008 | M | |
| Aiden Clinkscales | Victor | 2024 | M | SUNY Stony Brook |
| Steven Clinkscales | Irondequoit | 2025 | M/A | |
| Justin Closser | Pal-Mac | 2018 | M/A | |
| Kevin Clough | Fairport | 2018 | A | |
| Jerrod Clowes | Irondequoit | 2009 | D | |
| Armand Cnockaert | Waterloo | 2012 | M | |
| Team Coach | Fairport | 2014 | A | |
| Greg Coady | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Mike Coady | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Dan Cobb | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | A | |
| Matt Cobb | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | G | Alfred State |
| Tom Cobo | Spencerport | 2012 | A | |
| Jordon Cochrane | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | LSM | |
| Nick Cocilova | Penfield | 2012 | D | |
| Ricky Cocilova | Hilton | 2014 | M | |
| Rob Cocilova | Hilton | 2006 | M | |
| Jake Codding | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Bill Cody | Newark | 2013 | M | |
| Grant Cody | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Jaxxon Cody | Churchville-Chili | 2025 | D | |
| Lee Cody | Victor | 2007 | A | |
| Michael Cody | Gates Chili | 2019 | G | |
| Gianmarco Coelho | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | G | |
| Dylan Coene | Wayne | 2023 | G | |
| Anthony Coffaro | Eastridge | 2013 | A | |
| Michael Coffaro | Thomas | 2012 | M | |
| Blake Cognata | Fairport | 2013 | D | |
| Cooper Cohen | Brighton | 2022 | M | |
| Matan Cohen | Brighton | 2010 | A | |
| Drew Coholan | Irondequoit | 2009 | A | Hofstra |
| Greg Coholan | Irondequoit | 2011 | A | Virginia |
| Kevin Coholan | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Mike Coholan | Irondequoit | 2017 | M | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Leo Cohrs | Geneva | 2024 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Noah Coiro | Irondequoit | 2017 | M | OCC |
| Henry Coke | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | St Bonaventure |
| Max Coke | Brighton | 2016 | A | |
| Jullien Cokely | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | A | |
| Cam Colacino | Midlakes | 2013 | D | |
| Brett Colbert | Penfield | 2016 | A | |
| Anthony Cole | Newark | 2006 | G | |
| Anthony Cole | Brighton | 2016 | D | |
| Dennis Cole | Victor | 2025 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Mike Cole | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | M | |
| Owen Cole | Eastridge | 2020 | D | |
| Owen Cole | East United | 2020 | D | |
| Shane Cole | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Sheldon Cole | Brighton | 2015 | M | |
| Sheldon Cole | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | M | |
| Steve Cole | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | G | |
| Zach Colegrove | Haverling | 2026 | A | |
| Andrew Coleman | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | A | |
| Brad Coleman | Thomas | 2023 | D | |
| Cody Coleman | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | A | |
| Joe Coleman | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Jordan Coleman | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | D | |
| Shane Coleman | Wayne | 2027 | A | |
| Zachery Coleman | Waterloo | 2021 | D | |
| Christian Coler | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Jake Colf | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2021 | M | |
| Jesse Colf | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | LSM | |
| Knight Colin | Schroeder | 2025 | M | |
| Austin Collett | Midlakes | 2009 | M | Hilbert |
| Austin Colletta | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M/D | |
| Dominic Collichio | Hilton | 2005 | G | Neumann |
| Tyler Colligan | Thomas | 2017 | M | |
| Drew Collins | Victor | 2016 | A | Lycoming |
| Kyle Collins | Victor | 2014 | A | |
| Markell Collins | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Nick Collins | Newark | 2012 | M/A | |
| Pat Collins | Victor | 2011 | A | |
| Teddy Collins | Newark | 2015 | A/M | |
| Will Collins | Newark | 2005 | M | |
| Zach Collins | Victor | 2021 | A | |
| Bryan Collister | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | M/A | |
| Hunter Colomaio | Haverling | 2019 | A | |
| Giancarlo Colon | Newark | 2024 | DM | |
| Nico Colon | Waterloo | 2016 | D | |
| Cam Colt | Avon | 2020 | G/D | |
| Tyler Colton | Waterloo | 2018 | A | |
| Nicholas Colucci | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | M | RPI |
| Noah Colvin | Mynderse | 2019 | M | |
| Joey Colyer | Victor | 2018 | M | |
| Brady Comella | Canandaigua | 2022 | D | Hobart |
| Dom Comella | Canandaigua | 2021 | M | RIT |
| Trey Comella | Canandaigua | 2025 | M | |
| Cameron Comer | Batavia | 2013 | G/D | |
| Hunter Commissso | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | D | |
| Joe Como | Canandaigua | 2015 | M | |
| Nick Como | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | |
| Austin Conaway | Marcus Whitman | 2016 | D | |
| Sean Conaway | Marcus Whitman | 2019 | D | |
| Kaleb Condello | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | D | |
| John Condon | Penfield | 2016 | M | Oswego |
| Luke Condon | Penfield | 2020 | M | |
| Matt Condon | Penfield | 2012 | M | St John Fisher |
| Mike Condon | Victor | 2005 | D | |
| Sean Condon | Canandaigua | 2013 | D | |
| Sean Cone | Victor | 2008 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Ethan Conger | Schroeder | 2021 | M | |
| Garrett Conger | Schroeder | 2025 | M | |
| Hunter Conger | Waterloo | 2024 | D | |
| Cam Congilaro | Hilton | 2012 | DM | |
| Dan Conklin | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | D | |
| Gavin Conlan | Aquinas | 2021 | G | Lake Erie |
| Josh Conley | Penn Yan | 2013 | A | |
| Spencer Conley | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | LSM | |
| Jacob Connell | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | M | |
| James Connelly | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | M | Alfred |
| John Connelly | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | DM | |
| Justin Connelly | Batavia | 2018 | M/A | |
| Kevin Connelly | Irondequoit | 2010 | D | |
| Liam Connelly | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | M/A | |
| Oliver Connelly | Penn Yan | 2022 | M | |
| Correy Conners | Batavia | 2014 | M | |
| Jared Conners | Pittsford | 2016 | D | Virginia |
| Jesse Conners | Pittsford | 2015 | M | |
| Max Conners | Pittsford | 2022 | M | |
| Andrew Connolly | Spencerport | 2011 | M | |
| Justin Connolly | Schroeder | 2018 | A | |
| Nate Connolly | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | M | |
| Ryan Connolly | Pittsford | 2025 | D | |
| Stephen Connolly | Schroeder | 2018 | D | |
| Ben Connor | Pittsford | 2009 | M | |
| Bryan Connor | Pittsford | 2013 | D | |
| Matthew Connor | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | M/A | |
| Wil Connors | Pittsford | 2021 | M | |
| Aidan Conolly | Spencerport | 2014 | M | |
| Curtis Conrad | Haverling | 2021 | M | |
| Zac Conrad | Haverling | 2006 | A | |
| Sean Conroy | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | M | |
| Jamie Consler | Pal-Mac | 2009 | A | |
| Robert Consolvo | Gates Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Alec Constable | Penfield | 2022 | A | Le Moyne |
| Cody Consul | Schroeder | 2010 | A | Cortland |
| Ryan Conti | Brighton | 2007 | M | |
| Mike Converse | Pal-Mac | 2007 | D | |
| Josh Conversi | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | D | |
| Dan Conway | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | D | |
| Kevin Conway | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | A | |
| Landon Conyers | Fairport | 2023 | DM | |
| Andrew Cook | Hilton | 2018 | A | |
| Ben Cook | Schroeder | 2024 | D | |
| Ben Cook | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | D | RIT |
| Danny Cook | Avon | 2019 | M/FO | |
| Geoffrey Cook | Fairport | 2006 | D | Nazareth |
| James Cook | Pittsford | 2022 | A | |
| Jarrett Cook | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Jordan Cook | Waterloo | 2009 | D | Herkimer |
| Kenneth Cook | Batavia | 2012 | LSM | |
| Riley Cook | Pal-Mac | 2020 | M | |
| Ryan Cook | Penn Yan | 2007 | A | |
| Ryan Cook | Waterloo | 2016 | M | |
| Tanner Cook | Batavia-Attica | 2017 | M | |
| Tanner Cook | Batavia | 2018 | M | |
| Timothy Cook | Fairport | 2009 | M | Brockport |
| Travis Cook | Waterloo | 2012 | D | |
| Zack Cook | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | D | |
| Ben Cooley | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | D | |
| Caleb Cooley | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | D | |
| Zac Cooley | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Zac Cooley | Pittsford | 2015 | M | Le Moyne |
| Dominic Coon | Livonia | 2015 | A | |
| Jake Coon | Schroeder | 2017 | D | |
| Logan Coon | Pal-Mac | 2021 | M/D | |
| Kyle Cooney | Victor | 2025 | DM | |
| Zach Cooney | Victor | 2023 | A | |
| Cullen Coons | Livonia | 2018 | A/M | |
| Cullen Coons | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | A/M | |
| Nate Coons | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | D | |
| Billy Cooper | Pittsford | 2014 | A | St Lawrence |
| Evan Cooper | Pal-Mac | 2023 | D | |
| Garret Cooper | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | A/M | |
| Garrett Cooper | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | A/M | |
| Gary Cooper | Greece Storm | 2024 | M | |
| Matt Cooper | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | M | St John Fisher |
| Omarri Cooper | Gananda | 2020 | G | |
| Preston Cooper | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | M | |
| Taz Cooper | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| Timmy Cooper | Pittsford | 2012 | M | |
| Ethan Copeland | Aquinas | 2025 | M | |
| Larry Copeland | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Tim Copeland | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | D | |
| Travis Copp | Mynderse | 2015 | D | |
| Andrew Coppeta | Hilton | 2025 | D | |
| Wally Cora | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | D | |
| Pierce Corbelli | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | D | |
| Bailey Corbett | Eastridge | 2016 | M/A | |
| Aidan Corbitt | Brighton | 2010 | M | |
| Brandon Corcoran | Batavia | 2011 | D | |
| Jack Corcoran | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | G | Potsdam |
| Jacob Corcoran | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | D | |
| Marty Corcoran | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | A | |
| Ryan Cordaro | Irondequoit | 2006 | D | |
| Jorge (Tito) Cordero | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | M | |
| Andrew Cordes | Irondequoit | 2012 | D | Towson |
| Jared Cordon | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | M | |
| James Coriale | Penn Yan | 2007 | M | |
| Colin Cornaire | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | M | MCC |
| Elliott Cornaire | Haverling | 2006 | D | |
| Kevin Cornelia | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | M | |
| Cody Cornelius | Newark | 2013 | G | |
| Elisander Cornier | Aquinas | 2016 | M | |
| Derrick Cornish | Haverling | 2021 | M | |
| Devin Cornish | Haverling | 2024 | M | |
| Timmy Cornish | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | A | |
| Ethan Corona | Spencerport | 2016 | G | |
| Joe Corona | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Nolan Corrigan | Avon | 2014 | M | |
| Cameron Corsaro | Aquinas | 2009 | A | |
| Grant Corsaro | Aquinas | 2006 | M | |
| Jordan Corter | Brockport | 2021 | A | |
| Evan Corteville | Newark | 2015 | D | Ohio Northern |
| Juan Cortez | Haverling | 2009 | D | |
| Brock Corwin | Victor | 2020 | G | |
| Kyle Cosentino | Geneva | 2014 | M | |
| Ryan Cosgrove | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | A | Le Moyne |
| Nick Cosmano | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | G | |
| Nathan Costantino | Waterloo | 2023 | A | |
| Nick Costantino | Waterloo | 2017 | M | |
| Dennis Costanza | Schroeder | 2006 | G | Geneseo |
| Tom Costanza | Schroeder | 2005 | A | Geneseo |
| Brandon Costanzo | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | |
| Joe Costello | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | D | |
| Carter Coston | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | D | |
| Raiden Cota | Pal-Mac | 2024 | UTIL | |
| Ryan Cotroneo | Victor | 2007 | A | |
| Seth Cottengim | Fairport | 2016 | D | |
| Chris Cottom | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Brady Cotton | Victor | 2006 | D | Buffalo |
| Sean Cottrell | Schroeder | 2019 | M | Wells |
| Donovan Coughlin | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Kenny Council | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | D | |
| Jacob Cournoyer | Irondequoit | 2011 | D | |
| Lucas Courtney | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Sam Covell | Fairport | 2010 | A | |
| Ben Covert | Penn Yan | 2015 | M | |
| Jake Covert | Penn Yan | 2015 | D | |
| Blain Covey | Waterloo | 2013 | M/D | |
| Dale Covey | Waterloo | 2006 | D | |
| Kyle Covley | Penfield | 2012 | LSM | |
| Andy Cowan | Batavia | 2008 | M | |
| Nick Cowie | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | A | |
| Ryan Cowles | Waterloo | 2009 | M | |
| Connor Cox | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Zach Cox | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | G | |
| Danny Coyne | Pittsford | 2027 | D | |
| James Coyne | Newark | 2006 | M | |
| Billy Craft | Geneva | 2009 | G | FLCC |
| Isaac Craft | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | G | Wells |
| Griffin Craig | Irondequoit | 2014 | D | |
| McGuire Craig | Irondequoit | 2019 | D | |
| Tanner Craig | Irondequoit | 2013 | D | |
| Schuyler Crain | Pittsford | 2018 | M | |
| Kyle Craine | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | D | |
| Robert Craine | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | G/D | |
| Dom Crance | Midlakes | 2020 | A | |
| Matt Crandall | Schroeder | 2005 | D | Le Moyne |
| Cody Crane | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | G | |
| Hunter Crane | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2018 | D | |
| Rowen Crane | Gates Chili | 2022 | LSM | |
| Dylan Crary | Irondequoit | 2005 | G | MCC |
| Ryan Crater | Fairport | 2014 | A | John Carroll |
| Ben Cratsley | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Anthony Crawford | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | A | |
| Ben Crawford | Fairport | 2018 | A | |
| Cole Crawford | Wayne | 2015 | D | |
| Jon Crawford | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | G | |
| Mike Crawford | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | A | |
| Zach Crawford | Thomas | 2010 | M | |
| Jabari Crayon | UPrep | 2016 | M | |
| Jack Creatura | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Steven Cregan | Brighton | 2011 | M | Geneseo |
| Austyn Crego | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | D | |
| James Creighton | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Sergio Crespo | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | D | |
| Troy Crevier | Thomas | 2012 | M | |
| Fred Crilly | Penfield | 2011 | M | |
| Logan Crisp | Geneva | 2018 | A | |
| Adam Crist | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Andrew Crocker | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | A | |
| Joey Crocker | Gates Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Nicholas Crocker | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Tommy Crocker | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | A/M | |
| Bryson Croft | Newark | 2021 | A | |
| Matt Cronk | Fairport | 2019 | M/FO | |
| Shane Cronkwright | Fairport | 2014 | M | |
| Vinny Cropo | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | D | |
| Griffin Cross | Pittsford | 2018 | G | |
| Harrison Cross | Pittsford | 2021 | A | Williams |
| Jack Cross | Canandaigua | 2019 | D | |
| Tyler Crough | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | D | |
| Pat Crowe | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | A | |
| Jim Crowell | Livonia | 2007 | M | |
| Andrew Crowley | Fairport | 2025 | A | |
| Jay Crowley | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | |
| Jayson Crowley | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | LSM | |
| Nate Crowley | Irondequoit | 2017 | M | |
| Rob Crowley | Fairport | 2021 | M | |
| Eric Crumb | Wayne | 2015 | M | |
| Pat Crumb | Spencerport | 2009 | M | |
| Mike Crumlish | Hilton | 2009 | A | |
| Jayce Cruz | Newark | 2012 | M | |
| xRey Cruz-Colon | East United-Eastridge | 2026 | A | |
| Jonathan Crye | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | D | |
| Jonah Crystler | Gates Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Phillip Cubiotti | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | A | |
| Michael Cuciti | Canandaigua | 2013 | G | |
| Bryan Cuckovich | Hilton | 2010 | D | |
| Ethan Cudzilo | Schroeder | 2007 | M | |
| John Culhane | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Jack Cullen | Greece Storm | 2021 | D | |
| Jamie Cullen | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | G | |
| Mitchell Culver | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | Nazareth |
| Taylor Culver | Newark | 2009 | M | FLCC |
| Eli Cummings | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Jack Cummings | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Quintin Cummings | Batavia | 2024 | M | |
| Quintin Cummings | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | A/M | |
| Sam Cummings | Penfield | 2021 | A | |
| Charlie Cummins | Penfield | 2013 | D | Tampa |
| Mike Cummins | Penfield | 2006 | M | St John Fisher |
| Brett Cunningham | Gananda | 2018 | A | MCC |
| James Cunningham | Fairport | 2010 | LSM | Hobart |
| Jason Cunningham | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Jason Cunningham | Hilton | 2027 | D | |
| Ryan Cunningham | Canandaigua | 2005 | D | Loyola |
| Sean Cunningham | Geneva | 2013 | M | Hobart |
| Theo Cup | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| Lucas Cupelli | Geneva | 2019 | A | |
| Connor Cupp | Haverling | 2018 | A | |
| Hunter Cupp | Haverling | 2021 | M | Alfred |
| Jacob Cupp | Haverling | 2016 | G | |
| Steven Curci | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | |
| Joe Curcio | Spencerport | 2018 | D | |
| Conner Curley | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Owen Curley | Gates Chili | 2024 | A | |
| Jake Curran | Mynderse | 2017 | A | |
| John Curran | Midlakes | 2018 | D | |
| Nick Curran | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | D | |
| Pierce Currie | Thomas | 2016 | A | Clarkson |
| Reed Currie | Thomas | 2020 | M | St John Fisher |
| Fendi Curry | Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Fendi Curry | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Tanner Curtis | Gananda | 2013 | M | |
| Joe Curtone | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | M | |
| Bruce Curwin | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | D | |
| Thomas Curyto | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Blake Cusse | Aquinas | 2025 | D | |
| Tyler Cusse | Hilton | 2014 | G | |
| Nick Cutrona | Hilton | 2015 | D | |
| Ben Cutter | Brighton | 2019 | D | |
| William Czebatol | Hilton | 2019 | D | |
| Jake Czwilinski | Eastridge | 2009 | G | |
| Eamon D-Kane | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | LSM | |
| Kevin Dacey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | M | |
| Ryan Dacey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Kal Dachtler | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | M | MCC |
| Brody Daciw | Gananda | 2029 | M | |
| Tucker Daddis | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | M | |
| Rhett Daggar | Fairport | 2019 | A/M | |
| Mac Dailey | Brighton | 2007 | M | |
| O`Brien Dailey | Penn Yan | 2017 | A | |
| Tyler Dailey | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2016 | A | |
| Tyler Dailey | Avon | 2020 | D | |
| Tyson Dailey | Victor | 2020 | D | |
| A.J. Daily | Waterloo | 2008 | D | |
| Steve Daily | Haverling | 2007 | M | |
| Killian Dainard | Pal-Mac | 2017 | A | |
| Matt Dakin | Gates Chili | 2011 | A | |
| John Dalberth | Livonia | 2006 | A | |
| Owen Dalberth | Thomas | 2022 | G | Alfred |
| Ty Dalberth | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Ben Dale | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| Logan Dale | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | D | |
| Sully Dale | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | A/M | |
| Paul Dalessio | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | G | |
| Tyler Dalle | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | A | Belmont Abbey |
| Tyler Dalle | Hilton | 2017 | M | |
| Jack Dallo | Gates Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Chris Dalton | Thomas | 2012 | D | |
| Gehrig Dalton | Mynderse | 2023 | D | |
| Gerhig Dalton | Mynderse | 2023 | D | |
| Justin Dalton | Pal-Mac | 2009 | M | |
| Nicholas Dalton | Thomas | 2004 | M | |
| Carson Daly | Brockport | 2018 | M | |
| Conor Daly | Victor | 2006 | M | |
| Dean Damon | Livonia | 2014 | D | |
| Jaheim Dana | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M/A | |
| Jaheim Dana | Batavia | 2020 | M/A | |
| Tyler Dancause | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | M | |
| Paul Dancy | Fairport | 2009 | M | |
| Jason Dang | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | |
| Mike Danylyshyn | Fairport | 2007 | A | Bucknell |
| Stephen Danylyshyn | Fairport | 2011 | A/M | Ithaca |
| Ryan Danzig | Hilton | 2019 | M | |
| Gavin Darks | Brighton | 2034 | 0 | |
| Matt Darnieder | Penfield | 2005 | D | RIT |
| Matthew Darrow | Spencerport | 2007 | M | |
| Erik Dash | Victor | 2015 | A | Pittsburgh |
| Ryan Daucher | Geneva | 2015 | D | SUNY Poly |
| Dan Daugherty | Gates Chili | 2011 | M | |
| James Daum | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Peter Daum | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Sheldon Daunce | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | A | |
| Robert Dauphinee | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Drew Davenport | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Sean Davern | Irondequoit | 2008 | D | Cortland |
| Rowan Davey | Greece Storm | 2026 | D | |
| Doug David | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Eric Davids | Mynderse | 2006 | M | |
| Connor Davidson | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Germaine Davidson | Eastridge | 2006 | D | |
| Joe Davidson | Eastridge | 2012 | A | |
| Matt Davidson | Hilton | 2008 | D | Clarkson |
| Tim Davidson | Eastridge | 2009 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Jake Davies | Brockport | 2019 | A/M | |
| Tyler Davies | Brockport | 2020 | M | |
| Valentino Davila Penaloza | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | A | |
| A.J. Davis | Thomas | 2004 | G | Oswego |
| Alex Davis | Victor | 2012 | D | |
| Cole Davis | Brockport | 2023 | A | |
| Cole Davis | Brockport | 2024 | M/FO | |
| Colin Davis | Brighton | 2006 | A | MCC |
| Corey Davis | Livonia | 2008 | D | |
| Evan Davis | Brighton | 2009 | M | Jacksonville |
| Hayden Davis | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Ian Davis | Batavia | 2013 | D | |
| Jake Davis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | D | Lycoming |
| Kellen Davis | Penfield | 2022 | M | |
| Ryan Davis | Penfield | 2023 | M | |
| Tyler Davis | Brockport | 2026 | M | |
| Rion Davison | Penn Yan | 2014 | A/M | Hartford |
| Zach Davison | Midlakes | 2017 | G | |
| Adam Davoli | Waterloo | 2009 | D/G | SUNY Delhi |
| Ricky Dawley | Midlakes | 2006 | M | |
| Garrett Day | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | |
| Jakob Day | Pal-Mac | 2022 | D | Hartwick |
| Tanner Day | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | |
| TJ Day | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | MCC |
| Trevor Day | Batavia | 2012 | A | |
| Jonas Deacon | Marcus Whitman | 2019 | A | |
| Jamison Deal | Mynderse | 2013 | D | |
| Justin Deal | Waterloo | 2007 | A/M | |
| Joe Dean | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Matt Dean | Penn Yan | 2011 | M | |
| Santana Deanda | Wayne | 2015 | LSM | |
| Travis Dear | Schroeder | 2020 | M | |
| Jack Dearcop | Pittsford | 2018 | A | |
| Jonathan Deats | Haverling | 2018 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Jordon Deats | Haverling | 2020 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Michael DeBalso | Schroeder | 2024 | D | |
| Charlie DeBiase | Pittsford | 2022 | D | St John Fisher |
| Marco DeBole | Schroeder | 2013 | A | |
| Pat DeBolt | Waterloo | 2005 | G | Hofstra |
| Jeff Debona | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Joey DeBonis | Aquinas | 2020 | D | |
| Mason Debottis | Victor | 2025 | M | |
| Wyatt DeCann | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | D | |
| Alec DeCarlo | Victor | 2015 | M | |
| Ethan DeCarlo | Marcus Whitman | 2022 | D | |
| Alex Decker | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | D | |
| Patrick Decker | Spencerport | 2007 | A | Oswego |
| Nick Deckert | Midlakes | 2020 | D | |
| Dan Declerk | Victor | 2012 | D | |
| Dave DeCocq | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | A | Hilbert |
| Jack Dedrick | Canandaigua | 2026 | D | |
| Sean Deegan | Schroeder | 2010 | D | |
| Nolan Deehan | Pittsford | 2023 | G | |
| Tim Defendis | Fairport | 2020 | G | |
| Anthony DeFrancesco | Waterloo | 2019 | A | |
| Luke DeGaetano | Canandaigua | 2013 | M | Canton |
| Erich Dehm | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2004 | M | Geneseo |
| Jake DeHond | Thomas | 2015 | D | |
| Chris Deisenroth | Thomas | 2013 | M/D | |
| Collin Deisenroth | Thomas | 2017 | G | |
| Derek DeJoe | Fairport | 2012 | A/M | Syracuse |
| Drew DeJohn | Newark | 2010 | M/D | |
| Connor DeJoy | Victor | 2015 | LSM | |
| Mitchell Dekanski | Mynderse | 2022 | A | |
| Brady Del Pozzo | Penfield | 2009 | G | |
| Steven Del Vecchio | Eastridge | 2012 | D | |
| Hunter Delaney | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2020 | D | |
| Jake Delaney | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Jeff Delaney | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | G | |
| Owen Delaney | Pittsford | 2023 | M | |
| Hunter DeLany | Brockport | 2012 | G | |
| Connor Delavak | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | D | |
| Luke Delavak | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | LSM | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Noah Delcamp | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | M | |
| Zach deLeeuw | Avon | 2017 | A/M | |
| Anthony DeLeo | Canandaigua | 2009 | G | RIT |
| Antonio Deleo | Schroeder | 2017 | G | |
| Tony Deleo | Aquinas | 2017 | G | |
| Rocky Delfino | Aquinas | 2015 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Johnny DelForte | Canandaigua | 2016 | A | |
| Brian Delgado | East Rochester | 2013 | A | |
| Max Delgado | Geneva | 2027 | M | |
| Brad Delgatti | Hilton | 2009 | A | |
| Tyler Deline | Newark | 2022 | A/M | |
| Brian Dell | Penfield | 2006 | G | |
| Cory Della Stua | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | D | |
| Chris Dellavilla | Schroeder | 2008 | M | |
| Carson Delmarle | Pal-Mac | 2023 | M/D | |
| Mason Delmarle | Pal-Mac | 2026 | LSM | |
| Nate Delone | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | A | Nazareth |
| Jeff DeLong | Hilton | 2007 | M | |
| Jason DeLorenzo | Fairport | 2020 | A | |
| Andrew Delorme | Irondequoit | 2009 | D | |
| Dylan DeLorme | Fairport | 2016 | A/M | |
| Jake DeLorme | Fairport | 2014 | D | |
| Zach DeLorme | Irondequoit | 2022 | M | |
| Alex DelPozzo | Penfield | 2005 | M | |
| Payton Delrosa | Geneva | 2015 | M | |
| Dylan DeLucia | Waterloo | 2020 | A | Keuka |
| Nathan Delvecchio | Aquinas | 2018 | G | |
| William Delzell | Fairport | 2008 | M | |
| Austin DeMar | Schroeder | 2015 | G | |
| Mike DeMar | Pal-Mac | 2011 | A | St John Fisher |
| Zach Demar | Schroeder | 2017 | M | |
| Andrew DeMarco | Thomas | 2008 | M | |
| Mike DeMarco | Victor | 2016 | M | |
| Matt DeMay | Pal-Mac | 2010 | D | |
| Lucas DeMedeiros | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Anthony DeMeo | Pittsford | 2023 | M | Le Moyne |
| Sean DeMers | Spencerport | 2009 | M | |
| Jack DeMeyers | Pal-Mac | 2014 | G | |
| Benjamin Deming | Waterloo | 2016 | D | |
| Mason Demmer | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | A/M | |
| Mike Demmin | Penn Yan | 2010 | M | |
| Kyle Denhoff | Penfield | 2008 | M | St John Fisher |
| Keenan Denis | Schroeder | 2013 | M | |
| Jeremy Denisi | Midlakes | 2005 | M | |
| Curtis Denison | Geneva | 2022 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Brandon Dennie | Pal-Mac | 2026 | A/M | |
| Jackson Dennie | Pal-Mac | 2027 | A/M | |
| Tyler Dennie | Pal-Mac | 2013 | D | |
| Christian Dennis | Newark | 2018 | M | |
| Trevor Dennis | Aquinas | 2014 | M | |
| Cormac Denniston | Pal-Mac | 2026 | D | |
| John Denniston | Newark | 2012 | A | |
| Brian Denny | Fairport | 2008 | M | |
| Alex deNormand | Victor | 2015 | D | |
| Jeremy deNormand | Victor | 2018 | D | |
| Schuyler DePauw | Newark | 2008 | M/D | |
| Anthony Depetres | Spencerport | 2014 | A | |
| Anthony DePetres | Aquinas | 2014 | M | |
| Jimmy Depetres | Aquinas | 2017 | G | |
| Jordan DePetres | Hilton | 2018 | A | St John Fisher |
| Mason DePew | Canandaigua | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Steve Depew | Pal-Mac | 2006 | M | |
| Sam Deprez | Hilton | 2019 | DM | |
| Dave DeRaddo | Geneva | 2007 | D | St John Fisher |
| Jake DeReamer | Waterloo | 2013 | M | |
| Spencer DeRidder | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Ryan Derion | Fairport | 2019 | M | Potsdam |
| Peter Dermody | Canandaigua | 2013 | D | |
| Andrew Derooy | Spencerport | 2014 | D | |
| Jacob Derooy | Spencerport | 2012 | D | |
| Anthony DeRosa | Schroeder | 2024 | M | RIT |
| Kyle DeRosa | Fairport | 2009 | D | Oswego |
| Ryan DeRosa | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | |
| Kevin Derosier | Haverling | 2008 | M | |
| Nate Derue | Canandaigua | 2019 | G | |
| Tyler DeRue | Canandaigua | 2024 | G | |
| Egzon Dervisholli | East Rochester | 2013 | M | |
| Liridon Dervisholli | East Rochester | 2012 | G | |
| Kody Desain | Newark | 2019 | D | |
| Mike DeSain | Pal-Mac | 2020 | D | Alfred |
| Luca DeSandis | Brighton | 2025 | M/D | |
| Mike DeSantis | Eastridge | 2014 | M | |
| Ben DesCamp | Midlakes | 2008 | D | |
| Salvatore Desiato | Wayne | 2013 | M | |
| Mark Detroia | Hilton | 2013 | G | |
| Robert Dettman | Gananda | 2027 | M | |
| Kurt Detwiller | Thomas | 2006 | M | Nazareth |
| Zach Deuel | East Rochester | 2010 | D | |
| Michael DeVaney | Geneva | 2017 | A | |
| Owen Devaney | Geneva | 2026 | M | |
| Eli Devereaux | Schroeder | 2019 | A | |
| Will DeVinney | Bishop Kearney | 2016 | A | |
| Ethan DeWilde | Brockport | 2024 | D | |
| Jayden DeWilde | Brockport | 2021 | M | |
| Eric Dewind | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | D | |
| Michael DeWind | Fairport | 2017 | LSM | |
| Justin Dey | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | A | |
| Aiden DeYager | Churchville-Chili | 2027 | A | |
| Alec DeYoung | Schroeder | 2017 | LSM | |
| Michael Dhondt | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | G | |
| Peter Diak | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | D | |
| Anthony Diamantopoulos | Aquinas | 2010 | A | |
| Abe Diaz | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | D | |
| Alex Diaz | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | A | |
| Austin Diaz | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | M | |
| Brian Dibble | Thomas | 2013 | DM | |
| Ryan Dibble | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Justin Dibernardo | Thomas | 2012 | M | |
| Chris Dicesare | Irondequoit | 2016 | M | |
| Ethan DiCicco | Canandaigua | 2012 | A | |
| Tyler Dicicco | Waterloo | 2010 | A | |
| Chase Dickens | Victor | 2021 | M | |
| Andy Dickinson | Haverling | 2009 | D | |
| Brady Dickson | Haverling | 2022 | M | |
| Brandon Dickson | Haverling | 2013 | A | Alfred State |
| Cole Dickson | Mynderse | 2020 | D | |
| Eric Dickson | Haverling | 2010 | M | |
| Joe Didia | Schroeder | 2006 | M | |
| Connor DiDomineck | Haverling | 2018 | A | Alfred |
| Ian DiDomineck | Haverling | 2021 | A | |
| James DiDomineck | Haverling | 2016 | D | |
| Brian DiDona | Mynderse | 2009 | D | |
| Adam DiDuro | Canandaigua | 2005 | D | |
| Dominic DiDuro | Geneva | 2008 | M | |
| Gio DiDuro | Geneva | 2007 | M | |
| Riley Diegert | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | D | |
| Reid Diehl | Pal-Mac | 2027 | A/M | |
| Brett Diener | Livonia | 2013 | D | |
| Steven Diener | Livonia | 2011 | M | |
| Antonio DiEngeniis | Brockport | 2022 | G | MCC |
| Ronald Dietz | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | G | |
| Dylan DiFante | Schroeder | 2011 | M | Oswego |
| John DiFante | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Adam Difulvio | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | G | |
| Stephen DiFulvio | Spencerport | 2006 | M | |
| Matt DiGiambattista | Fairport | 2004 | D | |
| Ben DiGiovanni | Pittsford | 2020 | M | Dartmouth |
| Justin Digiovanni | Pittsford | 2025 | M | |
| Nick DiGrazia | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M/A | |
| Matt Dilak | Pittsford | 2012 | A | |
| John Dilal | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | D | |
| Pete DiLaura | Gates Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Pete DiLaura | Aquinas | 2012 | M | |
| Andrew Dill | Irondequoit | 2006 | D | |
| Braeden Dilley | Midlakes | 2017 | A | |
| Ryan Dillon | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | D/LSM | |
| Anthony DiMarco | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Michael DiMarco | Gates Chili | 2021 | M/FO | |
| Ryan DiMarco | Eastridge | 2017 | M | |
| Will DiMarco | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Joey DiMaria | Hilton | 2021 | A | Hilbert |
| Anthony DiMarsico | Fairport | 2005 | A | |
| Ross Dinan | Geneva | 2010 | G | |
| Bryce Dinehart | Penn Yan | 2015 | M | |
| Micah Dingman | Newark | 2009 | M | |
| Nicholas Dingman | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Troy Dingman | Canandaigua | 2023 | A | |
| Tyelor Dingman | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | |
| Spencer Dino | Waterloo | 2010 | A | |
| Drew DiPalma | Hilton | 2020 | M | Brockport |
| Gavin DiPaola | Irondequoit | 2018 | A | |
| Albie DiPasquale | Pittsford | 2013 | A | |
| Nino DiPasquale | Pittsford | 2012 | M | |
| Anthony DiPrima | Penfield | 2017 | LSM | |
| Hunter DiProsa | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | D | |
| Hunter DiProsa | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Mike DiProspero | Spencerport | 2008 | D | FLCC |
| Sam Dirisio | Penn Yan | 2014 | M | Alfred |
| Bryce Dirlam | Gananda | 2022 | A/M | |
| Joe Disalvo | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | Cobleskill |
| Joe DiSalvo | Eastridge | 2018 | A | |
| Mitchell DiSanto | Fairport | 2017 | A | |
| TJ DiSanto | Victor | 2012 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Steve DiSessa | Gates Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Steve Ditzel | Batavia | 2007 | A | |
| Miles Ditzell | Penn Yan | 2027 | G/M | |
| Dylan Dix | Gates Chili | 2013 | G | Lake Erie |
| Jack Dix | Aquinas | 2022 | A | |
| Riley Dix | Waterloo | 2020 | M | |
| Caden Dixon | Penn Yan | 2023 | M | |
| Kyle Dixon | Canandaigua | 2005 | D | |
| Ben Dlugosh | Pal-Mac | 2005 | G | Medaille |
| Shane Dobies | Canandaigua | 2009 | A | |
| Trevor Dobies | Canandaigua | 2014 | A | |
| Ben Dodds | Bishop Kearney | 2026 | M | |
| Ben Dodds | Wayne | 2026 | D | |
| Mike Dodge | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Ryan Dodge | Victor | 2023 | D | SUNY Stony Brook |
| Dugan Doeblin | Geneva | 2020 | A | St John Fisher |
| Matt Doeller | Eastridge | 2009 | A/M | |
| Ryan Doherty | Aquinas | 2009 | M | Niagara |
| Peter Dohr | Aquinas | 2010 | A | |
| Brayden Dohse | Gananda | 2024 | M | |
| Andrew Doktor | Eastridge | 2017 | A | RIT |
| Chris Doktor | Eastridge | 2014 | G | Alfred |
| Daniel Doktor | Irondequoit | 2016 | A | |
| Nick Doktor | Irondequoit | 2012 | A | Penn |
| Billy Dolan | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Zachary Dolce | Fairport | 2023 | D | |
| Jarrett Doll | East Rochester | 2013 | D | |
| Dylan Dollar | Pal-Mac | 2021 | G | |
| Pete Dolliver | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | D | |
| Nick Domicello | Wayne | 2016 | M | |
| Will Domingo | Pittsford | 2013 | D | |
| CJ Dominic | Pittsford | 2011 | D | |
| Nick Dominic | Pittsford | 2017 | D | Cobleskill |
| Max Dominikoski | Penfield | 2021 | D | |
| Mike Domizio | Victor | 2007 | A | |
| Aaron Donahey | Hilton | 2007 | G | |
| Dane Donahoe | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | Alfred State |
| Patrick Donahoe | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | M | Lake Erie |
| Ian Donahue | Hilton | 2020 | D | |
| Mike Donals | Livonia | 2010 | A | Keuka |
| Rusty Donlon | Gates Chili | 2007 | M | |
| Ben Donnan | Gananda | 2016 | M | |
| John Donnell | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Brian Donnelly | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | D | MCC |
| Jack Donnelly | Schroeder | 2015 | A | Susquehanna |
| Kevin Donnelly | Victor | 2009 | G | |
| Patrick Donnelly | Schroeder | 2016 | D | Susquehanna |
| Tim Donnelly | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | D | MCC |
| AJ Donoghue | Irondequoit | 2011 | A | Morrisville |
| Jack Donovan | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Owen Donovan | Irondequoit | 2024 | M/A | |
| David Dooley | Gates Chili | 2017 | D | |
| Brennan Dooling | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Reid Doolittle | Thomas | 2024 | M | |
| Shawn Doran | Hilton | 2019 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Michael Dorbiala | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M/A | |
| William Dorfner | Wayne | 2016 | D | |
| Rodrigo Doria | Livonia | 2007 | M | |
| Kyle Dorman | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Jake Dorn | Irondequoit | 2019 | A | |
| Jeremy Dornford | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | M | |
| Zeus Doser | Hilton | 2016 | A | |
| Kokou Dossau | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | M | |
| Collin Dotterer | Gananda | 2012 | M | |
| Evan Dotterer | Gananda | 2016 | LSM | |
| Sean Doudell | Brockport | 2020 | M | |
| Ryan Doudt | Avon | 2013 | A | |
| Eian Dougherty | Gates Chili | 2011 | D | |
| Jake Dougherty | Irondequoit | 2014 | G | |
| Ryan Douglas | Hilton | 2023 | G | |
| Sam Dovan | Fairport | 2014 | D | Jacksonville |
| Brad Dove | Mynderse | 2009 | G | |
| Randy Dove | Mynderse | 2005 | D | |
| Brad Doway | Gananda | 2015 | M | |
| Demetrius Dowdell | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | M | |
| Michael Dowden | Thomas | 2023 | M | |
| Troy Dowdle | Victor | 2013 | G | |
| Grant Dowler | Brighton | 2019 | D | |
| James Downs | Fairport | 2010 | D | King`s |
| Eddie Doyle | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | A | |
| Eddie Doyle | Penfield | 2013 | D | |
| Jesse Doyle | Pal-Mac | 2009 | M | |
| Sean Doyle | Irondequoit | 2005 | M | Bellarmine |
| Tim Doyle | Pal-Mac | 2009 | G | Nazareth |
| Jimmy Drabin | Gates Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Joe Drabin | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Cameron Drain | Haverling | 2016 | M | |
| Caleb Drake | Pittsford | 2018 | A | |
| Caleb Drake | Haverling | 2020 | M | |
| Landon Drake | Penn Yan | 2015 | G | |
| Ethan Draper | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Trevor Draper | Aquinas | 2020 | M | |
| Matt Draveck | Victor | 2014 | G | |
| Zach Dreisbach | Canandaigua | 2021 | G | |
| Jacob Drennen | Geneva | 2018 | G | |
| Eric Drewel | Hilton | 2011 | LSM | |
| Jake Drier | Victor | 2011 | D | |
| Matt Driffill | Eastridge | 2008 | A | |
| Shane Driffill | Eastridge | 2008 | M | |
| Evan Drinkwater | Fairport | 2007 | M | |
| Holden Driscoll | Avon | 2018 | A | |
| Will Driscoll | Geneva | 2016 | A | |
| Triton Drock | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Kendall Dron | Thomas | 2012 | M | |
| Jon Droney | Penn Yan | 2020 | M | |
| Anthony Druker | Penn Yan | 2023 | D | Keuka |
| Camden Drum | Haverling | 2025 | LSM | |
| Matthew Dryer | Fairport | 2011 | D | |
| Mike Dryer | Fairport | 2011 | D | |
| David Dube | Canandaigua | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Paul Dubman | Spencerport | 2011 | A | |
| David Dubois | Haverling | 2013 | M | |
| Josh DuBois | Haverling | 2012 | A | |
| Jack DuBose | Fairport | 2024 | M | |
| Gavin Ducar | Canandaigua | 2025 | A | |
| Jarett Duchesneau | Pal-Mac | 2014 | M | |
| Justin Dude | Hilton | 2018 | D | Wells |
| Robert Duell | Fairport | 2006 | D | |
| Clayton Duford | Hilton | 2021 | G | |
| Hunter Duford | Hilton | 2016 | M | Belmont Abbey |
| Enoch Duhart | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | D | MCC |
| Ryan Dumont | Pittsford | 2019 | A | |
| Calum Dunbar | Brockport | 2018 | G | |
| Colin Duncan | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | A | SUNY Albany |
| Lawrence Duncan | Haverling | 2025 | M | |
| Ty Duncan | East Rochester | 2015 | M | |
| Aaron Duncanson | Marcus Whitman | 2019 | D | |
| Bryan Dunham | Fairport | 2015 | M | |
| Jack Dunham | Geneva | 2027 | A | |
| Ryland Dunham | Geneva | 2026 | A | |
| Ashtain Dunning | Penn Yan | 2023 | D | |
| Tanyon Dunning | Penn Yan | 2023 | D | |
| Shawn Dunphy | Waterloo | 2005 | A | |
| Aiden Dunton | Marcus Whitman | 2028 | D | |
| Blake Dunton | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | G | Morrisville |
| Michael Dunton | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | M | |
| Zach DuPan | Brockport | 2013 | D | |
| Jacob Dupont | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | A/M | |
| Thayer Dupont | Pal-Mac | 2019 | M | |
| Joe Dupra | Pittsford | 2010 | D | RIT |
| Sam Dupra | Pittsford | 2007 | G | |
| Bryan Duran | Penn Yan | 2019 | D | GCC |
| Milo Duran | Thomas | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Milo Duran | Thomas | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Alex Durham | Haverling | 2005 | D | |
| McKenzie Durham | Haverling | 2008 | M | |
| Tyler Duris | Rush-Henrietta | 2016 | D | |
| Zachary Duris | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | D | |
| George Durkin | Aquinas | 2022 | D | Keuka |
| Cameron Dusett | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | A | |
| Dodge Dustin | Spencerport | 2013 | G | |
| Trevor Dustin | Spencerport | 2015 | A | |
| John Duthoy | Brockport | 2008 | G | |
| Paul Duthoy | Brockport | 2011 | G | |
| Logan DuVall-Swartzenberg | Wayne | 2025 | G | |
| Anthony Dwyer | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | A | |
| James Dwyer | Penfield | 2009 | M | |
| Mike Dyakiv | Eastridge | 2013 | A | |
| Tim Dyer | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | Alfred State |
| Tom Dyer | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | D | |
| Thomas Dyer II | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | D | |
| Aaron D`Agostino | Canandaigua | 2019 | A | |
| Jake D`Agostino | Canandaigua | 2017 | D | |
| Dylan D`Aloisio | Hilton | 2019 | D | |
| Chris D`Ambrosia | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | D | |
| David D`Ambrosia | Schroeder | 2008 | M | |
| Chase D`Amico | Spencerport | 2025 | M | |
| Frank D`Amico | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | M | |
| Joe D`Amico | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Gino D`Angelo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | M | |
| Pat D`Angelo | Victor | 2011 | A | St John Fisher |
| Thomas D`Angelo | Brighton | 2024 | G | Union |
| Tommy D`Antonio | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | D | |
| Matt D`Arduini | Pal-Mac | 2022 | A/M | |
| Mike D`Arduini | Pal-Mac | 2023 | A/M | |
| Anthony D`Elia | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | A | |
| Rob D`Ettore | Aquinas | 2006 | M | |
| David D`Ettorre | Brockport | 2019 | A | |
| Brady D`Hont | Penfield | 2017 | D | Canisius |
| Chase D`Hont | Penfield | 2019 | M | |
| Michael Eagan | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | Mars Hill |
| Carter Earl | Penn Yan | 2023 | M | Wilmington |
| Gavin Earl | Penfield | 2026 | D | |
| Nathan Earl | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Aiden Early | Greece Storm | 2024 | A | |
| Greg Earnhart | Hilton | 2008 | D | |
| Brandon East | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | M | |
| David Easton | Gates Chili | 2007 | D | Wells |
| Steve Eaton | Gates Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Tim Eaton | Gates Chili | 2017 | A | |
| Tucker Eaton | Wayne | 2026 | M/A | |
| Alex Eaves | Marcus Whitman | 2016 | M | |
| Jacob Eaves | Penn Yan | 2026 | M | |
| Eli Ebanks | Newark | 2011 | M | |
| Griffin Eberhardt | Fairport | 2011 | A/M | |
| Jake Eccleston | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | M | |
| Brian Eckam | Gates Chili | 2010 | M | FLCC |
| Kyle Eckam | Gates Chili | 2011 | D | FLCC |
| Chris Ecker | Wayne | 2015 | M | |
| Jon Ecker | Wayne | 2017 | A/M | |
| Alec Eckert | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | D | |
| Ethan Eckert | Canandaigua | 2023 | D | |
| Ian Eckert | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | |
| Oliver Eckert | Eastridge | 2008 | M | |
| Ryan Eckhardt | Greece Ath_Ody | 2008 | M | |
| Joe Edd | Aquinas | 2006 | D | |
| Joe Eddinger | Canandaigua | 2014 | D | |
| Billy Eddington | Geneva | 2011 | A | |
| Eddie Eddington | Geneva | 2014 | M | Cortland |
| Drew Eddy | Aquinas | 2023 | A | |
| Justin Edicola | Schroeder | 2009 | M | |
| Cameron Edmiston | Pittsford | 2007 | A/M | Mercyhurst |
| Aiden Edwards | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | G/D | |
| Alex Edwards | Fairport | 2014 | LSM | |
| Dave Edwards | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | D | |
| David Edwards | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | G | |
| Jacob Edwards | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Jason Edwards | Geneva | 2006 | D | Alfred |
| Keenan Edwards | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Kenneth Edwards | East United | 2022 | A | |
| Kenneth Edwards | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Nick Edwards | Hilton | 2009 | M/A | |
| Zach Edwards | Spencerport | 2019 | A | |
| Andrew Egan | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | A | |
| Nick Egan | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Nicholas Ehmann | Gates Chili | 2017 | A | |
| Noah Ehret | Penfield | 2024 | M | |
| Ryan Eichas | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Zach Eichas | Brockport | 2022 | M | |
| Mason Eichmann | Fairport | 2017 | A/M | |
| Dylan Eichorn | Avon | 2016 | A/M | |
| Bailey Eigbrett | Avon | 2015 | A/M | |
| Josh Eigbrett | Avon | 2019 | D | |
| Aiden Eighmey | Geneva | 2021 | M | |
| Noah Eighmey | Geneva | 2019 | A | |
| Quinn Eighmey | Geneva | 2017 | A | |
| Matt Eisenhauer | Hilton | 2016 | D | |
| Jake Eismann | Irondequoit | 2018 | D | |
| Max Eismann | Irondequoit | 2016 | G | Seton Hill |
| Theo Ekiyor | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | M | |
| Terence El-Damaa | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | M | |
| Caleb Eldridge | Midlakes | 2018 | D | |
| Isaiah Eldridge | Midlakes | 2017 | M | |
| Jeshurun Eldridge | Midlakes | 2015 | A | |
| Tristan Eldridge | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Michael Elie | Fairport | 2015 | D | |
| Jefferson Elisofon | Waterloo | 2016 | D | |
| Mike Elkins | Irondequoit | 2008 | DM | |
| Tom Elkins | Gates Chili | 2008 | A | |
| Nate Elliot | Penn Yan | 2018 | M | |
| Brandon Ellis | Spencerport | 2014 | A | |
| Colin Ellis | Avon | 2014 | M | |
| Nate Ellis | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | M | |
| Noah Ellis | Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Noah Ellis | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Tim Ellis | Mynderse | 2005 | M | |
| Austin Ellison | Geneva | 2017 | D | |
| Travin Ellison | Livonia-Avon | 2024 | D | |
| Colin Ellsworth | Livonia-Avon | 2024 | D | |
| David Ellsworth | Pal-Mac | 2012 | M | |
| Doug Ellsworth | Pal-Mac | 2012 | M | GCC |
| Alex Elmore | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | D | |
| Carson Eltz | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | A | |
| Elijah Elvin | Fairport | 2015 | D | |
| Ethan Ely | Pal-Mac | 2023 | M/D | |
| Pat Embury | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Ben Emerson | Penn Yan | 2018 | A | |
| Griffin Emerson | Penn Yan | 2022 | G | Clarkson |
| Reid Emerson | Canandaigua | 2023 | M | |
| Sean Emerson | Penn Yan | 2016 | A/M | |
| Tyler Emerson | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | D | |
| Tyler Emery | Canandaigua | 2005 | M | |
| Jack Emmens | Brighton | 2012 | D | |
| Sean Emmert | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | Buffalo |
| Jacob Emmick | Penfield | 2019 | A | St Bonaventure |
| Rich Emminger | Batavia | 2008 | D | |
| Will Empey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2004 | D | St John Fisher |
| Brian Enck | Schroeder | 2008 | G | |
| Brett Endres | Hilton | 2009 | M/A | |
| Cory Endres | Hilton | 2012 | M | |
| Mason Endres | Spencerport | 2028 | M | |
| Regan Endres | Victor | 2020 | M/FO | SUNY Albany |
| Shane Endres | Hilton | 2012 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Zach Engel | Irondequoit | 2008 | D | |
| Jack Engin | Pittsford | 2026 | D | |
| Mark Engle | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Will Engle | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Camden Englert | Greece Storm | 2020 | M | |
| Colton Englert | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | M | |
| Jaime Englert | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | M | |
| Jeff Englert | Irondequoit | 2009 | A | |
| Johnthan Englert | Hilton | 2021 | A | |
| Joshua Englert | Hilton | 2016 | D | |
| Owen Englert | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | D | |
| Noah Englerth | Penfield | 2015 | D | |
| Justin Englin | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | D | |
| Michael English | Bishop Kearney | 2022 | D | |
| Tucker English | Brockport | 2007 | A | |
| TJ Ennis | Eastridge | 2012 | G | |
| Connor Enright | Irondequoit | 2012 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Darren Enright | Penfield | 2020 | D | |
| Jack Enright | Irondequoit | 2015 | D | |
| Patrick Enright | Irondequoit | 2018 | M | |
| Ryan Enright | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | M | Keuka |
| Henry Erbland | Pittsford | 2014 | D | |
| Lucas Erbland | Pittsford | 2017 | G | |
| Scotty Erbland | Aquinas | 2011 | M | |
| Delvin Ergott | Hilton | 2015 | G | |
| Kurt Erhardt | Thomas | 2010 | M | |
| Duncan Erickson | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | M | |
| Travis Ernst | Wayne | 2020 | D | |
| Cam Ernstberger | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| Deniz Erol | Gates Chili | 2022 | D | |
| Devon Errigo | Fairport | 2011 | M | |
| Ian Erskine | Pittsford | 2024 | A | |
| Jake Erskine | Pittsford | 2021 | M | Canton |
| Eren Ersoy | Eastridge | 2007 | D | |
| Aaron Ersthausen | Aquinas | 2023 | D | |
| Blaine Erway | Haverling | 2009 | D | |
| Jack Erway | Waterloo | 2021 | G | |
| Asher Erwin | Victor | 2023 | M | |
| Liam Erwin | Victor | 2021 | A | |
| Parker Erwin | Victor | 2024 | G | |
| Charlie Eshenour | Waterloo | 2013 | M/D | |
| Christian Eskander | Thomas | 2014 | A | |
| Isaiah Espaillat | Gananda | 2023 | M | |
| Trevor Ess | Geneva | 2017 | M | Alfred |
| Zach Estabrooks | Victor | 2017 | A | Seton Hill |
| Lucas Estelle | Thomas | 2028 | A/M | |
| Riki Ettinger | Batavia | 2010 | A | |
| Rikki Ettinger | Batavia | 2010 | A | |
| Maxfield Ettinghausen | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | A | Tufts |
| Zach Ettinghausen | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | St Lawrence |
| Tom Etzel | Livonia | 2009 | M | |
| Christian Evans | Fairport | 2024 | M | |
| Dan Evans | Pal-Mac | 2007 | M | |
| Devante Evans | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M | |
| Malik Evans | Brighton | 2016 | M | |
| Matt Evans | Waterloo | 2013 | G/D | |
| Jon Eveland | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Dave Everett | Waterloo | 2005 | M/D | |
| Devin Everett | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Jayvon Everett | Brighton | 2025 | M/D | |
| LaQuan Everett | Newark | 2018 | M | |
| Todd Everts | Canandaigua | 2019 | D | |
| Mike Ewanechko | Victor | 2011 | M | |
| Derek Excell | Waterloo | 2018 | D | |
| Steve Excely | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Pat Eyre | Aquinas | 2005 | M | |
| Carter Fabian | Greece Storm | 2025 | M | |
| Nick Fabino | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Joseph Fabrizi | Irondequoit | 2022 | M | |
| Steve Fabrizio | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Ed Facer | Newark | 2011 | M | |
| Donovan Fagan | Eastridge | 2017 | A | |
| Gordon Fagan | Pittsford | 2023 | LSM | |
| Vincent Fagan | Eastridge | 2020 | M | |
| Vincent Fagan | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Scott Fagner | Newark | 2012 | M | |
| Tyler Fagner | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | M | |
| Andy Fahy | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | D | |
| Brady Fahy | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | D | Purchase |
| Phil Fahy | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | D | Pfeiffer |
| Nick Failing | Irondequoit | 2010 | D | |
| Andrew Faillace | Penfield | 2021 | D | |
| Alex Fain | Brighton | 2019 | M | |
| Alexander Fain | Penfield | 2019 | M | |
| Jack Faiola | Canandaigua | 2023 | G | Hobart |
| Eddie Fairben | Canandaigua | 2019 | M | |
| Ryan Fairbrother | Pittsford | 2015 | M | USMA |
| Greg Faklaris | Penfield | 2018 | A | |
| Jacob Falbo | Spencerport | 2023 | D | |
| Jeff Falco | Eastridge | 2018 | M | |
| Tyler Fales | Batavia | 2015 | A | |
| Tyler Fales | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | A | |
| Jason Falk | Pittsford | 2008 | D | Potsdam |
| Matt Falkenstein | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | M | |
| Jimmy Fallon | Brockport | 2012 | M/A | |
| Bobby Fallone | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | M | |
| Nick Falso | Gananda | 2026 | G | |
| Pete Falsone | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | M | |
| Ethan Fame | Schroeder | 2020 | D | |
| Carl Fantauzzo | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | M | |
| Steve Fantigrossi | Schroeder | 2011 | D | |
| David Farchione | East Rochester | 2010 | D | |
| Marty Farchione | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | A | |
| Will Fargo | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | G | |
| Ryan Farley | Newark | 2018 | A | |
| Logan Farney | Thomas | 2024 | D/LSM | |
| Tyler Farrel | Hilton | 2014 | M | |
| Brett Farrell | Schroeder | 2010 | A | St John Fisher |
| Evan Farrell | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | M | |
| Malachy Farrell | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | M | |
| Shane Farrell | Schroeder | 2008 | D | Clarkson |
| Trevor Farrell | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | A | |
| Makhi Farrier | Fairport | 2025 | A/M | |
| Eathyn Fasciana | Mynderse | 2026 | M | |
| Zachary Faucher | Spencerport | 2021 | D | |
| Matt Faulks | Hilton | 2005 | D | |
| Marc Favro | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | D | |
| Riley Favro | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | A | |
| Zach Fay | Batavia | 2008 | M | |
| Nick Fazio | Geneva | 2013 | M | |
| Steve Fazio | Geneva | 2017 | M | |
| Aaron Feary | Batavia | 2015 | M | |
| Kyle Featherly | Midlakes | 2012 | A | |
| John Fecik | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | D | |
| Nicholas Fede | Hilton | 2023 | A | |
| Matt Fedick | Brighton | 2009 | A | |
| Johnathan Fedison | Eastridge | 2019 | M | |
| Andon Fedor | Pal-Mac | 2022 | M/D | |
| Matt Fedzcuk | Newark | 2015 | A | |
| Austen Fee | Fairport | 2013 | D | |
| Drew Feinberg | Geneva | 2013 | A | |
| Jason Feinberg | Geneva | 2016 | A | |
| Brian Feldman | Canandaigua | 2014 | A | Quinnipiac |
| Nick Feldman | Livonia | 2011 | D | |
| Joey Felice | Victor | 2021 | M | |
| Rhyzear Feliciano | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | LSM | |
| James Felix | Pittsford | 2015 | M | Le Moyne |
| Jordan Felize | Mynderse | 2021 | D | |
| William Fell | Penfield | 2018 | D | |
| Jake Fellows | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Zachary Fellows | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Blake Fennel | Gates Chili | 2021 | M/FO | |
| Blake Fennell | Gates Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Tristan Fenner | Waterloo | 2021 | M | |
| Patrick Fenton | Aquinas | 2021 | D | |
| David Feor | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | D | |
| Amir Ferchichi | Eastridge | 2020 | A | |
| Christopher Ferguson | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Grant Ferguson | Gates Chili | 2011 | A | Eastern |
| Justin Ferguson | Marcus Whitman | 2009 | M | |
| Teddy Ferguson | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | Lake Erie |
| Geoffrey Ferington | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | D | |
| Dominic Ferlito | Penn Yan | 2018 | D | |
| Carlos Fernandez | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | D | |
| Connor Fernberg | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Mason Ferrara | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | D | |
| Justin Ferraraccio | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | D | |
| Christian Ferraro | Penfield | 2010 | M | |
| Eugene Ferrera | Eastridge | 2008 | G | |
| Aidan Ferrin | Eastridge | 2014 | D | |
| Chris Ferrin | Eastridge | 2009 | D | |
| Connor Ferrin | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| Brendyn Ferrington | Waterloo | 2020 | M | |
| Ryan Ferrini | Mynderse | 2017 | D | FLCC |
| Alec Ferris | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Jayden Ferris | Brighton | 2021 | D | |
| Julian Ferris | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Jack Ferruzza | Schroeder | 2018 | D | Buffalo |
| Luke Ferruzza | Schroeder | 2012 | M | |
| Chris Ferry | Schroeder | 2006 | A/M | |
| Jason Fersaci | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | M | |
| Matt Fessler | Greece | 2005 | D | |
| Vaughn Fetkenhour | Brighton | 2019 | D | |
| Will Fetkenhour | Brighton | 2022 | D | |
| Jack Fialkoff | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | A/M | |
| Jeff Fichtner | Gates Chili | 2008 | M | FLCC |
| Ricky Figueroa | Gananda | 2011 | M | |
| Lorenzo Filardo | Spencerport | 2019 | D | |
| Tiara Filbert | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | DM | |
| Tiara Filbert | Batavia | 2016 | DM | |
| Anthony Fili | Geneva | 2008 | A | |
| Jerimiah Fils | Mynderse | 2025 | M | |
| Drake Filyaw | Mynderse | 2026 | A | |
| Brandon Finch | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Tyler Finch | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Lucas Findlay | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | A | |
| Parker Finestone | Brighton | 2015 | M | |
| Aaron Fingar | Canandaigua | 2007 | D | FLCC |
| Adam Fingar | Canandaigua | 2010 | D | Hartford |
| Austin Fingar | Penn Yan | 2016 | M | |
| Braden Fingar | Penn Yan | 2026 | M | |
| Conner Fingar | Penn Yan | 2019 | M | SUNY Albany |
| Kyle Fingar | Gates Chili | 2019 | M | Canton |
| Scott Fingar | Penn Yan | 2016 | D | |
| Teagan Fingar | Penn Yan | 2025 | M | Mt St Mary |
| Dan Fingland | Churchville-Chili | 2010 | D | |
| Connor Finnegan | Gananda | 2013 | D | |
| Ryan Finnegan | Gananda | 2017 | A | |
| Ryan Finnell | Pittsford | 2024 | D | |
| Ryan Finney | Haverling | 2005 | A | |
| Coz Fiore | Thomas | 2014 | M | Oneonta |
| Matt Fiore | Thomas | 2015 | A | |
| Noah Fiori | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | M | |
| Ryan Firmstone | Aquinas | 2022 | A | |
| Eric Fischer | Irondequoit | 2012 | G | SUNY Binghamton |
| Matt Fischer | Victor | 2008 | D | |
| Nick Fischer | Spencerport | 2010 | A | |
| Richard Fischer | Greece Arc_Oly | 2011 | A | Morrisville |
| Brian Fisher | Haverling | 2005 | M | |
| Christian Fisher | Waterloo | 2008 | D | |
| Joe Fisher | Gananda | 2016 | A | Nazareth |
| Josh Fisher | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Levi Fisher | Penn Yan | 2027 | M | |
| Steven Fisher | Gananda | 2012 | G | |
| Tukker Fisher | Penn Yan | 2026 | A | |
| Tyler Fisher | Midlakes | 2012 | D | |
| Mike Fisk | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Charlie Fite | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Chase Fitzgerald | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Connor Fitzgerald | Pittsford | 2017 | M | Tampa |
| Jeremy Fitzgerald | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | A | |
| Kevin Fitzgerald | Geneva | 2009 | D | |
| Rory Fitzpatrick | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Sean Fitzpatrick | Penfield | 2010 | D | |
| Daniel Fladd | Geneva | 2021 | A | |
| Matthew Flagg | Spencerport | 2020 | M | |
| Brendan Flaherty | Bishop Kearney | 2016 | A/M | |
| Connor Flaherty | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | A | Babson |
| Mike Flaherty | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | D | Wells |
| Ryan Flaherty | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Branden Flanagan | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | G | |
| Devan Flanagan | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | M/A | |
| Riley Flanagan | Hilton | 2014 | M | |
| Tyler Flanagan | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | A | |
| Tyler Flanagan | Greece Storm | 2019 | A | |
| Corey Flanigan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | A/M | Clarkson |
| Salvatore Flannaca | Livonia | 2009 | A | |
| Cole Flannery | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | A | |
| Colton Flannery | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| Ryder Flaum | Brighton | 2025 | D | |
| Lucas Fleig | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | D | |
| Eion Flemming | Mynderse | 2025 | M | |
| Kody Fletcher | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Fletcher | Brighton | 2010 | D | |
| Jordan Flint | Batavia | 2023 | A | |
| Jordan Flint | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | A | |
| Tristan Flint | Batavia | 2014 | G | |
| Wyatt Flint | Bishop Kearney | 2015 | M | |
| Luke Fliss | Pittsford | 2024 | M | Providence |
| Joey Flores | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Manuel Flores | East United | 2021 | M | |
| Manuel Flores | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | M | |
| Misael Flores | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | M/A | |
| AJ Florio | Schroeder | 2018 | M | |
| Armand Florio | Hilton | 2015 | D | |
| Jack Flowerday | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | M | |
| Isaac Floyd | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | D | |
| Braden Flynn | Brockport | 2008 | M | |
| Brady Flynn | Wayne | 2026 | M | |
| Conor Flynn | Batavia | 2007 | D | |
| Devin Flynn | Wayne | 2019 | A/M | |
| Jordan Flynn | Irondequoit | 2021 | D | |
| Patrick Flynn | Batavia | 2012 | A | |
| Seamus Flynn | Brockport | 2015 | D | |
| Austin Foe | Geneva | 2016 | D | MCC |
| Logan Fogarty | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | M/A | |
| Peter Fogle | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Dan Foley | Aquinas | 2010 | D | |
| David Foley | Fairport | 2009 | D | |
| Neil Foley | Aquinas | 2008 | M | |
| Nick Foley | Fairport | 2014 | M | King`s |
| Jon Folts | Penn Yan | 2006 | A | |
| Eduardo Fontan-Keating | East United | 2019 | D | |
| Jacob Foote | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Adam Force | Haverling | 2011 | G/M | |
| Anthony Force | Haverling | 2015 | D | |
| Travis Ford | Thomas | 2016 | M | Fairfield |
| Trevor Ford | Thomas | 2018 | A | Fairfield |
| Ricky Forero | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| Jake Forken | Penfield | 2012 | DM | |
| Joey Fornataro | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | M | Alfred |
| Peter Fornorola | Aquinas | 2005 | M | |
| Dustin Forsha | Batavia | 2022 | G/D | |
| Dustin Forsha | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | G/D | |
| Ryan Forshay | Midlakes | 2006 | M | |
| Liam Forsyth | Thomas | 2022 | A | |
| Andrew Forte | Spencerport | 2016 | M | |
| Andrew Forte | Pittsford | 2016 | M | GCC |
| Paul Forte | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | A | |
| Paul Forte | Greece Storm | 2019 | A | Alfred |
| Nicholas Fosegan | Fairport | 2024 | A/M | |
| Andrew Foster | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | M | |
| Aven Foster | Penn Yan | 2025 | D | |
| Ben Foster | Penfield | 2006 | M | |
| Kellen Foster | Newark | 2024 | M | |
| Tim Foster | Pittsford | 2014 | M | |
| Steve Foulkrod | Mynderse | 2010 | D | |
| Korey Fovel | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | D | |
| Austin Fox | Thomas | 2009 | G | Air Force |
| Collin Fox | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Connor Fox | Midlakes | 2012 | M | |
| Corey Fox | Thomas | 2007 | A | |
| Jake Fox | Livonia | 2011 | M | |
| Jake Fox | Penfield | 2021 | A/M | |
| Josh Fox | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | D | |
| Justin Fox | Greece Storm | 2026 | A | |
| Kyle Fox | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | M | |
| Matthew Fox | East United | 2018 | M | |
| Remmington Fox | Thomas | 2007 | M | Brockport |
| Tanner Fox | Pal-Mac | 2012 | D | |
| Teryn Fox | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | D | |
| Matt Fracassi | Hilton | 2009 | A | |
| Matt Francis | Eastridge | 2005 | A | |
| Aiden Franco | Mynderse | 2014 | M | |
| Jonathan Francois | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Dylan Frank | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | D | |
| Eric Frank | Penfield | 2007 | A/M | |
| Jared Frank | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Nicholas Frank | Thomas | 2009 | A | |
| Zach Franzese | Schroeder | 2021 | M | |
| Sal Franzone | Mynderse | 2019 | D | Keuka |
| Carter Frasch | Brockport | 2026 | M | |
| Isaac Fraser | Brockport | 2009 | LSM | |
| Frank Frattali | Gates Chili | 2013 | D | |
| Alexander Frazee | Fairport | 2014 | M | |
| Coby Frazier | Newark | 2017 | G | |
| Evan Frazo | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | M | |
| Dan Frazzo | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2018 | M | |
| Jack Fredericksen | Pittsford | 2015 | D | |
| Jesse Freeman | Waterloo | 2022 | M | |
| Mathew Freeman | Livonia | 2017 | M | |
| Justus Freeville | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | G | |
| Mike Freier | Waterloo | 2012 | M/D | |
| Tim Freier | Waterloo | 2010 | M | Morrisville |
| Jeff Frelier | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | G/M | |
| Aaron French | Newark | 2022 | M | |
| Austin Freudenvoll | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | A | |
| Zach Frey | Victor | 2007 | D | |
| Jake Fricano | Fairport | 2006 | M | |
| Alec Frick | Batavia | 2007 | A | |
| Carter Fries | Victor | 2025 | G | |
| Kyler Friesner | Gananda | 2013 | A/M | |
| Peyton Fritz | Canandaigua | 2027 | M/FO | |
| Ryan Fritz | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Fronczak | Victor | 2021 | A | |
| Nick Frontuto | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Mike Frosino | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Asah Frost | Gates Chili | 2026 | A/M | |
| Doug Fry | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | M | |
| Mark Fry | Eastridge | 2011 | A | |
| Ian Fuchs | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | D | |
| Ian Fuchs | Batavia | 2021 | D | |
| Victor Fuentes | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Brad Fuerst | Haverling | 2007 | A | |
| Dan Fuhrken | Mynderse | 2012 | D | |
| Jacob Fuller | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | D | |
| Keith Fuller | Penn Yan | 2018 | G | |
| Mitch Fuller | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| Foxx Fulton | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| Ryan Fulton | Penfield | 2014 | A | |
| Connor Fundis | Fairport | 2021 | D | SUNY Albany |
| Orian Furber | Brighton | 2014 | A/M | |
| Yakow Furdey | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M | |
| Abdullah Furgan | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| Michael Furia | Aquinas | 2023 | M | |
| Sam Furioso | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | M/D | |
| Angelo Fusilli | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Adrien Fytros | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | A/M | |
| Matt Gabbard | Gananda | 2019 | D | |
| Brian Gable | Haverling | 2011 | M | |
| Caleb Gable-Hyer | Haverling | 2015 | A | |
| Joey Gadomski | Avon | 2016 | A | |
| John Gadomski | Avon | 2014 | D | |
| Jimmy Gaffney | Hilton | 2009 | M | |
| Shane Gaffney | Pittsford | 2018 | D | |
| Jon Gaglio | Schroeder | 2019 | G | |
| Jon Gaglio | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | G | John Carroll |
| Nick Gaglio | Schroeder | 2014 | DM | |
| Nick Gaglio | Thomas | 2024 | M/D | |
| Michael Galante | Hilton | 2019 | A | |
| Chris Galayda | Hilton | 2009 | M | |
| John Galbraith | Pittsford | 2017 | M | Colgate |
| Taylor Galbraith | Brighton | 2008 | M | Union |
| Jake Gales | Gananda | 2018 | D | |
| Jack Galipeau | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | A | |
| Alex Galka | Gananda | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Tim Gallahan | Victor | 2007 | D | |
| Marco Galleli | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | D | |
| Eric Gallert | Brockport | 2007 | M | |
| Jade Galligan | Haverling | 2015 | M | |
| Evan Gallina | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | Siena |
| Jake Gallina | Pal-Mac | 2019 | M | St John Fisher |
| Kasey Gallina | Pal-Mac | 2017 | M | Keuka |
| Nick Gallina | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | D | |
| Nick Gallina | Gananda | 2024 | A/M | |
| Anthony Gallo | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Kyle Gallo | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Reiner Gallogly | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | M | |
| Teague Gallogly | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | A | |
| Danny Galusha | Mynderse | 2011 | M | |
| Justin Galusha | Penn Yan | 2008 | G | |
| Phil Galusha | Mynderse | 2015 | M | |
| Cordell Galvan | Haverling | 2020 | D | |
| Dakota Galvan | Haverling | 2021 | D | |
| Xzavier Galvin | Haverling | 2023 | D | |
| Reilly Gamache | Mynderse | 2013 | A/M | |
| Robert Gamache | Mynderse | 2011 | A | |
| Johnell Gamble | Brighton | 2016 | D | |
| Jared Gammill | Wayne | 2023 | D | |
| Mason Gams | Newark | 2012 | M | |
| Codee Gangarossa | Batavia | 2012 | D | |
| Josh Gangarossa | Fairport | 2019 | G | MCC |
| Logan Gantz | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | G | |
| Dave Garbach | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | M | |
| Ryan Garbaz | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| John Garbeck | Victor | 2017 | D | |
| Anthony Garcia | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | D | |
| Izayah Garcia | Gates Chili | 2024 | M | |
| Joseph Garcia | Gates Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Mykael Garcia | Brighton | 2005 | M | |
| Neudy Garcia | Geneva | 2015 | M | |
| Ben Gardner | Newark | 2014 | D | |
| Brodie Gardner | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | M | |
| Bryan Gardner | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | A | |
| Caleb Gardner | Livonia | 2020 | M | |
| Caleb Gardner | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | D | |
| Connor Gardner | Pal-Mac | 2017 | M | |
| Diamond Gardner | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | D | |
| Diamond Gardner | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| John Gardner | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| John Gardner | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | G | |
| Matt Gardner | Victor | 2017 | D | |
| Nate Gardner | Newark | 2010 | G | Alfred State |
| Shawn Gardner | Thomas | 2016 | M | |
| Jack Garland | Pittsford | 2023 | G | |
| Nick Garnier | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | M | |
| Patrick Garnish | Eastridge | 2009 | LSM | |
| Treese Garofalo | Batavia | 2013 | LSM | |
| Andrew Garrett | Newark | 2015 | M | Canton |
| Alex Garrow | Wayne | 2024 | M | |
| Ronnie Garrow | Irondequoit | 2021 | A | |
| Kevin Garvey | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | M | |
| Matt Garvey | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | M | |
| Mason Gasbarre | Fairport | 2019 | LSM | St John Fisher |
| Matt Gasbarre | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Ryan Gascon | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | M | |
| Cody Gates | Irondequoit | 2023 | M/A | |
| David Gates | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | |
| Jared Gates | Hilton | 2015 | M | |
| Andrew Gatti | Aquinas | 2023 | D | |
| Evan Gaudette | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | |
| Anthony Gaudio | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | A | |
| John Gause | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | M | RIT |
| Bernard Gauthier | Aquinas | 2010 | M | MCC |
| Graham Gauthier | East United | 2019 | M/FO | |
| Jacob Gauthier | Victor | 2020 | M | |
| Luke Gauthier | East United | 2019 | D | FLCC |
| Noah Gauvin | Wayne | 2024 | G | |
| Justin Gavette | Haverling | 2012 | M | |
| Ethan Gawel | Pal-Mac | 2005 | D | |
| Garrett Gaydosh | Waterloo | 2018 | D | |
| Yusuf Gazali | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Cameron Gebhardt | Fairport | 2016 | A/M | RIT |
| Jeff Geddis | Fairport | 2012 | A/M | |
| Jon Gee | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | A | |
| Daniel Geen | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Zach Geer | Victor | 2020 | A | |
| Doug Geertz | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Cameron Gefell | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | M | St Rose |
| Grant Gefell | Wayne | 2013 | M | |
| David Geffel | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | D | |
| Divonte Geiger | Livonia | 2014 | M | |
| Luke Geiger | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | M/A | |
| Jon Gelinas | Canandaigua | 2014 | G | |
| Ben Gensiejewski | Victor | 2023 | D | |
| Nathan Genthner | Livonia | 2019 | M | |
| Nathan Genthner | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | A/M | |
| Eric Gentile | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Matt George | Canandaigua | 2010 | D | |
| Michael George | Haverling | 2016 | M | |
| Mike George | Geneva | 2005 | D | |
| Samuel George | Brighton | 2019 | D | |
| Tommy George | Haverling | 2016 | M | |
| Caleb George-Cady | Newark | 2022 | G | |
| Adam Gerbasi | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Derek Gerega | Hilton | 2006 | M | |
| Ben Gerhardt | Rush-Henrietta | 2016 | D | |
| Bill Gerhardt | Penn Yan | 2014 | D | |
| Craig Gerhardt | Penn Yan | 2016 | A | |
| Devon Gerhardt | Penn Yan | 2021 | A/M | Keuka |
| Tyler Gerhardt | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | M | |
| Max Gerling | Fairport | 2013 | M | |
| Cameron Germain | Victor | 2020 | D | St Bonaventure |
| Louie Germain | Victor | 2022 | D | Bucknell |
| Michael Germano | Avon | 2020 | G | |
| Michael Germano | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | G | |
| Noah Germano | Schroeder | 2019 | M | |
| Patrick Gerrie | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | M | |
| Henry Gerstner | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Jeff Gerstner | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Jeff Gertin | Thomas | 2009 | D | |
| Julian Gervais | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| TJ Geyer | Aquinas | 2024 | M | |
| Santino Giachetti | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| David Giallanza | Aquinas | 2018 | M | |
| Joe Giamberdine | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | M | |
| Nicholas Giambrone | Fairport | 2018 | A | |
| Phillip Giambrone | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | M | |
| Albert Gianforti | Canandaigua | 2005 | M | |
| JP Gianforti | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Domenic Giangreco | McQuaid Jesuit | 2026 | M | |
| Vincenzo Giangreco | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Andrew Giannino | Mynderse | 2009 | A | |
| Zack Gibaud | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | Alfred |
| Justin Gibb | Schroeder | 2018 | D | |
| Robert Gibb | Schroeder | 2016 | M | |
| Collin Gibboney | East Rochester | 2013 | M | |
| Pete Gibbons | Fairport | 2004 | M | Le Moyne |
| Eddie Giblin | Aquinas | 2016 | A | |
| Jake Gibson | Aquinas | 2026 | G | |
| Joseph Gibson | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | D | |
| Noah Gibson | Irondequoit | 2022 | A | St Rose |
| Charles Giehl | Gates Chili | 2006 | A | |
| Michael Gigantelli | Pittsford | 2016 | D | St Lawrence |
| Joey Giggie | Fairport | 2022 | M/FO | |
| Mike Gigliotti | Penn Yan | 2027 | A | |
| Brian Gilbert | Victor | 2011 | M | |
| Christopher Gilbert | Fairport | 2005 | D | |
| Mike Gilbert | Victor | 2018 | A | |
| Rick Gilbert | Newark | 2007 | A | |
| Trevor Gilliard | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | A | |
| Trevor Gilliard | Greece Storm | 2019 | A | |
| Brendan Gillmore | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | A | |
| Sebastian Gimeli | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Eric Gimlin | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Chris Gionta | Aquinas | 2006 | M | |
| Dante Giordano | Hilton | 2013 | M | St John Fisher |
| Eddy Giordano | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Ed Giorgi | Aquinas | 2006 | D | |
| Louis Giorgione | Hilton | 2025 | D | |
| Braden Gioseffi | Canandaigua | 2024 | M | Nazareth |
| Nick Giovannini | Mynderse | 2010 | A | |
| Matt Girolmo | Livonia | 2009 | M | |
| Trevor Girouard | Penfield | 2011 | D | St John Fisher |
| Chris Giruzzi | Eastridge | 2012 | A/M | MCC |
| Frankie Gissendanner | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Alex Gitsis | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | D/LSM | Keuka |
| Nick Gitsis | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | M | Keuka |
| Anthony Giudice | Thomas | 2018 | M | |
| Bruin Giudice | Irondequoit | 2021 | D | |
| Colin Giudice | Irondequoit | 2026 | A/M | |
| Jake Giudice | Thomas | 2013 | A | Brockport |
| Nick Giuliano | Schroeder | 2023 | D | |
| Cosmo Giunta | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Dante Giunta | Gates Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Mike Gizzi | Hilton | 2020 | D | |
| Sam Gizzi | Aquinas | 2024 | D | |
| Matt Gladstone | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | G | |
| Rene Glafenheim | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Andrew Glagolev | Thomas | 2009 | D | Drexel |
| Alex Glathar | Hilton | 2009 | D | |
| Rian Glatz | Gates Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Aiden Gleason | Brighton | 2018 | A | |
| Colby Gleason | Aquinas | 2026 | D | |
| Connor Gleason | Haverling | 2023 | G/D | |
| Greg Gleason | Haverling | 2005 | M | |
| Jake Gleason | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | A | |
| Jay Gleason | Haverling | 2009 | D | |
| Kaleb Glessing | Wayne | 2022 | A | Keuka |
| Remmy Glod | Gananda | 2016 | M | |
| Liam Glover | Haverling | 2005 | A | |
| George Glynn | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Joe Glynn | Brockport | 2022 | D | |
| Sean Glynn | Brockport | 2020 | D | |
| Will Glynn | Brockport | 2010 | D | |
| Justin Gmeinweiser | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | M | |
| TEAM GOAL | Spencerport | 2012 | A | |
| TEAM GOAL | Aquinas | 2012 | A | |
| TEAM GOAL | Schroeder | 2012 | A | |
| TEAM GOAL | Penfield | 2013 | A | |
| TEAM GOAL | Canandaigua | 2014 | A | |
| TEAM GOAL | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | A | |
| TEAM GOAL | Hilton | 2015 | - | |
| Team Goal | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | A | |
| Team Goal | Livonia | 2016 | A | |
| Team Goal | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2016 | G | |
| TEAM GOAL | Irondequoit | 2030 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Canandaigua | 2034 | 0 | |
| TEAM GOAL | Irondequoit | 2034 | 0 | |
| TEAM GOAL | Marcus Whitman | 2034 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Haverling | 2034 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Geneva | 2035 | 0 | |
| TEAM GOAL | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2035 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Pal-Mac | 2035 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Newark | 2035 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Mynderse | 2035 | 0 | |
| Team Goal | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2035 | 0 | |
| TEAM GOAL | Haverling | 2036 | 0 | |
| Dillon Godfrey | Newark | 2007 | M | |
| Jarrett Godin | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | D | |
| Harry Goebel | Wayne | 2014 | D | |
| Jarid Goebel | Penfield | 2014 | D | |
| Tom Goebel | Wayne | 2014 | D | |
| Ryan Goel | Thomas | 2024 | M | |
| Connor Goessling | Penfield | 2023 | D | |
| Connor Goessling | Penfield | 2024 | D | |
| Brady Goetz | Pittsford | 2025 | A | |
| Cole Goetz | Pittsford | 2027 | A/M | |
| Peter Goff | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Matt Gold | Pittsford | 2011 | M | Clarkson |
| Alex Goldan | Fairport | 2023 | A | |
| AJ Golden | Gananda | 2021 | A | |
| Chase Golden | Brockport | 2016 | D | |
| Davis Goldfeder | Brighton | 2020 | A/M | |
| Adam Golding | Newark | 2007 | M | |
| DJ Goldstein | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | |
| Dylan Goldstein | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Hunter Goldstin | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | G | |
| Harry Goluses | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | G | |
| Harry Goluses | Pittsford | 2009 | G | |
| Grayson Gomes | Aquinas | 2024 | M | |
| James Gomez | Batavia | 2012 | G | |
| Brandon Gonzales | Aquinas | 2012 | M | |
| Chris Gonzales | Newark | 2007 | A | |
| Nico Gonzales | Aquinas | 2013 | D | |
| John Gonzalez | Newark | 2009 | M | |
| Marcel Gonzalez | Newark | 2026 | A | |
| Matteo Gonzalez | Gates Chili | 2019 | A | |
| Nate Gonzalez | Newark | 2011 | A | |
| Tristan Gonzalez | Midlakes | 2019 | M | |
| Graham Gooch | Irondequoit | 2014 | LSM | |
| Jason Good | Gananda | 2018 | G | |
| Noah Goodall | Mynderse | 2017 | G | |
| Grady Goodberlet | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2027 | A | |
| Tyler Goode | Canandaigua | 2019 | A | GCC |
| Tyler Goodenough | East Rochester | 2013 | M | |
| Rob Goodenow | Waterloo | 2009 | A | |
| Alex Goodermote | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Andrew Goodermote | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | A | |
| Andrew Goodlein | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| Chris Goodman | Midlakes | 2015 | M | |
| Jesse Goodman | Midlakes | 2007 | M | |
| Joseph Goodman | Waterloo | 2013 | M | |
| Mike Goodman | Waterloo | 2010 | A | |
| Nick Goodman | Greece Storm | 2021 | A | |
| Will Goodness | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Justin Goodrich | Hilton | 2015 | M | Seton Hill |
| Kyle Goodrich | Hilton | 2017 | D | |
| Robert Goodridge | Aquinas | 2023 | G | |
| Zach Goodsell | Spencerport | 2012 | A | |
| Zachary Goole | Gates Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Desmond Goolsby | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Greg Gora | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | M | |
| Kelsey Gordinier | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | D | |
| Ben Gordon | Brighton | 2008 | M | |
| Phil Gordon | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | M | |
| Will Gordon | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | G | |
| Tyler Gorgione | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Nick Gorino | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | A | |
| Austin Gorman | Aquinas | 2010 | A | |
| Francis Gorman | Pittsford | 2007 | D | |
| Jackson Gorman | Hilton | 2025 | A | |
| James Gorman | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | D | |
| Cam Gormel | Gates Chili | 2010 | M | Keuka |
| Artur Gorniak | Eastridge | 2014 | M | |
| Koebi Gorske | Newark | 2019 | A | |
| Connor Gorton | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | M | Utica |
| Tyler Gostling | Spencerport | 2021 | A | |
| Sam Gotham | Victor | 2023 | A | SUNY Stony Brook |
| Troy Gothem | Mynderse | 2005 | M | |
| Colin Gottko | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M | |
| Noah Gottko | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | A | |
| Chase Gottstein | Thomas | 2022 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Matthew Gouger | Hilton | 2018 | M | |
| Mike Gouger | Hilton | 2014 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Kody Gould | Fairport | 2020 | M | Wittenberg |
| Kyle Gould | Fairport | 2022 | A/M | Wittenberg |
| Trent Gould | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | G | |
| Tyler Gould | Schroeder | 2022 | M | Potsdam |
| Reis Gouldrick | Gananda | 2016 | D | |
| Noah Goulette | Newark | 2016 | A | |
| Brandon Grace | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | Potsdam |
| Corey Grace | Penn Yan | 2013 | M | Morrisville |
| Don Grace | Thomas | 2011 | G | |
| Forrest Grady | Brockport | 2012 | A | |
| Justin Graham | Victor | 2020 | M | |
| Taunce Grahman | Hilton | 2013 | D | |
| Malik Gramling | Geneva | 2020 | D | |
| Chris Grammatico | Batavia | 2010 | M | |
| Ian Grana | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | A | |
| Nick Grana | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | |
| Matt Grande | Thomas | 2015 | M | |
| Jack Graney | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | D | |
| Kevin Granger | Newark | 2007 | D | |
| David Granito | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| Elijah Grant | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Jaxon Grant | Canandaigua | 2022 | M | Wingate |
| Nick Grant | Aquinas | 2012 | M | |
| Zach Grant | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Jon Graus | Hilton | 2007 | A | |
| Thomas Gravino | Victor | 2023 | M | Maryland |
| Alex Gray | Aquinas | 2008 | D | St John Fisher |
| Chris Gray | Penfield | 2012 | M | |
| Cory Gray | Midlakes | 2011 | A | Keuka |
| Evan Gray | Marcus Whitman | 2020 | M | |
| Karl Gray | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | M/A | |
| Leo Gray | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | D/LSM | |
| Mike Gray | Aquinas | 2008 | M | |
| Nicholas Gray | Brighton | 2025 | M | |
| Nick Gray | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Tanner Gray | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | A | |
| Jonathan Graziose | Wayne | 2019 | D | |
| Nick Graziose | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Aidan Greco | Irondequoit | 2023 | A/M | Robert Morris |
| Brendan Green | Pittsford | 2008 | G | Ithaca |
| Caleb Green | Brighton | 2018 | G | Bowdoin |
| Colt Green | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Jackson Green | Pittsford | 2023 | M | Princeton |
| Jordan Green | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Kevin Green | Penfield | 2007 | A | Potsdam |
| Koby Green | Fairport | 2011 | M | |
| Maxwell Green | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Mekhi Green | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Mike Green | Gates Chili | 2008 | A | |
| Carson Greene | Canandaigua | 2017 | A | |
| Colin Greene | Canandaigua | 2020 | M | |
| Joey Greene | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | A | Elmira |
| Quantel Greene | East United | 2023 | M/D | |
| Quantel Greene | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Terrance Greene | Newark | 2018 | M | GCC |
| Mark Greer | Canandaigua | 2011 | M | |
| Jesse Gregory | Pal-Mac | 2008 | D | |
| Mitchell Grieb | Thomas | 2019 | A | |
| Phil Griffe | Spencerport | 2009 | M | |
| Austin Griffin | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | M | |
| Collin Griffin | Schroeder | 2018 | A/M | |
| Corey Griffin | Canandaigua | 2011 | G | |
| Ian Griffin | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M/A | |
| Jared Griffin | Schroeder | 2016 | A/M | |
| Josh Griffin | Spencerport | 2017 | A | |
| Kenny Griffin | Batavia | 2015 | D | |
| Kenny Griffin | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | D | |
| Kyle Griffin | Schroeder | 2014 | D | |
| Nick Griffin | Penn Yan | 2016 | A/M | |
| Ryan Griffin | Spencerport | 2019 | G | |
| Tyler Griffin | Penn Yan | 2021 | D | Clarkson |
| Aiden Griffiths | Penn Yan | 2026 | G/M | |
| Derek Grillone | Geneva | 2013 | G | |
| Keagen Grim | Hilton | 2021 | M | |
| Westin Grim | Hilton | 2022 | D | |
| Bryson Grimes | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Curtis Grimes | Midlakes | 2020 | M | |
| Jamison Grimes | Gates Chili | 2033 | M | |
| R.J. Gringeri | Geneva | 2007 | M | Nazareth |
| Oliver Grisdale | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | A | |
| Oliver Grisdale | Irondequoit | 2024 | A/M | |
| Ryan Grogan | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | A | Alfred State |
| Hunter Groh | Gananda | 2023 | M | |
| Mason Groh | Gananda | 2028 | A | |
| Matt Grome | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Trevor Groom | Waterloo | 2020 | D | |
| A.J. Groot | Canandaigua | 2007 | M | |
| Dan Groot | Canandaigua | 2005 | M | Maryland |
| Johnny Groover | Gates Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Matthew Gropp | Fairport | 2006 | A | Oswego |
| Pete Gropp | Fairport | 2012 | G | Potsdam |
| Thomas Gropp | Fairport | 2008 | G | Oswego |
| Jake Gross | Pittsford | 2008 | D | |
| Trevor Gross | Wayne | 2017 | D | |
| Tyler Gross | Wayne | 2015 | M | |
| Jackson Grosshans | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | |
| Jackson Grossman | Penfield | 2020 | M | |
| Zach Grossman | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | |
| Sean Grove | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | M | |
| Matthew Grover | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Mike Grover | Midlakes | 2005 | M | |
| Nicholas Grover | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | A/M | |
| Chance Groves | Penn Yan | 2027 | D | |
| Collin Grow | Thomas | 2019 | D | |
| Jordan Growney | Fairport | 2013 | A/M | |
| Dom Gruttadauria | Spencerport | 2013 | A | |
| Rocky Gruttadauria | Spencerport | 2010 | M | |
| Cole Gruttadaurio | Wayne | 2016 | A/M | |
| Frank Guadagnino | Schroeder | 2010 | M | |
| Mike Guard | Geneva | 2006 | A | |
| Phill Guard | Geneva | 2011 | G | |
| Hulian Guarnere | Brockport | 2015 | A | |
| Yancarlos Guarnizo | Eastridge | 2015 | D | |
| Evan Gudell | Brighton | 2016 | D | |
| Justin Gudell | Brighton | 2014 | D | |
| Dillon Gue | Rush-Henrietta | 2027 | M | |
| Jonah Guelzow | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | D | |
| Caden Guenot | Mynderse | 2024 | A | |
| Rob Guenther | Thomas | 2011 | A | |
| Brandon Guentner | Schroeder | 2016 | D | |
| Dan Guererri | Penn Yan | 2012 | D | |
| Jeremy Guererri | Penn Yan | 2009 | M | |
| Peter Guerrieri | Gates Chili | 2017 | LSM | |
| Cole Guest | Penfield | 2016 | D | St John Fisher |
| David Guest | Hilton | 2016 | M | |
| Justin Guest | Hilton | 2024 | D/LSM | |
| Aaron Gugel | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Jake Guggino | Aquinas | 2026 | A | |
| Anthony Guida | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | M | |
| Chris Guido | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | D | |
| Mike Guinan | Geneva | 2021 | A | |
| Liam Guiton | Penfield | 2014 | G | St Rose |
| Elvis Gujic | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Alex Gulisano | Thomas | 2013 | G | MCC |
| Cayden Gullace | Canandaigua | 2026 | M | |
| Dom Gullace | Canandaigua | 2024 | D | Wingate |
| Amani Gullo | Canandaigua | 2024 | M | |
| Uriah Gumaer | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2028 | M | |
| Brad Gurbacki | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M/A | |
| Jeff Gurbacki | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | A | |
| Rob Gurgansky | Irondequoit | 2008 | DM | |
| Vitaliy Gurman | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Max Gurowski | Thomas | 2008 | A | Jacksonville |
| William Gurowski | Thomas | 2009 | M | |
| Corey Gurski | Hilton | 2011 | M | |
| Jordan Gushue | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M | |
| Sean Gustafson | Mynderse | 2011 | D | |
| Billy Gutheil | Spencerport | 2007 | M | |
| Reyluis Gutierrez | Victor | 2013 | M | |
| David Gutman | Thomas | 2019 | M | MCC |
| Colin Guy | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Jake Guy | Aquinas | 2013 | D | |
| Jake Guy | Schroeder | 2013 | D | |
| Austin Guyett | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | D | |
| Jacob Guzda | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Sam Guzzetta | Hilton | 2025 | G | |
| JT Haag | Brighton | 2011 | A | MCC |
| Scott Haag | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Emmett Haak | Wayne | 2026 | M | |
| Robby Haak | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | G | |
| James Haas | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | D | |
| Matt Haas | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | |
| Zach Haas | Spencerport | 2010 | M | |
| Colby Habermacher | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | A | |
| Sven Habitzreuther | Irondequoit | 2025 | G | |
| Tyler Hacker | Hilton | 2019 | M | |
| Anthony Hackett | Spencerport | 2024 | M | |
| Zach Hackett | Midlakes | 2015 | A/M | |
| Ben Hadley | Fairport | 2022 | DM | |
| Clark Hadley | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Harry Hadley | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | D | |
| Matthew Hadley | Fairport | 2019 | M | |
| Brian Hadsell | Canandaigua | 2005 | M | |
| Jack Haefner | Irondequoit | 2017 | M | Buffalo |
| Jake Hagadone | Haverling | 2025 | D | |
| Ryan Hage | Brockport | 2008 | M | |
| Robert Haggerty | Brighton | 2013 | A | |
| Bryan Haight | Irondequoit | 2008 | M | MCC |
| Mickey Haight | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | Loyola |
| Bernie Haims | Pittsford | 2019 | D | Oswego |
| Connor Haims | Pittsford | 2017 | D | Le Moyne |
| Matt Hair | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | M | |
| Connor Hakes | Gananda | 2017 | D | |
| Kyle Hale | Fairport | 2010 | M | |
| Tyler Hale | Spencerport | 2014 | D | |
| Colin Haley | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | DM | |
| Zachary Haley | Avon | 2014 | A/M | |
| Leroy Halftown | Mynderse | 2012 | M | |
| Scott Halik | Fairport | 2008 | D | |
| Aaron Hall | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Brendan Hall | Aquinas | 2010 | M | |
| Codey Hall | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | M | |
| David Hall | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | M | |
| Donnell Hall | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2023 | D | |
| Giovani Hall | UPrep | 2016 | D | |
| Grace Hall | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2021 | D | |
| Kenny Hall | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | G | |
| Kyle Hall | Fairport | 2009 | G | |
| Matt Hall | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | A | FLCC |
| Nate Hall | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | LSM | |
| Pat Hall | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | D | |
| Payton Hall | Schroeder | 2018 | M/FO | |
| Trevar Hall | Pittsford | 2018 | D | Tufts |
| Wyatt Hall | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| Brett Hallembeck | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | D | |
| AJ Haller | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | D | |
| Liam Haller | Victor | 2019 | G | |
| Ben Halleran | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | G | |
| Grant Halleran | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | D | |
| Joe Hallowell | Greece | 2005 | A | |
| Joe Hallowell | Greece Ath_Ody | 2005 | M | Keuka |
| Zaire Halmond | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Andrew Halpern | Pittsford | 2007 | M | |
| Mike Halsey | Pal-Mac | 2023 | A | |
| Josh Halter | Fairport | 2013 | A/M | |
| Nikolai Hama | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | A/M | |
| Zain Hameed | Thomas | 2018 | A | |
| Andy Hamel | Wayne | 2021 | A/M | Nazareth |
| Josh Hamel | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Michael Hamiche | Victor | 2016 | D | |
| Brady Hamilton | Gates Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Charlie Hamilton | Pal-Mac | 2014 | D | |
| Cody Hamilton | Gates Chili | 2014 | LSM | |
| Connor Hamilton | Gates Chili | 2019 | A | |
| Cooper Hamilton | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | A | |
| Ethan Hamilton | Penfield | 2023 | M | |
| Jake Hamilton | Pal-Mac | 2010 | LSM | |
| Jake Hamilton | Gates Chili | 2022 | LSM | MCC |
| Jordan Hamilton | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Justin Hamilton | Batavia | 2015 | M | |
| Justin Hamilton | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | A/M | |
| Ryan Hamilton | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | D | |
| Ryan Hamilton | Batavia | 2023 | A | |
| Ryan Hamilton | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Zachary Hamilton | Fairport | 2007 | M | Oswego |
| Rainer Hamm | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | |
| Billy Hamman | Wayne | 2014 | G | |
| Justin Hammond | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | D | |
| Wyatt Hammond | Haverling | 2020 | M/A | |
| Zach Hammond | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | M | |
| Markel Hampton | Victor | 2024 | M | |
| Patrick Hampton | Marcus Whitman | 2020 | M | |
| Nick Hancock | Penfield | 2010 | M | |
| Seamus Hand | Penfield | 2022 | G | Oswego |
| Will Hand | Penfield | 2021 | M | |
| Eric Haney | Victor | 2014 | A | |
| Jon Hankin | Victor | 2005 | M | |
| Henok Hankinson | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Tommy Hanley | Thomas | 2016 | A | |
| Nick Hann | Newark | 2006 | D | |
| Craig Hanna | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | D | |
| Joe Hanna | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | A/M | |
| Mark Hanna | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | A | |
| Nikolai Hanna | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | A/M | |
| Ted Hanna | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | D | |
| Matt Hannan | Newark | 2005 | D | |
| Brigham Hansen | Penn Yan | 2022 | D | |
| Jake Hanson | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| John Hanss | Irondequoit | 2004 | DM | Nazareth |
| Brian Hantzis | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | A | Delaware |
| Thomas Harden | Wayne | 2014 | D | |
| Jared Hardies | Brockport | 2019 | M | |
| John Harding | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Cosmo Hardy | Fairport | 2012 | M | |
| Harrison Hardy | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Jake Harford | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | D | |
| Dan Hargrave | Pal-Mac | 2006 | D | |
| Quinn Hargrave | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| Tal Haring | Brighton | 2010 | M | |
| Karmine Harlan | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Garrett Harloff | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | A/M | |
| Brian Harman | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | D | |
| Devon Harmon | Newark | 2021 | M | |
| Dylan Harmon | Newark | 2016 | M | Belmont Abbey |
| Owen Harnden | Hilton | 2026 | G | |
| Jason Harness | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | D | |
| Jocob Harnischfeger | Penfield | 2019 | A | |
| Ethan Harold | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Nolan Harold | Haverling | 2020 | LSM | |
| Josh Harp | Victor | 2014 | D | |
| Tyler Harper | Gananda | 2017 | D | |
| Caden Harrington | Penfield | 2023 | M | |
| Dan Harrington | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | M | |
| Mason Harrington | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2023 | D | |
| Pat Harrington | Gates Chili | 2011 | D | |
| Alex Harris | Gates Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Audi Harris | East Rochester | 2012 | M | |
| Billy Harris | Schroeder | 2008 | A | |
| Brandon Harris | Schroeder | 2012 | M | |
| Cameron Harris | Brighton | 2011 | M | |
| Daniel Harris | Irondequoit | 2016 | D | St John Fisher |
| Dave Harris | Haverling | 2008 | A | |
| Jared Harris | Hilton | 2013 | LSM | |
| Josh Harris | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | D | |
| Mitchell Harris | Fairport | 2011 | A/M | |
| Tristan Harris | Newark | 2025 | M | |
| Zachary Harris | Fairport | 2006 | G | Oswego |
| Brent Harrison | Haverling | 2009 | D | |
| Connor Harrison | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | D | |
| Josh Harrison | Wayne | 2022 | D | |
| Kyle Harrison | Haverling | 2011 | A | |
| Mike Harrison | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | D | |
| Aiden Harrod | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | M | |
| Andrew Hart | Irondequoit | 2007 | A | |
| Chris Hart | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| John Hart | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| John Hart | East United-Eastridge | 2027 | A | |
| Nick Hart | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Peter Hart | Thomas | 2007 | M | Keuka |
| Zack Hart | Brockport | 2015 | D | |
| Jason Harter | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | G | |
| Heath Hartgrove | Wayne | 2021 | G | |
| Jon Hartkley | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | |
| Wes Hartley | Spencerport | 2006 | D | |
| Ben Hartman | Newark | 2008 | G | |
| Luke Hartman | Newark | 2010 | A | |
| Pat Hartnett | Penfield | 2010 | D | |
| Tim Hartnett | Penfield | 2018 | D | |
| Jamaar Harvey | Thomas | 2023 | D | |
| Will Harvey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| David Haseley | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | D | St John Fisher |
| Adam Hasenauer | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| Britain Hasler | Avon | 2020 | DM | |
| Britt Hasler | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | D | |
| Kyle Haslinger | Victor | 2013 | A | |
| David Hassett | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | M | |
| Ryan Hasson | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Ron Hatch | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | MCC |
| Dalton Hathaway | Mynderse | 2012 | D | |
| Devin Hathaway | Geneva | 2016 | D | |
| Jordan Hathorn | Marcus Whitman | 2009 | M | |
| Greyson Hathway | Penn Yan | 2028 | M | |
| Zachary Haubner | Avon | 2014 | D | |
| JT Hauck | Thomas | 2011 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Bryan Haude | Hilton | 2009 | M | |
| Riley Hauf | Victor | 2019 | D | |
| Nick Haug | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | M | |
| Matt Haugh | Fairport | 2027 | D | |
| Ryan Haugh | Livonia | 2020 | M | |
| Ryan Haugh | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | M/A | Brockport |
| Josh Hauman | Schroeder | 2020 | A/M | Alfred |
| Nick Hauman | Schroeder | 2022 | M | Towson |
| Matt Hauryski | Haverling | 2014 | G | |
| Gunnar Hausknecht | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Bailey Havranek | Penfield | 2017 | M | |
| Adam Hawk | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Casey Hawk | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| John Hawk | Fairport | 2011 | M | |
| Matt Hawk | Fairport | 2015 | G | |
| Brandon Hawkins | Pal-Mac | 2017 | D | |
| Trevor Hawkins | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | A | |
| Alex Hawkins-Rusch | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Thomas Haworth | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | M | |
| Joe Hawryschuk | Victor | 2022 | D | |
| Matt Haws | Waterloo | 2005 | A | |
| Pete Hawyrschuk | Mynderse | 2007 | D | |
| Camden Hay | Victor | 2020 | A | |
| Tanner Hay | Victor | 2018 | D | SUNY Albany |
| Atlaure Hayes | Eastridge | 2014 | M | |
| Cody Hayes | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | M | |
| Joe Hayes | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | A/M | |
| Michael Hayes | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Mike Hayes | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Nick Hayes | Newark | 2023 | A/M | |
| Stewart Hayes | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Stuart Hayes | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Zacchaeus Hayles | Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| Zacchaeus Hayles | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| Andrew Hays | Fairport | 2011 | M | North Carolina |
| Gavin Hayslip | Brighton | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Gavin Hayslip | Brighton | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Aaron Hayward | Hilton | 2009 | D | |
| Kyle Hayward | Hilton | 2007 | M | St John Fisher |
| Trevor Hayward | Brockport | 2010 | A | |
| Mike Hazard | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Owen Hazard | Hilton | 2023 | A | |
| Dylan Hazlett | Midlakes | 2019 | M | FLCC |
| Kevin Heacock | Spencerport | 2010 | M | |
| Tim Heacock | Spencerport | 2006 | G | |
| Rowyn Heagney | Canandaigua | 2024 | M/FO | |
| Matthew Healey | Schroeder | 2015 | D | |
| Jack Healy | Pittsford | 2027 | M | |
| Steve Healy | Geneva | 2006 | D | |
| Steven Hearn | Victor | 2007 | M | MCC |
| Dynell Heath | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Larry Heath | Livonia | 2008 | A | |
| Henry Heaton | Geneva | 2005 | M | |
| Ty Heaton | Spencerport | 2023 | M | |
| Tyler Heaton | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| James Hedger | Aquinas | 2013 | D | |
| Brendan Heeb | Canandaigua | 2011 | D | |
| Connor Heeb | Canandaigua | 2014 | A | |
| Ryan Heeb | Canandaigua | 2015 | A | |
| Peyton Heid | Greece Storm | 2019 | A | |
| Max Heieck | Geneva | 2025 | M | |
| Craig Heier | Fairport | 2010 | M | |
| Matthew Heininger | Brighton | 2026 | M | |
| Lucas Heinsler | Spencerport | 2023 | A | |
| Kendrick Heintzelman | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | M | |
| John Heisel | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | D | |
| Garrett Heisinger | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | |
| Danny Helfrich | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | D | |
| Chris Hellmers | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | A/M | |
| Eric Hellmers | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | A/M | |
| Schuyler Helmer | Geneva | 2010 | D | |
| Evan Helming | Canandaigua | 2011 | A | St Rose |
| Troy Helsdon | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | M/D | |
| Troy Helsdon | Batavia | 2021 | D/LSM | |
| Doug Hemink | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | M | RIT |
| Jon Hemink | Churchville-Chili | 2010 | A | |
| Clay Hemminger | Midlakes | 2007 | M | |
| AJ Hems | Pal-Mac | 2016 | A | |
| Andrew Hems | Pal-Mac | 2008 | D | |
| Gray Hendershot | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Austin Henderson | Avon | 2014 | G | |
| Casey Henderson | Penfield | 2025 | A | |
| Christian Henderson | Avon | 2016 | G | |
| Connor Henderson | Canandaigua | 2008 | A | St John Fisher |
| Josh Henderson | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | |
| Mark Henderson | Penfield | 2023 | A | |
| Noah Henderson | Gananda | 2014 | A | |
| Omari Henderson | Brighton | 2013 | D | |
| Kevin Hendricks | Newark | 2007 | A | |
| TJ Hendricks | Fairport | 2017 | A/M | RIT |
| Josh Hendrickson | Livonia | 2005 | M | |
| Jimmy Hendron | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Sean Henley | Pal-Mac | 2023 | LSM | |
| Robert Henning | Batavia | 2010 | M | |
| Mark Henrichs | Brighton | 2009 | A | |
| Ian Henrichsen | Haverling | 2012 | M | |
| Tony Henriquez | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | M | |
| Royal Henrrix | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | |
| Alex Henry | Hilton | 2010 | A | |
| Cody Henry | Schroeder | 2011 | M | |
| Nick Henry | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | A | |
| Nick Henry | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Dylan Henshaw | Haverling | 2026 | D | |
| Andrew Henssen | Bishop Kearney | 2022 | A/M | |
| Jake Hepner | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | LSM | |
| Max Herbison | Pittsford | 2024 | D | |
| Nick Herbst | Canandaigua | 2021 | D | |
| Preston Herbst | Canandaigua | 2014 | D | |
| Lucas Herd | Newark | 2025 | D | |
| Jack Herendeen | Victor | 2024 | A | Cornell |
| Luke Herendeen | Pal-Mac | 2024 | D | |
| Sebastin Hergert | Gananda | 2019 | M | |
| Colin Herington | Fairport | 2021 | M | |
| Jackson Herman | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | G | |
| Jesse Herman | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Jordan Herman | Schroeder | 2015 | DM | |
| Chris Hermann | Brighton | 2013 | D | |
| Drake Hernandes | Newark | 2023 | G/D | |
| Alex Hernandez | Victor | 2018 | M | |
| Dominic Hernandez | East United | 2021 | A | |
| Dominic Hernandez | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| Eric Hernandez | Victor | 2017 | M | |
| Evan Hernandez | Victor | 2014 | D | |
| Julian Hernandez | Hilton | 2013 | M | |
| Jay Hernandez Rivas | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | M/A | |
| Casey Herod | Canandaigua | 2020 | M | |
| Ryan Herod | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | A/M | |
| Kole Herren | Fairport | 2019 | A | |
| Cody Herrgesell | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | M | |
| Damon Herrick | Haverling | 2020 | M | |
| Dan Herrick | Haverling | 2008 | D | |
| DeAndre Herring | Spencerport | 2016 | M | |
| Owen Herring | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | G | |
| Brady Herrneckar | Greece Storm | 2022 | M | |
| Jake HerrNeckar | Greece Arc_Oly | 2020 | A/M | |
| Jake Herrneckar | Greece Storm | 2020 | A | |
| Ryan HerrNeckar | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | D | |
| Dan Hershelman | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| Jonah Hershey | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2016 | A | |
| Jud Hershey | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | G | |
| Jerrett Hertzel | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | A/M | |
| Ben Herzog | Fairport | 2009 | D | |
| Brayden Hess | Haverling | 2021 | M | |
| Matt Hess | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| Randy Hess | Wayne | 2013 | D | |
| Klay Heston | Aquinas | 2011 | A | Lehigh |
| Kraig Heston | Aquinas | 2009 | G | SUNY Binghamton |
| Andrew Hewitt | Gates Chili | 2023 | A | |
| Holden Hewlett | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | D/LSM | Canton |
| Matt Hey | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | M | |
| Matt Heyden | Brockport | 2019 | M | North Greenville |
| Charles Hezel | Pittsford | 2027 | D | |
| Noah Hezel | Pittsford | 2023 | D | Lafayette |
| Colin Hickey | Brighton | 2006 | A | |
| Dan Hickey | Geneva | 2013 | D | |
| Dylan Hickey | Hilton | 2010 | D | Mt Olive |
| Nick Hickey | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | G | |
| Sean Hickey | Aquinas | 2008 | M | |
| Nathan Hickok | Wayne | 2018 | D | |
| John Hicks | Midlakes | 2010 | D | |
| Mike Hicks | Spencerport | 2006 | M | |
| Niger Hicks | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | D | |
| Matt Hierlwimmer | Livonia | 2012 | M | |
| Owen Higgins | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | D | |
| Jason Hightower | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | D | |
| Griffin Hilimire | Mynderse | 2025 | A | |
| Adam Hill | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | D | Cazenovia |
| Andrew Hill | Greece Storm | 2024 | M/A | |
| Brady Hill | Thomas | 2024 | DM | |
| Brock Hill | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | M | |
| Christian Hill | Livonia | 2018 | G | |
| Christian Hill | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | G | |
| Cody Hill | Brockport | 2009 | M | |
| Collin Hill | Thomas | 2019 | DM | |
| Dan Hill | Brighton | 2007 | M | |
| DaShon Hill | UPrep | 2016 | M | |
| David Hill | Brighton | 2011 | D | |
| Dylan Hill | Livonia | 2015 | D | |
| Isaiah Hill | Batavia | 2023 | M/A | |
| Isaiah Hill | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | A | |
| Jake Hill | Greece Ath_Ody | 2020 | A | |
| Jake Hill | Greece Storm | 2020 | M | |
| John Hill | Thomas | 2013 | A | RIT |
| Kevin Hill | Thomas | 2015 | M | Penn State |
| Mark Hill | Penfield | 2007 | A | |
| Mason Hill | Thomas | 2009 | D | |
| Matt Hill | Thomas | 2018 | M | UMass-Amherst |
| Max Hill | Victor | 2012 | A | |
| Max Hill | Pal-Mac | 2028 | A | |
| Theo Hill | Batavia | 2010 | G | |
| Tucker Hill | Victor | 2018 | M/FO | MCC |
| Justin Hillery | Brighton | 2008 | M | |
| Joe Hillier | Fairport | 2022 | D | |
| Marc Hillier | Fairport | 2026 | M | |
| Sam Hillier | Fairport | 2023 | D | |
| Tom Hilling | Brighton | 2012 | G | |
| Austin Hillman | Waterloo | 2018 | M | |
| Makai Hillmon | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | A | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Sam Hillmon | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | A | |
| Steve Hilsdorf | Gates Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Andrew Hilton | Gates Chili | 2007 | A | Brockport |
| Dan Hinderland | Thomas | 2007 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Jack Hinderland | Thomas | 2010 | A | |
| Terrance Hinds | Aquinas | 2026 | D | |
| Ryan Hinman | Hilton | 2020 | M/FO | |
| Austin Hintz | Spencerport | 2010 | A | |
| Tyler Hintz | Spencerport | 2006 | M | |
| Cullen Hirschman | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Ryan Hirschman | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | A | |
| CJ Hiscock | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Justyn Hiscock | Eastridge | 2020 | A | |
| Justyn Hiscock | East United | 2020 | A | |
| Zach Hiscock | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Zachary Hiscock | Eastridge | 2020 | M | |
| Eric Hislop | Fairport | 2008 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Steven Hislop | Fairport | 2005 | D | Clarkson |
| Michael Hixson | Midlakes | 2007 | D | |
| Justin Hlywa | Mynderse | 2013 | A | |
| Allison Hoad | Haverling | 2027 | D | |
| Darrell Hoad | Haverling | 2022 | D | |
| Dylan Hoad | Haverling | 2019 | G/D | Keuka |
| Ezra Hoad | Haverling | 2024 | M | |
| Max Hoadley | Penfield | 2019 | M | |
| Colin Hoage | Brockport | 2024 | A | |
| Brayden Hoak | Churchville-Chili | 2025 | A/M | |
| Bryce Hoang | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | M | |
| Rooney Hoang | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | DM | |
| Ben Hoban | Thomas | 2020 | A | |
| Nathan Hoban | Thomas | 2022 | M | Le Moyne |
| Hayden Hobbs | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Dominic Hoch | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | A | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Casey Hochheimer | Aquinas | 2018 | M | Hobart |
| Max Hochheimer | Eastridge | 2014 | M | |
| Dylan Hochreiter | Hilton | 2016 | LSM | |
| Justin Hockenberger | Spencerport | 2019 | A | |
| Cam Hocker | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Jordon Hodder | Victor | 2013 | A | |
| Mason Hodge | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Brett Hodgeman | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | M | |
| Trevor Hodgins | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | A | Ohio State |
| Keagan Hoesterey | Pal-Mac | 2024 | A/M | |
| Kyle Hoesterey | Pal-Mac | 2022 | D | |
| Patrick Hoff | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | D/LSM | |
| Chandler Hoffman | Penfield | 2009 | M | |
| James Hoffman | Brockport | 2020 | D | |
| Conor Hogan | Midlakes | 2009 | A | |
| Joe Hogan | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | DM | |
| Liam Hogan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | M | |
| Steve Hogan | Spencerport | 2009 | M | |
| Griffin Hogle | Penfield | 2015 | G | |
| Kyle Hohmann | Brighton | 2009 | G | |
| Chris Hoke | Fairport | 2013 | M | |
| Jack Holbrough | Brighton | 2024 | A | |
| James Holbrough | Brighton | 2026 | A | |
| Jacob Holdaway | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | A | |
| Jacob Holdaway | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| Josh Holdaway | Greece Ath_Ody | 2018 | LSM | |
| Ben Holdsworth | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | A/M | |
| Austin Holley | Hilton | 2020 | M | |
| Brandon Holley | Livonia | 2014 | A | |
| Bear Hollingsworth | McQuaid Jesuit | 2026 | D | |
| Steve Hollis | Schroeder | 2005 | M | |
| John Holly | Penn Yan | 2025 | M | |
| Cody Holman | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Ben Holmes | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2017 | D | |
| Nick Holmquist | Pittsford | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Alex Holt | Midlakes | 2015 | A | |
| Reece Holt | Midlakes | 2017 | D | |
| Ian Holtby | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | M | Hilbert |
| Alex Holton | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M | |
| Ross Holton | Brighton | 2017 | D | |
| Ari Holtzman | Brighton | 2007 | D | |
| Ben Holtzman | Brighton | 2008 | M | |
| Charlie Holvey | Pal-Mac | 2015 | G | |
| Conor Holvey | Batavia | 2012 | A/M | |
| Patrick Holzschuh | Brockport | 2018 | D | |
| Caleb Homer | Haverling | 2027 | D | |
| Nigel Honczek | Midlakes | 2011 | D | |
| Steven Hondorf | Thomas | 2006 | G | |
| Justin Honeck | Schroeder | 2018 | M | |
| Matthew Hood | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Nate Hood | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Sam Hoodak | Pittsford | 2013 | A | |
| Ernie Hook | Pittsford | 2009 | G | |
| Jared Hoose | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | A | |
| Nathan Hoover | Greece Storm | 2023 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Brian Hopkins | Pal-Mac | 2014 | M | |
| John Hopkins | Brockport | 2007 | A | |
| Jeremy Hopsicker | Brockport | 2021 | A | |
| Colin Horan | Thomas | 2018 | M | |
| Evan Horan | Thomas | 2015 | D | |
| Eric Horeth | Schroeder | 2008 | D | RIT |
| Garrett Horne | Brockport | 2024 | LSM | |
| Todd Horne | Eastridge | 2007 | M | |
| Trevor Horne | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Ian Horning | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Casey Horschel | Brockport | 2024 | D | |
| Gabe Horton | Brockport | 2020 | M | |
| Andrew Hosenfeld | Greece Ath_Ody | 2008 | G | |
| Marc Hosey | Spencerport | 2005 | LSM | |
| Eric Hostetter | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Parker Hotchkiss | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| Cam Hotto | Victor | 2018 | A | |
| John Houck | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Shane Hough | Newark | 2008 | D | |
| Nick Houghtaling | Penn Yan | 2020 | D | |
| Stephen Houlihan | Wayne | 2017 | D | |
| Guy House | Haverling | 2020 | M | |
| Zach House | Haverling | 2023 | M | |
| Tyler Houseman | Brockport | 2025 | M/A | |
| Jason Houtenbrink | Victor | 2007 | M | MCC |
| Josh Hovey | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | G | |
| Connor Howard | Newark | 2015 | M | |
| Grant Howard | Newark | 2015 | M | Walsh |
| John Howard | Penfield | 2019 | G | |
| Owen Howard | Gananda | 2016 | M/A | |
| Alex Howell | Pittsford | 2010 | G | Geneseo |
| Brenden Howell | Hilton | 2019 | A/M | |
| Nick Howell | Pittsford | 2013 | M | |
| Ashton Howlett | Brockport | 2020 | D | Alfred |
| Mike Howlett | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | D | |
| Brian Howse | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Tyler Hoye | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Garrett Hoyler | Penfield | 2011 | M | |
| Kevin Hoyler | Penfield | 2007 | D | |
| Roman Hoyser | Gananda | 2025 | M | |
| Jhari Hoyte | UPrep | 2017 | M | |
| Eraklis Hristodoulou | Schroeder | 2012 | M | |
| Michael Hristodoulou | McQuaid Jesuit | 2027 | D | |
| Ethan Hryhorenko | Hilton | 2020 | LSM | |
| Nick Hryzna | Thomas | 2019 | M | |
| Taylor Hubbard | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Timothy Hubbard | Hilton | 2021 | D | Brockport |
| Craig Hubler | Fairport | 2015 | A/M | |
| Adam Huck | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Jeremy Hudak | Livonia | 2007 | D | |
| Tristan Hudak | Livonia | 2010 | D | St John Fisher |
| Austin Hudson | Penfield | 2017 | M | |
| Ethan Hudson | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | A | |
| Mike Hudson | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | A | |
| Torin Hudson | East Rochester | 2011 | M | |
| Joshua Hueber | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Rhyder Huff | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | M | |
| Wyatt Huff | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | D | |
| John Hugh | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | M | |
| Cameron Hughes | Avon | 2016 | A/M | |
| Deakyn Hughes | Waterloo | 2024 | D | |
| Greg Hughes | Newark | 2011 | M | |
| Jake Hughes | Rush-Henrietta | 2016 | M | |
| Jason Hughes | Pal-Mac | 2011 | D | |
| Kieran Hughes | Brighton | 2024 | LSM | Hamilton |
| Alex Huie | Midlakes | 2015 | M | |
| Slavic Huley | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Wolodia Huley | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | G | |
| Connor Hulme | Canandaigua | 2015 | A | |
| Anthony Hulse | East United | 2022 | D | |
| Anthony Hulse | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | D | |
| Brandyn Humberstone | Penfield | 2011 | D | |
| Caleb Humbert | Thomas | 2014 | A | |
| Cameron Humbert | Hilton | 2025 | M | |
| Thomas Hummel | Irondequoit | 2014 | D | |
| Evander Hummer | Mynderse | 2013 | M | |
| Matt Humnicky | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Jacob Hundley | Penfield | 2024 | DM | |
| Will Hunnerlach | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Cutter Hunt | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2020 | A | |
| Elijah Hunt | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | DM | |
| Joshua Hunt | Brighton | 2014 | M/A | |
| Chrishawn Hunter | East United | 2022 | M | |
| Chrishawn Hunter | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Deon Hunter | Penfield | 2014 | DM | |
| Sage Hunter | Pal-Mac | 2035 | 0 | |
| Andrew Huntington | Penfield | 2012 | A/M | |
| Dan Huntington | Penfield | 2007 | M | |
| Justin Huntsman | Midlakes | 2009 | D | |
| Alex Hurd | Victor | 2013 | M | |
| Evan Hurlbutt | Pal-Mac | 2020 | A | |
| Jared Hurlbutt | Pal-Mac | 2017 | G | Keuka |
| Tyler Hurlbutt | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | A | |
| Tyler Hurlbutt | Pal-Mac | 2015 | A | |
| Daniel Hurley | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Matthew Hurley | Fairport | 2007 | G | |
| Jessie Hurysz | Eastridge | 2012 | D | |
| Andrew Hurzy | Wayne | 2018 | D | |
| Andrew Hussar | Spencerport | 2021 | M | |
| Nate Hussar | Batavia | 2018 | D | |
| Tyler Hutcheson | Haverling | 2011 | LSM | |
| Mitch Hutteman | Thomas | 2014 | A | |
| Brad Hutton | Thomas | 2010 | A | Hartford |
| Steve Hutton | Thomas | 2004 | M | Geneseo |
| Henry Huynh | Newark | 2019 | A/M | |
| Parker Hyatt | Pittsford | 2019 | M | |
| Alex Hyde | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | A/M | |
| Cory Hyde | Pal-Mac | 2011 | LSM | |
| James Hyde | Irondequoit | 2021 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Nick Hyland | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Connor Hynes | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| Patrick Hynes | Irondequoit | 2017 | G | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Haein Hyun | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Nick Iacchetta | Spencerport | 2014 | LSM | |
| Steve Iachetta | Spencerport | 2010 | A | |
| Dakoda Iamele | Eastridge | 2018 | D | |
| Michael Iannone | Midlakes | 2009 | G | |
| Chayse Ierlan | Victor | 2018 | G | Johns Hopkins |
| T.D. Ierlan | Victor | 2016 | M | Denver |
| Jakson Ihnatiuk | Eastridge | 2020 | M/D | |
| Frank Imburgia | Pittsford | 2017 | M | Hobart |
| Sonny Imburgia | Pittsford | 2019 | A | SUNY Binghamton |
| Nicholas Impson | Fairport | 2011 | M | |
| Anthony Inclima | Spencerport | 2021 | D | |
| Reese Inclima | Spencerport | 2015 | D | |
| Alex Infantino | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | M | |
| Owen Infantino | Greece Storm | 2021 | A/G | MCC |
| Ryan Ingalis | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | M | |
| Sam Ingallina | Gates Chili | 2008 | D | |
| Gavin Ingalls | Fairport | 2020 | M/FO | |
| Matt Ingalls | Brighton | 2011 | G | |
| Brett Ingersoll | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| Will Ingle | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Gavin Ingles | Penn Yan | 2022 | M | |
| Mike Ingolia | Hilton | 2011 | M | |
| Jacob Ingram | Haverling | 2025 | A | |
| Alan Ingrasio | Eastridge | 2007 | M | |
| Dean Ingrassia | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Josh Inguaggiato | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | D | |
| Frank Insalaco | Aquinas | 2012 | D | |
| James Inuzuka | Victor | 2011 | M | |
| Chris Ioannone | Brockport | 2010 | G | |
| Tommy Ippolito | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Troy Ireland | Batavia | 2009 | D | |
| Casey Irland | Mynderse | 2012 | A | |
| John Irvine | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2023 | M | |
| Addison Irwin | Irondequoit | 2016 | M | |
| Tanner Irwin | Penn Yan | 2016 | D | |
| Adam Isaac | Canandaigua | 2016 | D | |
| Cam Isaac | Thomas | 2015 | M | RIT |
| Zachary Isaac | Thomas | 2023 | G | |
| Ehab Isriwea | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| TJ Iuppa | Pittsford | 2010 | M | |
| Joseph Ives | Thomas | 2023 | D | |
| David Jackson | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Keegan Jackson | Canandaigua | 2023 | D | |
| Kerwin Jackson | Gates Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Koppers Jackson | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | A | |
| Kordell Jackson | Victor | 2019 | M | |
| Preston Jackson | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Zymier Jackson | Greece Storm | 2024 | M | |
| Zymier Jackson | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| Bobby Jacob | Pittsford | 2022 | M | Nazareth |
| Jeremy Jacob | Pittsford | 2017 | M | Nazareth |
| Brent Jacobs | Fairport | 2007 | D | |
| Brett Jacobs | Gates Chili | 2015 | A | |
| Chris Jacobs | Pittsford | 2006 | G | |
| Matt Jacobs | Victor | 2010 | D | |
| Zack Jacobs | Batavia | 2009 | D | |
| Travon Jacobson | Waterloo | 2021 | D | |
| Tyler Jacobson | Gates Chili | 2012 | G | |
| Nate Jacon | Geneva | 2018 | D | |
| Phineous Jacques | East Rochester | 2014 | M | |
| Mitchell Jagodeinski | Gates Chili | 2007 | G | |
| Samir Jahic | Schroeder | 2010 | D | |
| Erik Jakobsze | Schroeder | 2018 | D | RIT |
| CJ James | Victor | 2021 | M | |
| Jahmere James | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | MCC |
| Jake Jamieson | Spencerport | 2018 | G/M | |
| Aaron Jamison | Livonia | 2006 | G | |
| Bradley Jamison | Fairport | 2007 | M | |
| Derek Jamison | Pittsford | 2012 | D | |
| Ethan Jamison | Livonia | 2012 | G | |
| Jesse Janas | Mynderse | 2010 | D | |
| Matthew Jansen | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | D | |
| Nathaniel Jansen | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | G | |
| Brian Jantz | Thomas | 2019 | D | St John Fisher |
| Cal Jantzi | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | A | |
| Cal Jantzi | Batavia | 2016 | A | |
| Omar Jaohar | Newark | 2012 | A/M | |
| Bryce Jarboe | Haverling | 2024 | M | |
| Mason Jarboe | Haverling | 2021 | A/M | |
| Nick Jarecke | Penn Yan | 2021 | A | |
| Nick Jasie | Fairport | 2020 | D | |
| Tamar Jasper | Greece Storm | 2024 | M | |
| Waleed Javed | Mynderse | 2007 | M | |
| Avery Javier | Midlakes | 2014 | A/M | |
| Travis Jaycox | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M/FO | |
| Moses Jeary | Brighton | 2023 | M | |
| Andrew Jebo | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | M | |
| Nick Jeffries | Brighton | 2006 | D | |
| Peter Jeffries | Brighton | 2007 | D | |
| Andrew Jenkins | Wayne | 2014 | A | |
| John Jenkins | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Pat Jenkins | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Pat Jenkins | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | M | |
| Terrell Jenkins | Newark | 2026 | DM | |
| Adam Jensen | Waterloo | 2017 | A | |
| Caleb Jensen | Midlakes | 2008 | D | |
| Ed Jensen | Waterloo | 2008 | D | |
| Jack Jensen | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Jaxon Jensen | Penn Yan | 2027 | G | |
| Josh Jensen | Hilton | 2006 | G | |
| Kyle Jensen | Penn Yan | 2005 | M | Keuka |
| Kyle Jensen | Hilton | 2021 | M | |
| Tucker Jensen | Midlakes | 2011 | G/D | |
| Ty Jensen | Midlakes | 2014 | G | |
| Kyle Jenson | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Craig Jerabeck | Pittsford | 2010 | M | Babson |
| George Jerman | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | |
| Ben Jesmer | Canandaigua | 2008 | M | |
| Delbosa Jesse | Schroeder | 2026 | A | |
| Devin Jessop | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Nolan Jessop | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | M | Alfred |
| Trevor Jessop | Churchville-Chili | 2008 | M | |
| Ryan Jeter | Gates Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Kevin Jimenez | Newark | 2016 | A | |
| Ryan Jobe | Gananda | 2019 | M | |
| Austin Jobson | Victor | 2016 | M | St John Fisher |
| Jonah Jobson | Thomas | 2028 | A/M | |
| Joshua Jobson | Thomas | 2026 | G | |
| Logan Jock | Mynderse | 2024 | M/D | |
| Keyshawn John-Charles | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Aaron Johnson | Greece Storm | 2026 | M | |
| Brady Johnson | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Brandon Johnson | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | D | |
| Bryan Johnson | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Bryan Johnson | Batavia | 2013 | M | |
| Chad Johnson | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | G | |
| Cody Johnson | Brockport | 2014 | A | |
| Colin Johnson | Newark | 2008 | A | |
| Colin Johnson | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Colton Johnson | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | D | |
| Dan Johnson | Newark | 2010 | D | |
| Dan Johnson | Brighton | 2023 | M | |
| Gabe Johnson | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | D | |
| Garrett Johnson | Newark | 2019 | D | |
| Jack Johnson | Brighton | 2018 | A | |
| Jacob Johnson | Gates Chili | 2007 | D | |
| Jake Johnson | Wayne | 2022 | D | |
| Jason Johnson | Newark | 2005 | A | |
| Jason Johnson | Waterloo | 2005 | M/A | |
| Joey Johnson | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | A | Alfred State |
| Kaden Johnson | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | Wingate |
| Kevin Johnson | Brockport | 2027 | DM | |
| Liam Johnson | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | LSM | |
| Marshall Johnson | Canandaigua | 2009 | M | Fairfield |
| Maxx Johnson | Gates Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Mitch Johnson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Nate Johnson | Newark | 2006 | A | |
| Nick Johnson | Canandaigua | 2015 | M | St Rose |
| Ray Johnson | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | M | |
| Robby Johnson | Geneva | 2025 | M | |
| Ross Johnson | Hilton | 2006 | M | |
| Sam Johnson | Aquinas | 2016 | M | |
| Seth Johnson | Brockport | 2015 | D | |
| Stephen Johnson | Newark | 2008 | A | |
| Troy Johnson | Hilton | 2008 | M | Alfred State |
| Will Johnson | Canandaigua | 2009 | A | Eastern |
| Will Johnson | Victor | 2026 | M | |
| Wyatt Johnson | Brockport | 2014 | D | |
| Tim Johnson Jr | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Brandon Johnston | Avon | 2013 | M | |
| Clay Johnston | Eastridge | 2018 | M | |
| Ian Johnston | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Jack Johnston | Canandaigua | 2019 | A | |
| Noah Johnston | Eastridge | 2014 | D | |
| Parker Johnston | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | M | |
| Mike Joint | Haverling | 2008 | M | |
| Steve Joint | Haverling | 2007 | M | |
| Sam Jokl | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2026 | D | |
| Aaron Jollow | Thomas | 2015 | A/M | |
| Adam Jollow | Thomas | 2013 | M | |
| Bill Jolly | Waterloo | 2006 | M/A | |
| Zach Jonas | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Nick Jonasse | Livonia | 2012 | D | |
| Aaron Jones | Fairport | 2009 | M | Hofstra |
| Bryant Jones | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | D | |
| Cody Jones | Canandaigua | 2011 | M | |
| Corey Jones | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | A | |
| Daniel Jones | Midlakes | 2007 | A | |
| Evan Jones | Midlakes | 2011 | M | |
| Ezra Jones | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | M | |
| Jakson Jones | Penn Yan | 2023 | D | |
| Jamir Jones | Aquinas | 2016 | M | |
| Jason Jones | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | A | |
| Jerry Jones | Mynderse | 2010 | M | |
| Jonathan Jones | Waterloo | 2015 | M | |
| Josh Jones | Mynderse | 2011 | G/M | |
| Kacie Jones | Brockport | 2008 | M | |
| Kyle Jones | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | D | |
| Mathias Jones | Mynderse | 2015 | LSM | |
| Mike Jones | Livonia | 2016 | M | |
| Nate Jones | Schroeder | 2025 | D | |
| Raymond Jones | Waterloo | 2023 | G | |
| Sintral Jones | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | G | |
| Tahji Jones | Brighton | 2012 | D | |
| TJ Jones | Fairport | 2017 | A | |
| Tyler Jones | Greece Ath_Ody | 2018 | D | |
| Zahmir Jones | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | D | |
| Bill Jones Jr | Gananda | 2011 | M | |
| Alex Jordan | Brighton | 2009 | D | |
| Ammon Jordan | Brighton | 2019 | M | |
| Carter Jordan | Penfield | 2015 | A | |
| Christian Jordan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | D | |
| Kayden Jorolemon | Brockport | 2023 | D | |
| Tariq Joseph | Newark | 2023 | M | Alfred |
| Tyler Joslyn | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2018 | A | |
| Dylan Joy | Gananda | 2016 | D | Canisius |
| Brodie Joyce | Penfield | 2026 | A | |
| Jack Joyce | Penfield | 2018 | M | Geneseo |
| Kile Joyles | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| Josiah Joyner | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Danny Judge | Pittsford | 2021 | A | |
| Matt Judge | Bishop Kearney | 2034 | A/M | |
| Nick Judge | Midlakes | 2010 | M | Keuka |
| Daniel Judkins | Greece Storm | 2022 | G | |
| Harald Juergens | Hilton | 2014 | M | |
| Connor Jugle | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Taylor Jungermann | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | G | |
| Gunnar Jurgensen | Schroeder | 2015 | D | |
| Jon Kabes | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | D | |
| Jared Kachaylo | Penfield | 2014 | A | |
| Peter Kachurak | Fairport | 2025 | A/M | |
| Quinn Kailbourne | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | A/M | |
| Caleb Kaiser | Fairport | 2020 | M | |
| Cody Kaiser | Fairport | 2023 | A/M | |
| Evan Kaiser | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Matt Kaiser | Waterloo | 2005 | M/A | St John Fisher |
| Fred Kaksonsen | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | M | |
| Ian Kalb | Aquinas | 2019 | D | Eastern |
| Jorryn Kalkowski | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Nick Kallio | Livonia | 2016 | A | MCC |
| Jabr Kamhed | Gates Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Ethan Kamholtz | Penn Yan | 2009 | G | Keuka |
| Talen Kanaley | Newark | 2025 | D | |
| Talen Kanaley | Spencerport | 2025 | D | |
| Jack Kander | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | D | |
| Max Kander | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | M | |
| Ian Kane | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | LSM | Geneseo |
| Nick Kane | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| Benjamin Kanelis | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Matt Kanzler | Penfield | 2010 | M/D | |
| Nate Karatas | Penfield | 2015 | G | Baldwin Wallace |
| Mike Karns | Aquinas | 2013 | M | |
| Ryan Karns | Haverling | 2013 | D | |
| Jacy Karpovage | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | |
| Scott Kart | Fairport | 2005 | M | |
| Matt Kaser | Spencerport | 2013 | A | SUNY Binghamton |
| Jake Kasmarek | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Michael Kast | Brockport | 2016 | A/M | |
| Mike Katz | Brighton | 2005 | G | |
| Stevie Katz | Thomas | 2019 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Jack Kaufman | Pittsford | 2016 | A | Union |
| Tyler Kaufman | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M/A | |
| Andrew Kausch | Aquinas | 2014 | G | |
| Harrison Kay | Canandaigua | 2012 | D | |
| Jonathan Kay | Schroeder | 2018 | M | Alfred |
| Stephen Kay | Schroeder | 2020 | D | Clarkson |
| Brody Kaye | Spencerport | 2027 | D | |
| Taylor Kaye | Spencerport | 2024 | G | |
| Garrett Kayser | Geneva | 2022 | G | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Logan Kayser | Geneva | 2023 | D | |
| Patrick Keady | Spencerport | 2027 | M/A | |
| Ross Kean | Brighton | 2017 | D | |
| Tristan Keas | Penn Yan | 2006 | D | Belmont Abbey |
| Brody Keech | Penn Yan | 2026 | A | |
| Mike Keech | Batavia | 2008 | D | |
| Sean Keefe | Irondequoit | 2016 | D | |
| Keith Keehn | Penfield | 2012 | G | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Kevin Keehn | Penfield | 2015 | DM | |
| Connor Keenan | Victor | 2018 | M | |
| Derek Keens | Spencerport | 2027 | M | |
| Samuel Keens | Spencerport | 2022 | M | |
| Matt Kegler | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Brayden Kehr | Wayne | 2021 | M | |
| Alexander Keil | Fairport | 2008 | A | |
| Max Keil | Fairport | 2006 | A | |
| Cameron Keith | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | D | |
| Dave Kelbe | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Andrew Keller | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Jake Keller | Livonia | 2011 | D | |
| Mark Keller | Eastridge | 2007 | M | |
| Michael Keller | Batavia | 2018 | M/A | |
| Mike Keller | Batavia | 2018 | A | |
| Jeff Kellerson | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Brendon Kelley | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Brennan Kelley | Geneva | 2019 | M | |
| Edward Kelley | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | A | |
| Jim Kelley | Spencerport | 2009 | M | |
| Michael Kellman | Thomas | 2011 | A | |
| Mike Kellogg | Haverling | 2014 | D | |
| Joe Kells | Pittsford | 2009 | M | |
| Alexander Kelly | Aquinas | 2021 | D | |
| Austyn Kelly | Penfield | 2021 | M | |
| Brian Kelly | Pittsford | 2009 | A/M | |
| Bryce Kelly | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | G | |
| Bryce Kelly | Aquinas | 2016 | G | Geneseo |
| Connor Kelly | Marcus Whitman | 2013 | A | GCC |
| Conor Kelly | Aquinas | 2019 | LSM | |
| Dylan Kelly | Gates Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Evan Kelly | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2017 | A | Le Moyne |
| Evan Kelly | Aquinas | 2017 | A | Le Moyne |
| Greg Kelly | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | A/M | |
| Jack Kelly | Fairport | 2022 | D | |
| Jameson Kelly | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | DM | |
| Keghan Kelly | Marcus Whitman | 2016 | D | |
| Luke Kelly | Thomas | 2010 | D | |
| Matt Kelly | Fairport | 2009 | D | |
| Max Kelly | Eastridge | 2016 | G | |
| Reece Kelly | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Ryan Kelly | Midlakes | 2011 | A | |
| Ryan Kelly | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | A | Geneseo |
| Tyler Kelly | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Jacob Kelsey | Brockport | 2019 | M | |
| Jacob Kelsey | Hilton | 2019 | G | |
| Mitchell Kelsey | Aquinas | 2023 | M | |
| Zach Kelsey | Aquinas | 2021 | M | |
| Quinn Kelstone | Brighton | 2024 | M | |
| Brandon Kemp | Canandaigua | 2012 | D | Potsdam |
| Kevin Kemp | Thomas | 2006 | M | |
| Maddie Kemp | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M/A | |
| Matt Kemp | Thomas | 2005 | D | |
| Mike Kemp | Greece | 2005 | M | |
| Zack Kemp | Gates Chili | 2009 | D | |
| Brenden Kendrick | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | DM | |
| William Kennard | Aquinas | 2022 | M | |
| Carroll Kennedy | Aquinas | 2006 | D | |
| Daniel Kennedy | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | |
| Nolan Kennedy | Waterloo | 2020 | G | |
| Elijah Kenney | Irondequoit | 2013 | D | Cortland |
| Jeff Kenny | Fairport | 2015 | A | |
| Robert Kenny | Schroeder | 2026 | D | |
| Chris Kent | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Nate Kenville | Newark | 2014 | A | |
| Aiden Kenyon | Canandaigua | 2019 | G | Oswego |
| Shane Kenyon | Canandaigua | 2013 | M | |
| Matt Keough | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | A/M | |
| Brendan Kepes | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Cullen Kephart | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | M | |
| Micah Kephart | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | D | |
| Ashton Kepler | Newark | 2027 | M | |
| Jagger Kerr | Geneva | 2020 | D | Le Moyne |
| Daniel Kerrick | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | D | |
| Kevin Kerrick | Penn Yan | 2012 | D | Pfeiffer |
| Ryan Kerrick | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | Brockport |
| David Kersh | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Jacob Kershner | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | A/M | |
| Justin Kesselring | Fairport | 2014 | A/M | Le Moyne |
| Rex Kesselring | Pittsford | 2023 | A | |
| Justin Kessler | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | M | |
| Nate Kessler | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | M | |
| Max Kestenbaum | Pittsford | 2007 | M | |
| Harry Kestler | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | D | |
| Damien Ketchum | Newark | 2007 | M | |
| Alex Kettell | Fairport | 2020 | D | |
| Sean Kettles | Churchville-Chili | 2008 | G | Medaille |
| Jonny Keyes | Irondequoit | 2020 | G | |
| Jagroop Khosa | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | A | |
| Navraj Khosa | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Karl Khuns | Hilton | 2023 | D | |
| Andy Kicera | Victor | 2005 | D | |
| Mitch Kicher | Penn Yan | 2007 | D | Eastern CT |
| Dexter Kichline | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | M | |
| Yosief Kidane | Schroeder | 2018 | M | |
| Jake Kidd | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | D | Lawrence Tech |
| Casey Kidder | Victor | 2014 | A | |
| Sean Kidder | Livonia | 2013 | D | |
| Jayson Kieffer | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | D | |
| Dustin Kiellach | Schroeder | 2009 | D | |
| Greg Kier | Pal-Mac | 2009 | M | FLCC |
| Jeff Kier | Pal-Mac | 2011 | M | |
| Rhylee Kierst | Waterloo | 2023 | A | |
| Trevor Kijowski | Wayne | 2021 | A/M | |
| Tom Kikkert | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | A | |
| Owen Kilby | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | M/A | |
| Joe Killinger | Pal-Mac | 2005 | A | |
| Connor Kimball | Victor | 2011 | M | Nazareth |
| Owen Kimball | Wayne | 2025 | D | |
| Tanner Kimball | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | M | |
| Anthony Kimber | Eastridge | 2020 | A | |
| Kevin Kimber | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| AJ Kimble | Eastridge | 2018 | M | |
| Jarod Kimble | Hilton | 2015 | G | Indianapolis |
| Shawn Kimble | Hilton | 2015 | A | Indianapolis |
| Nick Kimmins | Penfield | 2013 | D | Hartford |
| Justin Kimple | Waterloo | 2012 | M/D | |
| Kyle Kimpton | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | D | |
| Aaron King | Schroeder | 2010 | D | |
| Austin King | Brockport | 2017 | D | |
| Julian King | Brockport | 2013 | G | |
| Kyle King | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Nick King | Canandaigua | 2010 | G | OCC |
| Nick King | Brockport | 2015 | M | |
| Nygel King | East United | 2019 | G | |
| Owen King | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | A | |
| Pat King | Aquinas | 2006 | M | |
| Isaac Kingsley | Brockport | 2027 | M | |
| Mason Kingston | Waterloo | 2020 | D | |
| Tavish Kinkead | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Taylor Kinne | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | M | |
| Jeramiah Kinner | Haverling | 2017 | LSM | Alfred |
| Trey Kinner | Haverling | 2018 | G | |
| Alex Kinney | Livonia | 2015 | M | |
| Mitchell Kinney | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | |
| Mitchell Kinney | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | GCC |
| Josh Kinsey | Penn Yan | 2014 | D | |
| Robert Kinslow | Pal-Mac | 2023 | D | Hobart |
| Clay Kinyoun | Penn Yan | 2019 | M | |
| Jeff Kinyoun | Penn Yan | 2020 | G | Oswego |
| Jared Kirchner | Gates Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Adam Kirkland | Gates Chili | 2013 | LSM | |
| Brett Kirkpatrick | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Jarrett Kirkpatrick | Gates Chili | 2017 | A | |
| Thomas Kirnie | Newark | 2024 | G | |
| Matt Kiser | Schroeder | 2007 | M | |
| Griffin Kiss | Gananda | 2024 | D | |
| Chris Kist | Pittsford | 2007 | M | Canisius |
| Robert Kitchen | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | A/M | |
| Jayden Kittelberger | Spencerport | 2024 | M | |
| Nick Kivinen | Penfield | 2012 | D | Buffalo |
| Max Klaehn | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | D | |
| Willie Klan | Schroeder | 2014 | G | |
| Willie Klan | Penfield | 2015 | G | Syracuse |
| Jared Klatt | Penfield | 2018 | D | |
| Jodan Klatt | Penfield | 2020 | M | |
| Erik Kleehammer | Irondequoit | 2010 | A | MCC |
| Tim Kleehammer | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | Pfeiffer |
| Tyler Kleehammer | Irondequoit | 2008 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Brandon Kleiman | Brighton | 2011 | M | |
| Eric Klein | Canandaigua | 2006 | A | St John Fisher |
| John Klein | Canandaigua | 2009 | M | |
| Michael Klem | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Matt Klim | Gates Chili | 2018 | A | |
| Daniel Klimek | Eastridge | 2020 | D | |
| Alex Klimowski | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M | LSU |
| Scott Kline | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Zachary Kline | Brockport | 2012 | A | |
| Brenden Klish | Livonia | 2014 | D | |
| Erik Klobodovic | Gananda | 2021 | D | |
| Paul Klopf | Midlakes | 2015 | A/M | |
| Ali Klube | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2020 | D | |
| Derek Kluge | Victor | 2014 | D | |
| Devin Kluth | Hilton | 2022 | D | |
| Justin Klymochko | Brockport | 2007 | A | |
| Damian Knaak | Pal-Mac | 2022 | A/M | |
| Evan Knapp | Newark | 2015 | A | |
| Jake Knapp | Fairport | 2020 | M/FO | |
| Josh Knapp | Fairport | 2022 | LSM | Geneseo |
| Thomas Knapp | Wayne | 2017 | M | |
| Adam Knapton | Canandaigua | 2010 | A | Western NE |
| Ben Knapton | Canandaigua | 2008 | D | Hartford |
| Brady Knauf | Gates Chili | 2021 | A | |
| Ethan Knauf | Gates Chili | 2021 | A | |
| Jory Knauf | Gates Chili | 2023 | M | |
| TJ Knauf | Schroeder | 2007 | M | |
| Brian Knecht | Geneva | 2006 | D | Brockport |
| John Kneidel | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | D | |
| Mitch Kneidel | Bishop Kearney | 2024 | M | |
| Jason Knerr | Penfield | 2005 | A | Northeastern |
| Travis Knicley | Fairport | 2020 | M | |
| Blake Knifley | Geneva | 2018 | M | |
| Braiman Knight | Eastridge | 2017 | M | |
| Brian Knight | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Colin Knight | Schroeder | 2025 | DM | |
| Lewis Knight | Newark | 2021 | A | |
| Sam Knipper | Mynderse | 2008 | D | |
| Andrew Knoblauch | Canandaigua | 2008 | M | St John Fisher |
| Marcus Knoell | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Trevor Knoepfler | Thomas | 2016 | D | MCC |
| Andrew Knope | Irondequoit | 2015 | A | |
| Kyle Knopp | East Rochester | 2010 | M | |
| Camdin Knowles | Haverling | 2020 | D | |
| Gregory Knowles | Fairport | 2007 | D | |
| Jordan Knowles | Haverling | 2016 | D | |
| Ted Knowles | Fairport | 2010 | D | MCC |
| Justin Knowlton | Waterloo | 2025 | 0 | |
| AJ Knox | Schroeder | 2023 | D | |
| Alex Kober | Pittsford | 2011 | A | Clarkson |
| Ethan Kober | Pittsford | 2015 | M | |
| Danny Kobler | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | A | |
| Jake Kobza | Haverling | 2012 | LSM | |
| Jimmy Koch | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Austin Koczent | Geneva | 2011 | M | |
| Zach Koczent | Geneva | 2010 | M | Keuka |
| Patrick Koehler | Haverling | 2019 | M | |
| Drew Kogler | Irondequoit | 2024 | M | |
| Seth Kohler | Hilton | 2008 | G | |
| Taylor Kolmer | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Ryan Kommer | Newark | 2010 | A/M | |
| Cooper Koneski | Brockport | 2018 | M | |
| David Konko | Spencerport | 2011 | G | |
| Jeff Konko | Spencerport | 2007 | M | Pfeiffer |
| Ryan Konko | Spencerport | 2006 | G | |
| Owen Konrad | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Dane Koomen | Livonia | 2014 | D | |
| Jake Koonmen | Fairport | 2022 | A/M | Baldwin Wallace |
| Eric Koop | Brockport | 2008 | D | |
| Matt Koopman | Mynderse | 2010 | A | |
| Nick Koopman | Mynderse | 2011 | D | |
| Max Koos | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | D | |
| Aidan Kopacz | Aquinas | 2019 | G | |
| Casey Kopp | Brighton | 2013 | M | Hamilton |
| Aiden Kopper | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | D | |
| Anthony Kopper | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | D | |
| Tim Korn | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Chris Kornacki | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | M | |
| Kirk Kornbau | Livonia | 2016 | M | |
| Tyler Koroly | Brockport | 2013 | LSM | |
| Zack Kosakowski | Livonia | 2011 | D | |
| Josh Kosciol | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | A | |
| Ryan Kosciolek | Batavia | 2011 | D | |
| Stephen Koscumb | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | M | |
| Cody Kosel | Gates Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Max Kostyk | Irondequoit | 2011 | A | |
| Eddy Kotok | Gananda | 2014 | M | |
| Tristin Kouwe | Mynderse | 2013 | M | |
| Matt Koval | Victor | 2011 | M | |
| Oliver Kowal | Victor | 2026 | DM | |
| Simon Kowal | Victor | 2025 | D | |
| Noah Kozak | Greece Storm | 2024 | A | |
| Michael Kozar | Fairport | 2017 | D | SUNY Albany |
| John Kpaka | Avon | 2016 | A | |
| Joel Kraft | Waterloo | 2020 | M/D | |
| Jordan Kraft | Waterloo | 2022 | M | |
| Nick Kraft | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | A | |
| Izak Krajeski | Wayne | 2023 | A/M | |
| Mark Kratochvil | Penn Yan | 2005 | A | |
| Bobby Krause | Livonia | 2015 | D | |
| Jacob Krause | Fairport | 2018 | D | |
| Josh Krause | Fairport | 2016 | D | |
| Cameron Kremer | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Ethan Krenzer | Wayne | 2017 | M | |
| Nate Krenzer | Eastridge | 2013 | D | |
| Kaleb Kreuzer | Irondequoit | 2017 | A/M | |
| Jubalee Krisher | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Logan Krisher | Haverling | 2015 | M | |
| Zach Krisher | Haverling | 2015 | M | |
| Andrew Kristy | Fairport | 2010 | DM | Ithaca |
| Tyler Kruezer | Hilton | 2013 | D | |
| Cameron Krug | Fairport | 2015 | M | |
| Nick Krug | Fairport | 2020 | D | Delaware |
| Kyle Krystan | Gates Chili | 2019 | A | MCC |
| Andrey Kuchma | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Danny Kucmerowski | Brockport | 2025 | G | |
| Ian Kuebler | Aquinas | 2017 | D | |
| Kyle Kuebler | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | M/A | |
| Tyler Kuell | Mynderse | 2015 | G | |
| Chase Kuhl | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Brenden Kuhlenbeck | Thomas | 2025 | G | |
| Cassidy Kuhn | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | D | |
| Clai Kuhn | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M | MCC |
| Gavin Kuhn | Gananda | 2025 | D | |
| Jacob Kuhn | Batavia | 2011 | A | |
| Jaden Kuhn | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Sam Kuhn | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2026 | A/M | |
| Tyler Kuhn | Batavia | 2013 | M | |
| Tyler Kuhn | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | G | |
| Tyler Kuhn | Batavia | 2020 | G | |
| Jake Kulig | Aquinas | 2011 | D | |
| Tyler Kulikowski | Haverling | 2014 | D | |
| Brandon Kunick | Victor | 2015 | D | |
| Austin Kuntz | Churchville-Chili | 2010 | M | |
| Danny Kuntz | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Atari Kunzer-Cruz | Gananda | 2021 | M | |
| Josh Kurdziolek | Mynderse | 2007 | M | |
| Adams Kurtis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Andy Kurtz | Livonia | 2006 | D | |
| Connor Kurtz | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | A | |
| Jadyn Kurtz | Avon | 2019 | M/D | |
| Jadyn Kurtz | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | D | |
| Joshua Kurtz | Batavia | 2016 | D | |
| William Kurtz | Livonia | 2017 | D | |
| Christian Kurz | Victor | 2022 | M | |
| Steve Kuti | Waterloo | 2006 | M/A | |
| Mason Kuver | Penn Yan | 2021 | D | |
| Cameron Kuzniar | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | G | Brockport |
| Elliot Kwaitkowski | Newark | 2018 | D | |
| Paul Kysor | Brockport | 2012 | A | |
| Patrick LaBarge | Gananda | 2017 | A | |
| Josh LaBarr | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | A | |
| Zack LaBarr | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | G | |
| Michael Laber | Hilton | 2018 | A | |
| Dylan LaBerge | Pal-Mac | 2024 | A/M | |
| Alex Labombard | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | D | |
| Anthony Lacatena | Eastridge | 2005 | D | |
| Ian LaCroix | Thomas | 2017 | A | |
| Dan LaCrosse | Canandaigua | 2013 | M | Colgate |
| Tom LaCrosse | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | Penn State |
| Devin Ladue | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Jeremy LaDue | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| John LaDue | Schroeder | 2012 | A | |
| Justin LaDuke | Livonia | 2017 | G | Canton |
| Todd Laemlein | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| Brody Laese | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | A | |
| Austin Lafferty | Penn Yan | 2018 | A | |
| AJ Laffin | Thomas | 2006 | D | |
| Anthony Lafica | Gananda | 2012 | D | |
| Marty LaFica | Gananda | 2016 | G | |
| Steven Laframboise | Greece Storm | 2022 | A | MCC |
| Landon Lafranco | Thomas | 2023 | M | |
| John Laganello | Eastridge | 2007 | A | |
| Angelo Lagenello | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Ricky Lagiewski | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | A | |
| Sean Lagonegro | Avon | 2019 | M | |
| Sean Lagonegro | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | A | |
| Ben Lagoner | Thomas | 2021 | D | Potsdam |
| Chris Lahr | Waterloo | 2007 | D | |
| Colby Lahr | Geneva | 2026 | D | |
| Gordy Lahr | Waterloo | 2005 | M/A | |
| Jordan Lahue | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | D/LSM | |
| Jared Laird | Wayne | 2017 | G | |
| Kyle Lake | Pittsford | 2013 | G | John Carroll |
| Stephen Lake | Eastridge | 2014 | M | |
| Martin Lalisse | Brighton | 2016 | M | |
| James Lally | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | G | |
| AJ LaLonde | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | D | Potsdam |
| Devin Lamb | Pittsford | 2008 | M | RIT |
| Cal Lambert | Victor | 2021 | M/A | USMA |
| Caleb Lambert | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | D | |
| Cody Lambert | Livonia | 2017 | D | Keuka |
| Max Lambert | Victor | 2016 | A | |
| Ryan Lambert | Livonia | 2019 | A/M | |
| Ryan Lambert | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | A/M | |
| Sam Lambert | Victor | 2018 | A | Le Moyne |
| Tyler Lambert | Penn Yan | 2016 | M | |
| Tyler Lambert | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | |
| Ben Lamendola | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | |
| Tim Lamendola | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2011 | D | |
| Blake Lamere | Brockport | 2025 | A | |
| Nick Lamkin | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | M | |
| Nick Lamkin | Batavia | 2021 | M | |
| Sam Lamont | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Chase Lamora | Schroeder | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Chase Lamora | Schroeder | 2026 | M | |
| Brandon Lampart | Batavia | 2015 | D | |
| Brandon Lampart | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | D | |
| Bryce Lampson | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | M | |
| Doug Lancie | Thomas | 2009 | D | |
| Thomas Lancie | Schroeder | 2015 | D | |
| Matt Landfried | Batavia | 2008 | G | Washington & Jefferson |
| Jon Landre | Canandaigua | 2011 | M | |
| James Landrigan | Schroeder | 2027 | A/M | |
| Kyle Landrigan | Canandaigua | 2015 | A | Alfred |
| Zach Landrigan | Canandaigua | 2015 | M | Alfred |
| Andrew Landschoot | Midlakes | 2016 | A/M | |
| Ben Landschoot | Midlakes | 2010 | D | |
| Christopher Landschoot | Midlakes | 2012 | A | |
| Jeff Landuyt | Midlakes | 2016 | D | |
| Brian Lane | Gates Chili | 2011 | G | Gordon |
| Garrett Lane | Gates Chili | 2009 | D | |
| Kenny Lane | Livonia | 2011 | M | |
| Mickey Lane | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Phil Lane | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | M | |
| Trevor Lane | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Matt Laney | Brockport | 2006 | D | |
| Trevor Lang | Haverling | 2012 | D | |
| Matt Langan | Victor | 2026 | LSM | |
| Derek Langdon | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | A | |
| Jeff Langschwager | Churchville-Chili | 2008 | A | |
| John Thomas Lannak | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | D | |
| DJ Lanning | Pal-Mac | 2014 | D | |
| Brady Lannon | Midlakes | 2019 | D | |
| Mike Lannone | Midlakes | 2007 | G | |
| Sean Lanpher | Livonia | 2008 | M | |
| Kristian Lapp | Geneva | 2017 | G | |
| Brandon Lappetito | Eastridge | 2019 | M | |
| Joshua Larabee | Hilton | 2025 | M | |
| Bruce Larick | Victor | 2005 | D | |
| Dylan Larizza | Mynderse | 2021 | M | |
| Mike Larkin | Penfield | 2012 | A | MCC |
| James LaRocca | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | A | |
| Joseph LaRocca | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | A | |
| Tommy LaRocca | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | A | |
| Rich LaRock | Spencerport | 2008 | M | |
| Anthony Larosa | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | |
| Bryce LaRose | Schroeder | 2016 | A | |
| Mark LaRose | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Ryan LaRose | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | A | |
| Kaiden Larsen | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | G | |
| Andrew Larson | Pittsford | 2011 | LSM | |
| Kaiden Larson | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | G | |
| Jack LaRue | Victor | 2019 | M | |
| Frank LaRussa | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | D | |
| Kurtis Lash | Wayne | 2017 | M | |
| Brandon Lasher | Eastridge | 2016 | D | |
| Jason LaShomb | Aquinas | 2005 | G | Mercyhurst |
| Mike Lashter | Eastridge | 2008 | D | |
| Dylan LaShure | Batavia | 2015 | M | |
| Dylan LaShure | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | A/M | |
| David Laspina | Schroeder | 2014 | M | Alfred |
| Cooper Lass | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Adam Latacki | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | |
| Gavin Lathrop | Midlakes | 2020 | A | |
| Nate Lathrop | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2026 | A/M | |
| Jonah Latimer | Geneva | 2019 | A | |
| Michael Latone | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Isaac Latoski | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Matthew Latragna | Brockport | 2016 | D | |
| Anthony Laudisi | Canandaigua | 2012 | G | |
| Sam Launt | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Michael Laure | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | LSM | |
| Jack Lauroesch | Pittsford | 2012 | A | Williams |
| Kyle LaVallee | Thomas | 2009 | M | |
| Ben LaValley | Mynderse | 2007 | G | |
| Kyle LaVarre | Midlakes | 2005 | A | |
| Joe Lavier | Hilton | 2012 | LSM | |
| Tyler Laviere | Spencerport | 2009 | G | |
| Ed LaVilla | Gates Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Henry Lavoie | Mynderse | 2027 | D | |
| Ashton Law | Waterloo | 2023 | M | |
| Matt Law | Livonia | 2018 | M | |
| Michael Law | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Stan Law | Haverling | 2013 | M | |
| Tiege Lawler | Aquinas | 2007 | M | |
| Max Lawless | Victor | 2011 | D | |
| Gavin Lawlis | Batavia | 2023 | D | |
| Gavin Lawlis | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | D | |
| Adam Lawrence | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | M | |
| James Lawrence | Newark | 2017 | M | |
| Parker Lawrence | Brighton | 2016 | D | Nazareth |
| Brian Lawson | Victor | 2011 | D | |
| Cael Lawson | Wayne | 2023 | D/LSM | Hartwick |
| Cash Lawson | Hilton | 2014 | D | Wells |
| Gavin Lawyer | Thomas | 2025 | M/D | |
| Dan Layfield | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | M | Drexel |
| Josh Layfield | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | D | |
| Nick Lazarony | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Dylan Lazzaro | Thomas | 2021 | A | |
| Taylor Lazzaro | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | M | |
| Jack Leach | Schroeder | 2021 | G | |
| Riley Lease | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Ron LeBeau | Hilton | 2025 | D | |
| Jacob LeBlanc | Aquinas | 2018 | A | |
| Alex Lebowitz | Brighton | 2011 | M | |
| Dan Leccese | Aquinas | 2013 | A | |
| Austin Leckinger | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Michael Leckinger | Wayne | 2018 | M | |
| Doug Leclair | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Mason Leddon | Batavia | 2015 | M | |
| Mason Leddon | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | M | |
| Francis Leddy | Mynderse | 2014 | A | |
| Ryan Ledermann | Thomas | 2021 | D | Grove City |
| Ken Ledgerwood | Penn Yan | 2011 | D | FLCC |
| Brandon Lee | Waterloo | 2025 | 0 | |
| Cooper Lee | Schroeder | 2014 | DM | |
| Jaehong Lee | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Jake Lee | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2011 | M | |
| Jared Lee | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | A | |
| Nate Lee | Hilton | 2022 | M/FO | |
| Nolan Lee | Marcus Whitman | 2022 | M | |
| Nicholas Leeber | Waterloo | 2008 | M | |
| Michael Leet | Fairport | 2008 | D | |
| Mike LeFever | Pal-Mac | 2010 | M | |
| Adam Legler | Aquinas | 2010 | D | |
| Eric Legott | Geneva | 2009 | A | |
| Isaac Lehigh | Penfield | 2020 | LSM | |
| Nathan Lehigh | Penfield | 2023 | D | |
| David Lehman | Schroeder | 2014 | M | MCC |
| Matt Lehman | Schroeder | 2019 | M | |
| Noah lehman | Thomas | 2019 | G | |
| Mike Lehmann | Fairport | 2009 | M | Northeastern |
| Jack Lehtonen | Spencerport | 2018 | M | |
| Greg Leiby | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | DM | |
| Franz Leinders | Livonia | 2017 | A/M | |
| Zach Leinenbach | Penfield | 2018 | DM | |
| Riley Leipold | Pittsford | 2018 | A | |
| Zach Leiter | Pal-Mac | 2017 | M | |
| Aaron Lembaris | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | M | |
| Alec Lembaris | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| Markus Lembcke | Eastridge | 2012 | A | |
| Ian Lemcke | Hilton | 2014 | M | |
| Pat LeMoine | Thomas | 2015 | M | |
| Dmarquis Lenear | Greece Storm | 2032 | 0 | |
| Nick Lenhard | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | A | |
| Zack Lenhard | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | A | |
| Kyle Lenhart | Gates Chili | 2017 | A | |
| Kamer Lenio | Brighton | 2021 | M | |
| Josh Lennon | Pal-Mac | 2013 | D | |
| Taylor Lennon | Pal-Mac | 2009 | D | |
| Teddy Lenz | Canandaigua | 2021 | D | St Michael |
| Dustin Lenz Emmi | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | A/M | |
| Ian Lenz Emmi | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | A | |
| Ben Leonard | Pittsford | 2026 | M | |
| Jaxon Leonard | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | A | |
| Matt Leonard | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Nick Leonard | Victor | 2024 | A | |
| Ryan Leonard | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | M | St John Fisher |
| Shane Leonard | Pittsford | 2021 | M | |
| Stephen Leonard | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2011 | G | |
| Andrew Leonardi | Hilton | 2014 | D | |
| Andrew Leonardi | Greece Arc_Oly | 2020 | A/M | |
| Andrew Leonardi | Greece Storm | 2020 | D | |
| Nicholas Leonardi | Greece Storm | 2021 | M | |
| Nick Leonardi | Greece Arc_Oly | 2021 | A/M | |
| Jamie Leone | Pittsford | 2008 | M | |
| Matt Leone | Pittsford | 2010 | M | |
| Nick Leone | Wayne | 2014 | A | |
| Vincent Leone | Geneva | 2012 | D | |
| Paul Leonhard | Penfield | 2007 | M | St John Fisher |
| Ed Leoni | Gates Chili | 2004 | M | |
| Peter Leoni | Gates Chili | 2006 | D | |
| Craig Lepiane | Irondequoit | 2004 | M | |
| Nick Lepiane | Irondequoit | 2023 | G | |
| Tyler LePore | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | LSM | |
| Holden Lescord-Fry | Marcus Whitman | 2022 | D | |
| Matt Lesczynski | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | A | RIT |
| Connor Leslie | Schroeder | 2014 | D | |
| Aric Lesperance | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Matt Lester | Brockport | 2009 | A | |
| Noah Letizia | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Anthony Letta | Hilton | 2024 | D | |
| Leo Letta | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | |
| Max Letta | Irondequoit | 2019 | A | |
| Vaughn Letta | Irondequoit | 2021 | A | |
| Liam Letters | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | D/LSM | |
| Greer Leva | Aquinas | 2014 | A | |
| Miles Leva | Irondequoit | 2025 | D | |
| Sam Leva | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | LSM | |
| William Levchuk | Brockport | 2017 | M/A | |
| Jake Leve | Pittsford | 2015 | A | |
| Jason LeVesque | Livonia | 2005 | D/M | FLCC |
| Josh Levesque | Livonia | 2007 | M | |
| Sean Levey | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | M/FO | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Brandon Lewis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | M | |
| Brandon Lewis | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | |
| Caleb Lewis | Pittsford | 2023 | D | Bucknell |
| Corey Lewis | Aquinas | 2018 | M | |
| Dane Lewis | Pittsford | 2025 | D | |
| Deven Lewis | Newark | 2015 | M | |
| Dom Lewis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | LSM | |
| Dominic Lewis | Eastridge | 2021 | M | |
| Dominic Lewis | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | M | |
| Dylan Lewis | Spencerport | 2023 | M | |
| Grant Lewis | Pittsford | 2027 | A/M | |
| Jesse Lewis | Geneva | 2013 | M | FLCC |
| Josh Lewis | Waterloo | 2006 | D | RIT |
| Justin Lewis | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Kien Lewis | Newark | 2014 | M | |
| Robert Lewis | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | A | |
| Tim Lewis | Schroeder | 2013 | D | |
| Trevor Lewis | Spencerport | 2025 | A/M | |
| William Lewis | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | M | |
| Erik Lewish | Brighton | 2005 | M | |
| James Liberi | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | D | |
| Mark Liberti | Schroeder | 2005 | D | |
| Mike Liberti | Schroeder | 2013 | D | |
| Carson Lich | Pal-Mac | 2026 | D/LSM | |
| Peyton Lich | Pal-Mac | 2024 | G | Ohio Northern |
| Riley Lich | Pal-Mac | 2022 | A/M | |
| Justin Lichti | Newark | 2019 | D | |
| Mitchell Liegerot | Victor | 2007 | G | |
| Brandon Liemthepha | Greece Ath_Ody | 2020 | D | |
| Maliek Likely | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Jake Lill | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | D | |
| Trevor Lillie | Thomas | 2021 | A | |
| Matt Lilly | Waterloo | 2005 | G/D | |
| Nicholas LiMuti | Avon | 2014 | A/M | |
| Alex Linares | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | D | |
| Ethan Lincoln | Canandaigua | 2015 | G | FLCC |
| Jacob Lindberg | Newark | 2017 | A | |
| Riley Lindberg | Newark | 2016 | D | |
| Jack Lindenmuth | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | A | |
| Christopher Lindner | Fairport | 2005 | M | |
| Eric Lindquist | Irondequoit | 2008 | M | |
| Marc Lindsay | Irondequoit | 2008 | A | |
| Brian Lingg | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Bob Link | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | M | |
| Brandon Link | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | D | |
| John Linnan | Penn Yan | 2009 | M | |
| Nick Lipinscyk | Brockport | 2011 | A | |
| Matt Lippa | Schroeder | 2020 | D | |
| Michael Lippa | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | |
| Robbie Lippa | Livonia | 2007 | D | |
| Timothy Lischer | Livonia | 2016 | M | Canisius |
| Troy Lischer | Livonia | 2012 | G | |
| Ethan Lischerelli | Victor | 2023 | A | |
| David Lisena | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | |
| Maximus Lisk | Waterloo | 2020 | D | |
| Ben Lissow | Hilton | 2015 | M | |
| Cody List | Greece | 2005 | D | |
| Cody List | Greece Ath_Ody | 2005 | D | Keuka |
| Billy Lista | Livonia | 2008 | M | |
| Zane Lister | East United | 2020 | D | |
| Tai Little | Penfield | 2019 | LSM | |
| Sam Livecchi | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | D | |
| Doug Livingston | Gates Chili | 2010 | M | |
| Douglas Livingston | Gates Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Alan Liwush | Thomas | 2005 | M | |
| Ashton Llano | Midlakes | 2020 | M | |
| Kyler Lloyd | Penn Yan | 2021 | D | |
| Mason Lloyd | Canandaigua | 2024 | M | |
| Max Lloyd | Pal-Mac | 2015 | D | |
| Shaun Lobene | Spencerport | 2010 | D | |
| Matt LoBiondo | Penfield | 2016 | D | |
| AJ Lobrutto | Aquinas | 2015 | D | |
| Jeff Locey | Pal-Mac | 2019 | M | |
| Joseph Lochner | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | A | |
| Brent Lockerby | Penfield | 2019 | D | |
| Kierus Lockett | East United | 2019 | M | |
| Austin Lockhart | Gates Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Luke Lockhart | Hilton | 2024 | M | |
| Rob Lockhart | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | M | |
| Jack Lockmeyer | Irondequoit | 2020 | M | |
| Adam Lockwood | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Lily Lockwood | Avon | 2020 | G/D | |
| Cole Loewke | Hilton | 2022 | A | Alfred |
| Mike LoFaso | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | D | |
| Terrean Lofton | Waterloo | 2022 | A | |
| Will Loftus | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Isaiah Logins | Newark | 2018 | A | |
| Evan Lohkamp | Brighton | 2025 | A | |
| Brandon Lohman | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | D | |
| Dan Lohman | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | A | |
| Trystan Lomb | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Brent Lombard | Mynderse | 2008 | D | |
| Billy Lombardi | Aquinas | 2013 | M | Penn State |
| John Lombardi | Irondequoit | 2015 | A/M | Cornell |
| Hunter Lombardo | Pittsford | 2016 | D | |
| Kyle Lombardozzi | Gananda | 2016 | M | |
| Joe LoMonaco | Brockport | 2020 | LSM | |
| John LoMonaco | Brockport | 2022 | M | |
| John Long | Hilton | 2012 | M | |
| Bob Longboat | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | M | |
| Rick Looby | Irondequoit | 2010 | D | |
| Cole Loomis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | A | |
| David Loomis | Aquinas | 2011 | G | |
| Jack Loomis | Hilton | 2020 | A | |
| Nikolai Lopatka | Penfield | 2024 | M | Mount Union |
| Abraham Lopez | UPrep | 2016 | D | |
| Jose Lopez | Brighton | 2010 | D | |
| Sam Lopez | Irondequoit | 2013 | D | |
| Sergio Lopez | Gananda | 2020 | 0 | |
| Jessie Lord | Batavia | 2018 | D | |
| Owen Lorenzetti | Mynderse | 2019 | A | |
| Sam Lorenzetti | Mynderse | 2021 | M | |
| Anthony Loria | East Rochester | 2011 | D | |
| Dylan Losey | Haverling | 2011 | M | |
| Steven LoTempio | Gananda | 2023 | D/LSM | Sage |
| Tim Lotemple | Gates Chili | 2019 | D | |
| Akari Lott | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| Amari Lott | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| Kyle Lotz | Waterloo | 2016 | M | |
| Cody Loucks | Waterloo | 2023 | A | |
| Mike Loucks | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | M | |
| Toby Loucks | Waterloo | 2019 | G/M | |
| Jake Loughlin | Victor | 2024 | DM | |
| Tim Louks | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Josh Louth | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | A | |
| Alex Love | Geneva | 2008 | A | Hobart |
| Phillip Love | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Damyan Lovejoy | Canandaigua | 2022 | M | |
| Dawson Lovejoy | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | |
| Zack Lovejoy | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | D/LSM | |
| Kenyen Lovette | Irondequoit | 2023 | D | TCCC |
| Luke Loveys | Pittsford | 2012 | G | |
| Terren Lovria | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Connor Lowe | Fairport | 2009 | M | Ithaca |
| Ryan Lowe | Fairport | 2006 | M | Ithaca |
| Wyatt Lowe | East United | 2018 | LSM | |
| Alan Lowery | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Matt Lowney | Victor | 2007 | D | |
| Chance Lowry | Waterloo | 2010 | M | Alfred State |
| Chris Lozada | Newark | 2016 | G | |
| Sam Lublin | Penfield | 2023 | M | |
| Alex Lucas | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | D | |
| Daniel Lucas | Brockport | 2026 | M | |
| Jordan Lucas | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2027 | D | |
| Steve Lucchesi | Mynderse | 2009 | A | |
| Chad Luce | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Cody Lucey | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | M | |
| Sam Lucisano | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | D | |
| Dustin Luckinbill | Mynderse | 2008 | A | |
| Joe Luconte | Thomas | 2018 | M | Geneseo |
| David Ludeke | Brockport | 2016 | G | |
| Javia Ludgood | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | M | |
| Kyle Ludwig | Pal-Mac | 2012 | A | |
| Sulli Ludwig | Livonia | 2008 | A | |
| Anthony Luffman | Mynderse | 2025 | M | |
| Ron Luhtanen | Penfield | 2008 | M | |
| James Lukomsky | Hilton | 2024 | D | |
| Nate Luong | Brighton | 2017 | G | |
| Danny Lupiani | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | M | |
| Anthony Luppino | Penn Yan | 2011 | M | |
| John Luppino | Penn Yan | 2016 | D | |
| Nolan Lusk | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | D | |
| Brian Lustick | Canandaigua | 2007 | A | |
| Corey Luty | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | G | GCC |
| Travis Luty | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Sam Lutz | Waterloo | 2015 | M/A | |
| Tom Lutz | Waterloo | 2006 | D | |
| Kevin Lux | Fairport | 2004 | D | St John Fisher |
| Sean Lydon | Pittsford | 2009 | M | |
| Joe Lyko | Pal-Mac | 2017 | A | |
| Rowan Lyle | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | M | |
| Jim Lynah | Gates Chili | 2007 | M | |
| Kyle Lynah | Gates Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Patrick Lynah | Gates Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Cullen Lynch | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Jake Lynch | Eastridge | 2017 | D | |
| Kevin Lynch | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Tom Lynch | Geneva | 2012 | G | |
| Robbie Lynn | Gananda | 2023 | M | |
| Aric Lyon | Canandaigua | 2018 | D | |
| Isaiah Lyon | Newark | 2018 | M | |
| Lucas Lyon | Newark | 2023 | M | |
| Noah Lyon | Newark | 2020 | M | |
| Evan Lyons | Livonia | 2012 | M | |
| Josh Lyons | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | |
| David Lyttle | Canandaigua | 2021 | M | |
| Alexander Mabbett | Victor | 2018 | M | Johns Hopkins |
| Nick Mabe | Thomas | 2018 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Greg MacBride | Newark | 2006 | M | |
| James Maccallini | Greece Storm | 2026 | A | |
| Colby MacCheyne | Waterloo | 2023 | A | |
| Jeff MacDonald | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | A | |
| Trevor MacDonald | Spencerport | 2021 | D | |
| Brandon Macdonell | Midlakes | 2019 | A | Keuka |
| Ryan Macdonell | Midlakes | 2017 | A | |
| Brandon MacDougal | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | D | |
| Lucas Machado | Brighton | 2016 | M | |
| Matt Machucki | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | A | Penn |
| Brandon Maciejewski | Penn Yan | 2014 | G | SUNY Stony Brook |
| Preston Maciejewski | Penn Yan | 2010 | A | |
| Ryan Maciejewski | Penn Yan | 2013 | A | |
| Alex Mack | Newark | 2016 | D | Buffalo |
| Ethan Mack | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | |
| Ryan Mack | Newark | 2023 | D | |
| Trumaine Mack | East United | 2019 | D | |
| Connor MacKenzie | Spencerport | 2016 | G | |
| Connor Mackenzie | Pittsford | 2017 | D | |
| Garrett Mackenzie | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Carter MacKerchar | Penn Yan | 2027 | D | |
| Brennan Mackey | Victor | 2016 | G | |
| RJ Macks | Gates Chili | 2011 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Ethan MacLennan | Marcus Whitman | 2024 | M | |
| Sean Maclennan | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | D | |
| Gunner MacMillan | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Jack MacMillan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Tyler MacNamara | Gananda | 2022 | M | |
| Jaydon MacNeil | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | |
| Luke MacNeil | Canandaigua | 2015 | G | |
| Zack MacNeil | Canandaigua | 2012 | D | |
| Nate Macpherson | Pittsford | 2024 | D | |
| Benjamin Madafferi | Brockport | 2012 | A | |
| Dylan Maddock | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| Alex Madigan | Penn Yan | 2014 | M | |
| Bryant Madigan | Haverling | 2007 | D | |
| Jerrold Madigan | Livonia | 2005 | G/A | |
| Pierce Madigan | Pittsford | 2027 | G | |
| Jordan Madison | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | D | |
| Cole Madsen | Greece Storm | 2020 | D | |
| Brian Maehr | Pittsford | 2007 | A | |
| Bryan Magee | Aquinas | 2020 | D | |
| Robert Magee | Fairport | 2009 | D | |
| Alex Maggio | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Daniel Maggio | Pittsford | 2020 | M | |
| Gian Maggio | Penfield | 2009 | A | |
| Jeremy Maggio | Hilton | 2007 | M | |
| John Maggio | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Tim Maggio | Newark | 2009 | G | |
| Tommy Maggio | Aquinas | 2024 | A/M | |
| Chris Magill | Mynderse | 2011 | - | |
| Connor Magin | Victor | 2023 | M | Indianapolis |
| Erik Magliato | Penfield | 2018 | A | |
| Manny Magliocco | Aquinas | 2010 | D | MCC |
| Patrick Magliocco | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Evan Magovero | Newark | 2018 | M | |
| Mark Magro | Irondequoit | 2005 | M | |
| Kevin Maguire | Pittsford | 2015 | G | |
| Pat Maguire | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | G | |
| Dylan Mahan | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | M | |
| Mekhi Mahan | Penn Yan | 2021 | M | |
| Cody Maher | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Evan Maher | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | M | |
| Rory Maher | Fairport | 2020 | G | |
| Zach Maher | Bishop Kearney | 2025 | M | |
| Kevin Mahler | Eastridge | 2008 | M | |
| Ammar Mahmood | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | M | |
| Kaleb Mahoney | Midlakes | 2019 | D | |
| Keenan Mahoney | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | LSM | Cazenovia |
| Matthew Mahoney | Mynderse | 2024 | LSM | |
| Pat Mahoney | Geneva | 2017 | D | |
| Kevin Mai | Gates Chili | 2015 | D | MCC |
| Jeremiah Maichuk | Schroeder | 2019 | D | |
| Adam Maier | Pal-Mac | 2005 | A/M | |
| Caleb Maier | Livonia | 2018 | D | |
| Caleb Maier | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | D | |
| Jacob Maier | Pal-Mac | 2023 | M | |
| Louie Maier | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | M | |
| Riley Maier | Greece Storm | 2022 | M | |
| Keith Maimone | Thomas | 2008 | D | |
| Nolan Maines | Brockport | 2017 | D | |
| Tyler Maines | Schroeder | 2015 | D | |
| Ed Maio | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | D | |
| Jahyden Maiorani | East United-Eastridge | 2027 | M | |
| Peter Maklos | Pal-Mac | 2008 | M | FLCC |
| Ryan Makowski | Greece Ath_Ody | 2019 | LSM | |
| Ryan Makowski | Greece Storm | 2019 | D | GCC |
| Connor Maksymciw | Hilton | 2019 | G/D | |
| Reilly Maksymciw | Hilton | 2025 | D | |
| Taiden Makubire | Irondequoit | 2025 | D | |
| Joe Malach | Rush-Henrietta | 2004 | M | Geneseo |
| Adam Malachowski | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Fernando Malave | East United | 2019 | D | |
| Johnny Maldanado | Newark | 2013 | D | |
| Shane Malead | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | M | |
| John Mallaber | Fairport | 2028 | D | |
| Zach Mallette | Newark | 2022 | D | |
| Will Mallia | Pal-Mac | 2007 | A | |
| Matt Malloy | Canandaigua | 2006 | D | Belmont Abbey |
| Matt Malloy | Penfield | 2008 | M | Springfield |
| Mike Malloy | Penfield | 2009 | A | |
| Billy Malone | Pittsford | 2012 | D | |
| Dave Malone | Penfield | 2006 | A | St John Fisher |
| Matt Malone | Pittsford | 2016 | A | Geneseo |
| Brennan Maloney | Fairport | 2018 | A | |
| Jered Maloney | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | A | |
| John Maloney | Victor | 2012 | M | SUNY Albany |
| Pat Maloney | Thomas | 2007 | M | |
| Ryan Maloney | Victor | 2016 | A | Cornell |
| Giovanni Malorzo | Penfield | 2015 | D | |
| Joe Malovics | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M/A | |
| Jacob Malsegna | Hilton | 2018 | M | |
| Jacob Malyk | Hilton | 2021 | M | |
| Nick Manaci | Eastridge | 2012 | D | |
| Austin Manchester | Brockport | 2016 | A | |
| Owen Manchester | Brockport | 2018 | M | |
| Eric Mancuso | Batavia | 2012 | G | |
| Joe Mancuso | Batavia | 2008 | M | |
| Noah Mancuso | Gananda | 2022 | D | |
| Rosolino Mancuso | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | D | |
| Austin Mandarano | Spencerport | 2022 | A | |
| Jayden Mandarano | Spencerport | 2025 | A | |
| Joseph Maneti | Hilton | 2022 | M | |
| Jacob Mangano | Irondequoit | 2014 | LSM | |
| Brian Mangene | Hilton | 2014 | D | |
| Tate Mangiarelli | Marcus Whitman | 2016 | M | |
| Peter Mangione | Spencerport | 2008 | D | |
| Kyle Maniace | Batavia | 2010 | A | GCC |
| James Manilla | Fairport | 2011 | A/M | Ithaca |
| Martin Manilla | Fairport | 2010 | A | Gettysburg |
| John Manion | Geneva | 2006 | A | Nazareth |
| Michael Manley | Penn Yan | 2007 | D | Duke |
| Owen Manley | Hilton | 2020 | D | |
| Alex Mann | Brockport | 2016 | G | |
| Andrew Mann | Brockport | 2017 | M | |
| Caden Mann | Irondequoit | 2020 | M | MCC |
| Christian Mann | Brighton | 2014 | M | |
| Ethan Mann | Hilton | 2019 | D | |
| Pat Mann | Brighton | 2012 | M | |
| Spencer Mann | Hilton | 2020 | D | |
| Joseph Manners | Greece Storm | 2025 | D | |
| Charlie Mannix | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Anthony Manthorne | Newark | 2012 | M | |
| Aaron Manzer | Canandaigua | 2005 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Jordan Manzer | Canandaigua | 2007 | A | |
| Eric Manzler | Marcus Whitman | 2020 | M | Alfred State |
| Brody Mapes | Eastridge | 2005 | A | |
| Alex Mapstone | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | A/M | St Lawrence |
| Andrew Mapstone | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | A | Lehigh |
| Ben Marangola | Brighton | 2026 | M | |
| John Marangola | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | M | |
| Allen Marble | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | D | |
| Jon Marble | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2018 | M | |
| Pat Marble | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Patrick Marble | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | M | |
| Thomas Marble | Pal-Mac | 2012 | D | |
| Gino Marcello | Churchville-Chili | 2008 | A | Keuka |
| John Marcello | Hilton | 2007 | A | |
| Jacob Marchetti | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Ethan Marchitell | Canandaigua | 2015 | M | Keuka |
| Anthony Marcuccili | Geneva | 2018 | D | Cortland |
| Kevin Marfioti | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | M | |
| Alessandro Margiotta | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Ben Marianacci | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | A | |
| Brendan Mariano | Brighton | 2023 | M | |
| Dominic Mariano | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | D | |
| Dominic Mariano | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | D | |
| Dan Maring | Penfield | 2012 | A | |
| Danny Maring | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | A | |
| Ryan Maring | Penfield | 2017 | M | |
| Sandro Marini | Victor | 2021 | D | |
| Dan Marino | Spencerport | 2005 | A | |
| James Marino | Spencerport | 2012 | D | |
| Joseph Marino | Spencerport | 2011 | A | |
| Kyle Mark | Spencerport | 2009 | A | |
| Steve Mark | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Isaiah Markel | Brockport | 2025 | A | |
| Greg Marks | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| Daniel Markwitz | Wayne | 2015 | D | |
| Ray Marotta | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | M | |
| Bradley Marquart | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | D | |
| Zach Marquart | Waterloo | 2014 | D | |
| Brandon Marquez | Schroeder | 2018 | M | |
| Josh Marr | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Dominic Marra | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | G | |
| Nick Marrapese | Irondequoit | 2004 | D | Geneseo |
| Joey Marrocco | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | M | |
| Michael Marrocco | Batavia-Attica | 2017 | G/M | |
| Michael Marrocco | Batavia | 2017 | A | |
| Brian Marron | Penfield | 2012 | D | |
| Mike Marseglia | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Casey Marsh | Penn Yan | 2015 | M | |
| Gregg Marsh | Waterloo | 2005 | D | Keuka |
| Griffin Marsh | Penn Yan | 2013 | D | |
| Justice Marsh | Penfield | 2024 | D | |
| Mitch Marsh | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | G | |
| Riley Marsh | Penn Yan | 2017 | D | |
| Spencer Marsh | Thomas | 2007 | M | |
| Akeem Marshall | Batavia | 2007 | M | |
| Brandt Marshall | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Pax Marshall | Victor | 2023 | A | Georgetown |
| Tim Marshall | Schroeder | 2007 | D | |
| Zach Marshall | Schroeder | 2007 | G | |
| Brenden Martel | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | M | |
| Mike Martell | Aquinas | 2027 | M | |
| JP Martello | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | D | |
| JP Martello | Greece Storm | 2018 | D | |
| Luke Martello | Eastridge | 2012 | M | |
| Aries Martin | Canandaigua | 2019 | D | |
| Bobby Martin | Geneva | 2009 | D | |
| Brian Martin | Fairport | 2012 | M | Potsdam |
| Cam Martin | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Eric Martin | Fairport | 2007 | M | Cortland |
| Katinontie Martin | Pittsford | 2025 | M | |
| Kevin Martin | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | A/M | |
| Matt Martin | Gates Chili | 2013 | A/M | Eastern |
| Nate Martin | Wayne | 2015 | A | |
| Nic Martin | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Ryan Martin | Schroeder | 2010 | D | Providence |
| Ryan Martin | Brighton | 2018 | D | |
| Ryan Martin | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | LSM | |
| William Martin | Irondequoit | 2010 | G | |
| Kyle Martinez | Newark | 2019 | A/M | |
| Will Martins | Pittsford | 2022 | M | Vassar |
| Mark Martuscello | Haverling | 2010 | A | |
| Cody Marvin | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | M | |
| Mike Marvin | Pal-Mac | 2012 | M | |
| Jayden Maryjanowski | Gates Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Kyle Mascia | Spencerport | 2021 | A | |
| Luke Mascitti | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Michael Mascitti | Pittsford | 2020 | M | |
| Keeton Mashtare | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Lucas Mashtare | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | M | |
| Grant Masingill | Victor | 2013 | D | |
| Scot Masingill | Victor | 2011 | D | |
| Carter Maslyn | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2023 | A/G | |
| Jacob Maslyn | Midlakes | 2019 | D | |
| Lucas Maslyn | Midlakes | 2011 | A | |
| Bobby Mason | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | G | |
| Brady Mason | Schroeder | 2027 | M | |
| Chris Mason | Schroeder | 2009 | M | |
| Cory Mason | Victor | 2015 | D | |
| Dave Mason | Aquinas | 2010 | M | |
| Eric Mason | Geneva | 2011 | A | |
| Joe Mason | Irondequoit | 2005 | D | |
| Tyler Mason | Schroeder | 2011 | A | St John Fisher |
| Clint Masterson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | M | St John Fisher |
| Cole Masterson | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | D | Lycoming |
| Robert Masti | Haverling | 2011 | G | |
| Josh Mastin | Eastridge | 2010 | A | |
| Michael Mastrosimone | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Isaiah Mateo | Newark | 2019 | A | |
| Jaymin Mateo | Waterloo | 2016 | M | |
| Josh Mateo | Waterloo | 2007 | A/M | |
| Ralph Mateo | Midlakes | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Materise | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | D | |
| Michael Matheson | Victor | 2017 | M | |
| Steve Mathews | Pittsford | 2005 | G | |
| Kyluc Mathipannha | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Jake Mathis | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | A/M | |
| Timothy Mathis | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | D | |
| Madut Mathuc | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | M | |
| Joe Matison | Schroeder | 2008 | A | Brockport |
| Mike Matteo | Eastridge | 2005 | G | |
| Cody Matteson | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Ethan Matteson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | G | |
| Jalen Matteson | Wayne | 2017 | D | |
| Terry Matthews | Livonia | 2007 | M | |
| Mark Mattiacio | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | A | |
| Dale Mattice | Victor | 2012 | M | VMI |
| Pattrick Mattice | Livonia | 2013 | D | |
| Travis Mattison | Brockport | 2010 | D | |
| Reid Mattle | Livonia | 2016 | A | |
| Dylan Mattoon | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2023 | M | |
| Matt Mattoon | Midlakes | 2019 | M | |
| Will Matuska | Irondequoit | 2023 | DM | |
| Ryan Matzek | Livonia-Avon | 2024 | M/D | |
| Sawyer Matzky | Bishop Kearney | 2027 | M | |
| Colin Mau | Aquinas | 2022 | M | |
| James Mault | Brockport | 2010 | D | |
| Jake Maurer | Penfield | 2027 | M | |
| Trent Maurer | Penfield | 2014 | M | |
| Andy Mavromatis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | D | |
| Tim Mavromatis | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | D | |
| Justin Mawhir | Mynderse | 2006 | D | |
| Brandon Maxwell | Pal-Mac | 2009 | D | |
| Christian Maxwell | Victor | 2011 | M | |
| Josh Maxwell | Victor | 2005 | A | |
| Brian May | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Connor May | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | A | |
| Jonny May | Schroeder | 2027 | A | |
| Cruz Mayberry | Gananda | 2016 | A | |
| Alex Mayen | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | D | |
| Cody Mayer | Gates Chili | 2021 | A | MCC |
| Liam Mayer | Thomas | 2021 | M | |
| Zack Mayer | Thomas | 2011 | G | |
| Nathan Mayeu | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | D | |
| Trevor Maylin | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | D | |
| Mike Maynard | Victor | 2011 | M | FLCC |
| Geoffrey Mayor | Fairport | 2006 | G | |
| Ben Mays | Midlakes | 2008 | D | |
| Josh Mays | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Randy Mays | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | M | |
| Brent Mazurkiewicz | Fairport | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Mazza | Schroeder | 2022 | A | |
| Scott McAllister | Batavia | 2011 | M | |
| Kevin McAree | Haverling | 2010 | D | |
| Dan McAvoy | Fairport | 2014 | A/M | |
| Kyle McAvoy | Fairport | 2017 | A/M | |
| Timothy McBride | Wayne | 2018 | D | |
| Craig McCabe | Thomas | 2015 | M | |
| Craig McCabe | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | M | |
| Ethan McCabe | Avon | 2020 | A | |
| Teddy McCabe | Thomas | 2014 | M | |
| Trevor McCabe | Avon | 2018 | A | |
| Drew McCandless | Victor | 2023 | A | |
| Jack McCandless | Victor | 2020 | D | Potsdam |
| Kevin McCandless | Penfield | 2020 | A | |
| Luke McCandless | Penfield | 2018 | LSM | |
| Chris McCann | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | D | Canton |
| Dillon McCann | Waterloo | 2020 | A | Brockport |
| Ryan McCannon | Midlakes | 2006 | A | |
| Tyler McCarrick | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2023 | M | |
| JP McCarten | Schroeder | 2019 | LSM | |
| Blake McCarthy | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Brendan McCarthy | Fairport | 2008 | M | |
| Brett McCarthy | Spencerport | 2010 | D | |
| Joshua McCarthy | Batavia | 2010 | M | |
| Justin McCarthy | Penfield | 2005 | M | |
| Patrick McCarthy | Penfield | 2020 | D | |
| Ryan McCarthy | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Sean McCarthy | Victor | 2023 | D | |
| Jared McCaughey | Hilton | 2007 | A | |
| Connor McClain | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | |
| Elijah McClain | Spencerport | 2016 | M | |
| Michel McClain | Canandaigua | 2015 | D | |
| Donnie McClary | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | D | |
| Cam McClenin | Fairport | 2026 | G | |
| Braeden McConville | Victor | 2023 | M | |
| Connor McCool | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | D | |
| Conor McCool | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | D | |
| Brigid McCormack | Batavia | 2018 | M/A | |
| Jack McCormack | Geneva | 2024 | M | |
| Warren McCormick | Haverling | 2026 | A/D | |
| Alex McCracken | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Noah McCray | UPrep | 2019 | G | |
| Luke McCrobie | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | A | |
| Luke McCrobie | Canandaigua | 2023 | M/FO | Manhattan |
| Liam McCullough | Penfield | 2012 | LSM | |
| Neiko McCullough | Penfield | 2016 | DM | |
| Kevin McCully | Mynderse | 2007 | M | |
| Dalton McCumber | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | Alfred |
| Gavin McCumiskey | Marcus Whitman | 2017 | LSM | |
| Brady McDermott | Brighton | 2018 | A | Yale |
| Casey McDermott | Brighton | 2020 | A | Johns Hopkins |
| Conor McDermott | Pittsford | 2008 | A | |
| Matt McDermott | Greece Storm | 2020 | A | |
| Max McDermott | Mynderse | 2019 | LSM | |
| Will McDermott | UPrep | 2016 | M | |
| Eddie McDonald | Batavia | 2007 | D | |
| Jack McDonald | Fairport | 2021 | D | |
| Jacob McDonald | Eastridge | 2020 | A | |
| Joe McDonald | Mynderse | 2025 | D | |
| Jordyn McDonald | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | D | |
| Shea McDonald | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| John McDonnell | Fairport | 2008 | M | Nazareth |
| Connor McDonough | Marcus Whitman | 2018 | M/A | |
| Matte McDonough | Penfield | 2013 | DM | |
| Dallas McDougal | Haverling | 2013 | D | |
| Garrett McDougal | Waterloo | 2025 | 0 | |
| Evan McDougall | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | D | |
| Jordan McElligot | Spencerport | 2011 | D | |
| Colin McElligott | Spencerport | 2016 | A | Nazareth |
| Craig McEneany | Thomas | 2024 | D | |
| Jackson McEnerney | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | A | RIT |
| Max McEnerney | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | A/M | |
| Andrew McEntee | Gates Chili | 2006 | M | |
| Ryan McEvily | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | A/M | |
| Andy Mcfadden | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | D | |
| Dion McFadden | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | M | |
| Myles Mcfadden | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Ross McFarland-Porter | Brighton | 2015 | D | |
| Ian McGarry | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Max McGee | Pittsford | 2022 | M | |
| Colin McGhan | Geneva | 2026 | D | |
| Devin McGhee | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | D | |
| Jayden McGhee | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | |
| Matt McGlory | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Jon McGovern | Geneva | 2012 | A | |
| Tyler McGowan | Avon | 2014 | D | |
| Ty McGrail | Eastridge | 2019 | D | |
| Devin McGrath | Brockport | 2014 | D | |
| Jake McGrath | Schroeder | 2018 | G | |
| Liam McGrath | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Ryan McGrath | Thomas | 2007 | D | Nazareth |
| Kyle McGraw | Penfield | 2013 | A | |
| Trenton McGraw | Batavia | 2016 | D | |
| Sean McGrimley | Mynderse | 2006 | A | |
| Liam McGuey | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | |
| Dan McGuffie | Penn Yan | 2006 | A | |
| Collin McGuigan | Midlakes | 2016 | A | |
| Liam McGuire | Brighton | 2022 | M | Vassar |
| Miles McGuire | Brighton | 2025 | A | |
| Riley McGwin | Irondequoit | 2015 | LSM | |
| Rowan McGwin | Irondequoit | 2021 | G | |
| Matt McHale | Greece Arc_Oly | 2019 | A/M | |
| Matthew McHale | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| Ethan McIntyre | Penn Yan | 2024 | M | |
| Jake McIntyre | Pal-Mac | 2021 | M/D | |
| Connor McJury | Fairport | 2011 | A/M | |
| Matt McKay | Irondequoit | 2018 | M | |
| Max McKay | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Paul McKee | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | D | |
| Casey McKenna | Canandaigua | 2020 | M | |
| Connor McKenna | Canandaigua | 2023 | M | |
| Kelly McKenna | Penfield | 2006 | M | Notre Dame |
| Liam McKenna | Brighton | 2019 | D | |
| Owen McKenna | Brighton | 2023 | D | |
| Afton McKenzie | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | D | |
| Aidan McKenzie | Pittsford | 2020 | A | |
| Ben McKeown | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Luke McKeown | Avon | 2013 | D | |
| Jeff McKinley | Haverling | 2012 | M | |
| Wesley McKinley | Eastridge | 2017 | M | |
| Nathaniel McKinney | Pal-Mac | 2027 | A/M | |
| Parrish McKnight | Schroeder | 2012 | M | |
| Devon McKoy | Pal-Mac | 2023 | M | |
| Avery McLaughlin | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | M/A | |
| Lukas McLaughlin | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | D | |
| Patrick McLaughlin | Penfield | 2023 | D | |
| Chris McLean | Penfield | 2022 | D | |
| Dillon McLean | Pittsford | 2008 | M | FLCC |
| Justice Mclean | Mynderse | 2026 | G | |
| Aidan McLellan | Aquinas | 2020 | D | |
| Justin McLiverty | Pittsford | 2010 | D | Robert Morris |
| Charlie McMahon | Spencerport | 2017 | A | |
| Patrick McMahon | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Gage McManus | Livonia | 2017 | D | |
| Ryan McManus | Newark | 2005 | D | |
| Brett McMichael | Penn Yan | 2013 | M | |
| Chris McMillan | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Stanley McMullen | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | D | |
| Logan McMurtry | Gates Chili | 2021 | D | Keuka |
| Ashton McNair | Spencerport | 2025 | D/LSM | |
| Ryan McNair | Hilton | 2019 | A | |
| Max McNally | Fairport | 2021 | M | |
| Zackary McNally | Fairport | 2024 | LSM | |
| CJ McNamara | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | M | |
| Kevin McNamara | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | M | |
| Brandon McNeil | Newark | 2021 | M | |
| Jeffery McPherson | Spencerport | 2023 | D | |
| Tanner McQuaid | Haverling | 2026 | D | |
| Keian McRae | Haverling | 2022 | M | |
| Ryan McRae | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | D | |
| Brian McShea | Rush-Henrietta | 2005 | A | |
| Matt McShea | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | G | St John Fisher |
| Alex McVean | Penfield | 2026 | D | |
| Adam McWilliams | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Brian McWilliams | Canandaigua | 2004 | D | Drexel |
| Chris McWilliams | Canandaigua | 2006 | M | MCC |
| Joe Mead | Eastridge | 2006 | M | |
| Ryan Mead | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | M | SUNY Poly |
| Billy Meagher | Fairport | 2022 | M | Nazareth |
| Noah Mean | Wayne | 2022 | A | |
| Noah Means | Wayne | 2022 | A/M | |
| Ben Meath | Midlakes | 2011 | M | |
| Antonio Medina | Penfield | 2024 | D | |
| Dan Medina | East Rochester | 2014 | M | |
| Jose Medina | Mynderse | 2019 | M | |
| Justin Medley | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | M | |
| Bennett Medyn | Pal-Mac | 2020 | A | Thiel |
| Bryce Medyn | Pal-Mac | 2018 | M | |
| Cory Mee | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | M | Alfred State |
| Ben Meeks | Geneva | 2022 | D | |
| Mike Meeks | Hilton | 2011 | A/M | |
| Holden Meier | Greece Storm | 2025 | D | |
| Rich Meier | Thomas | 2007 | M | |
| Cory Meintel | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| Finn Meiring | Brighton | 2024 | M | |
| Johannes Meissner | Brighton | 2007 | A | |
| Aaron Meister | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Christopher Mekeel | Avon | 2015 | D | |
| Mackenzie Mekeel | Avon | 2018 | A/D | |
| Mackenzie MeKeel | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | D | |
| Binyam Mekonen | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Kyle Melito | Aquinas | 2019 | D | |
| Harold Mellander | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Mike Mellini | Mynderse | 2010 | D | |
| Miles Meltzer | Bishop Kearney | 2022 | LSM | |
| Sam Melvin | Irondequoit | 2013 | A | |
| Shane Melvin | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | D | |
| Justin Mendenhall | Spencerport | 2006 | M | |
| Michael Mendicino | Thomas | 2011 | D | |
| Manuel Mendoza-Reese | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Ethan Mentchy | Newark | 2024 | D | |
| Jake Merica | Gates Chili | 2020 | A/M | |
| Chris Merkel | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | A | |
| Jake Merkel | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | M | |
| Joshua Merkel | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| James Merkley | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Zachary Merkley | Waterloo | 2021 | M | |
| Will Merle | Spencerport | 2018 | D | |
| Anthony Merola | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | A | |
| Hunter Merola | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | G | |
| Hunter Merola | Hilton | 2016 | G | |
| Charlie Merrill | Pittsford | 2007 | M | |
| Marcus Merriman | Fairport | 2007 | A | |
| Chris Merritt | Pal-Mac | 2009 | M | |
| Dave Merritt | Pal-Mac | 2006 | D | |
| Luke Merritt | Livonia | 2006 | M | |
| Brett Mersdorf | Thomas | 2025 | M | |
| Mitch Mertel | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Cameron Mesh | Spencerport | 2023 | M | |
| Connor Mesh | Spencerport | 2021 | M | St John Fisher |
| Dan Mesler | Penn Yan | 2006 | M | Pfeiffer |
| Jake Messimer | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | D | Stevens |
| Jordan Messimer | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Joseph Messina | Brighton | 2024 | M | |
| Mike Messina | Aquinas | 2011 | M | Syracuse |
| Thomas Messina | Pittsford | 2015 | D | |
| Mike Messineo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M | |
| Jake Messiner | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | M | |
| Dawson Messmer | Irondequoit | 2022 | A | MCC |
| Elliott Messmer | Waterloo | 2012 | A/M | |
| George Messmer | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | |
| Nick Messmer | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | M | |
| Zach Messmer | Waterloo | 2009 | M/D | |
| Anthony Messura | Hilton | 2016 | D | |
| Joel Messura | Hilton | 2022 | D | |
| Samuel Messura | Hilton | 2019 | D | |
| Austin Mettler | Waterloo | 2013 | A | |
| Ryan Metz | Haverling | 2006 | M | |
| Sean Metzger | Fairport | 2006 | D | |
| Cody Meunier | Victor | 2022 | M | |
| Adam Mevs | Brighton | 2025 | M | |
| Dahjear Mewborn | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Xavier Mewborn | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| Dylan Meyer | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | G | |
| Eoin Meyer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Jake Meyer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | G | |
| Kenny Meyer | Geneva | 2021 | D | |
| Matt Meyer | Aquinas | 2017 | D | |
| Peyton Meyerhoefer | Brockport | 2019 | M/D | |
| Joshua Meyerowitz-Shipper | Brighton | 2025 | D | |
| Brendon Meyers | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | M | |
| Ian Miano | East United-Eastridge | 2026 | A | |
| Mike Miara | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | G | |
| Joe Micca | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | D | |
| Mike Micca | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | D | |
| Anthony Miceli | Spencerport | 2019 | D | |
| Zach Miceli | Spencerport | 2027 | G | |
| Tony Micelotta | Irondequoit | 2008 | A | Alfred State |
| Jacob Michaels | Gananda | 2024 | A | Alfred |
| Tyler Michaels | Newark | 2015 | D | |
| Eli Michalak | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | A/M | |
| Nick Michalko | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | |
| Mason Michel | Wayne | 2025 | A/M | |
| Nate Michel | Wayne | 2023 | A/M | Cortland |
| Jordan Michele | East Rochester | 2012 | A | |
| Dave Micheli | Irondequoit | 2009 | M | |
| Hannes Michelsen | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| Liam Michener | Pittsford | 2009 | M | |
| Jason Micklei | Spencerport | 2024 | A | |
| Robert Middlebrook | Midlakes | 2017 | M | |
| Keith Mierzwa | Fairport | 2012 | D | Clarkson |
| Kevin Mierzwa | Pal-Mac | 2014 | D | |
| Theodore Mierzwa | Fairport | 2006 | A | |
| Andrew Mietelski | Fairport | 2013 | D | |
| Matthew Mietelski | Fairport | 2007 | D | |
| Dominic Migliorini | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | A | |
| John Migliorini | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| John Mikel | Irondequoit | 2010 | D | |
| Joe Mikiciuk | Thomas | 2013 | M | Brockport |
| Kelton Milanette | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | A | |
| Doug Milano-Johnson | Pittsford | 2007 | A | Nazareth |
| Jeff Milano-Johnson | Pittsford | 2009 | A | |
| Hunter Mileham | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | D | |
| Joe Miler | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | A | |
| Alex Miles | Penfield | 2011 | A | |
| Josh Miles | Haverling | 2021 | G | |
| Bennett Miley | Gates Chili | 2025 | M | |
| Ayden Millan | Spencerport | 2024 | D | |
| Henry Millard | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | |
| A.J. Miller | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | D | |
| Aaron Miller | Livonia | 2008 | A/M | |
| Alan Miller | Victor | 2023 | D | Queens University |
| Alex Miller | Irondequoit | 2014 | A | |
| Alik Miller | Gates Chili | 2007 | A | |
| Andrew Miller | Penfield | 2016 | D | Thiel |
| Ares Miller | Aquinas | 2026 | M | |
| Braden Miller | Hilton | 2024 | D | |
| Brady Miller | Schroeder | 2024 | D | Messiah |
| Brandon Miller | Brockport | 2010 | LSM | |
| Cam Miller | Irondequoit | 2024 | D | |
| Clyde Miller | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Cole Miller | Livonia | 2019 | A | |
| Cole Miller | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | D | |
| Colin Miller | Penfield | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Dakota Miller | Penn Yan | 2018 | D | |
| Darren Miller | Mynderse | 2019 | M | |
| Dylan Miller | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | A | |
| Evan Miller | Brockport | 2022 | D | Buffalo |
| Evan Miller | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | A/M | |
| Frank Miller | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | M | |
| Gunnar Miller | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | USMA |
| Jack Miller | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Jaden Miller | East United | 2020 | M | |
| Jake Miller | East Rochester | 2014 | M | |
| Jon Miller | Brockport | 2013 | A | |
| Jordan Miller | Midlakes | 2011 | M | |
| Kyle Miller | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | M | |
| Lindsay Miller | Newark | 2025 | D | |
| Matt Miller | Geneva | 2013 | A | |
| Matt Miller | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Matthew Miller | Aquinas | 2018 | M | |
| Max Miller | Geneva | 2022 | A | |
| Max Miller | Fairport | 2024 | M | |
| Michael Miller | Gates Chili | 2025 | A/G | |
| Mike Miller | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | M | |
| Robert Miller | Geneva | 2016 | D | |
| Ryan Miller | Aquinas | 2015 | D | |
| Ryan Miller | Brockport | 2026 | A | |
| Sam Miller | Geneva | 2019 | M | St John Fisher |
| Scott Miller | Penn Yan | 2010 | D | Keuka |
| Sean Miller | Aquinas | 2017 | A | |
| Seth Miller | Spencerport | 2012 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Steven Miller | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Troy Miller | Haverling | 2009 | M | |
| Nigel Millick | Pal-Mac | 2011 | D | |
| Alex Milliken | Hilton | 2013 | M | Wells |
| Jordan Milliken | Hilton | 2016 | A/M | |
| Dave Milliman | Newark | 2012 | D | FLCC |
| Mike Millis | Mynderse | 2013 | D | Morrisville |
| Tyler Mills | Gates Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Chris Milne | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | G | |
| Ivan Milovidov | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | M/A | |
| Connor Mims | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | M | |
| Michael Minarich | Brighton | 2007 | D | |
| Lyell Mincer | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M | |
| Dave Miner | Hilton | 2010 | M | |
| Charlie Minges | Brighton | 2014 | M | |
| Kurt Minges | Brighton | 2011 | A | Hamilton |
| Daniel Minguela | Gananda | 2027 | D | |
| Isaac Minguez | Waterloo | 2019 | D | |
| Jayson Minguez | Waterloo | 2022 | LSM | |
| Quinn Minich | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Frank Minnier | Waterloo | 2015 | M/D | |
| Tyler Minnier | Waterloo | 2016 | M | |
| Brendan Minor | Penn Yan | 2009 | M | |
| Mitch Minor | Brighton | 2026 | M | |
| Tyler Minotti | Pittsford | 2014 | D | |
| Blake Minster | Avon | 2014 | M | |
| Marc Minutolo | Newark | 2009 | D | |
| TJ Miranda | Spencerport | 2012 | D | |
| Anthony Mitchell | Penfield | 2013 | M | |
| Caleb Mitchell | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | M | |
| Chris Mitchell | Waterloo | 2015 | A | |
| Evan Mitchell | Thomas | 2020 | D | |
| Matthew Mitchell | Churchville-Chili | 2025 | M | |
| Michael Mitchell | Penfield | 2019 | M | |
| Patrick Mitchell | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | M | Canisius |
| Justin Mitchinson | Newark | 2014 | D | |
| Michael Mitchko | Victor | 2021 | D | |
| Anthony Mitrano | Hilton | 2026 | M | |
| Ben Mitrano | Hilton | 2020 | A | Marist |
| John Mitrano | Aquinas | 2007 | D | |
| Michael Mitrano | Hilton | 2024 | M/FO | Mercy |
| Zachary Mitrano | Hilton | 2018 | M | St John Fisher |
| Andy Mittiga | Waterloo | 2013 | M | |
| Colin Mix | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | G | |
| Owen Mix | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | G | Utica |
| Rob Mizelle | Pittsford | 2004 | D | RIT |
| Dan Mizro (#23 away) | Newark | 2006 | A | |
| Andrew Moak | Pal-Mac | 2008 | LSM | |
| Shayne Moak | Batavia | 2030 | 0 | |
| Jamil Modafarri | Penn Yan | 2010 | G | |
| Paul Modera | Geneva | 2005 | M | |
| Michael Modesti | Fairport | 2016 | A | |
| Tim Modesti | Fairport | 2010 | M | Providence |
| Utah Moffitt | Pittsford | 2013 | M | |
| Ieesa Mohammed | Aquinas | 2023 | M | |
| Jonathan Mohnkern | Livonia | 2016 | M | |
| Ian Mohr | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | MCC |
| Ken Mohrman | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | G | |
| Nikita Moiseiev | Brighton | 2024 | D | |
| Matthew Mojsej | Hilton | 2021 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Bobby Molinari | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Drew Moll | Pittsford | 2009 | D | |
| Luke Molnar | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Mason Mondo | Aquinas | 2020 | 0 | |
| Parker Monette | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | M | |
| Tom Monna | Thomas | 2008 | A | |
| Clinton Monson | Gates Chili | 2011 | D | |
| Landon Monson | Penn Yan | 2025 | M | |
| Luca Montana | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| Christian Montaque | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Jackson Monte | Fairport | 2023 | A | |
| Mitchell Monte | Fairport | 2025 | A/M | Dartmouth |
| Alex Montemorano | Victor | 2010 | M | |
| Nick Montemorano | Victor | 2015 | M | RIT |
| Giovanni Montes | Gates Chili | 2018 | G | |
| Jake Montgomery | Hilton | 2012 | A | MCC |
| Matthew Montgomery | Schroeder | 2016 | A/M | |
| Zach Montgomery | Mynderse | 2020 | M | |
| Carson Montone | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | M | |
| Carson Montoney | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Braiden Montour | Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| Braiden Montour | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| Eli Moon | Penn Yan | 2019 | M | |
| Ji-Hwan Moon | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | D | |
| Ryan Moon | Penn Yan | 2020 | M | |
| Brennan Mooney | Pittsford | 2017 | A/M | |
| Chris Mooney | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | A | |
| Jack Mooney | Schroeder | 2005 | A/M | Le Moyne |
| Nick Mooney | Schroeder | 2008 | M | St John Fisher |
| Tyler Mooney | Pal-Mac | 2017 | D | |
| Andrew Moore | Geneva | 2022 | M | |
| Austin Moore | Geneva | 2025 | M | |
| Brandon Moore | Canandaigua | 2017 | G | St John Fisher |
| Christian Moore | Midlakes | 2016 | D | |
| Connor Moore | Canandaigua | 2013 | M | St Rose |
| Connor Moore | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Cooper Moore | Irondequoit | 2026 | A/M | |
| Grady Moore | Canandaigua | 2004 | D | Bryant |
| Griffin Moore | Batavia | 2017 | A | |
| Jadyn Moore | Churchville-Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Kaiden Moore | Newark | 2019 | D | |
| William Moore | Gates Chili | 2023 | D | |
| Dylan Morabito | Gananda | 2027 | M | |
| Matt Morabito | Geneva | 2005 | M | |
| Josh Moracco | Midlakes | 2007 | D | |
| Darwin Morales | Newark | 2012 | D | |
| Edguardo Morales | East United | 2020 | M | |
| George Morales | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| Alex Moran | Spencerport | 2018 | G | |
| Jamie Moran | Pittsford | 2006 | M/A | |
| Matt Moran | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | A | Holy Cross |
| Max Moran | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Shane Moran | Livonia | 2006 | D | |
| Bryce Moravec | Penn Yan | 2017 | M | |
| Brandon Morehouse | Waterloo | 2015 | M | |
| Nelson Morel | Irondequoit | 2006 | D | |
| Liam Moreland | Fairport | 2025 | A | |
| Jayden Moreta | Eastridge | 2019 | M | |
| Steven Moretti-Ransom | Wayne | 2018 | M | |
| Casey Morey | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | M | |
| Alan Morgan | Mynderse | 2012 | M | |
| Andy Morgan | Spencerport | 2006 | A | |
| Blake Morgan | Greece Storm | 2025 | M | |
| Chase Morgan | Canandaigua | 2020 | G | Gettysburg |
| Conor Morgan | Spencerport | 2024 | D | |
| Elliott Morgan | Canandaigua | 2022 | M | St Joseph |
| Josh Morgan | Batavia | 2007 | D | |
| Rhyan Morgan | Wayne | 2022 | M | |
| Ryan Morgan | Haverling | 2013 | M | |
| Sayeed Morgan | Geneva | 2016 | M | |
| William Morgan | Churchville-Chili | 2025 | M | |
| Max Morgenstern | Pittsford | 2027 | A | |
| Mike Moriarty | Schroeder | 2008 | D | |
| Tom Moriarty | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Chase Morley | Pittsford | 2017 | M | Adelphi |
| Nick Mormino | Eastridge | 2007 | M | |
| Radel Moronta | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Nicholas Morreale | Aquinas | 2017 | A | |
| Stephen Morrell | Pal-Mac | 2014 | M | Ithaca |
| Jon Morrello | East Rochester | 2015 | M | |
| Alex Morrice | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | M | |
| Ben Morrill | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Max Morrill | Thomas | 2018 | M | |
| Mitch Morrill | Irondequoit | 2011 | M | MCC |
| Pat Morrill | Thomas | 2009 | M | Potsdam |
| Conner Morris | Brockport | 2020 | M | |
| Jonathan Morris | Greece Storm | 2023 | M/A | MCC |
| Mike Morris | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | DM | |
| Matt Morrisey | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | LSM | |
| Chad Morrison | Newark | 2009 | M | |
| Caleb Morrow | Batavia | 2011 | D | |
| Peyton Morrow | Midlakes | 2019 | M | |
| Reese Morrow | Batavia-Attica | 2017 | D | |
| Reese Morrow | Batavia | 2018 | D | |
| Cody Morse | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | A | |
| Fred Morse | Pittsford | 2006 | M | |
| Geoff Morse | Irondequoit | 2008 | G | |
| Will Morse | Pittsford | 2005 | D | |
| Ian Mort | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Perry Mortensen | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | M | |
| Jake Mortier | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | M | Le Moyne |
| Joe Mortillaro | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Mike Mortillaro | Eastridge | 2011 | A/M | Buffalo |
| Leighton Mortimer | Aquinas | 2027 | M | |
| Nick Mortis | Schroeder | 2022 | M | |
| Brian Morton | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Rafe Moscoe | Brighton | 2008 | D | |
| Alijah Moses | Geneva | 2016 | M | |
| Jason Mosher | Hilton | 2023 | G | Ohio Wesleyan |
| Justin Mosher | Hilton | 2019 | A | Alfred |
| Scott Mosher | Livonia | 2006 | M | |
| Dylon Moskal | Gananda | 2020 | D | |
| Justen Moskal | Gananda | 2022 | D | |
| Dillon Moss | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Jake Moss | Wayne | 2015 | M | MCC |
| James Moss | Hilton | 2008 | A | Alfred State |
| Jacob Moszkowicz | Irondequoit | 2018 | G | |
| Darryl Mott | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | M | FLCC |
| Billy Motzer | Livonia | 2009 | A | |
| Cahal Moulton | Pittsford | 2012 | G | |
| Tim Moulton | Pittsford | 2009 | M | |
| Gavin Mount | Hilton | 2017 | D | |
| Zakk Mount | Hilton | 2015 | M | FLCC |
| Jayden Mowers | Gates Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Ayden Mowry | Penn Yan | 2021 | A/M | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Michael Moxley | Aquinas | 2025 | M | |
| Michael Moxley | Penfield | 2025 | A | |
| Alex Moyer | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M | |
| Josh Moyer | Pal-Mac | 2018 | M | Keuka |
| Keenan Moyer | Canandaigua | 2015 | A | |
| Kyle Moyer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | M | |
| Zach Moyer | Pal-Mac | 2018 | D | Keuka |
| Brandon Moynihan | Eastridge | 2008 | A | |
| Patrick Moynihan | Eastridge | 2010 | A | |
| John Mozrall | Pittsford | 2018 | A | RIT |
| James Mroczek | Irondequoit | 2018 | D | |
| Tom Mscichowski | Aquinas | 2012 | G | |
| Jacob Mueller | Fairport | 2020 | M | |
| Peter Mueller | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2023 | A | |
| Tom Mueller | Midlakes | 2015 | M | |
| Sam Muir | Aquinas | 2024 | A | |
| Dusty Mulcahey | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | D | |
| Ryan Mulcahey | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | D | |
| Alex Mulcahy | Thomas | 2025 | M | |
| Matt Mulcahy | Irondequoit | 2021 | A | |
| Nicholas Mulcahy | Irondequoit | 2019 | D | |
| Ross Mulcahy | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | M | |
| Shawn Mulcahy | Livonia | 2005 | A | |
| Will Mulcahy | Batavia | 2010 | A | Lake Erie |
| Connor Mulhern | Gates Chili | 2016 | A | |
| Brian Mulheron | Mynderse | 2009 | D | |
| Chris Mulheron | Canandaigua | 2005 | A | SUNY Binghamton |
| Adam Mullen | Batavia | 2012 | D | |
| Jamison Mullen | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | M | |
| Patrick Mullen | Fairport | 2016 | D | |
| Collin Muller | Haverling | 2006 | M | |
| Mitch Muller | Haverling | 2008 | D | |
| Philipp Muller | Gates Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Cody Mullins | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | |
| Evan Multala | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | G | |
| Brett Mulvaney | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | D | |
| Scott Mummery | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | M | |
| Austin Mundorff | Brockport | 2011 | A | |
| Eric Munn | Canandaigua | 2014 | M | Siena |
| Nick Munn | Canandaigua | 2008 | M | |
| Isaiah Munroe | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Joe Muoio | Batavia | 2009 | A | |
| Tyson Murante | Hilton | 2023 | D | |
| Anthony Muratore | Wayne | 2019 | M | |
| Matt Murney | Geneva | 2017 | A | |
| Ethan Muroski | Penfield | 2024 | M | |
| Andrew Murphy | Canandaigua | 2024 | D | |
| Austin Murphy | Schroeder | 2024 | DM | |
| Cole Murphy | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | D | |
| Colin Murphy | Newark | 2014 | D | FLCC |
| Colin Murphy | Pittsford | 2018 | LSM | |
| Collin Murphy | Pal-Mac | 2017 | A/M | |
| Gustav Murphy | Pittsford | 2022 | M | |
| Kaden Murphy | Schroeder | 2022 | D | |
| Kevin Murphy | Pittsford | 2007 | A | |
| Kyle Murphy | Marcus Whitman | 2022 | A | Keuka |
| Max Murphy | Pittsford | 2020 | D | |
| Nick Murphy | Victor | 2010 | D | |
| Owen Murphy | Thomas | 2021 | D | |
| Shaun Murphy | Pal-Mac | 2019 | G | |
| Blane Murray | Waterloo | 2006 | M/D | |
| Cam Murray | Irondequoit | 2023 | D | |
| Jimmy Murray | Batavia | 2015 | G | |
| Jimmy Murray | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | D | |
| Johnny Murray | Schroeder | 2010 | M | MCC |
| Noah Murray | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | M | |
| Sean Murray | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M | |
| Travontay Murray | Newark | 2021 | M | |
| Dawaundrick Murrell | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | A/M | |
| Dawaundrick Murrell | Batavia | 2021 | M | |
| Austin Muscianese | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | A/G | |
| Sam Musso | Haverling | 2008 | M | |
| Addulhahab Muthana | Eastridge | 2019 | G | |
| Jordan Myer | Geneva | 2021 | M | |
| Austin Myers | Brockport | 2016 | M | |
| Jesse Myers | Marcus Whitman | 2019 | A | |
| Connor Mykins | Brockport | 2007 | G | |
| Tony Mykins | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | M | |
| Peyton Myles | Irondequoit | 2013 | LSM | |
| Mason Mylott | Thomas | 2025 | M | |
| Brandon Mynter | Avon | 2015 | M | |
| Nick Nadeau | East Rochester | 2012 | M | |
| Owen Nadiak | Penfield | 2015 | A | |
| Justin Nadler | Pittsford | 2005 | M | Pfeiffer |
| Craig Nairn | Fairport | 2006 | M | RIT |
| Christian Nairy | Thomas | 2015 | A | |
| Ryan Nairy | Thomas | 2019 | M | |
| Darius Nakis | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | D | |
| Brian Nally | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | A | |
| Shawn Nally | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | A | RIT |
| Elias Naoum | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Georges Naoum | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| Joe Napier | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Jordan Napierala | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | |
| Jacob Napoleon | Newark | 2018 | M | |
| Ben Napoli | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Bill Napoli | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | A/M | |
| Nestor Naranjo | Midlakes | 2014 | G/D | |
| Ethan Narby | Haverling | 2023 | G | |
| Austin Nasca | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Scotty Nasca | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Ian Nash | Irondequoit | 2008 | LSM | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Tyler Nash | Irondequoit | 2010 | G | Mercyhurst |
| Zach Nash | Irondequoit | 2007 | G | Mercyhurst |
| Jackson Natapow | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Killian Nau | Penfield | 2012 | D | FLCC |
| Adam Nauerth | Brockport | 2007 | A | Nazareth |
| Jacob Nauerth | Greece Storm | 2025 | A | |
| Da`Vique Naulls | Livonia | 2018 | A/M | |
| Da`Vique Naulls | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | D | |
| Nick Navarra | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | M | |
| Nkodia Ndongala | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| Steve Neal | Mynderse | 2011 | D | |
| Justin Nealey | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | D | |
| Mark Nearpass | Waterloo | 2006 | G | |
| Patrick Neary | Bishop Kearney | 2016 | M | |
| Paul Nebbia | Livonia | 2007 | M | |
| Mike Neckers | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | D | |
| Brady Nelson | Penfield | 2024 | M | |
| Jonathan Nelson | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | M/A | |
| Kenny Nelson | Schroeder | 2013 | A | |
| Ryan Nelson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Tucker Nelson | Penfield | 2010 | A | SUNY Binghamton |
| Jeremy Nemecek | Canandaigua | 2005 | A | |
| Jon Neri | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | D | MCC |
| Andy Nesbitt | Haverling | 2009 | M | |
| Charles Nesbitt | Hilton | 2007 | M | |
| Dan Nesbitt | Newark | 2007 | D | |
| Matt Nesbitt | Haverling | 2010 | M | |
| Ryan Netchke | Eastridge | 2012 | M | |
| Brad Netcke | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Andrew Neth | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | M | |
| Andrew Neth | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Zach Neu | Spencerport | 2024 | M | |
| Charlie Neuman | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | D | |
| Connor Nevil | Midlakes | 2015 | D | |
| Brendon Newbauer | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | M | |
| Connor Newberry | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | G | |
| Shea Newell | Victor | 2020 | M | Mercyhurst |
| TJ Newell | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | M | |
| Jake Newkirk | Fairport | 2013 | G | |
| Joe Newland | Midlakes | 2015 | M | |
| Mike Newland | Midlakes | 2010 | A | |
| Nick Newland | Midlakes | 2008 | M | |
| Sterling Newsom | UPrep | 2016 | M | |
| Quentin Newsome | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | DM | |
| Corey Newton | Wayne | 2025 | D | |
| James Newton | East Rochester | 2014 | M | |
| James Newton | Brockport | 2028 | G | |
| Andrew Ng | Penfield | 2006 | D | |
| Spencer Ngo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | A | |
| Anthony Nguyen | Gates Chili | 2020 | M | |
| James Nguyen | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | M | |
| Kenneth Nguyen | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | M | |
| Richard Nguyen | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Steven Nguyen | East United | 2019 | A | |
| Thien Nguyen | Gates Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Tommy Nguyen | Gananda | 2012 | M | |
| Alex Nicastro | Fairport | 2020 | A | |
| Aiden Nice | Pal-Mac | 2023 | A/M | Keuka |
| Aidan Nichols | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | D | |
| Craig Nichols | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | D | |
| Jay Nichols | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | G | |
| Nate Nichols | Penn Yan | 2010 | M | |
| Will Nichols | Pal-Mac | 2022 | G | |
| Connor Nicholson | Wayne | 2015 | M | MCC |
| Kiernan Nicholson | Brighton | 2025 | A | |
| Ryan Nicholson | Wayne | 2015 | M | |
| Branden Nick | East Rochester | 2013 | M | |
| Chris Nicodemi | Schroeder | 2006 | D | |
| Joe Nicodemi | Schroeder | 2010 | M | |
| Tyler Nicolay | Thomas | 2024 | M/D | |
| Andrew Nicolella | Victor | 2019 | A | |
| Ryan Nicoletta | Penfield | 2006 | G | |
| Nick Nicoletti | Canandaigua | 2018 | M | |
| Dan Nielsen | Irondequoit | 2005 | D | |
| Jackson Nieman | Canandaigua | 2021 | D | Stevens |
| Noel Nieves | Eastridge | 2020 | G | |
| Noel Nieves | East United | 2020 | G | |
| Jojo Nigro | Mynderse | 2027 | D | |
| Collin Nims | Gananda | 2014 | D | |
| Nick Nisbet | Pal-Mac | 2011 | A | |
| Cameron Nitti | Spencerport | 2018 | A | |
| Jeff Nitti | Aquinas | 2012 | M | |
| Jeff Nitti | Spencerport | 2012 | M | MCC |
| Justin Nitti | Irondequoit | 2025 | M | |
| Nic Nittolo | Newark | 2021 | A | |
| Zakari Noah | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Brady Nobes | Fairport | 2022 | D | |
| Bronson Nobes | Fairport | 2024 | DM | |
| Patrick Nobes | Fairport | 2024 | DM | |
| Ryan Nobes | Fairport | 2025 | DM | |
| Dan Noble | Midlakes | 2011 | D | |
| Pat Noble | Hilton | 2007 | LSM | |
| Jordan Nolan | Irondequoit | 2024 | DM | |
| Quinn Nolan | Pal-Mac | 2022 | M | St Bonaventure |
| Sean Nolan | Fairport | 2006 | D | |
| Sean Nolan | Pal-Mac | 2012 | M | |
| Nikko Nolletti | Brockport | 2013 | A | |
| Jayden Noone | Mynderse | 2021 | D | |
| Cade Norris | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M/A | Navy |
| Andrew Norrison | Marcus Whitman | 2019 | A/M | |
| Jeremy Norsen | Pal-Mac | 2007 | M | |
| Ryan Norsen | Mynderse | 2013 | M | |
| Ben Norten | Pittsford | 2024 | D | |
| Ben Northrup | Canandaigua | 2013 | M | |
| Mike Northrup | Schroeder | 2019 | M/FO | |
| Austin Norwood | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | D | |
| Zach Notebaert | Midlakes | 2017 | M | |
| Hunter Noteware | Haverling | 2019 | M | St John Fisher |
| Jack Nothnagle | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | A | St Rose |
| Pete Noto | Schroeder | 2010 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| John Novitsky | Victor | 2012 | D | Oswego |
| Michael Novitsky | Victor | 2018 | D | |
| Nick Novy | Penfield | 2015 | M | |
| Alex Nowak | Penfield | 2008 | LSM | Canisius |
| Eric Nowak | Newark | 2016 | A | |
| Jeff Nowak | Newark | 2011 | A | |
| Matt Nowak | Newark | 2008 | D | |
| Steve Nowak | Schroeder | 2007 | M | |
| Dan Nowakowski | Aquinas | 2018 | D | |
| Spencer Nuccitelli | Thomas | 2019 | A/M | |
| Nate Nuccotelli | Thomas | 2024 | M/D | |
| Brady Nugent | Greece Storm | 2024 | D | |
| Ryan Nugent | Thomas | 2014 | D | |
| Jamison Nuijens | Penfield | 2018 | A | |
| Kenny Nyguen | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | M | |
| Jani Nylund | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Armel N`Dobi | East United | 2022 | M | |
| Armel N`Dobi | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Trevor Oakes | Wayne | 2017 | M | |
| Sean Oberlies | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | M | |
| Tim Oberlies | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M | |
| Andrew Oberst | Aquinas | 2011 | A/M | |
| Cal Oberst | Brighton | 2022 | M | Geneseo |
| Kevin Oberst | Aquinas | 2005 | M | |
| Liam Oberst | Brighton | 2015 | D | Baldwin Wallace |
| Joe Oca | Thomas | 2012 | M | |
| Frank Ochoa | Penn Yan | 2023 | A | |
| Alex Ochs | Brighton | 2022 | M | |
| Rob Ockenden | Penfield | 2009 | A | |
| Austin Ocwieja | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Ayden Odachowski | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Tim Oddi | Wayne | 2014 | A | |
| Eric Odell | Greece Storm | 2026 | M/FO | |
| Dan Odorczyk | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Steve Odorczyk | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Noah Ogden | Aquinas | 2015 | M | Keuka |
| Trenttyn Ohearn | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | A | |
| John Oherron | Greece Storm | 2026 | A/M | |
| Tyler Ohle | Livonia | 2010 | D | |
| Remy Okeefe | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| Jonathan Olbrich | Aquinas | 2014 | A | Nazareth |
| Noah Olbrich | Aquinas | 2025 | A | |
| Tanner Olbrich | Aquinas | 2020 | A | |
| Tyler Olbrich | Aquinas | 2017 | D | USMA |
| Shane Olin | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | A/M | St Michael |
| Willem Oliveiri | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | A | |
| Joe Oliver | Penfield | 2014 | A/M | |
| Brett Olney | Irondequoit | 2019 | G | Mercyhurst |
| Derek Olney | Irondequoit | 2017 | A | St John Fisher |
| Nevin Olney | Irondequoit | 2016 | A | Elmira |
| Bryce Olsen | Schroeder | 2022 | A/M | |
| Conner Olsen | Penn Yan | 2017 | D | |
| Hunter Olsen | Schroeder | 2018 | A | Canton |
| Kasey Olsen | Spencerport | 2014 | A | MCC |
| Kyle Olsen | Livonia | 2007 | A | |
| Maddox Olsen | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | A/M | |
| Keegan Olton | Pal-Mac | 2007 | D | |
| Sean Olvany | Canandaigua | 2024 | A/M | Wingate |
| Aidan Oniel | Eastridge | 2010 | D | |
| Nicholas Opett | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | A | |
| Zack Opiela | Canandaigua | 2013 | D | Canton |
| Josh Opladen | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | DM | |
| Connor Orcutt | Fairport | 2017 | D | |
| Dylan Orcutt | Fairport | 2018 | M | Buffalo |
| Jacob Ordiway | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | D | |
| Austin Orengo | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Cameron Orengo | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | D | |
| Cullen Orengo | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Paul Organek | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | LSM | |
| Carl Orlando | Hilton | 2011 | D | |
| Ruairi Orlando | Mynderse | 2014 | M | |
| Dalton Ormsbee | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | M/A | |
| Hunter Ornt | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | D | |
| Brody Orr | Rush-Henrietta | 2027 | D | |
| Austin Orsini | Schroeder | 2007 | A | Springfield |
| Nick Orsini | Fairport | 2014 | A/M | Potsdam |
| Peter Orszagh | Brockport | 2009 | M | |
| Sergio Ortega | Waterloo | 2016 | DM | |
| Dan Ortenzi | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | D | |
| AJ Ortiz | Newark | 2014 | D | |
| Dominic Ortiz | Newark | 2015 | A | |
| Jayden Ortiz | Newark | 2023 | M | |
| Justin Ortiz | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Carlos Ortiz-Speed | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | M | |
| Carlos Ortiz-Speed | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Caydin Orwen | Penn Yan | 2024 | D | |
| Gannon Osborn | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | Marist |
| Liam Osborn | Wayne | 2020 | M | |
| Brock Osborne | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Chris Osborne | Haverling | 2005 | A | |
| Jaden Osbourne | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | D | |
| Jaden Osbourne | Batavia | 2021 | D | |
| Kevin Osgood | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Matt Osgood | Penn Yan | 2009 | A | MCC |
| Aleksandr Osipovitch | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | D | |
| Alex Osman | Spencerport | 2016 | D | |
| Dylan Osman | Spencerport | 2013 | LSM | |
| Tarik Osmancevic | East Rochester | 2011 | A | |
| Marwan Osmen | Newark | 2023 | A | |
| Charlie Oster | Aquinas | 2006 | D | |
| Joe Osterhout | Waterloo | 2010 | A | |
| Ben Osterling | Victor | 2008 | M | |
| PJ Ostrowski | Wayne | 2024 | M | |
| Gianni Oswald | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Oliver Oswald | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | D | Brockport |
| Tyler Osypian | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | M | |
| Danny Ott | Eastridge | 2012 | A | |
| Jett Otwell | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | M | |
| Ben Overslaugh | Pittsford | 2013 | M | |
| Mason Overton | Victor | 2025 | D | |
| Jordan Owen | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| DJ Owens | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | |
| Jack Owens | Aquinas | 2017 | D | |
| Mike Owens | Aquinas | 2010 | D | |
| Kyle Owlett | Pittsford | 2020 | M | |
| Weston Oyer | Victor | 2025 | DM | |
| Brady OYong | Hilton | 2017 | M | |
| Tamer Ozkum | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | M | |
| Adam Ozuna | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | LSM | |
| Connor O`Brien | Midlakes | 2020 | G | |
| Dan O`Brien | Penfield | 2011 | M | |
| Devin O`Brien | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | |
| Jacob O`Brien | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | G | |
| Jake O`Brien | Midlakes | 2015 | D | |
| Jordan O`Brien | Penfield | 2009 | A | |
| Keanan O`Brien | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | D | |
| Kyle O`Brien | Waterloo | 2014 | A | |
| Stephen O`Brien | Thomas | 2008 | M | |
| Nolan O`Brocta | Aquinas | 2027 | M | |
| Drew O`Buck | Hilton | 2025 | M/FO | Hobart |
| Dylan O`Buck | Hilton | 2023 | M | |
| Bobby O`Connell | Gananda | 2016 | M | |
| David O`Connell | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | |
| Mason O`Connell | Waterloo | 2027 | 0 | |
| Andrew O`Connor | Midlakes | 2020 | D | |
| Geoffrey O`Connor | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | D | |
| Jacob O`Connor | Penfield | 2014 | D | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Jacob O`Connor | Bishop Kearney | 2016 | D | |
| Ryan O`Connor | Victor | 2007 | A | Lycoming |
| Shayne O`Connor | Gananda | 2018 | M/D | |
| Zach O`Connor | Gananda | 2011 | A | |
| Kyle O`Connors | Waterloo | 2005 | M | |
| Kyle O`Dea | Victor | 2016 | D | St John Fisher |
| Hugh O`Donnell | Brighton | 2025 | D | |
| Kevin O`Donnell | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | M | St John Fisher |
| J.R. O`Flynn | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Kevin O`Hara | Eastridge | 2018 | LSM | |
| Joseph O`Hare | Gates Chili | 2016 | A | Nazareth |
| Mike O`Hare | Victor | 2005 | A | |
| John O`Hern | Penfield | 2012 | D | |
| Brad O`Keefe | Spencerport | 2008 | M | |
| Ty O`Keefe | Thomas | 2024 | A | |
| Colin O`Leary | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M/A | |
| Kevin O`Leary | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Tommy O`Leary | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M | |
| Tyler O`Neal | Spencerport | 2018 | D | |
| Dean O`Neil | Thomas | 2014 | G | |
| Jamail O`Neil | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | D | |
| James O`Neil | Thomas | 2009 | G | |
| Jamie O`Neil | Haverling | 2022 | A | Oneonta |
| Jimmy O`Neil | Pittsford | 2008 | A | |
| Collin O`Shea | Victor | 2010 | M | Bentley |
| Josh O`Shea | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | G | |
| Ryan O`Shea | Aquinas | 2009 | D | |
| Trevor O`Shea | Victor | 2011 | A | |
| Colin O`Shell | Penfield | 2010 | D | |
| Tim O`Toole | Hilton | 2007 | G | |
| Tony Paba | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | D | |
| Kevin Pabon | Geneva | 2015 | D | |
| Evan Pace | Hilton | 2011 | A | MCC |
| John Pacitto | Brockport | 2010 | D | Eastern |
| Ricardo Padilla | Pittsford | 2016 | M | |
| John Padulo | Irondequoit | 2010 | A | |
| Nick Padulo | Irondequoit | 2008 | D | |
| Casey Pagano | Schroeder | 2027 | LSM | |
| Chris Pagano | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Damien Pagano | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Drew Pagano | Schroeder | 2023 | LSM | |
| Danny Page | Pittsford | 2013 | M | St John Fisher |
| Zach Page | Waterloo | 2017 | DM | |
| Jaquan Paige | Brockport | 2015 | D | |
| Johovon Paige | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Lucas Paige | Penn Yan | 2019 | A | |
| Thomas Paine | Waterloo | 2022 | D | |
| Troy Pakusch | Hilton | 2012 | D | |
| Brenton Paladino | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Bryson Paladino | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Brad Palermo | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| Kyle Palka | Brockport | 2019 | M | |
| Gavin Palleschi | Fairport | 2022 | M | |
| Nick Palliani | Penfield | 2015 | A | |
| Tony Pallidino | Mynderse | 2007 | G | |
| Connor Palmer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | A | |
| Danny Palmer | Thomas | 2020 | DM | |
| Drew Palmer | Schroeder | 2007 | D | Fairfield |
| Drew Palmer | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Ian Palmer | Gananda | 2012 | A | |
| Jack Palmer | Hilton | 2026 | M | |
| James Palmer | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| Liam Palmer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Matt Palmer | Pittsford | 2011 | M | Oswego |
| Matt Palmer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Qinton Palmer | Geneva | 2014 | D | |
| Riley Palmer | Gananda | 2015 | M | |
| Jason Palmeri | Hilton | 2005 | M | |
| Ryan Palmeri | Hilton | 2013 | DM | |
| Joshua Palmgreen | Greece Storm | 2023 | M | |
| CJ Palmiere | Victor | 2023 | D | Lynn |
| Austin Palozzi | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Blake Palozzi | Gates Chili | 2020 | M | Brockport |
| CJ Palozzi | Gates Chili | 2013 | DM | |
| Angelo Palumbo | Aquinas | 2022 | M | Le Moyne |
| Nick Paluso | Bishop Kearney | 2022 | M | |
| Marcus Palvino | Spencerport | 2011 | M | Brockport |
| Mike Palvino | Spencerport | 2008 | G | FLCC |
| Nick Panara | Pittsford | 2014 | D | Fairfield |
| Roger Panara | Canandaigua | 2017 | D | St John Fisher |
| Mike Pane | Canandaigua | 2004 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Jared Panek | Newark | 2018 | D | |
| Dmitriy Panfilov | Spencerport | 2014 | DM | |
| Josh Pangburn | Brockport | 2017 | M | |
| Jackson Paolozzi | Victor | 2024 | D | |
| John Papa | Gates Chili | 2010 | LSM | |
| Aidan Papalia | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | D | |
| Chris Papalia | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | M | |
| Mike Papas | Schroeder | 2014 | D | |
| Trae Papke | Victor | 2018 | A | FLCC |
| Jimmy Paris | Irondequoit | 2012 | M | |
| Cory Parish | Geneva | 2011 | M | |
| Jordan Parish | Mynderse | 2009 | D | |
| Tim Parish | Waterloo | 2007 | A/M | |
| Trace Parish | Mynderse | 2026 | M | |
| Joe Park | Brighton | 2008 | M | |
| Corey Parke | Pittsford | 2012 | M | Georgetown |
| Aaron Parker | Victor | 2007 | D | |
| Ben Parker | Pittsford | 2010 | G | |
| Chris Parker | Brockport | 2021 | A | |
| CJ Parker | Gates Chili | 2017 | G/D | |
| Isaiah Parker | Gates Chili | 2019 | D | |
| Joe Parker | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | |
| Kyle Parker | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | DM | |
| Mason Parker | Victor | 2016 | M | |
| Mitchell Parker | Fairport | 2022 | M | |
| Seamus Parker | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Will Parker | Fairport | 2016 | D | |
| Johari Parker-Nash | UPrep | 2020 | M | |
| Johari Parker-Nash | Irondequoit | 2020 | M | |
| Derek Parkison | Newark | 2012 | D | |
| Emerson Parks | Penfield | 2018 | G | |
| Ethan Parks | Penfield | 2015 | D | Cortland |
| Gavin Parks | Brighton | 2025 | M | |
| Dalton Parmalee | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| Eric Parmelee | Brockport | 2008 | D | Guilford |
| Gary Parmelee | Geneva | 2009 | A | Alfred State |
| Kyle Parnell | Pittsford | 2011 | D | |
| Andy Paro | Pal-Mac | 2012 | D | |
| Alex Paroda | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | M | Boston U |
| Max Paroda | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Jonathan Parrinello | Aquinas | 2018 | M | Nazareth |
| Spencer Parrinello | Pittsford | 2024 | M | |
| Eathon Parrish | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | M | |
| Ondrayus Parrish | Newark | 2022 | A | |
| Miles Parrotta | East Rochester | 2012 | M | |
| Mitch Parrotta | East Rochester | 2012 | D | |
| Jaden Parshall | Haverling | 2023 | M/A | |
| Tyler Parsons | Wayne | 2015 | A | |
| Alex Parton | Victor | 2021 | D | |
| Brett Partridge | Haverling | 2011 | D | |
| Jason Partridge | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | M | Nazareth |
| Victor Pascucci | Spencerport | 2016 | A | |
| Ben Paserk | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | A/M | |
| Ben Paserk | Batavia | 2020 | A/M | |
| Blake Paserk | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | D | |
| Blake Paserk | Batavia | 2021 | D | |
| Evan Pashalidis | Thomas | 2022 | A | |
| Gianni Passalacqua | Brockport | 2025 | D | |
| Joe Passalacqua | Geneva | 2009 | D | |
| Mike Passantino | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| Doug Passero | Thomas | 2011 | D | VMI |
| Thomas Passewe | Brighton | 2021 | M | |
| Kenneth Patane | Midlakes | 2008 | A | |
| Reid Patchett | Geneva | 2019 | D | |
| Sohil Patel | Geneva | 2018 | D | |
| Jeff Patnode | Pal-Mac | 2017 | D | |
| Jake Patrei | Greece Storm | 2024 | M/D | St Bonaventure |
| Michael Patriaca | Pittsford | 2022 | M | |
| Connor Patterson | Fairport | 2024 | DM | |
| Devan Patterson | Wayne | 2020 | A/M | |
| Jordan Patterson | Wayne | 2015 | D | |
| Justin Patterson | Newark | 2016 | D | |
| Bobby Pattridge | Rush-Henrietta | 2008 | A | Oswego |
| Kenny Pattridge | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | A | |
| TJ Paul | Victor | 2010 | D | |
| Alex Pautler | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | A | |
| Zach Pavia | Victor | 2022 | G | |
| Salvador Pavia-Vicente | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | A | |
| Alex Pavone | Churchville-Chili | 2010 | A | |
| Michael Pavone | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | A | |
| John Pawluk | Schroeder | 2006 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Aaron Payne | Victor | 2011 | D | |
| Brad Payne | Victor | 2006 | D | |
| Ethan Payne | Victor | 2008 | A | Lycoming |
| Chase Peacock | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | A | |
| Jace Peacock | Fairport | 2016 | M | |
| Mike Peacock | Pittsford | 2006 | M | |
| Sean Peacock | Midlakes | 2014 | A | |
| Alex Peake | Newark | 2010 | M/A | |
| Thad Peake | Mynderse | 2017 | D | |
| Clark Pearce | Eastridge | 2017 | A | |
| Grant Pearce | Eastridge | 2015 | LSM | |
| Zach Pearson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | G/M | |
| Kevin Pease | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Mason Pease | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | Pittsburgh |
| Ryan Pease | Irondequoit | 2018 | D | |
| Tim Pease | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | |
| Bryan Peck | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | |
| Collin Peck | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | |
| David Peck | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Kevin Peck | Canandaigua | 2007 | M | |
| Max Peck | Brockport | 2007 | D | |
| Nate Peck | Pal-Mac | 2017 | A/M | |
| Ryan Peck | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | M | |
| Sean Peck | Midlakes | 2011 | M | |
| Tyler Peck | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2015 | D | |
| Luke Pecora | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | D | |
| Nick Pecora | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Preston Pedersen | Penn Yan | 2017 | A | |
| Ryan Pedersen | Haverling | 2005 | D | |
| Joe Pedro | Batavia | 2010 | A | Mt Olive |
| Ryan Pedro | Fairport | 2024 | A/M | |
| Vin Pedro | Batavia | 2010 | M | Mt Olive |
| Anthony Peelle | Eastridge | 2014 | LSM | |
| Colin Peers | Fairport | 2020 | A | |
| Jordan Peeso | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | M | |
| Gage Peffers | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Christian Pehrson | Waterloo | 2024 | D | |
| Julian Pehrson | Waterloo | 2023 | D | |
| Phil Peindel | Eastridge | 2017 | M | |
| Grant Peinkofer | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | D | |
| Joe Pekich | Pittsford | 2006 | A | |
| Buddy Pelish | Penfield | 2020 | D | Haverford |
| Dave Pels | Spencerport | 2006 | LSM | |
| Kyle Pendell | Fairport | 2013 | M | |
| Cameron Penders | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Kyle Penders | Pittsford | 2016 | M | |
| Brad Pendle | Haverling | 2020 | M | |
| Sean Pennino | Brighton | 2007 | M | |
| Gavin Pentland | Pal-Mac | 2021 | M/D | |
| James Peppard | East United | 2021 | A | |
| James Peppard | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| Nathan Peppard | East United | 2020 | A | |
| Colby Percey | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | D | |
| Reed Perestam | Pittsford | 2017 | M | MCC |
| Felix Perez | Hilton | 2008 | M | |
| Louie Perez | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Perez | Aquinas | 2007 | D | |
| Nadin Perez II | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | DM | |
| Ethan Perham | Livonia | 2016 | D | |
| A.J. Peri | Livonia-Avon | 2024 | A/M | |
| Colin Perkins | Gates Chili | 2016 | A | |
| Joe Perkins | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | A | Ithaca |
| Josh Perkins | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| Andrew Perl | Penn Yan | 2014 | A/M | |
| Corey Perno | Aquinas | 2010 | D | |
| Jonathan Perotto | Aquinas | 2016 | A | |
| Jonathan Perotto | Pittsford | 2016 | A | |
| Mike Perotto | Aquinas | 2015 | D | |
| Mike Perotto | Pittsford | 2015 | D | |
| Josh Perrault | Penn Yan | 2007 | A | Lycoming |
| Jay Perrill | Gananda | 2014 | M | |
| Bryce Perry | Penfield | 2025 | A | |
| Carrighan Perry | Pal-Mac | 2014 | D | |
| Jackson Perry | Fairport | 2025 | D | |
| Jonathan Perry | Brockport | 2025 | D/LSM | |
| Matt Perry | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | M | |
| Chase Perryman | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | A | St Bonaventure |
| Ayden person | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | D | |
| Ayden Person | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | D | |
| Brendan Personale | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | LSM | FLCC |
| Mark Personale | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | A | |
| Stephen Personale | Victor | 2006 | M | |
| Antonio Pesante | Geneva | 2024 | D | |
| Mike Pesce | Gates Chili | 2013 | D | |
| Johnny Pestillo | Batavia | 2013 | M | |
| Andy Peter | Schroeder | 2005 | G | |
| Aaron Peterman | Mynderse | 2013 | M | |
| Andrew Peterman | Mynderse | 2018 | M | Keuka |
| Kyle Peters | Waterloo | 2012 | M/D | |
| Matthew Peters | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | D | |
| Matthew Peters | Greece Storm | 2018 | D | |
| Owen Peters | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Vinny Petersen | Geneva | 2013 | M | |
| Eric Peterson | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | Wells |
| Eric Peterson | Geneva | 2007 | M | |
| Jack Peterson | Penn Yan | 2019 | D | |
| Jack Peterson | Pittsford | 2019 | M | |
| Justin Peterson | Batavia | 2007 | LSM | |
| Kevin Peterson | Greece | 2005 | M | |
| Mike Petralia | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | D | |
| Luciano Petrella | Spencerport | 2008 | M | |
| Dominic Petrillo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | A | |
| Matt Petrillo | Pittsford | 2006 | D | |
| Mike Petronio | Geneva | 2019 | M | |
| Gianni Petrontoni | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | D | |
| CJ Petruzzelli | Midlakes | 2014 | M | |
| Matt Petruzzo | Greece | 2005 | LSM | |
| John Petry | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | D | Keuka |
| John Petry | Batavia | 2020 | D | GCC |
| Julia Petry | Batavia | 2023 | D/LSM | |
| Julia Petry | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | D | |
| Chase Petschke | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Justin Petsos | Eastridge | 2017 | D | |
| Craig Pettingil | Mynderse | 2015 | G/D | |
| Logan Pettingil | Mynderse | 2024 | G | |
| Marc Pettrone | Victor | 2012 | D | |
| Marc Pettrone | Aquinas | 2012 | D | |
| Vince Pettrone | Victor | 2010 | A | |
| Kyle Petty | Brockport | 2007 | D | |
| PJ Petty | Newark | 2012 | D | |
| David Petz | Thomas | 2022 | A | |
| Anthony Pezzimenti | Victor | 2018 | M | Canisius |
| Dante Pezzimenti | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | A | |
| Dante Pezzimenti | Victor | 2025 | A | |
| Dom Pezzimenti | Victor | 2023 | D | Le Moyne |
| Dominic Pezzimenti | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | M | |
| Joey Pezzimenti | Victor | 2020 | A | Le Moyne |
| Dylan Pfahl | Aquinas | 2009 | A | |
| Andrew Pfeffer | Victor | 2010 | M | |
| Jeff Pfeffer | McQuaid Jesuit | 2002 | A | Drexel |
| Tim Pfeffer | Penfield | 2005 | A | Ithaca |
| Daniel Pfeifer | Fairport | 2005 | M | |
| Mitch Pfeiffer | Canandaigua | 2019 | M | Richmond |
| Patrick Pfeiffer | Pittsford | 2011 | A | |
| Dylan Pfendler | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Matt Pheilshifter | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | D | |
| Adam Phelan | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Thomas Joseph Phelan | Gates Chili | 2024 | G | |
| DeAndre Phelps | Gates Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Max Phelps | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | A | |
| Jesse Phillippsen | Eastridge | 2013 | D | |
| Asher Phillips | East United | 2019 | G | |
| Brock Phillips | Wayne | 2025 | M/A | |
| Carter Phillips | Avon | 2020 | M/A | |
| Dalton Phillips | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2016 | A | |
| David Phillips | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | D | |
| David Phillips | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | A | |
| Davy Phillips | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | D | |
| Ford Phillips | Pittsford | 2019 | M | |
| John Phillips | Victor | 2011 | G | |
| Keifer Phillips | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | G/M | |
| Logan Phillips | Wayne | 2025 | G | |
| Lucas Phillips | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | LSM | Buffalo |
| Matthew Phillips | Wayne | 2022 | D | |
| Mitchell Phillips | Gates Chili | 2017 | M | |
| Robert Phillips | Gates Chili | 2017 | G/D | |
| Tyler Phillips | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | D | GCC |
| Tyler Phillips | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Joel Phillips-Pearson | Waterloo | 2011 | M | |
| Brandon Phimprachanh | Eastridge | 2012 | M | |
| Callaway Phommachanh | Gates Chili | 2026 | A | |
| Nicholas Piano | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Bob Piazza | Bishop Kearney | 2011 | M | |
| Chris Picchi | Waterloo | 2013 | D | |
| Derek Piccola | Pal-Mac | 2006 | A | |
| Adam Pickering | Haverling | 2020 | D | |
| Cole Pickering | Victor | 2013 | D | |
| Luke Pickering | Victor | 2008 | A | |
| Ben Pickett | Gananda | 2018 | A/M | |
| Joe Pickett | Gananda | 2011 | D | |
| Connor Piecuch | Gates Chili | 2023 | D | |
| Dan Pierce | Brighton | 2011 | D | Hartford |
| Elijah Pierce | Haverling | 2021 | M | |
| Sean Pierce | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | D | |
| Talyn Pierce | Newark | 2019 | G | |
| Cooper Pieroni | Wayne | 2017 | A/M | |
| Richie Pierpont | Victor | 2019 | M/FO | |
| Jake Pieters | Pal-Mac | 2008 | D | |
| Max Pieters | Thomas | 2024 | D | |
| Nathan Pieters | Irondequoit | 2022 | M | |
| Wil Pieters | Thomas | 2022 | D | Marywood |
| Will Pieterse | Pittsford | 2016 | D | Le Moyne |
| Brandon Pignato | Greece Storm | 2021 | A | TCCC |
| Danny Pignato | Irondequoit | 2013 | A | |
| Nicholas Pignato | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| Braydon Pike | Hilton | 2025 | M | Syracuse |
| Ryan Pimm | Midlakes | 2017 | M | |
| Mark Pincelli | Aquinas | 2006 | M/A | |
| Cameron Pincus | Pittsford | 2013 | D | Boston U |
| Adrian Pinkard | Waterloo | 2014 | M | MCC |
| Andre Pinkard | Waterloo | 2018 | A | |
| Andrew Pinkham | Pittsford | 2022 | M | |
| Derek Pino | Irondequoit | 2006 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Dylan Pinto | Aquinas | 2009 | M | |
| Joseph Pinto | Fairport | 2008 | M | MCC |
| Jackson Pioli | Greece Storm | 2026 | A/M | |
| Giancarlo Piperni | Spencerport | 2023 | M | |
| Josh Pitcher | Wayne | 2020 | LSM | |
| Joshua Pitcher | Wayne | 2020 | LSM | |
| Justin Pitcher | Mynderse | 2011 | M | |
| Chris Pitifer | Geneva | 2011 | M | |
| Trevor Pitt | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | M | |
| Mason Pittenger | Penn Yan | 2024 | M | |
| Jason Pittman | Spencerport | 2020 | D | |
| R.J. Pixley | Eastridge | 2006 | M | |
| Zack Pixley | Irondequoit | 2005 | M | |
| Greg Plaatje | Avon | 2020 | G/D | |
| Greg Plaatje | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | D | |
| Andrew Placious | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | LSM | |
| Stephen Placious | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | D | |
| Josh Plant | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | M | |
| Chris Plate | Mynderse | 2015 | M/D | |
| Eric Platten | Canandaigua | 2022 | D | Yale |
| Team Player | Brockport | 2016 | A | |
| Unknown Player | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | A | |
| Jeremy Plisk | Greece Arc_Oly | 2006 | D | |
| Chase Plumadore | Eastridge | 2015 | M/A | |
| Josh Plumlee | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | |
| Bill Pluta | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | A/M | |
| Charlie Pluta | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2017 | A | |
| Peter Pluta | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2013 | M | Lycoming |
| Emmy Poccia | Irondequoit | 2011 | M | Cornell |
| Alex Pochodylo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Liam Podszebka | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | D | SUNY Poly |
| Joey Pogoda | Victor | 2017 | A | Temple |
| Andy Poitras | Victor | 2011 | M | Albright |
| Tom Poitras | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Jack Polito | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | D | |
| Jake Polizzi | Thomas | 2025 | M | |
| Quinton Polk | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M/A | |
| Quinton Polk | Batavia | 2020 | M/A | |
| Josh Polle | Pal-Mac | 2005 | D | |
| Jacob Polowachak | Fairport | 2019 | D | |
| Jack Pomeroy | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Ryan Pomeroy | Haverling | 2005 | A | |
| Gage Ponsetti | Penn Yan | 2016 | G | Alfred |
| Alex Pool | Geneva | 2008 | A | |
| Carson Poole | Geneva | 2005 | M | |
| Kyle Pooler | Victor | 2015 | A | |
| Kyle Poormon | Waterloo | 2006 | D | |
| Elijah Pope | East United-Eastridge | 2026 | D | |
| Jack Pope | Livonia | 2014 | M | |
| Jayden Pope | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Cam Popham | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | LSM | |
| Mike Popielec | Victor | 2013 | D | |
| Nick Popielec | Victor | 2018 | DM | |
| Dixon Popp | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Gino Poretta | Mynderse | 2021 | G | |
| George Porter | Pittsford | 2014 | D | |
| Jordan Porter-Lemon | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | A | Keuka |
| Eric Posick | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | M | |
| Joe Post | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | St John Fisher |
| Matt Post | Brockport | 2021 | A | |
| Sam Post | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | |
| J.J. Postel | Pittsford | 2006 | M | |
| Jared Potter | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | M | |
| Matt Potter | Victor | 2019 | D | |
| Henry Potts | Pittsford | 2014 | M/A | |
| Jake Potts | Penn Yan | 2011 | M | |
| Zach Poudrier | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| RJ Pound | Pittsford | 2014 | DM | |
| Nate Powe | Schroeder | 2008 | M | |
| Alex Powell | Schroeder | 2010 | A | Pittsburgh |
| Brian Powell | Schroeder | 2008 | A | Buffalo |
| Evan Powell | Schroeder | 2016 | G | |
| Mike Powell | Gananda | 2020 | M | |
| Nick Powell | Schroeder | 2012 | A | |
| Adam Power | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | A/D | |
| Dave Power | Gananda | 2013 | LSM | |
| Kyle Power | Newark | 2014 | M | |
| Mark Power | Gananda | 2012 | M | |
| Devon Powers | Midlakes | 2012 | D | |
| Jeremy Powers | Spencerport | 2014 | M | MCC |
| Matt Powers | Pittsford | 2018 | LSM | |
| Max Powers | Brighton | 2010 | D | |
| Trevor Powers | Batavia | 2011 | D | |
| Will Powers | Fairport | 2014 | D | |
| Andrew Powlin | Penfield | 2017 | M | RIT |
| David Powlowski | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | A/M | |
| Tom Prato | Livonia | 2012 | D | |
| Holton Pratt | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | LSM | |
| Peter Pratt | Wayne | 2018 | A | |
| Ryan Pratt | Brockport | 2009 | A | Brockport |
| Luke Prattico | Penfield | 2005 | D | Mercyhurst |
| David Premyslovsky | Pal-Mac | 2024 | D | |
| Myles Prendergast | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | D | |
| Joe Presher | Midlakes | 2010 | D | |
| Zach Presher | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | |
| Joe Presicci | Penfield | 2020 | A | |
| Nick Presicci | Penfield | 2013 | G | |
| Andrew Prestigiacomo | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | M | |
| Gino Prestigiacomo | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | A/M | Cortland |
| Joe Prestigiacomo | Greece Ath_Ody | 2008 | D | |
| Aaron Preston | Haverling | 2012 | D | |
| Blake Preston | Schroeder | 2024 | M | Clarkson |
| Cody Preston | Schroeder | 2027 | M | |
| Drew Preston | Spencerport | 2015 | G | |
| Keith Preston | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Nicholas Presutti | Hilton | 2025 | M | |
| Tony Priano-Portillo | Geneva | 2022 | M | |
| Gavin Price | Haverling | 2025 | M/A | |
| Hayden Price | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Hunter Price | Waterloo | 2018 | D | |
| Jeff Price | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | A | St John Fisher |
| Matthew Prichard | Brockport | 2016 | D | |
| Tyler Prichard | Pittsford | 2008 | LSM | |
| Michael Priddy | Fairport | 2024 | A | |
| Ryan Priddy | Fairport | 2026 | A | |
| Sean Priddy | Fairport | 2025 | D | |
| Jonathan Pride | Eastridge | 2020 | M | |
| Anthony Prince | Pal-Mac | 2015 | G | |
| Donald Prince | Eastridge | 2020 | M | |
| Luke Prince | Pal-Mac | 2012 | D | |
| Mason Prince | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Ryan Prine | Thomas | 2021 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Aaron Printup | Batavia | 2010 | A | |
| Ethan Printy | Eastridge | 2012 | M | Cortland |
| Jahadi Prior | Fairport | 2016 | M | Brockport |
| Sam Prior | Aquinas | 2016 | D | |
| Casey Pritchard | Gates Chili | 2013 | LSM | |
| Brandon Proctor | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | D | |
| Louis Profetta | Wayne | 2023 | A/M | TCCC |
| Alex Proper | Pittsford | 2011 | D | St John Fisher |
| Kyle Prosperi | Fairport | 2018 | G | |
| Rob Protz | Fairport | 2025 | M | |
| Chris Provenzano | Schroeder | 2009 | D | |
| Landon Provenzano | Thomas | 2026 | D | |
| Erik Prudehome | Mynderse | 2005 | D | |
| Jesse Prue | Churchville-Chili | 2024 | DM | |
| John Pruyn | Haverling | 2007 | A | |
| Collin Pryzbylowicz | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Brandon Ptak | Gananda | 2016 | D | MCC |
| Sam Pucci | Fairport | 2024 | A/M | |
| Corban Puff | Newark | 2027 | G | |
| Dan Pufnock | Geneva | 2011 | D | Goucher |
| Aaron Pulinski | Penfield | 2010 | M | |
| Dan Pulinski | Penfield | 2012 | M | |
| James Pullano | Brighton | 2009 | A | |
| Jonah Pullen | Wayne | 2020 | D | |
| Adam Pulver | Newark | 2015 | A | |
| Alana Puma | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Griffin Pundt | Mynderse | 2021 | D | |
| Isaac Pundt | Mynderse | 2024 | D | |
| Tommy Puppatelli | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| James Purpura | Pittsford | 2010 | A | Geneseo |
| Anthony Pusateri | Schroeder | 2027 | A/M | |
| Billy Pusey | Irondequoit | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Mason Pusey | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | |
| Josh Putman | Newark | 2007 | G | |
| Justin Putt | Spencerport | 2008 | M | |
| Terry Pyfrom | Pal-Mac | 2013 | D | |
| AJ Quagrello | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Joshua Quatela | Aquinas | 2019 | A | |
| Jordan Quayle | Canandaigua | 2011 | D | FLCC |
| Jake Queener | Geneva | 2005 | M | |
| Kyle Quevedo | Pittsford | 2015 | D | |
| Sam Quick | Pal-Mac | 2020 | M | |
| Kyle Quigley | Pal-Mac | 2016 | D | |
| Brady Quill | Hilton | 2024 | D | SUNY Albany |
| Adam Quinn | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | A/M | |
| Caleb Quinn | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Conor Quinn | Pittsford | 2011 | G | |
| Jacob Quinn | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Jonathan Quinn | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | M | |
| Jonathan Quinn | Batavia | 2016 | D | |
| Michael Quinn | Thomas | 2008 | M | |
| Nolan Quinn | Rush-Henrietta | 2022 | A | |
| Spencer Quinn | Wayne | 2018 | A | |
| David Quinzi | Pittsford | 2008 | A | |
| Stephen Quinzi | Pittsford | 2014 | A | Georgetown |
| Alex Quku | Newark | 2006 | M | |
| Stuart Quku | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2026 | A/M | |
| Sam Rabinowitz | Brighton | 2011 | D | |
| Max Race | Penn Yan | 2017 | A | |
| Nate Raczkowski | Brockport | 2020 | D | |
| Jadyn Radam | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2026 | A/M | |
| Jake Radka | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | D | |
| T.J. Radka | Waterloo | 2005 | M | Keuka |
| Tanner Radogna | Victor | 2024 | M | SUNY Stony Brook |
| Kyle Radtke | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Todd Radtke | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Hammond Raes | Midlakes | 2017 | D | |
| Theodore Raes | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2022 | D | |
| Will Raes | Midlakes | 2016 | D | |
| Daniel Rago | Geneva | 2004 | M | |
| Willie Rago | Geneva | 2008 | M | |
| Karnan Rajkumar | Spencerport | 2014 | G | |
| Owen Raleigh | Wayne | 2026 | D/LSM | |
| Ben Ralph | Pittsford | 2019 | D | |
| McLean Ralston | Fairport | 2022 | G | Nazareth |
| Logan Ralyea | Hilton | 2021 | LSM | |
| Ryan Ramage | Fairport | 2011 | LSM | |
| Dan Ramich | Fairport | 2021 | D | |
| Zach Ramirez | Waterloo | 2010 | G | |
| Caleb Ramos | Spencerport | 2014 | M | |
| Jaiden Ramos | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| Justin Ramos | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | A | |
| Roberto Ramos | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | D | |
| Ben Ramsdell | Fairport | 2012 | D | Plattsburgh |
| Bob Ramsdell | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2009 | M | |
| Tom Ramsdell | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2011 | M | |
| Aaron Ramsey | Midlakes | 2017 | D | |
| Nate Ramsey | Midlakes | 2015 | A | Wells |
| Matthew Ranalletta | Greece Storm | 2023 | M | |
| Justin Rand | Pittsford | 2005 | A | Geneseo |
| Brett Randall | Brighton | 2017 | A | Richmond |
| Griffin Randall | Victor | 2018 | D | Nazareth |
| Kevin Randall | Penfield | 2008 | D | Notre Dame |
| Austin Randolph | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | D | |
| Ben Randolph | Livonia | 2016 | A | |
| Wayne Rapachietta | Aquinas | 2007 | D | |
| Mike Raplee | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Anthony Rapone | Avon | 2016 | M | |
| Jake Rapp | Gananda | 2020 | A | |
| Matt Rapp | Gananda | 2017 | D | |
| Nick Rapp | Gananda | 2015 | M | |
| Ryan Rathbun | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | M | |
| Cade Ratliff | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | D | |
| Cade Ratliff-Kailbourne | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | D | RIT |
| Josh Raty | Midlakes | 2008 | A | |
| Mike Rauen | Wayne | 2014 | D | |
| Thomas Rauen | Wayne | 2019 | A/M | |
| Jack Rawleigh | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | G | |
| Jon Ray | Geneva | 2016 | D | |
| Tyler Ray | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Brendan Raymond | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | D | |
| Curtis Raymond | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | M | |
| Tahair Rcketts | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Brent Read | Geneva | 2006 | D | |
| Ethan Reader | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | D | |
| David Reagan | Penfield | 2009 | DM | |
| David Reagan | Aquinas | 2021 | D | |
| John Reagan | Wayne | 2020 | A/M | |
| Brian Reakes | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M/D | |
| Carmen Reale | Geneva | 2008 | D | |
| Jordan Reals | Canandaigua | 2010 | A | |
| Connor Reardon | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Matt Reardon | Mynderse | 2020 | M | |
| Walker Rearick | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | D | |
| Tyrone Reaves | Brighton | 2011 | A/M | |
| Henry Reber | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | Potsdam |
| Ben Rebholz | Eastridge | 2015 | M | |
| Gage Record | Midlakes | 2013 | M | |
| Peter Record | Midlakes | 2013 | D | |
| Kyle Redden | Gananda | 2011 | M | |
| Jared Reding | Brighton | 2016 | D | |
| Steven Redlinski | Schroeder | 2024 | G | |
| Andy Reed | Brockport | 2014 | A | |
| Chris Reed | Fairport | 2010 | D | |
| Jake Reed | Aquinas | 2020 | A | |
| Josh Reed | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Kevin Reed | Geneva | 2012 | D | |
| Khaleef Reed | UPrep | 2016 | A | |
| Marquis Reed | East United | 2018 | M | |
| Michael Reed | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | Queens University |
| Tommy Reed | Schroeder | 2027 | D | |
| Tyler Reed | Haverling | 2009 | G/M | |
| Zach Reed | Haverling | 2011 | A | Hobart |
| Brandon Reeners | Thomas | 2006 | M | Utica |
| Dave Rees | Batavia | 2007 | M/A | |
| Colby Reese | Mynderse | 2020 | A | Brockport |
| Kyle Reese | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2023 | D | |
| Seb Reese | Mynderse | 2016 | A | |
| Trevor Reese | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2023 | G | |
| Will Reese | Mynderse | 2019 | A | |
| Jonathon Reeve | Pal-Mac | 2007 | G | |
| Ben Reeves | Pal-Mac | 2014 | A | Yale |
| Chase Reeves | Gananda | 2014 | D | |
| Jeremy Reeves | Pal-Mac | 2005 | M | |
| Mark Reeves | Pal-Mac | 2012 | D | |
| James Regan | Canandaigua | 2006 | M | Belmont Abbey |
| Sean Regan | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | Hobart |
| Sean Regan | Pittsford | 2021 | G | St Michael |
| Matt Reganbogen | Pittsford | 2005 | D | |
| Frank Regelski | Schroeder | 2012 | D | |
| Tyler Reger | Hilton | 2027 | M | |
| Joey Register | Irondequoit | 2019 | D | |
| Ryan Regruit | Penfield | 2008 | A | |
| Justin Rehm | Penfield | 2012 | LSM | Siena |
| Brian Reid | Newark | 2014 | D | |
| Jayden Reid | Penn Yan | 2023 | M | |
| Jordan Reid | Spencerport | 2027 | A | |
| Ray Reid | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Todd Reid | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Chris Reifsteck | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | M | |
| Kyle Reilly | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | D | |
| Patrick Reilly | Fairport | 2006 | A | |
| Jeff Reiman | Thomas | 2005 | M | |
| Cohyn Reisman | Gananda | 2023 | A | |
| John Reiss | East Rochester | 2011 | A | |
| Nick Reiss | East Rochester | 2010 | M | |
| Ian Remming | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| Dalton Renke | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| Garan Renner | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | D | |
| Gary Renney | Batavia | 2008 | M | |
| Alex Renz | Spencerport | 2016 | M | |
| Sam Rescorl | Mynderse | 2011 | A | |
| Zac Rescort | Mynderse | 2006 | G | |
| Trenton Resseguie | Hilton | 2025 | M | |
| Payton Ressegule | Hilton | 2011 | D | |
| Natti Rey | Midlakes | 2014 | D | |
| Remington Reyes | East United | 2018 | A | |
| Alek Reynolds | Wayne | 2023 | D | |
| Brendan Reynolds | Fairport | 2020 | D | |
| Nick Reynolds | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | A | |
| Quamere Reynolds | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | D | |
| Ryan Reynolds | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Tim Reynolds | Mynderse | 2015 | LSM | |
| Alex Rheude | Canandaigua | 2024 | M | |
| Ethan Rheude | Canandaigua | 2022 | A | |
| PJ Rheude | Canandaigua | 2021 | D | Clarkson |
| Will Rheude | Canandaigua | 2025 | D | Loyola |
| Adam Rhinehart | Geneva | 2022 | D | |
| Darnell Rhodes | East Rochester | 2012 | A | |
| Alex Ribalko | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | D | |
| Devon Ricard | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Antonio Riccardi | Greece Storm | 2022 | D | |
| Peter Riccardi | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | D | |
| Alexander Ricci | Brockport | 2016 | M | |
| Anthony Ricci | Aquinas | 2008 | M | |
| Eli Ricci | Victor | 2028 | M/FO | |
| JT Ricci | Victor | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Sam Ricci | Victor | 2023 | M/FO | Cornell |
| Steven Ricci | Pittsford | 2013 | M | RIT |
| Connor Rice | Penfield | 2008 | A | Marist |
| Eric Rice | Geneva | 2013 | M | |
| Michael Rice | Haverling | 2016 | M | |
| Mike Rice | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | M | |
| Tim Rice | Canandaigua | 2017 | G | |
| Trevor Rice | Penfield | 2005 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Derek Rice-Porter | Waterloo | 2018 | M | |
| Myles Rich | Brockport | 2019 | D | |
| Stephen Rich | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | M | |
| Cameron Richards | Gananda | 2028 | M | |
| Danny Richards | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | D | |
| Derek Richards | Hilton | 2013 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Jordan Richards | Gananda | 2023 | D | |
| Nick Richards | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Pamineo Richards | Bishop Kearney | 2012 | M | |
| Terrance Richards | Aquinas | 2015 | M | |
| Tyler Richards | Penfield | 2017 | LSM | |
| Jett Richardsen | Brighton | 2023 | A | |
| Jett Richardsen | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Cody Richardson | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | FLCC |
| Emmanuel Richardson | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | M | |
| Jens Richardson | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | A | |
| Matthew Richardson | Hilton | 2018 | M | |
| Michael Richardson | Hilton | 2016 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Scott Richardson | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | D | |
| Kayla Richenberg | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | A | |
| John Richiusa | Penfield | 2021 | M/FO | |
| Jake Rick | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | Castleton |
| Shane Rickard | Thomas | 2015 | M | St John Fisher |
| Chris Rickerson | Midlakes | 2011 | D | |
| Tahir Ricketts | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | LSM | |
| Jared Ricks | Brighton | 2010 | M | |
| Nash Ridley | Waterloo | 2020 | M/D | |
| Trent Ridley | Haverling | 2019 | M | |
| Josh Riedl | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | M/A | |
| Alec Riedman | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Andy Riegel | Waterloo | 2006 | G/M | |
| Cody Riegel | Waterloo | 2011 | A/M | |
| Austin Riesenberger | Schroeder | 2020 | D | |
| Braydan Riesenberger | Victor | 2022 | M | |
| Phoenix Rieth | Brighton | 2027 | A | |
| Alexander Rigerman | Batavia | 2017 | D | |
| JJ Riggins | UPrep | 2016 | M | |
| Jarrett Riker | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Brendan Riley | Fairport | 2022 | A/M | Alfred |
| Sam Rinaldo | Brighton | 2009 | D | |
| Bennito Rinaudo | Greece Storm | 2025 | D | |
| Steven Rinck | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Kevin Rinehart | Pal-Mac | 2016 | D | |
| Alex Ringo | Brighton | 2006 | D | |
| Zach Rink | Gananda | 2013 | A | |
| Bruce Rinker | Haverling | 2015 | A | |
| Blaze Riorden | Fairport | 2012 | G | SUNY Albany |
| Connor Riorden | Fairport | 2015 | A | Lycoming |
| Danny Riorden | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | A | |
| Dylan Rippe | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | D | |
| Nick Rippe | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Ken Rissew | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Charlie Rist | Aquinas | 2014 | D | |
| Mitch Ritchie | McQuaid Jesuit | 2008 | A | St John Fisher |
| Mitch Ritchie | Hilton | 2008 | A | |
| Hunter Rittenhouse | Wayne | 2016 | M | |
| A.J. Ritter | Geneva | 2018 | D | |
| Andrew Ritter | Geneva | 2013 | D | |
| Robert Ritter | Penfield | 2005 | D | |
| Trevor Rittersback | Batavia | 2015 | A | |
| Trevor Rittersback | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | A | |
| Louis Rivellino | Wayne | 2013 | A | |
| Christian Rivera | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Chystopher Rivera | Gates Chili | 2020 | G | |
| Danny Rivera | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | |
| Felix Rivera | Geneva | 2022 | M | |
| Reid Rivero | Penfield | 2026 | M/D | |
| Nicholas Riveros-Rodriguez | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | DM | |
| Kennon Rivkin-Russ | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Kennon Rivkin-Russ | Mynderse | 2012 | M | |
| Ben Rixen | Penfield | 2010 | DM | |
| Chase Rizzo | Fairport | 2022 | A | |
| Danny Rizzo | Schroeder | 2012 | M | |
| Levi Rizzo | Livonia | 2014 | M | |
| Alex Roach | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | M | |
| Liam Roach | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2024 | A | |
| Tommy Roach | Schroeder | 2010 | D | |
| Pat Roache | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2007 | G | |
| Ronald Robak | Greece Storm | 2025 | A/M | |
| Camden Robbins | Haverling | 2017 | M | |
| Charlie Robbins | Victor | 2021 | D | NJIT |
| Jaiden Robbins | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Jaiden Robbins | Batavia | 2018 | M/A | |
| Sam Robbins | Haverling | 2009 | M | |
| Marcus Roberton | East United | 2022 | M/D | |
| Marcus Roberton | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M/D | |
| Brenden Roberts | Batavia | 2012 | A | |
| David Roberts | Brockport | 2008 | A | |
| Ethan Roberts | Victor | 2020 | D | |
| Jon Roberts | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | A | |
| Spencer Roberts | Hilton | 2020 | M/FO | |
| Zach Roberts | Haverling | 2017 | M | |
| Zach Roberts | Eastridge | 2018 | D | |
| Michael Robertson | Aquinas | 2017 | M | |
| Brady Robinson | Victor | 2023 | G | Canisius |
| Brennan Robinson | Schroeder | 2025 | A | |
| Chuckie Robinson | Haverling | 2016 | LSM | |
| Eric Robinson | Spencerport | 2006 | M | |
| Iandre Robinson | Geneva | 2019 | M | |
| Jaden Robinson | Waterloo | 2022 | D | |
| Jake Robinson | Pittsford | 2018 | M | Buffalo |
| Jon Robinson | Spencerport | 2008 | A | |
| Alex Rockow | Brockport | 2017 | M | |
| Vinny Rockwell | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Dylan Rode | Livonia | 2020 | D | |
| Kyle Rodeman | Fairport | 2021 | M | |
| Andrew Rodenhouse | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | M | |
| Andrew Rodenhouse | Pittsford | 2013 | M | |
| Matthew Rodenhouse | Pittsford | 2017 | D | Baldwin Wallace |
| Thomas Rodenhouse | Pittsford | 2010 | M | Lynchburg |
| Walter Rodenhouse | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Chris Rodeo | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | D | |
| Payton Rodger | Waterloo | 2018 | M | |
| Kurtis Rodgers | Batavia | 2021 | M/A | |
| Aaron Rodney-Spencer | Newark | 2021 | D | |
| Abraham Rodriguez | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | D | |
| Anthony Rodriguez | Spencerport | 2024 | A | |
| Brandon Rodriguez | Greece Storm | 2025 | M | |
| Chris Rodriguez | East United | 2021 | A | |
| Chris Rodriguez | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | A | |
| D.J. Rodriguez | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | D | |
| Dave Rodriguez | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | A | |
| Jayden Rodriguez | Spencerport | 2025 | M | |
| Joel Rodriguez | UPrep | 2020 | D | |
| Jordan Rodriguez | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A/M | |
| Phil Rodriguez | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | A | |
| Trey Rodriguez | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2027 | M/A | |
| Kevin Roe | Penfield | 2007 | M | |
| Tarood Roedoe | Newark | 2007 | M | |
| Matt Roegner | Brockport | 2009 | M | |
| Joshua Roeland | Midlakes | 2013 | A | FLCC |
| Joel Roemer | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | |
| Connor Roeser | Fairport | 2024 | D | |
| Corey Roeser | Fairport | 2026 | M | |
| Tyler Roessel | Gananda | 2012 | D | |
| Evan Roesser | Greece Storm | 2025 | A | |
| Alex Rogemoser | Victor | 2008 | M | |
| Erick Rogemoser | Victor | 2006 | M | |
| Kyle Rogemoser | Victor | 2005 | A | |
| Tom Rogemoser | Victor | 2008 | A | |
| Austin Rogers | Canandaigua | 2008 | M | Hartford |
| Cody Rogers | Pal-Mac | 2012 | G | |
| Devin Rogers | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | A/M | |
| Jake Rogers | Gates Chili | 2022 | A | |
| Kurt Rogers | Irondequoit | 2009 | D | |
| Nick Rogers | Penfield | 2011 | DM | |
| Will Rogers | Penn Yan | 2019 | M | |
| Marlo Rogers-Collier | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | M | |
| Jonny Roggenbuck | Gates Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Jacob Rogowski | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | A | |
| Jackson Rohr | Greece Storm | 2025 | M | |
| Matt Roides | Hilton | 2010 | M | |
| Austin Roland | Fairport | 2010 | DM | |
| Chris Roland | Aquinas | 2006 | M/A | |
| Matthew Roland | Churchville-Chili | 2027 | A | |
| Justin Rolfe | Canandaigua | 2016 | D | |
| Patrick Roll | Geneva | 2010 | A | |
| Michael Rolla | Gates Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Sam Rollo | Geneva | 2010 | A | |
| Carlos Rolon | East United | 2018 | LSM | |
| Mac Romal | Irondequoit | 2011 | G | |
| Alexys Roman | East United | 2021 | M | |
| Alexys Roman | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | M | |
| Brandon Roman | Gates Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Andrew Romano | Spencerport | 2018 | A | |
| Anthony Romantini | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | M | |
| Stephen Romas | Pittsford | 2012 | M | |
| Ryan Romeo | Fairport | 2014 | M | |
| Adrian Romero | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | A/M | |
| Adrian Romero | Greece Storm | 2018 | A | Alfred |
| Peter Romig | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | M | |
| Thomas Romig | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| Owen Ronchetti | Brighton | 2019 | M | |
| Carmen Rondash | McQuaid Jesuit | 2006 | M | |
| Dylan Rondeau | Penfield | 2024 | G | Mount Union |
| Michael Roney | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | D | |
| Ian Rongo | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Dalton Rook | Haverling | 2022 | D | |
| Joe Rookey | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | D | |
| Zach Rooks | Pal-Mac | 2025 | M/D | |
| Jake Root | Gananda | 2017 | G | |
| Lincoln Root | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | M | |
| Trevor Rooze | Newark | 2019 | M | |
| David Roque Jr | Penfield | 2010 | M | |
| Chase Rorick | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2020 | D | Utica |
| Antonio Rosa | Gates Chili | 2024 | M/FO | |
| Stephen Rosa | Eastridge | 2020 | D | |
| Sergio Rosado | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | M | |
| Glenn Roschetzky | Penfield | 2015 | M | |
| Colton Rose | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | G | |
| Justin Rose | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | M | Pfeiffer |
| Tim Rose | Victor | 2005 | M | |
| Jacob Rosembloom | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Jacob Rosenbloom | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Dan Rosengard | Pittsford | 2009 | A | |
| Josh Rosenhack | Brighton | 2019 | G | |
| Nate Rosenzweig | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Cameron Ross | Livonia | 2008 | M | |
| Carlos Ross | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Ethan Ross | Aquinas | 2009 | D | |
| Matt Ross | Haverling | 2011 | M | |
| Owen Ross | Brighton | 2019 | A | |
| Colin Rossborough | Livonia | 2012 | A | |
| Troy Rossborough | Livonia | 2017 | M | |
| Chris Rossi | Penn Yan | 2017 | D | |
| Matt Rossi | Gananda | 2016 | M | |
| Nick Rossi | Haverling | 2011 | M | St John Fisher |
| A.J. Rossignol | Brighton | 2025 | D | |
| Zach Rossignol | Brighton | 2027 | D | |
| Ben Rossignolo | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | A | Alfred State |
| Mason Rosso | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Ben Rotenberg | Geneva | 2016 | G | |
| Jake Rotenberg | Geneva | 2014 | D | St John Fisher |
| Evan Roth | Canandaigua | 2008 | D | Harvard |
| Jaxen Roth | Victor | 2020 | M | |
| Jeff Roth | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | A | Keuka |
| John Roth | Mynderse | 2021 | A/D | |
| Jonathan Roth | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | Nazareth |
| Kyler Roth | Victor | 2018 | M | |
| Brendon Rothfuss | Thomas | 2007 | A | Brockport |
| Kyle Rothfuss | Thomas | 2011 | A | |
| Anthony Rotolo | Hilton | 2006 | D | |
| Cody Rougeux | Thomas | 2019 | A | |
| Mike Rouser | Irondequoit | 2011 | D | |
| Peter Roussell | Pittsford | 2026 | M | |
| Josh Rowland | Midlakes | 2006 | D | |
| Ed Rowley | Brockport | 2019 | G | |
| Aidan Royston | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | M | |
| Brody Royston | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | M | |
| Alex Rozaklis | Victor | 2013 | D | |
| Scott Rubino | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | M | MCC |
| Tyler Rubino | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | A | |
| Brett Ruby | Brighton | 2005 | D | |
| Andrew Rudd | Hilton | 2025 | A | |
| Kyle Ruddy | Mynderse | 2017 | M | |
| Shane Ruddy | Mynderse | 2008 | D | |
| Zack Rudgers | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | G | |
| Joel Rudnick | Brighton | 2010 | D | |
| Michael Rudy | Hilton | 2017 | M | |
| Phil Ruf | Gates Chili | 2013 | A | |
| Garrett Ruff | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | Cornell |
| Nick Ruff | Brighton | 2017 | A | |
| Brady Ruffalo | Schroeder | 2022 | A | |
| Cuyler Ruffell | Wayne | 2026 | LSM | |
| Sergio Ruffolo | Thomas | 2012 | D | |
| Mike Ruiz IV | Waterloo | 2009 | A | |
| Ethan Ruller | Thomas | 2021 | G | Cornell |
| Christian Rumfola | Livonia-Avon | 2023 | M | |
| Hunter Rumfola | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | M/A | |
| Carl Rumsey | Haverling | 2018 | M | |
| Cody Rumsey | Churchville-Chili | 2008 | A | |
| Paul Runge | Brighton | 2022 | G | |
| Shawn Runyon | Fairport | 2007 | M | Springfield |
| Andrew Rupp | Victor | 2010 | M | Potsdam |
| Mitch Rupp | Victor | 2012 | A | SUNY Albany |
| Justin Rusak | Haverling | 2012 | D | |
| Jordan Ruscher | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | DM | |
| Connor Ruscio | Fairport | 2020 | M | |
| Michael Rush | Spencerport | 2027 | D | |
| Mason Rusinko | Geneva | 2021 | M | |
| Adam Russell | Victor | 2016 | M | |
| Alec Russell | Victor | 2020 | A | Le Moyne |
| Andrew Russell | Victor | 2018 | M | |
| Bill Russell | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Connor Russell | Penfield | 2013 | M | SUNY Albany |
| Kyle Russell | Wayne | 2020 | A/M | |
| Mike Russell | Pal-Mac | 2011 | M | St John Fisher |
| Nick Russell | Penfield | 2009 | DM | MCC |
| Pat Russell | Pal-Mac | 2011 | D | St John Fisher |
| Ryan Russell | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | LSM | MCC |
| Tyler Russell | Livonia | 2008 | A | RIT |
| Brian Russo | Hilton | 2013 | M | |
| Joe Russo | Thomas | 2021 | A | |
| Nick Russo | Schroeder | 2011 | G | |
| Matthew Russotti | Thomas | 2020 | D | |
| John Rutan | Penfield | 2007 | D | |
| Aaron Ruth | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | D | |
| Anthony Ryan | Mynderse | 2022 | A | |
| Billy Ryan | Hilton | 2013 | D | |
| Bobby Ryan | Canandaigua | 2012 | D | |
| Cam Ryan | Victor | 2024 | D | Syracuse |
| Charlie Ryan | Pittsford | 2025 | A | |
| Colin Ryan | Mynderse | 2021 | M | |
| Elijah Ryan | Brockport | 2015 | G | Hilbert |
| Greg Ryan | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | M | |
| James Ryan | Brighton | 2005 | A | Yale |
| James Ryan | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | LSM | |
| Jonathon Ryan | Batavia | 2011 | LSM | |
| Justin Ryan | Brighton | 2011 | M | |
| Kevin Ryan | Thomas | 2007 | G | |
| Luke Ryan | Fairport | 2025 | G | USMA |
| Marty Ryan | Rush-Henrietta | 2009 | D | |
| Nick Ryan | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | |
| Sean Ryan | Brockport | 2007 | D | |
| Sean Ryan | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Thomas Ryan | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | D | |
| Tommy Ryan | Livonia | 2019 | D | |
| Mitch Ryczek | Victor | 2020 | M | |
| Mitch Rydzynski | Victor | 2018 | D | |
| Andrew Rye | Schroeder | 2016 | M | |
| Mike Ryerson | Brighton | 2005 | A | Geneseo |
| Thomas Rynn | Fairport | 2007 | M | Duke |
| Chris Saar | Victor | 2013 | G | |
| Alex Saavedra | Gates Chili | 2014 | D | |
| Carlos Saavedra | Gates Chili | 2007 | LSM | |
| Bryce Saba | Wayne | 2017 | D | Oswego |
| William Sabb | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | M/A | |
| William Sabb | Batavia | 2021 | M/A | |
| Quinn Sadler | Brighton | 2025 | M/D | |
| Jackson Sadowski | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | M | |
| Kyle Saeger | Victor | 2025 | A/M | Jacksonville |
| Daniel Saeva | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2021 | A/M | |
| Daniel Saeva | Batavia | 2022 | M | |
| Daniel Saeva | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2022 | M/A | |
| Dominic Saeva | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2023 | D | |
| Dave Safford | Greece Arc_Oly | 2018 | D | |
| Jacob Safford | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Josh Safford | Fairport | 2020 | D | |
| Josh Sahler | Mynderse | 2009 | D | |
| Sig Sahli | Schroeder | 2013 | M | |
| Kyle Sahmel | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| Josh Sahr | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Jake Sahrle | Geneva | 2013 | G | |
| Josh Sahrle | Geneva | 2016 | D | |
| Leo Saladino | Penfield | 2021 | DM | |
| Connor Salamida | Victor | 2020 | D | |
| Gary Salamone | Fairport | 2009 | A | |
| William Salamone | Hilton | 2022 | A | |
| Gianni Salandy | Gates Chili | 2026 | A/M | |
| Justin Sale | Irondequoit | 2016 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Nicolas Salerno | Newark | 2027 | D | |
| Jack Sallerson | Fairport | 2017 | A/M | |
| Marlon Salmon | Gates Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Triloni Salmon | Penfield | 2016 | M | |
| Tylor Salmon | Penfield | 2021 | M | |
| Alex Salone | Geneva | 2019 | M | |
| Dave Salone | Geneva | 2010 | D | |
| Jon Salotti | Midlakes | 2017 | M | |
| Michael Salotto | Marcus Whitman | 2011 | M | |
| Colten Salsburg | Victor | 2015 | D | |
| Taylor Salsburg | Victor | 2008 | D | |
| Robby Salsbury | Eastridge | 2017 | M | |
| Eric Saltrelli | Schroeder | 2011 | G | Keuka |
| Joe Saltrelli | Schroeder | 2014 | M | |
| Mark Saltrelli | Schroeder | 2009 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Kyle Saltzer | Midlakes | 2006 | M/A | |
| Sam Salupo | Gananda | 2018 | M | |
| Jake Sampson | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | Hobart |
| Adrian Sanchez | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | D | |
| Josh Sanchez | Batavia | 2010 | A | |
| Sage Sanchez | Geneva | 2017 | M | |
| Allyn Sanderson | Gananda | 2014 | M | |
| Mike Sanderson | Mynderse | 2008 | D | |
| Brad Sandroni | Mynderse | 2017 | M | Canton |
| Michael Sandruck | Bishop Kearney | 2024 | A | |
| Gio SanFillipo | Penfield | 2014 | A | |
| Jared Sangiorgi | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | LSM | |
| Brian Sanna | Fairport | 2006 | M | Geneseo |
| Jack Sanna | Fairport | 2013 | M | |
| Jeffrey Sanna | Fairport | 2006 | M | |
| Kevin Sanna | Pittsford | 2012 | D | Hartford |
| Patrick Sanna | Pittsford | 2019 | D | Clarkson |
| Mitch Sanson | Gananda | 2016 | M | |
| Gianni Sansone | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Tom Santelli | Newark | 2009 | D/M | |
| Andrew Santiago | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | M | |
| Andrew Santiago | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | M | |
| Jonathan Santiago | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Kenny Santiago | Geneva | 2018 | M | |
| Michael Santiago | Hilton | 2010 | D | |
| Nick Santiago | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | D | |
| Ryan Santiago | Gates Chili | 2022 | LSM | |
| Timothy Santiago | Hilton | 2016 | M | |
| Rocco Santillo | Spencerport | 2018 | M | Brockport |
| Jake Santini | Fairport | 2017 | G | |
| Christian Santos | Aquinas | 2022 | M | |
| John Santowski | Pittsford | 2022 | D | |
| Anthony Sapere | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | D | |
| Frank Sapere | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Alec Sapienza | Pal-Mac | 2020 | D | FLCC |
| Zac Sapor | Greece Arc_Oly | 2013 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Alex Saracene | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Joe Saraceni | Batavia | 2014 | M | |
| Nick Saraceno | Victor | 2018 | A | |
| Cam Saraco | Penfield | 2013 | DM | |
| Kyle Sarbou | Irondequoit | 2006 | D | |
| David Sardone | Fairport | 2006 | M | |
| Kristian Sarkis | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Chris Sauers | Spencerport | 2008 | D | |
| Corey Sauers | Spencerport | 2013 | M | |
| Brad Sauln | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | M | Boston U |
| Jackson Saulpaugh | Penfield | 2021 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Aiden Sauter | Livonia | 2019 | A/M | |
| Aiden Sauter | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | A/M | |
| Charlie Sauter | Canandaigua | 2007 | M | USMA |
| Brandon Sauve | Midlakes | 2012 | M | |
| Josh Sauve | Midlakes | 2006 | D | |
| Andy Savage | Victor | 2007 | A | |
| Shawn Savage | Eastridge | 2006 | M | |
| Zuma Savage-Katz | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Nick Savine | Eastridge | 2005 | A | St John Fisher |
| Dom Savitcheff | Canandaigua | 2011 | D | |
| Hunter Savitcheff | Penfield | 2016 | A/M | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Austin Sawyer | Fairport | 2017 | D | |
| Sean Sawyer | Eastridge | 2006 | M | |
| Trevor Sax | Waterloo | 2017 | D | |
| Owen Saxby | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2021 | G | |
| Mitchell Saxmen | Pittsford | 2015 | M | |
| Dylan Saxon | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | D | |
| Josh Saxton | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Brendan Saylor | Fairport | 2010 | A | Hobart |
| Anthony Sayvong | Avon | 2017 | A/M | |
| Richard Scacchetti | Hilton | 2015 | D | MCC |
| Joey Scalise | Fairport | 2014 | G | Cortland |
| Mike Scally | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | D | |
| Nick Scally | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | D | |
| Tito Scalvenzi | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| Dom Scalzo | Thomas | 2007 | A | |
| Nick Scalzo | Thomas | 2009 | A | Jacksonville |
| Ryan Scalzo | Schroeder | 2007 | M | OCC |
| Angelo Scannell | Mynderse | 2013 | M | |
| Nick Scarantino | Schroeder | 2012 | M | |
| Daniel Scarazzo | Fairport | 2006 | A | Oswego |
| Alex Scardino | Victor | 2012 | A | |
| Steve Scarlata | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Alden Schadt | Batavia-Attica | 2014 | M | |
| Arden Schadt | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Mitchell Schaefer | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | Penn State |
| Andrew Schaeffer | Victor | 2025 | DM | |
| Robert Schaeffer | Victor | 2023 | D | |
| Ryan Schaeffer | Wayne | 2021 | D | |
| Joseph Schaible | Gates Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Matt Scharr | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | St Leo |
| Tanner Scharr | Canandaigua | 2009 | A | Belmont Abbey |
| Jacob Schartau | Gates Chili | 2019 | LSM | |
| Kai Schedel | Brockport | 2020 | M | |
| Nathan Scheel | Fairport | 2018 | D | |
| Brian Scheetz | Canandaigua | 2009 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Zack Scheetz | Canandaigua | 2006 | A | |
| Kyle Scheib | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| Brendon Schell | Brighton | 2022 | M | |
| Corey Schell | Brighton | 2024 | A | |
| Adam Schembri | Penfield | 2024 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Mason Schembri | Penfield | 2026 | G | |
| Brian Scherer | Geneva | 2015 | M | |
| Matt Scherer | Pittsford | 2007 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Tommy Scherer | Pittsford | 2012 | D | |
| Eric Schertler | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | M | |
| Sammy Scherzi | Aquinas | 2019 | A | |
| Austin Schessi | Waterloo | 2015 | M | |
| Nick Schessl | Waterloo | 2010 | M | |
| Nico Schiano | Spencerport | 2028 | D | |
| Ron Schiefer | Hilton | 2009 | D | |
| Nick Schifano | Aquinas | 2020 | 0 | |
| Tyler Schiff | Eastridge | 2014 | A | |
| Matt Schiliro | Gates Chili | 2014 | G | |
| Dylan Schillacci | Penn Yan | 2016 | D | |
| Matt Schilling | Schroeder | 2026 | M | |
| Nate Schilling | Schroeder | 2024 | A | York |
| Brad Schillinger | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | A | Florida Inst |
| Jack Schimmel | Aquinas | 2024 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Logan Schimmel | Aquinas | 2026 | G | |
| Chris Schimpf | Wayne | 2014 | A | |
| Luke Schindler | Hilton | 2024 | A | |
| Ryan Schirano | Spencerport | 2014 | A | |
| Josh Schirtz | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | M/A | |
| Shane Schirtz | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | M | |
| Jack Schlifke | Penfield | 2019 | M | |
| Sam Schlifke | Penfield | 2021 | M/FO | |
| Jacob Schlink | Haverling | 2013 | LSM | |
| Matt Schlink | Haverling | 2011 | M | |
| Joe Schlooski | Hilton | 2006 | M | |
| Kevin Schlyer | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| David Schmandt | Aquinas | 2006 | A/M | |
| Ezra Schmeer | Spencerport | 2023 | A/G | |
| Riley Schmeer | Spencerport | 2019 | G/D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Luke Schmele | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | D | |
| Matt Schmelzlen | Victor | 2005 | G | |
| Phillip Schmid | Spencerport | 2007 | A | |
| Braeden Schmidt | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Chris Schmidt | Pittsford | 2016 | M | |
| DJ Schmidt | Thomas | 2016 | A | |
| Jake Schmidt | Irondequoit | 2012 | A | Tampa |
| Kyle Schmidt | Hilton | 2010 | A | |
| Trevor Schmidt | Eastridge | 2020 | A | |
| Trevor Schmidt | East United | 2020 | A | |
| Jonathan Schmitt | Thomas | 2024 | M/FO | |
| Daniel Schmitz | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | G | |
| Nick Schmitz | Pittsford | 2024 | D | |
| Tom Schmitz | Pittsford | 2008 | M | |
| Justin Schnauber | Spencerport | 2022 | A | |
| Mark Schnauber | Spencerport | 2018 | A | |
| Ian Schneeberger | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | D | |
| Joe Schneggenburger | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Braiden Schneider | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2027 | M | |
| Cooper Schneider | Fairport | 2016 | M | |
| Noah Schneider | Haverling | 2027 | A/M | |
| Richard Schneider | Midlakes | 2008 | A | |
| Robin Schneider | Hilton | 2009 | M | |
| Nate Schniedner | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | D | |
| Andrew Schoeneck | Penfield | 2013 | A | |
| Matthew Schoeneck | Penfield | 2017 | A | Indianapolis |
| Will Schoeneck | Aquinas | 2010 | A | |
| Will Schoeneck | Penfield | 2010 | A | |
| Jared Schoonerman | Midlakes | 2008 | G | |
| Zach Schoonmaker | Waterloo | 2011 | D | |
| Seth Schoonover | Livonia | 2015 | D | |
| Jeremy Schopinsky | Victor | 2018 | G | |
| Isaac Schorr | Canandaigua | 2016 | A | |
| Aric Schosek | Gates Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Eric Schott | Canandaigua | 2009 | M | |
| Brandon Schraeder | Schroeder | 2005 | M | |
| Dakota Schraffenberger | Gananda | 2015 | M | |
| Trevor Schraffenberger | Gananda | 2012 | M | |
| Mason Schram | Brockport | 2025 | M | |
| Gary Schreib | Penfield | 2009 | LSM | MCC |
| Tim Schrieber | Bishop Kearney | 2013 | D | |
| Sam Schubach | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Sean Schukraft | Gananda | 2019 | M | |
| Zak Schuler | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | A | |
| James Schultheis | Brockport | 2014 | D | |
| AJ Schultz | Batavia-Attica | 2017 | M | |
| AJ Schultz | Batavia | 2018 | M/A | |
| Brandon Schultz | Aquinas | 2017 | A | |
| Dallon Schultz | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Kevin Schultz | East Rochester | 2013 | M | |
| William Schultz | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | M | |
| William Schultz | Batavia | 2016 | A | |
| Alex Schum | Aquinas | 2010 | D | |
| Ben Schumacher | Gananda | 2014 | G | |
| Brad Schumacher | Pittsford | 2013 | A | |
| John Schumacher | Thomas | 2004 | A | Oswego |
| Nick Schumacher | Pittsford | 2012 | D | |
| Ryan Schumacher | Greece Storm | 2026 | D | |
| Nick Schuman | Thomas | 2014 | M | Oneonta |
| Matt Schumann | Spencerport | 2015 | M | |
| Trevor Schumann | Spencerport | 2018 | D | |
| Dan Schur | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Matt Schuster | Brighton | 2011 | A | |
| Aaron Schutt | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | DM | |
| Kaiden Schutt | Newark | 2024 | M/A | |
| Kevin Schutt | Gananda | 2015 | D | |
| Michael Schutt | Gananda | 2017 | D | |
| Matt Schutz | Geneva | 2007 | G | Alfred |
| Jacob Schwab | Aquinas | 2018 | M | |
| Joseph Schwab | Fairport | 2005 | D | |
| Landen Schwab | Brockport | 2022 | M | |
| Mike Schwab | Fairport | 2009 | M | |
| Peter Schwab | Penfield | 2017 | M | SUNY Albany |
| Cody Schwatz | Gates Chili | 2007 | D | |
| Tyler Schweikert | Spencerport | 2012 | G | |
| Will Schweitzer | Livonia-Avon | 2028 | A/M | |
| William Schweitzer | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | D | |
| Austin Schwenzer | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Andy Schwin | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | |
| Michael Sciarratta | Penfield | 2012 | DM | |
| Evan Scibelli | Canandaigua | 2025 | G | |
| Thomas Scibona | Waterloo | 2024 | M | |
| Brian Sciera | Livonia | 2007 | A | |
| Joey Sciortino | Aquinas | 2021 | A | |
| Frank Sciremammano | Brighton | 2005 | D | |
| Bradley Scism | Avon | 2013 | M | |
| Chauncey Scissum | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | M | |
| Sammy Bernard Scoppo | Spencerport | 2023 | D | Brockport |
| Branden Scott | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | |
| Curtis Scott | Eastridge | 2009 | A/M | |
| Isaac Scott | Newark | 2013 | A/M | |
| Justin Scott | East United | 2022 | D | |
| Justin Scott | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | D/LSM | |
| Mason Scott | Brockport | 2027 | D | |
| Max Scott | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | A/M | |
| Max Scott | Batavia | 2021 | A | Medaille |
| Nate Scott | Pittsford | 2005 | M | |
| Nick Scott | Schroeder | 2026 | M | |
| Shamar Scott | UPrep | 2018 | D | |
| Chris Scripione | Livonia | 2013 | G/D | |
| Andrew Scully | Irondequoit | 2025 | M/FO | Fairfield |
| Dalton Seager | Haverling | 2014 | D | |
| Rylan Seager | Victor | 2023 | G | Buffalo |
| Alex Seaman | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Brett Seaman | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | M | St John Fisher |
| Colby Sears | Pal-Mac | 2017 | A | |
| Justin Sears | Gates Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Ryan Sears | Gates Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Hunter Seaward | Geneva | 2014 | M | |
| Brody Secker | Victor | 2025 | M | |
| Brees Segala | Schroeder | 2018 | M | |
| Zach Sehm | Haverling | 2026 | D | |
| Alex Seiler | Victor | 2021 | M | Clarkson |
| Marty Seitz | Waterloo | 2007 | D | |
| Kevin Selig | Brockport | 2006 | M | |
| Tyler Selke | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| Kyson Sellars | Aquinas | 2027 | D | |
| Spencer Sells | Midlakes | 2011 | D | |
| Mateo Sementa | Schroeder | 2020 | M | |
| Noah Semler | Fairport | 2018 | LSM | |
| Brandon Semmel | Livonia | 2017 | D | |
| Kyle Semrau | Penfield | 2008 | G | St John Fisher |
| Turner Semrau | Penfield | 2005 | M | Marywood |
| Ben Sennett | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | M | |
| Connor Sennett | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | DM | |
| Cooper Sennett | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | DM | |
| Kris Sennett | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | M | FLCC |
| Braeden Sens | Penfield | 2022 | DM | |
| Nico Seppen | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Brian Sepulveda | Newark | 2014 | M | |
| Nelson Sepulveda | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Trevor Serafin | Penfield | 2025 | M | |
| Dan Serafine | Canandaigua | 2006 | G | St John Fisher |
| Timothy Sercu | Penfield | 2023 | A | |
| Zach Serencsa | Wayne | 2025 | D | |
| Logan Sergent | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Nick Serio | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | A | |
| Zackary Serio | Greece Arc_Oly | 2019 | A/M | |
| Mason Serrano | Thomas | 2012 | M | |
| Dave Serron | Canandaigua | 2012 | A | |
| Mike Serron | Canandaigua | 2005 | D | Ithaca |
| Scott Serron | Penfield | 2006 | A | |
| Griffin Serti | Pittsford | 2025 | M | |
| Samuel Servati | Gates Chili | 2020 | G | Canton |
| Logan Serve | Brighton | 2026 | G | |
| Trevor Serve | Brighton | 2025 | D | |
| Andrew Sformo | Spencerport | 2011 | D | |
| Cameron Sformo | Spencerport | 2006 | D | |
| John Sforza | Penfield | 2012 | D | |
| Colin Shafer | Irondequoit | 2017 | D | |
| Declan Shafer | Irondequoit | 2022 | D | |
| Jon Shafer | Waterloo | 2010 | M | |
| Josh Shafer | Pal-Mac | 2021 | D | |
| Payton Shafer | Irondequoit | 2020 | M | |
| Jacob Shaffer | Spencerport | 2016 | G | |
| Joe Shaffer | Waterloo | 2010 | A | |
| Nick Shaffer | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Raymond Shalvoy | East Rochester | 2013 | A | |
| Raymond Shalvoy | Irondequoit | 2013 | M | |
| Rob Shalvoy | Pittsford | 2007 | D | |
| Scott Shamp | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | D | |
| Tommy Shanahan | Victor | 2016 | A | |
| Caden Shangraw | Waterloo | 2025 | M | |
| Kyle Shangraw | Waterloo | 2026 | 0 | |
| Peter Shangraw | Waterloo | 2022 | M | |
| Jason Shanley | Gananda | 2011 | D | |
| Jon Shanley | Newark | 2006 | A | |
| Patrick Shanley | Gananda | 2018 | M | |
| Brian Shannon | Eastridge | 2018 | D | |
| Nick Shannon | Eastridge | 2015 | G | |
| Ethan Shappee | Schroeder | 2022 | M | |
| Ethan Shappee | Thomas | 2022 | M | |
| Nick Sharman | Geneva | 2005 | G | |
| Dylan Sharp | Brockport | 2016 | M | |
| Hunter Sharp | Spencerport | 2015 | M | |
| Tyler Shaut | Haverling | 2012 | LSM | |
| Owen Shavron | Aquinas | 2026 | D | |
| Bradley Shaw | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | G | |
| Evan Shaw | Thomas | 2023 | D | |
| Fran Shaw | Geneva | 2014 | A | |
| Justin Shaw | Waterloo | 2016 | A | |
| Mitch Shaw | Haverling | 2021 | D | |
| Josh Shay | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | D | |
| Cameron Shear | Fairport | 2025 | D | |
| Will Shear | Fairport | 2017 | LSM | |
| Ryan Shechet | Penfield | 2016 | LSM | |
| Cody Sheehan | Victor | 2011 | A | |
| Hunter Sheehan | Penn Yan | 2024 | D | Seton Hill |
| Kevin Sheehan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | D | |
| Marty Sheehan | Fairport | 2017 | D | |
| Brenten Sheffield | Spencerport | 2023 | D | |
| Mason Shehadi | Hilton | 2021 | D | |
| Chanceler Sheldon | Waterloo | 2018 | G | |
| Tyler Sheldon | Waterloo | 2011 | D | |
| Jake Shelton | Gates Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Jacob Shepard | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | A | |
| Jayden Shepherd | Newark | 2021 | G/M | |
| Conor Sheridan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Nate Sheridan | Canandaigua | 2023 | A | St Rose |
| Pat Sheridan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | G | Limestone |
| Patrick Sheridan | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | A | Brockport |
| Ryan Sheridan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | D | Hampden Sydney |
| Alex Sherman | Irondequoit | 2025 | D | |
| Brad Sherman | Pittsford | 2013 | A/M | |
| Henry Sherman | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | D/LSM | |
| Markus Sherman | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | G | |
| Matt Sherman | Irondequoit | 2018 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Zach Sherman | Pittsford | 2014 | D | |
| Zachary Sherman-Burke | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| David Shields | Irondequoit | 2009 | A | |
| Josh Shields | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | A | |
| Keenan Shields | Pittsford | 2014 | M | |
| Michael Shiferaw | Spencerport | 2022 | M | |
| Greg Shinaman | Brighton | 2013 | A | |
| Noah Shinaman | Brighton | 2018 | M | |
| Cameron Shipley | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Josh Shipper | Brighton | 2025 | D | |
| Alex Shoemaker | Irondequoit | 2013 | G | |
| Brock Shoemaker | Irondequoit | 2019 | A | |
| Matt Shoemaker | Irondequoit | 2017 | D | |
| Mark Shoen | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | A | |
| Seth Shoenhardt | East Rochester | 2009 | M | |
| Scott Shoff | Penn Yan | 2021 | M | |
| Magnus Shore | Mynderse | 2026 | D | |
| Zach Shores | Penfield | 2024 | A | |
| Mohamed Shuaeb | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | M | |
| Mark Shubber | Thomas | 2005 | D | |
| Carl Shubert | Greece Arc_Oly | 2016 | LSM | Alfred State |
| Trenton Shuler | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | D | |
| Evan Shulla | Newark | 2027 | A/M | |
| Ben Shultes | Midlakes | 2013 | D | |
| Ken Shultes | Midlakes | 2017 | D | |
| Anthony Shura | Thomas | 2022 | M/D | Lander |
| Dag Sibhat | Eastridge | 2011 | D | |
| Louie Siciliano | Victor | 2012 | A | MCC |
| Chris Siderakis | Thomas | 2011 | D | Buffalo |
| Evan Siebert | Eastridge | 2015 | D | |
| Anthony Siedlecki | Batavia | 2010 | G | |
| Nettie Sieh | East United | 2018 | D | |
| Dom Siesto | Bishop Kearney | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Dom Siesto | Aquinas | 2025 | M | |
| Peter Signanawhich | Midlakes | 2016 | D | |
| Joseph Signorino | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | A/M | |
| Aaron Sile | Hilton | 2014 | LSM | |
| Spencer Sillato | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | M | |
| Dan Silva | Batavia | 2007 | A | |
| Jake Silver | Brighton | 2009 | D | |
| Colin Simmons | Hilton | 2016 | M | |
| Joey Simmons | Bishop Kearney | 2027 | M | |
| Korbyn Simmons | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | A/M | |
| Mark Simmons | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | M | |
| Michael Simone | Hilton | 2014 | LSM | |
| Andrew Simonelli | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | G | |
| Colby Simonetti | Pittsford | 2022 | A | Hartwick |
| Dylan Simons | Haverling | 2021 | D | |
| Zach Simons | Schroeder | 2020 | D | |
| Dane Simonson | Irondequoit | 2021 | D | |
| Quinn Simonson | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Brent Simpson | Livonia | 2006 | A | |
| Jack Simpson | Livonia | 2014 | M | |
| Joe Simpson | Livonia | 2011 | G | |
| Tom Simpson | Aquinas | 2006 | D | |
| Daniel Sinack | Midlakes | 2007 | M | |
| Randy Sinack | Midlakes | 2009 | A | |
| Dominick Sindoni | Waterloo | 2012 | A/M | |
| Jake Singleton | Geneva | 2019 | A | |
| Jesse Singleton | Geneva | 2013 | A | |
| James Sinicropi | Mynderse | 2007 | D | |
| John Siniscalco | Penfield | 2012 | D | |
| Dominick Sinopoli | Greece Storm | 2024 | M | |
| Jamie Sinopoli | Pal-Mac | 2005 | A | |
| Sharmeer Sinopoli | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | D | |
| Pepsi Siouthoum | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| Adam Sisson | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Liam Sisson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | G | |
| Alex Sitton | Penfield | 2009 | D | |
| Colin Sixt | Hilton | 2009 | M/A | |
| Robert Skardinski | Wayne | 2021 | A | |
| Nate Skellie | Midlakes | 2019 | D | |
| Justin Skelly | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | M/A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Anthony Skiner | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Cody Skinner | Newark | 2009 | A | |
| Garret Skinner | Penn Yan | 2005 | D | |
| Travis Skinner | Newark | 2006 | D | |
| Nate Skorusa | Penn Yan | 2012 | A | |
| Nick Skorusa | Penn Yan | 2013 | D | MCC |
| John Skovira | Thomas | 2009 | M | |
| Tim Skrip | Irondequoit | 2006 | D | |
| John Skye-Moore | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | A | |
| Sam Slaninka | Brighton | 2024 | M | |
| Billy Slapar | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | M/A | |
| Frank Slapar | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | A/M | |
| Colton Slattery | Brockport | 2021 | D | |
| Nick Slattery | Irondequoit | 2018 | M | St Bonaventure |
| Jackson Slavny | Victor | 2023 | D | |
| Josh Slesack | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Josh Slesak | Gates Chili | 2017 | M | |
| Kelly Sloan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | G | |
| Zarrien Sloan | Waterloo | 2012 | A/M | |
| Riley Slovis | Bishop Kearney | 2026 | M | |
| Chris Slowig | Greece Arc_Oly | 2014 | M | |
| Ray Sluberski | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | D | |
| Brayton Slusser | Geneva | 2019 | D | |
| Brendan Smallcomb | Thomas | 2021 | M | |
| TJ Smalt | Haverling | 2008 | D | |
| Adam Smisloff | Penfield | 2008 | M | |
| Erik Smisloff | Penfield | 2016 | G | |
| Jake Smisloff | Penfield | 2010 | G | |
| Aaron Smith | Waterloo | 2013 | G/M | |
| Adam Smith | Pal-Mac | 2007 | M | |
| Adam Smith | Newark | 2009 | A | |
| Adam Smith | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | M | |
| Alex Smith | Penfield | 2008 | M | |
| Alex Smith | Spencerport | 2010 | M | |
| Allan Smith | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | M | Lees McRae |
| Andrew Smith | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| Andrew Smith | Livonia | 2018 | M | |
| Andrew Smith | Livonia-Avon | 2018 | D | |
| Andrew A Smith | Livonia | 2010 | M | Keuka |
| Austin Smith | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | D | |
| Avery Smith | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Blake Smith | Midlakes | 2017 | G | |
| Brad Smith | Thomas | 2017 | A | |
| Brandon Smith | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | A | |
| Brandon Smith | Gananda | 2013 | G | |
| Brandon Smith | Penn Yan | 2017 | M | Keuka |
| Brennan Smith | Pittsford | 2022 | A | |
| Charles Smith | Brighton | 2009 | D | |
| Chris Smith | Penfield | 2021 | M | |
| Christopher Smith | Thomas | 2022 | A | |
| Colton Smith | Penn Yan | 2020 | A/M | Cortland |
| Conor Smith | Pittsford | 2010 | A | |
| Conor Smith | Thomas | 2011 | LSM | |
| Craig Smith | Mynderse | 2006 | M | Cazenovia |
| Dan Smith | Fairport | 2015 | D | |
| David Smith | Hilton | 2011 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| DJ Smith | Haverling | 2022 | M | |
| Drew Smith | Gananda | 2023 | A | Alfred |
| Drew Smith | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | D | |
| Dylan Smith | Victor | 2016 | M | |
| Ethan Smith | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| Evan Smith | Gananda | 2018 | M | |
| Fenton Smith | Thomas | 2006 | D | |
| Gus Smith | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | D | |
| Hank Smith | Wayne | 2026 | M | |
| Hunter Smith | Hilton | 2015 | D | |
| Hunter Smith | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | D | Richmond |
| Jake Smith | Canandaigua | 2010 | D | |
| Jake Smith | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2014 | M | |
| Jake Smith | Aquinas | 2016 | A | |
| Jase Smith | Gananda | 2025 | A | |
| Jaymz Smith | Midlakes | 2015 | D | |
| Jeff Smith | Livonia | 2013 | D | |
| Joel Smith | Livonia | 2020 | M | |
| Joel Smith | Livonia-Avon | 2020 | M | |
| Jon Smith | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | D/LSM | |
| JW Smith | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | D | |
| Kaiden Smith | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | A | |
| Kendall Smith | Schroeder | 2006 | M | |
| Kyle Smith | Livonia | 2016 | D | |
| Kyle Smith | Gates Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Kyle Smith | Brockport | 2020 | D | |
| Landon Smith | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Liam Smith | Aquinas | 2014 | D | Lake Erie |
| Liam Smith | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Maddox Smith | Canandaigua | 2025 | M | |
| Maddox Smith | Canandaigua | 2025 | M | |
| Matt Smith | Aquinas | 2007 | A | Lycoming |
| Matt Smith | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | |
| Matt Smith | Haverling | 2018 | D | |
| Michael Smith | Gates Chili | 2019 | G | |
| Mike Smith | Penfield | 2005 | A | |
| Mitch Smith | Hilton | 2012 | A | |
| Nasir Smith | Brighton | 2024 | D | |
| Nate Smith | Schroeder | 2008 | D | |
| Nicholas Smith | Gananda | 2014 | D | |
| Nick Smith | Canandaigua | 2011 | D | Brockport |
| Nick Smith | Fairport | 2017 | M | |
| Ollie Smith | Newark | 2008 | M | |
| Owen Smith | Pittsford | 2015 | A | Ithaca |
| Owen Smith | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | LSM | Aurora |
| Robert Smith | Waterloo | 2019 | A | |
| Ryan Smith | Livonia | 2010 | M | |
| Sage Smith | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Sean Smith | Penfield | 2022 | M | RPI |
| Sean Smith | Irondequoit | 2022 | M | |
| Stanford Smith | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Stephen Smith | Canandaigua | 2004 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Tanner Smith | Marcus Whitman | 2014 | G | |
| Taylor Smith | Marcus Whitman | 2020 | M | |
| Todd Smith | Spencerport | 2020 | A/M | |
| Trent Smith | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | A | |
| Tristan Smith | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M | |
| Vincent Smith | Newark | 2012 | D | |
| Wil Smith | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | G/M | |
| Wyatt Smith | Midlakes | 2019 | M | |
| Zach Smith | Thomas | 2011 | D | |
| Zach Smith | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | D | |
| Zach Smith | Aquinas | 2019 | A | |
| Zack Smith | Gates Chili | 2009 | D | |
| Tim Smith (#21 away) | Newark | 2006 | M | |
| Ben Smith-Wilcox | Canandaigua | 2016 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Greg Smith-Wilcox | Canandaigua | 2011 | D | Alfred |
| Corey Smock | Irondequoit | 2007 | D | |
| Alex Snell | Batavia-Attica | 2017 | M | |
| Alex Snell | Batavia | 2017 | A | |
| Joe Snook | Aquinas | 2013 | A | |
| Patrick Sobus | Waterloo | 2015 | M/D | |
| Vince Soeffing | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | D | |
| Jordan Soler | Waterloo | 2017 | D | |
| Michael Soler | Waterloo | 2023 | D | |
| Carson Soles | Marcus Whitman | 2022 | D | |
| Dan Solimano | Thomas | 2010 | G | |
| Bobby Sollenne | Geneva | 2013 | D | Potsdam |
| Tyler Sollenne | Geneva | 2009 | D | |
| Nathan Soloman | Waterloo | 2020 | M | |
| Brenn Solomon | Waterloo | 2014 | M | |
| Bryce Solomon | Waterloo | 2016 | D | |
| Connor Solomon | Victor | 2016 | G | |
| Jamie Solomon | Penfield | 2010 | G | |
| Rob Solomon | Penfield | 2008 | D | |
| Joe Solomone | Brockport | 2016 | A/M | |
| Jay Sommerville | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | DM | |
| Colby Soper | Gananda | 2020 | M | |
| Chris Soprano | Aquinas | 2010 | M | Morrisville |
| Matt Sorce | Hilton | 2011 | M | |
| AJ Soto | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | A | Alfred State |
| Tanner Soudan | Fairport | 2020 | D | |
| Nick Soures | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Jonathan Spaan | Penfield | 2013 | A | Hobart |
| Max Spaan | Penfield | 2015 | A | RIT |
| Jake Spadoni | Schroeder | 2009 | M | Alfred |
| Brandon Spahn | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | G | |
| Anthony Spallone | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Ethan Spampinato | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | A | |
| Paul Spatola | Irondequoit | 2006 | M | |
| Drew Spears | Haverling | 2026 | M | |
| Gibson Spector | Penfield | 2022 | M | Nazareth |
| Keith Speed | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Brad Speer | Hilton | 2008 | G | |
| Tyler Speers | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | G | |
| Eli Speidel | Gates Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Ian Speidel | Gates Chili | 2020 | D | |
| Aaron Spencer | Newark | 2021 | D | |
| Ben Spencer | Penn Yan | 2011 | D | |
| Cade Spencer | Thomas | 2021 | M | |
| James Spencer | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2011 | M | |
| Jason Spencer | Hilton | 2018 | M | |
| Jon Spencer | Victor | 2015 | M | St John Fisher |
| Jon Spencer | Pal-Mac | 2019 | A | |
| Steve Spencer | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Alex Speranza | Eastridge | 2018 | M | |
| Taylor Spike | Canandaigua | 2012 | A | |
| DJ Spinks | Batavia | 2017 | M | |
| Terelle Spinks | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | GCC |
| Ethan Spinner | Mynderse | 2020 | M | |
| David Spires | Haverling | 2007 | M | |
| Brandon Spooner | Midlakes | 2019 | A/M | |
| McKenzie Spooner | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | G | |
| Matt Spoor | Penn Yan | 2012 | G/M | FLCC |
| Nate Spoor | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | Alfred State |
| Pat Sposato | Gates Chili | 2008 | M | MCC |
| Alexander Spoto | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| John Spoto | Pittsford | 2019 | A | Utica |
| James Sprague | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2027 | M | |
| Logan Spriggs | Greece Storm | 2022 | D | |
| Matt Springer | Penfield | 2011 | A | |
| Jeff Springmeier | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Nicholas Spronz | Hilton | 2017 | D | |
| Brandon Sproul | Pal-Mac | 2015 | M | |
| Jake Sproule | Penfield | 2014 | M | |
| Corey Spuck | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | G | Canton |
| Brett Spusta | Pal-Mac | 2012 | D | |
| Daniel Spychala | Gates Chili | 2018 | LSM | |
| Zach Squires | Waterloo | 2018 | D | |
| Noah St Croix | Irondequoit | 2015 | A/M | Ohio Northern |
| Camryn St Louis | East United | 2022 | M | |
| Camryn St Louis | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | M | |
| Rilee St. Croix | Irondequoit | 2022 | D | Canton |
| Scott St. George | Thomas | 2014 | DM | |
| Katie Stack | Batavia | 2007 | M | |
| Joe Stacy | Thomas | 2012 | M | St Lawrence |
| Ian Stahl | Schroeder | 2015 | G | |
| Ryan Stahlecker | Pittsford | 2012 | D | |
| Oliver Stamey | Penfield | 2017 | D | |
| Jack Stampone | Schroeder | 2022 | A/M | |
| Aksel Stanat | Brighton | 2024 | A | Geneseo |
| Lukas Stanat | Brighton | 2020 | A | Princeton |
| Olin Stanat | Brighton | 2021 | A | Le Moyne |
| Mitch Standera | Penfield | 2014 | A/M | Marist |
| Ian Standinger | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Jack Stanney | Canandaigua | 2025 | M | |
| Kyle Stanney | Canandaigua | 2010 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Chris Stanton | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | A | |
| Zachary Stanton | Pal-Mac | 2020 | D | |
| Dylan Stape | Penn Yan | 2018 | M | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Ryan Staples | Hilton | 2011 | M | |
| Kevin Stapleton | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Zack Starke | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | A | |
| Jason Starkweather | Greece Arc_Oly | 2010 | M | |
| Anthony Starnino | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Anthony Starnino | Aquinas | 2010 | LSM | Limestone |
| Alec Starr | Pittsford | 2016 | G | Tampa |
| Joe Staszczyck | Eastridge | 2005 | D | |
| Greg Statt | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Michael Statt | Thomas | 2013 | A/M | |
| Maximillian Stauber | Livonia | 2015 | G | |
| Robert Steen | Mynderse | 2007 | M | |
| Anthony Stefan | Irondequoit | 2018 | M | |
| Kessel Stefano | Irondequoit | 2018 | M | |
| Yavin Stefano | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | |
| Vlad Stefanovski | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | D | |
| Alexander Steffenhagen | Gates Chili | 2015 | M | |
| David Stehler | Irondequoit | 2007 | D | |
| Bryan Stehm | Spencerport | 2011 | A | |
| Zach Steidle | Fairport | 2021 | DM | |
| Damien Stein | Brockport | 2020 | G | |
| Kevin Stein | Pal-Mac | 2012 | M | |
| Trevor Stein | Brockport | 2017 | D | Wells |
| Garrett Steiner | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | D | |
| Gavin Steiner | Gates Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Ben Steingass | Pittsford | 2023 | M | Amherst |
| Alex Steinhoff | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2025 | M | |
| John Henry Steinhoff | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | D | |
| Josh Steinmetz | Greece Arc_Oly | 2020 | D | |
| Joshua Steinmetz | Greece Storm | 2020 | D | |
| Tim Stelianou | Thomas | 2013 | A | |
| Tyler Stell | Marcus Whitman | 2009 | M | |
| Tashko Stembenis | Churchville-Chili | 2015 | M | |
| Nicholas Stenberg | Waterloo | 2016 | D | |
| Phil Stendardo | East Rochester | 2009 | D | |
| Alex Steo | Irondequoit | 2012 | D | |
| Adam Stephens | Pal-Mac | 2010 | M | |
| Carl Stephens | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | M | |
| Carl Stephens | Batavia | 2016 | M | |
| Jacob Stephens | Spencerport | 2015 | M | |
| McLane Stermole | Haverling | 2026 | G | |
| Kris Sterzin | Fairport | 2009 | G | |
| Kyle Sterzin | Fairport | 2012 | A | RIT |
| Blake Steve | Newark | 2026 | A | |
| Preston Steve | Newark | 2023 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Aaron Stevens | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | A | |
| Andrew Stevens | Waterloo | 2010 | A | |
| Dave Stevens | Spencerport | 2007 | M | |
| Jake Stevens | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Nate Stevens | Midlakes | 2006 | M | |
| Nick Stevens | Eastridge | 2017 | G | |
| Parker Stevens | Irondequoit | 2018 | M | |
| Peter Stevens | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | D | |
| Sam Stevens | Midlakes | 2015 | A | |
| Zack Stevens | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Cody Stevenson | Penfield | 2018 | D | |
| Dan Stevenson | Brighton | 2013 | M | |
| Glen Stevenson | Midlakes | 2007 | A | |
| Richard Stevenson | Gates Chili | 2022 | D | |
| Ty Stevenson | Gates Chili | 2021 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Lucas Stevers | Mynderse | 2024 | A | |
| Peyton Stevers | Mynderse | 2019 | D | |
| David Steves | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Pat Steves | Brockport | 2010 | D | |
| Al Stewart | Haverling | 2017 | D | |
| Benjamin Stewart | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | D | |
| Evan (EJ) Stewart | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | M | |
| Kevin Stewart | Eastridge | 2010 | M | |
| Tate Stewart | Penn Yan | 2016 | A/M | |
| Shane Stickle | Fairport | 2012 | M | |
| Ashton Stidd | Eastridge | 2018 | G | |
| Josh Stiefel | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Tyler Stiefel | Brockport | 2017 | A | OCC |
| Hunter Stigler | Canandaigua | 2016 | G | |
| Anson Stiles | Newark | 2009 | D | |
| Ken Stiles | Hilton | 2010 | G | |
| Tyler Stiles | Hilton | 2006 | A | FLCC |
| Isiah Stine | Marcus Whitman | 2016 | A | |
| Anthony Stirpe | Schroeder | 2008 | M | |
| Drew Stirpe | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Eric Stivers | Newark | 2008 | M | |
| Christopher Stobie | Midlakes | 2007 | D | |
| JD Stockmann | Schroeder | 2027 | A/M | |
| Adam Stockmeister | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | M | |
| John Stockslader | Livonia | 2015 | G | |
| Ethan Stoddard | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | G | |
| Rob Stojanov | Spencerport | 2006 | A | |
| Evan Stojanovski | Penfield | 2022 | A | |
| Andrew Stokes | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | D | |
| Andrew Stokes | Batavia | 2016 | D | |
| Griffen Stokes | Batavia-Attica | 2016 | LSM | |
| Griffen Stokes | Batavia | 2016 | LSM | |
| Jacob Stokes | Batavia | 2018 | M/A | |
| Jonathan Stoklosa | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | D | |
| Drew Stoler | Penfield | 2018 | D | Ithaca |
| James Stoler | Penfield | 2016 | M | Bryant |
| Zack Stoler | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Jack Stone | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| James Stone | Brockport | 2016 | M | |
| Ryan Stone | Wayne | 2022 | A | |
| William Stone | Victor | 2020 | M | |
| Alex Stonegraber | Avon | 2013 | M | |
| Garrett Stonewell | Thomas | 2014 | D | Keuka |
| Nick Stonewell | Thomas | 2009 | D | |
| Shayne Stonier | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| John Storer | Midlakes | 2011 | D | Alfred |
| Alonso Storey | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2020 | A/M | |
| Alonso Storey | Batavia | 2021 | A/M | |
| Adam Stork | Penn Yan | 2011 | M | Salisbury |
| Joe Storms | Brockport | 2009 | A | |
| Logan Storms | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | M | |
| Dante Stoskopf | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | D | |
| Jackson Stout | Gates Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Dominic Stramonine | Wayne | 2018 | M | |
| Austin Strang | Victor | 2012 | D | |
| Nick Strassburg | Midlakes | 2018 | D | |
| Dan Strassner | East Rochester | 2012 | M | |
| Justin Strassner | Rush-Henrietta | 2010 | M | |
| Dylan Stratton | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2016 | A | |
| Willis Stratton | Wayne | 2025 | D | |
| Nathan Strauf | Pittsford | 2020 | M | Ohio Northern |
| Ryan Streb | Hilton | 2014 | M | |
| Jacob Strebel | Greece Storm | 2025 | A | |
| Dave Street | Gates Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Darrien Streeter | Newark | 2026 | D | |
| Matthew Streit | Schroeder | 2015 | D | RIT |
| Edward Strezlec | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | G/D | |
| Tas Strickland | Wayne | 2025 | A/M | |
| Mike Strohm | Waterloo | 2004 | A | Oswego |
| Garrett Strong | Haverling | 2014 | M | |
| Josh Strong | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | A | |
| Luke Strong | Greece Storm | 2021 | M | |
| Isaac Stroup | Brockport | 2022 | M | |
| Kyle Strowe | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Wyatt Struble | Livonia | 2012 | A | |
| Saige Stuber | Spencerport | 2018 | D | |
| Aric Stuck | Mynderse | 2016 | D | |
| Ted Stuck | Mynderse | 2016 | M | |
| Alex Stucki | Brighton | 2006 | M | |
| Conor Stucki | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Eugene Stuckless | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | D | |
| Randy Stuckless | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | D | |
| Pete Stupplebeen | Thomas | 2025 | D | |
| Todd Sturcken | Fairport | 2007 | M | |
| Jake Sturgis | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | D | |
| Dan Sturnick | McQuaid Jesuit | 2007 | M | |
| James Sturnick | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Kyle Sturnick | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | A | |
| Bobby Stuver | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | M | |
| Klay Stuver | Fairport | 2020 | M | Cortland |
| Kole Stuver | Fairport | 2021 | A | Cortland |
| Matt Stuver | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | D | |
| Jonathan Sucese | Fairport | 2009 | A | |
| Mark Suchewski | Geneva | 2018 | D | |
| Tom Sudek | Gates Chili | 2008 | A | |
| Anthony Suero | Eastridge | 2015 | M | |
| Mike Suess | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Mohamed Sulieman | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Ricky Sulkowski | Newark | 2018 | A | |
| Tom Sulli | Eastridge | 2008 | D | |
| Aiden Sullivan | Wayne | 2023 | LSM | TCCC |
| Chance Sullivan | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | M | |
| Cory Sullivan | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | D | |
| Kurt Sullivan | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Kyle Sullivan | Victor | 2005 | M | |
| Kyle Sullivan | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Lucas Sullivan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | |
| Michael Sullivan | Newark | 2014 | M | |
| Pat Sullivan | Victor | 2006 | D | |
| Patrick Sullivan | Pittsford | 2017 | M | Lenoir-Rhyne |
| Quinn Sullivan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | G | |
| Ryan Sullivan | Pittsford | 2010 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Steve Sullivan | Schroeder | 2007 | M | |
| Dylan Sulzbach | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | G | |
| Dylan Sulzbach | Pittsford | 2015 | G | Penn State |
| Holden Sulzbach | Victor | 2026 | G | |
| Kirk Summers | Pittsford | 2007 | D | |
| Leo Sunday | Gates Chili | 2022 | M | |
| Oliver Sunday | Gates Chili | 2025 | M | |
| Patrick Suozzi | Batavia | 2024 | A/M | |
| Patrick Suozzi | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | M | |
| Zach Surace | Penfield | 2011 | LSM | |
| Dom Sutberry | Pal-Mac | 2016 | G | |
| Jeremy Sutfin | Haverling | 2005 | M | |
| Nick Sutphen | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Tucker Sutphen | Brockport | 2018 | M | Alfred State |
| Tyler Sutphen | Brockport | 2008 | M | |
| Brian Sutton | Eastridge | 2005 | A | |
| Nivek Sutton | Mynderse | 2018 | M | |
| Ben Swan | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | D | Eastern |
| Cameron Swann | Newark | 2019 | G | |
| Chris Swanson | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | D | Syracuse |
| Damon Swanson | Canandaigua | 2025 | M | |
| Chris Swart | Midlakes | 2011 | A | |
| Tom Swart | Midlakes | 2005 | M | |
| Alex Swarthout | Penn Yan | 2009 | D | |
| Isaac Swartzman | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | D | |
| Josh Swartzman | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | DM | |
| Josh Sweeney | Spencerport | 2010 | D | |
| Marc Sweeney | Fairport | 2013 | D | |
| Will Sweeney | Wayne | 2022 | D | |
| John Sweeny | Wayne | 2017 | A/M | |
| David Sweet | Victor | 2010 | D | |
| Isaac Sweet | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | G | |
| Jake Sweet | Brockport | 2016 | M | |
| Kayden Sweet | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | M/A | |
| Mike Sweet | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | D | |
| Zack Sweet | Brockport | 2017 | D | |
| Tim Sweeting | Mynderse | 2007 | M | |
| Connor Swenson | Mynderse | 2018 | G | |
| Jake Swiatowy | Batavia | 2012 | A | |
| Samuel Swift | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | D | |
| Jordan Swilley | Spencerport | 2016 | M | |
| Grant Swinehart | Geneva | 2018 | M | |
| Andrij Sykes | Fairport | 2018 | D | |
| Eric Sykes | Penfield | 2009 | D | |
| Waddy Sykes | Canandaigua | 2011 | D | |
| Thomas Syracusa | Thomas | 2013 | D | |
| Corey Syverson | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | A | |
| TJ Szatko | Penfield | 2013 | LSM | |
| Nico Szmigel | Penfield | 2015 | D | |
| Ayden Szymanski | Livonia-Avon | 2026 | G | |
| Kevin Tabor | Brighton | 2006 | D | |
| Kevin Tack | Newark | 2012 | M | |
| Jamie Tackley | Greece Storm | 2021 | D | MCC |
| Dan Taddeo | Penfield | 2018 | A | Robert Morris |
| Drew Taddeo | Penfield | 2024 | A | |
| Jack Taddeo | Penfield | 2015 | D | Bentley |
| Robert Taddeo | Hilton | 2024 | M | St Rose |
| Jordan Taft | Canandaigua | 2014 | D | |
| Spencer Taft | Canandaigua | 2017 | D | |
| Jake Taggart | Haverling | 2017 | D | |
| Justin Tahara | Hilton | 2019 | LSM | |
| Eric Tait | Schroeder | 2009 | D | |
| Ryan Tait | Schroeder | 2015 | A | |
| Joe Talarico | Gates Chili | 2015 | A | |
| John Talen | Thomas | 2020 | D | |
| Max Talia | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Joey Taliento | Gates Chili | 2021 | A | |
| Jon Taliento | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Ralph Taliento | Gates Chili | 2012 | M | |
| Jon Tallent | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | D | |
| Ian Talley | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | G/D | |
| Cam Tallman | Canandaigua | 2021 | A | |
| Drew Tallon | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | A | |
| Jay Tallon | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | G | |
| Scotty Tam-Grimshaw | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | M | |
| Jimmy Tambe | Irondequoit | 2023 | D | |
| Dylan Tandle | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Nathan Tandle | Gananda | 2025 | D | |
| Jack Tanoory | Canandaigua | 2024 | M | |
| Danny Tantalo | Gates Chili | 2020 | M | |
| Jeremy Tantalo | Gates Chili | 2024 | M | |
| Jaden Tantillo | Victor | 2021 | D | St John Fisher |
| Landon Tantillo | Victor | 2025 | G | |
| Chris Tapscott | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Dave Tarana | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | G | |
| Jeremiah Tarnowski | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | M | |
| Nic Tartaglia | Geneva | 2012 | M | |
| Nicholas Tassone | Pittsford | 2020 | A | |
| Nate Tata | Spencerport | 2023 | M | |
| Ricky Tatar | Gates Chili | 2005 | M | |
| Chris Tateo | Penfield | 2005 | G | |
| Chris Tauterouff | Canandaigua | 2009 | D | Alfred |
| Frank Tavino | Aquinas | 2019 | D | |
| Ross Tawil | Victor | 2014 | D | |
| Camron Taylor | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Christopher Taylor | Livonia | 2019 | M | |
| Dylan Taylor | Geneva | 2015 | D | |
| Gavin Taylor | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | D | |
| Jayden Taylor | Brockport | 2025 | M | |
| Luke Taylor | Newark | 2026 | M/A | |
| Nathan Taylor | Avon | 2013 | M | |
| Oren Taylor | Livonia | 2007 | M | Pace |
| Ryan Taylor | Spencerport | 2008 | LSM | |
| Seth Taylor | Geneva | 2024 | M | |
| Zack Taylor | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | A | |
| Martin Tchamov | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Nic Teachout | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | G | |
| Connor Teal | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | D | |
| TEAM | Haverling | 2015 | A | |
| Team | Gates Chili | 2011 | - | |
| Goal TEAM | McQuaid Jesuit | 2015 | A | |
| Team Team | Haverling | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Livonia | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Penfield | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Thomas | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Hilton | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Pittsford | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Gates Chili | 2012 | - | |
| Team Team | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | A | |
| Team Team | Schroeder | 2012 | A | |
| TEAM TEAM | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | A | |
| Jason Tebo | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | M | OCC |
| Ryan Teed | Midlakes | 2009 | D | |
| Brian Teel | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | D | |
| Eric Teel | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2015 | A | |
| Darick Teeter | Pal-Mac | 2011 | LSM | |
| Jared Tegler | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Pat Tehan | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Josh Tellier | Newark | 2015 | M | |
| Brad Temple | Mynderse | 2005 | D | |
| Andy Teneyck | Waterloo | 2009 | D | FLCC |
| Will Teresi | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | D | |
| Chris TerHaar | Churchville-Chili | 2022 | G | |
| Ryan Terhaar | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | LSM | Mercyhurst |
| Connor Terilli | Churchville-Chili | 2026 | M | |
| Jaydon Terran | Greece Storm | 2026 | M/A | |
| David Terrell | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | A | |
| Pete Terrelli | Brockport | 2006 | M | |
| Philip Terresi | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Joseph Terruli | Schroeder | 2017 | M | |
| Jake Terry | Livonia | 2015 | A | |
| Luke Terry | Livonia | 2013 | D | |
| Jahquan Terry-Bradley | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | A | |
| Cory Terwilliger | Penfield | 2011 | A | |
| Toby Terwilliger | Penfield | 2008 | M | |
| Trey Terzo | Fairport | 2021 | A | |
| Peyton Tessier | Penfield | 2024 | A | |
| Peyton Tessier | Penfield | 2024 | M/A | |
| Jordan Testa | Pittsford | 2020 | A | |
| Varun Tewari | Mynderse | 2018 | M | |
| Huck Thayer | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Sutherland Thayer | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | FLCC |
| AJ Theodorakakos | Penfield | 2026 | D | |
| Allen Thibodeau | Fairport | 2015 | LSM | |
| Cole Thieme | Irondequoit | 2012 | A | |
| Mike Thiesmeyer | Penn Yan | 2012 | D | |
| Andy Thomas | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | M | |
| Ben Thomas | Thomas | 2014 | LSM | Brockport |
| Branden Thomas | Pal-Mac | 2027 | M/A | |
| Briyceton Thomas | East United-Eastridge | 2027 | D | |
| Caleb Thomas | Wayne | 2022 | D | |
| Christian Thomas | Brighton | 2014 | M | |
| Cody Thomas | Eastridge | 2016 | D | |
| Connor Thomas | Wayne | 2019 | D | |
| Damier Thomas | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | M | |
| Dan Thomas | Thomas | 2010 | D | |
| Devin Thomas | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | M | |
| Greg Thomas | Haverling | 2015 | D | |
| Jacob Thomas | Gananda | 2017 | M | |
| Kari Thomas | East United | 2022 | D | |
| Kari Thomas | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | D | GCC |
| Kevin Thomas | Pittsford | 2023 | M | |
| Malakai Thomas | Gananda | 2026 | G | |
| Michael Thomas | Brighton | 2015 | M | |
| Michael Thomas | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | D | |
| Noah Thomas | Brockport | 2022 | A | |
| Owen Thomas | Brighton | 2017 | D | |
| Ricardo Thomas | Midlakes | 2012 | M | |
| Ryan Thomas | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Spencer Thomas | Penfield | 2021 | LSM | |
| Andrew Thomolaris | Pittsford | 2015 | D | |
| Sammy Thomolaris | Pittsford | 2019 | M | |
| Josh Thompkins | Haverling | 2009 | M | |
| Cam Thompson | Schroeder | 2022 | D | |
| Chris Thompson | Livonia-Avon | 2024 | M | |
| Chris Thompson | Penfield | 2023 | M | |
| Cory Thompson | Haverling | 2013 | LSM | |
| Josh Thompson | Livonia | 2008 | D | |
| Jurrell Thompson | Marcus Whitman | 2009 | M | FLCC |
| Michael Thompson | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | M | |
| Nick Thompson | Thomas | 2017 | D | |
| Tanner Thompson | Pal-Mac | 2020 | D | |
| Will Thompson | Penn Yan | 2025 | G | Fairfield |
| Wyatt Thompson | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | A | |
| Alex Thoms | Newark | 2010 | D | FLCC |
| Brett Thoms | Newark | 2006 | D | |
| Billy Thomson | Canandaigua | 2005 | G | |
| Billy Thomson | Wayne | 2019 | A/M | |
| Brandon Thomson | Canandaigua | 2010 | A | Mercyhurst |
| Charlie Thomson | Penfield | 2017 | A/M | |
| Mike Thon | Penfield | 2005 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Cody Thongsavauh | Aquinas | 2024 | D | |
| Ethan Thonklinson | Newark | 2024 | D | |
| Sam Thore | Irondequoit | 2026 | D | |
| Austin Thorius | Haverling | 2022 | LSM | |
| Connor Thornton | Pittsford | 2020 | D | Rollins |
| Colton Thorp | Hilton | 2024 | M | |
| Anthony Thurston | Irondequoit | 2015 | A | |
| Da`Ron Thurston | Newark | 2013 | M | |
| Trent Thurston | Schroeder | 2007 | D | Alfred |
| Joseph Tiberio | Thomas | 2024 | A | |
| Karter Ticconi | Mynderse | 2024 | D | |
| Conor Tickner | Newark | 2015 | G | |
| Jack Tiffany | Midlakes | 2016 | M | |
| Tyler Tiffany | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | A | |
| Nick Tillinghast | Haverling | 2014 | A | |
| Brian Tillman | Gates Chili | 2009 | M | |
| Sean Tillman | Midlakes | 2017 | LSM | |
| Jack Timerson | Newark | 2011 | M | FLCC |
| Adam Timmerman | Penfield | 2013 | M | |
| Andrew Tirabassi | Rush-Henrietta | 2012 | A | Hilbert |
| Luke Toal | Churchville-Chili | 2017 | LSM | |
| Adam Tobey | Brockport | 2018 | A | |
| Brian Tobey | Rush-Henrietta | 2006 | D | |
| Chad Tobey | Brockport | 2016 | A | |
| Derek Tobey | Brockport | 2021 | D | |
| Carter Tochelli | Fairport | 2021 | A/M | |
| Gideon Todd | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Jack Todd | Aquinas | 2021 | D | |
| Ricky Todd | Aquinas | 2019 | G | |
| Mike Tomani | McQuaid Jesuit | 2005 | M | |
| Ben Tomaszewski | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2017 | G | Geneseo |
| Kenny Tomeno | Thomas | 2010 | M | |
| Sam Tomeno | Thomas | 2015 | A/M | |
| Bryce Tomion | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | A | |
| Connor Tomion | Marcus Whitman | 2022 | A | |
| Justin Tomkins | Midlakes | 2011 | D | |
| Sean Tomkinson | Rush-Henrietta | 2013 | M | Geneseo |
| Marc Tommasi | Pittsford | 2020 | D | |
| Reid Tompkins | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Justin Tomzak | Canandaigua | 2008 | A | St John Fisher |
| Chris Toner | Geneva | 2005 | A | |
| Dan Toner | Geneva | 2006 | D | |
| Mike Toner | Geneva | 2005 | A | Penn State |
| Kris Tones | Pal-Mac | 2014 | A | |
| Matt Tones | Penn Yan | 2025 | M | |
| Ethan Tonkinson | Newark | 2024 | D | |
| John Tooley | Brockport | 2010 | D | |
| Geoff Toomey | Victor | 2006 | M | |
| Trevor Topian | Victor | 2005 | A | |
| Chris Topping | Schroeder | 2009 | M | Geneseo |
| Brian Torcha | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | M | |
| Sam Torchia | Aquinas | 2009 | D | |
| Alex Torpey | Irondequoit | 2011 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Michael Torregiano | Avon | 2014 | D | |
| Ryan Torrelli | Fairport | 2025 | D | |
| Derek Torres | Penfield | 2023 | M | Clarkson |
| Jasen Torres | Aquinas | 2008 | A | |
| Javier Torres | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | D | |
| Andy Torruella | Geneva | 2007 | D | |
| Dan Torruella | Geneva | 2008 | D | |
| Luis Torruella | Geneva | 2021 | D | |
| Joseph Tortora | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | A/M | |
| Zach Tortora | Spencerport | 2026 | M | |
| Mike Tota | Schroeder | 2008 | A | Cortland |
| Scott Tota | Schroeder | 2010 | G | Cortland |
| Calvin Tourangeau | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Sam Tourangeau | Brighton | 2021 | M | |
| Tim Tourangeau | Brighton | 2027 | M | |
| Eli Towner | Hilton | 2007 | D | |
| Ethan Townsend | Geneva | 2022 | M | |
| Justin Townsend | Wayne | 2014 | G | St John Fisher |
| Jordan Tracey | Thomas | 2006 | D | |
| Jonah Trammel | Midlakes | 2007 | LSM | |
| Mike Trass | Schroeder | 2014 | M | |
| Matt Trau | Greece Ath_Ody | 2014 | D | |
| Brian Traugott | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | M | |
| Dan Traugott | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | A | |
| Drew Trausch | Brighton | 2010 | A | |
| Zach Trautman | Pal-Mac | 2021 | D | |
| Gianni Travaglini | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | G | |
| Anthony Travato | Eastridge | 2018 | A | |
| Hayden Travers | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | D | |
| Ryan Travers | Victor | 2021 | M | |
| Tyler Travis | Geneva | 2009 | D | Penn State |
| Colby Treat | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | Post |
| Brayden Treier | Schroeder | 2023 | A | |
| Dominic Trento | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Frank Triana | Geneva | 2010 | M | |
| Charlie Tribble | Mynderse | 2007 | A | |
| Caleb Tribotte | Brockport | 2024 | M | |
| Adam Tribunella | Spencerport | 2015 | D | |
| Ben Tribunella | Spencerport | 2012 | M | |
| Cooper Trickler | Geneva | 2026 | M | |
| Jacob Trickler | Geneva | 2022 | D | |
| Nick Trickler | Geneva | 2026 | D | |
| Tim Trickler | Mynderse | 2013 | G | |
| Jamie Trimboli | Greece Ath_Ody | 2016 | M | |
| Jamie Trimboli | Victor | 2016 | M | Syracuse |
| Joe Trimboli | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | M | |
| Chris Trimm | Brockport | 2018 | M | |
| AJ Trinchini | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| Conner Tripp | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2025 | D | |
| Gavynn Trippany | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | G/M | |
| Jason Trivigno | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2014 | M | |
| John Trivigno | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | D | |
| Adam Trombley | Penn Yan | 2010 | A | Ohio State |
| Brandon Trombley | Penn Yan | 2007 | M | St Leo |
| Ty Trombley | Penn Yan | 2009 | M | St Leo |
| Shane Trost | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | G | Post |
| Brandon Trottier | Thomas | 2025 | A | |
| Andrew Troup | Brockport | 2012 | D | |
| Mike Troup | Pittsford | 2007 | D | |
| Steven Troup | Pittsford | 2011 | M | Lycoming |
| Aidan Trout | Mynderse | 2017 | M/D | |
| Evan Trout | Mynderse | 2018 | A | |
| Blake Trowbridge | Hilton | 2008 | A | |
| Luke Trowbridge | Hilton | 2011 | M | |
| Nate Trowbridge | Geneva | 2019 | D | |
| Cameron Truax | Gates Chili | 2018 | D | |
| Josh Trubatch | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | LSM | |
| Jake True | Brockport | 2021 | M | |
| Paul True | Brockport | 2023 | M | |
| Jordan Truley | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | D | |
| James Truly | Geneva | 2014 | D | |
| Braydn Trybuskiewicz | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2023 | A | |
| Trevor Tryon | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2025 | M/A | |
| Drew Tschetter | Canandaigua | 2007 | M | |
| Nick Tschetter | Aquinas | 2016 | M | |
| Jason Tucker | Thomas | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Jaxson Tucker | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | G | |
| Jaxson Tucker | Canandaigua | 2024 | G | Keuka |
| Jeremiah Tucker | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | M | |
| Zane Tuller | Gates Chili | 2019 | A | |
| Ian Tulloch | Newark | 2016 | D | |
| Nick Tumminelli | Schroeder | 2022 | M | |
| Devon Tunley | Wayne | 2015 | G | |
| Kevin Turner | Eastridge | 2011 | M | |
| David Turrell | Geneva | 2017 | M | |
| Frank Turrie | Hilton | 2009 | D | |
| Colby Tuttle | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | D | |
| Eric Tuttle | Irondequoit | 2015 | D | |
| Alessandro Tuttobene | Aquinas | 2015 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Jared Twigg | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | D | |
| Jackson Twomey | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | M | John Carroll |
| Chris Tydings | Hilton | 2006 | D | |
| Nolan Tydings | Hilton | 2025 | M | |
| Josh Tyler | Waterloo | 2015 | D | |
| Tryon Tyler | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Herbert Tyndell | Brockport | 2009 | LSM | |
| Shane Tyree | Gates Chili | 2016 | M | |
| Ben Tyson | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | M | |
| Jeremiah Ubbink | Pal-Mac | 2013 | M | |
| Jariel Ubiles | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Marcello Ubiles | Mynderse | 2026 | D | |
| Colton Ugine | Schroeder | 2023 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Alex Uhlein | Aquinas | 2014 | G | |
| Ben Uline | Brighton | 2005 | D | |
| Josh Uline | Brighton | 2007 | M | |
| Sam Underhill | Newark | 2026 | M/A | |
| Danny Upton | Pittsford | 2007 | D | |
| Kyle Urban | Livonia | 2017 | D | |
| Billy Urbanski | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | DM | |
| Henry Urbland | Pittsford | 2013 | D | |
| Daniel Urlacher | Canandaigua | 2024 | D | |
| Joey Urlacher | Canandaigua | 2020 | D | St John Fisher |
| Ian Urquhart | Aquinas | 2005 | M/A | |
| Michael Ursulom | Hilton | 2012 | D | |
| Adam Usselman | Victor | 2022 | M | |
| Tony Ussia | Spencerport | 2012 | A | |
| Ben Utes | Thomas | 2018 | M | |
| AJ Uttaro | Gates Chili | 2010 | D | |
| Dan Utz | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | Gordon |
| Elijah Utz | Penfield | 2022 | M | Coker |
| Mike Utz | Irondequoit | 2010 | M | Gordon |
| Ryan Utz | Irondequoit | 2012 | M/A | Gordon |
| Tom Utz | Fairport | 2015 | M | |
| Ben Uveges | Midlakes | 2009 | M/A | McGill |
| David Uzialko | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | M | |
| Mike Vacanti | Penfield | 2009 | M | |
| Ryan Vacanti | Rush-Henrietta | 2025 | D | |
| Joe Vacca | Waterloo | 2010 | D | Utica |
| Peter Vacca | Waterloo | 2009 | A | Herkimer |
| Mark Vaccarrelli | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Shane Vadney | Fairport | 2024 | G | |
| Jay Vakiener | Fairport | 2013 | M | RIT |
| Brandon Valder | Waterloo | 2016 | A | |
| Mike Valent | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | M | Hobart |
| Paul Valente | Victor | 2013 | D | |
| Avery Valenti | Pittsford | 2026 | M | |
| Frank Valenti | Victor | 2008 | A | |
| Joe Valenti | Brighton | 2018 | D | |
| Matt Valentine | Livonia | 2010 | M | |
| Gio Valerie | Aquinas | 2025 | A | |
| Dominick Valerio | Midlakes | 2005 | A | |
| Aaron Valino | Gananda | 2012 | D | Hilbert |
| Evan Valle | East United-Eastridge | 2023 | D | |
| Foster Valle | Eastridge | 2019 | G/D | |
| Esteban Valle Vergara | Greece Storm | 2023 | G/D | |
| Josh Valletta | Eastridge | 2008 | D | |
| Evan Van Epps | Schroeder | 2007 | M | |
| Hunter Van Housen | Penn Yan | 2021 | D | |
| Hans Van Houten | Penn Yan | 2004 | D | Bellarmine |
| Jon Van Houten | Penn Yan | 2005 | A | Drexel |
| Peter Van Houten | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | M | |
| Max Van Orman | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | G | |
| Kyle Van Thof | Penfield | 2009 | M | Penn State |
| Steve Van Valin | Gates Chili | 2013 | D | |
| David VanAeker | Greece Arc_Oly | 2012 | D | |
| Kyle VanAernum | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | A | |
| Luke VanAlstyne | Gananda | 2020 | D | |
| Josh VanAmburg | Livonia | 2014 | D | |
| Pat VanBortle | Fairport | 2012 | A/M | GCC |
| Justin VanCamp | Midlakes | 2008 | A | |
| Dylan Vance | Wayne | 2023 | M | |
| Jonathan Vance | Gates Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Matt Vandamme | Midlakes | 2015 | M | |
| Ethan Vandelinder | Penn Yan | 2025 | D | |
| R.J. VanDeMortel | Newark | 2009 | M | |
| Jack Vandenbush | Aquinas | 2022 | M | |
| Caden VanDeusen | Irondequoit | 2025 | G | |
| Jacob VanDewalker | Livonia | 2017 | A/M | |
| Steve VanDeWalle | Pal-Mac | 2008 | A | |
| Kyle Vandewater | Canandaigua | 2016 | A | Alfred State |
| Peter VanEchaute | Mynderse | 2024 | M | |
| Darren VanEvery | Mynderse | 2016 | A/M | |
| Draven VanEvery | Mynderse | 2018 | A | |
| Cole Vangellow | Fairport | 2015 | M | |
| Luke VanGorden | Pal-Mac | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Erik Vanhooft | Midlakes | 2009 | D | |
| Bryant VanHousen | Penn Yan | 2024 | M | St Rose |
| Keegan Vankerkhove | Irondequoit | 2019 | M | |
| Zach Vankoevering | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Greg VanMeter | Greece Ath_Ody | 2006 | D | |
| Andrew Vannest | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | M | |
| Trevor VanNostrand | Midlakes | 2020 | M | |
| Derek VanOrman | Penfield | 2008 | G | |
| Tyler VanPutte | Pittsford | 2022 | D | |
| Duke Vansavage | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2027 | LSM | |
| James VanScoter | Geneva | 2017 | G | |
| Paul Vanthof | Penfield | 2007 | D | Nazareth |
| Owen VanWie | Spencerport | 2018 | M | Brockport |
| Jacob VanWuychuyse | Hilton | 2018 | G | |
| Joey VanZandt | Pittsford | 2020 | G | |
| Rider VanZandt | Livonia-Avon | 2027 | M/FO | |
| Austin Varga | Hilton | 2015 | M | |
| Edward Vargas | Gates Chili | 2006 | D | |
| Matt Vargo | Churchville-Chili | 2007 | D | |
| Trevor Vargo | Spencerport | 2023 | D/LSM | |
| Nick Varno | Avon | 2019 | A | |
| Nick Varno | Schroeder | 2019 | A | |
| Brandon Vasciannie | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Malik Vasciannie | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | M | |
| Joe Vasile | Thomas | 2016 | M | MIT |
| Joseph Vasile | Marcus Whitman | 2025 | G | |
| Nick Vasile | Thomas | 2019 | M | |
| Evan Vasquez | Newark | 2013 | A | |
| Steve Vaughan | Pittsford | 2007 | M | |
| Clayton Vaughn | East Rochester | 2012 | M | Keuka |
| Dan Vaughn | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Jake Vaughn | East Rochester | 2011 | M | |
| Kevin Vaughn | Fairport | 2013 | M | Mercyhurst |
| T.J. Vay | Irondequoit | 2016 | D | St John Fisher |
| Victor Vazquez Jr | Gates Chili | 2014 | M | |
| Dominick Vedora | Geneva | 2025 | M | |
| Andrew Vega | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| Dustin Veitch | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | G | |
| Gianni Velazquez | Geneva | 2026 | M/D | |
| Eli Velepec | Irondequoit | 2023 | M | |
| Hank Velepec | Irondequoit | 2026 | A/M | |
| Tucker Velepec | Irondequoit | 2020 | A | |
| Ryan Vella | Irondequoit | 2010 | D | Tampa |
| Marco Vengoechea | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2026 | M | |
| John Venner | Irondequoit | 2014 | G | |
| Trevor Veno | Thomas | 2024 | M | |
| Kyle Vent | Thomas | 2020 | LSM | |
| Nick Ventrella | Spencerport | 2013 | M | |
| Dutchie Venuti | Geneva | 2005 | D | St John Fisher |
| Nick Venuti | Haverling | 2007 | A | |
| Steve Venuti | Geneva | 2009 | M | |
| Scott Verdehem | Waterloo | 2022 | A | |
| Dylan Vergari | Brockport | 2020 | A | |
| Nick Vergari | Brockport | 2017 | M | |
| Josh Verna | East United-Eastridge | 2025 | A | |
| John Verroli | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | |
| Jimmy Verstrate | Thomas | 2015 | D | |
| Lucas Verstreate | Gananda | 2023 | D | Westminster PA |
| Mike Viavattine | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | G | |
| Nick Vicaretti | Brockport | 2016 | A | |
| Peter Vidler | Waterloo | 2018 | M | |
| Connor Viele | Greece Storm | 2024 | M | |
| Brian Vierhile | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | M | |
| Matt Vierhile | Canandaigua | 2020 | M | |
| Anthony Vigneri | Canandaigua | 2024 | G | |
| Jacob Vileria | Hilton | 2015 | D | |
| Al Vill | Greece Ath_Ody | 2007 | M | |
| Dan Villa | Penfield | 2009 | M | |
| Robert Villa | Thomas | 2023 | M/D | |
| Sam Villanti | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | M | |
| Cole Villareale | Fairport | 2023 | D | |
| Jack Villareale | Fairport | 2021 | M | |
| Sabastian Villatoro | Pal-Mac | 2025 | D | |
| Orlando Villegas | Greece | 2005 | G | |
| Steven Villegas | Greece Storm | 2025 | A | |
| Zach Villone | Rush-Henrietta | 2021 | D | |
| Nick Vincent | Aquinas | 2006 | A | |
| Dominic Vinci | Spencerport | 2022 | M | |
| Enzo Vinci | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Michael Vinci | Spencerport | 2019 | M | |
| Zach Viney | Brockport | 2015 | A | |
| Ivan Vinovrski | Greece Arc_Oly | 2019 | A/M | |
| Ivan Vinovrski | Greece Storm | 2019 | M | |
| Alex Viola | Schroeder | 2008 | M | |
| Marco Viola | Penfield | 2018 | DM | |
| Ben Visca | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Jack Visco | Aquinas | 2012 | M | |
| Jack Visco | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | M | |
| Jason Visco | Aquinas | 2015 | A | |
| Joe Visconte | Schroeder | 2019 | D | Alfred |
| Connor Visingrad | Newark | 2023 | A/M | |
| Allen Vitale | Brighton | 2014 | M | Alfred |
| Anthony Vitale | Penfield | 2014 | M | Lake Erie |
| Ben Vitale | Brighton | 2022 | D | |
| Chris Vitale | Churchville-Chili | 2008 | LSM | |
| Jacob Vitale | Brighton | 2020 | M | |
| Carter Vivian | Avon | 2016 | D | |
| Casey Vogl | Aquinas | 2009 | D | |
| Jake Vogl | Aquinas | 2012 | M | Hartford |
| Jay Vogler | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | D | |
| Evan Voglewede | Churchville-Chili | 2016 | D | |
| Austin Vogt | Gananda | 2016 | A | |
| Hunter Vogt | Gananda | 2026 | M | |
| Jaime Vogt | Marcus Whitman | 2010 | M/A | |
| Bradley Voigt | Penn Yan | 2014 | A/M | Syracuse |
| Jarrett Voigt | Penn Yan | 2013 | D | |
| JJ Voigt | Penn Yan | 2011 | M | Keuka |
| Jake Volhejn | Rush-Henrietta | 2019 | D | |
| Shane Volhejn | Fairport | 2024 | DM | |
| Roman Volpe | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | M | |
| Bryce Volschow | Irondequoit | 2017 | M | |
| Josh Volschow | Irondequoit | 2017 | D | |
| Michael Volta Jr | Gates Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Phoukham Vongkhily | Eastridge | 2020 | M | |
| Phoukham Vongkhily | East United | 2020 | M/D | |
| Colin Vonglis | Avon | 2015 | A/M | |
| Chase Voorhees | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2008 | D | |
| Tyler Vuichard | Victor | 2007 | D | |
| Danny Vyverberg | Greece Ath_Ody | 2010 | A | |
| Joe Vyverberg | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | M | |
| Steve Vyverberg | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | A | |
| Adam Wacenske | Gates Chili | 2009 | D | Ithaca |
| Philipp Wacker | Victor | 2011 | M | |
| Byron Waddell | Fairport | 2015 | M | |
| Brian Wade | McQuaid Jesuit | 2013 | A/M | |
| Justin Wade | Bishop Kearney | 2015 | M | |
| Max Wade | Victor | 2006 | G | |
| Zach Wade | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | |
| Brandon Waden | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | Lycoming |
| Collin Waden | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Jeff Wadhams | Waterloo | 2009 | A/M | |
| Drew Wager | Haverling | 2011 | A | |
| Andrew Wagner | Marcus Whitman | 2017 | D | |
| James Wagner | Penn Yan | 2005 | D | |
| Mark Wagner | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | G | |
| Travis Wagner | Aquinas | 2020 | G | |
| Travis Wagner | Penfield | 2020 | G | Cortland |
| Chris Waheibi | Irondequoit | 2004 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Alex Wahl | Pal-Mac | 2018 | M | |
| Owen Wahl | Pal-Mac | 2017 | D | |
| Kyle Wakefield | Canandaigua | 2005 | A | |
| Tyler Wakefield | Canandaigua | 2007 | A | |
| Bill Walczak | Thomas | 2004 | M | Oswego |
| Kevin Walders | Penfield | 2009 | M | |
| Ben Walence | Churchville-Chili | 2005 | M/D | |
| Cameron Walker | Batavia | 2015 | A | |
| Cameron Walker | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | A/M | |
| Colin Walker | Hilton | 2008 | A | |
| Hunter Walker | Gananda | 2025 | D | |
| Jeff Walker | Aquinas | 2004 | G | |
| Matt Walker | Pal-Mac | 2005 | M | |
| Ronin Walker | Rush-Henrietta | 2026 | M | |
| Tim Walker | Canandaigua | 2010 | D | |
| Willie Walker | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | M | |
| Brian Wall | Penfield | 2014 | M | Bellarmine |
| Colin Wall | Canandaigua | 2016 | M | |
| Kevin Wall | Penfield | 2016 | M | |
| Louis Wall | Gates Chili | 2023 | M | |
| Nathan Wall | Brockport | 2010 | M | |
| Brady Wallace | Wayne | 2025 | A | |
| Jack Wallace | Pittsford | 2021 | D | |
| Phil Wallace | Livonia | 2010 | M | |
| Mike Wallenhorst | Irondequoit | 2008 | M | |
| Nate Wallenhorst | Greece Ath_Ody | 2009 | A | |
| Ian Wallis | Haverling | 2016 | D | |
| Bryce Wallman | Pittsford | 2021 | M | Oswego |
| Stone Wallman | Livonia | 2017 | A | |
| Ryan Walpole | Pittsford | 2017 | D | |
| Dan Walsh | Greece | 2005 | D | |
| Ed Walsh | Canandaigua | 2005 | D | Oswego |
| Gaelin Walsh | Livonia | 2007 | M | |
| Hayden Walsh | East Rochester | 2010 | G | |
| Jessee Walsh | East Rochester | 2012 | D | |
| Jimmy Walsh | Irondequoit | 2008 | D | RIT |
| John Walsh | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | D | MCC |
| Justin Walsh | Eastridge | 2009 | D | |
| Kyle Walsh | Hilton | 2019 | M | |
| Ryan Walsh | Greece Ath_Ody | 2013 | D | |
| Ryan Walsh | Gananda | 2021 | A | |
| TJ Walsh | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2010 | M | |
| Will Walsh | Canandaigua | 2019 | M | |
| Conner Walter | Marcus Whitman | 2021 | M | |
| Colin Walters | Schroeder | 2014 | M | |
| Haidyn Walters | Newark | 2027 | D | |
| Henry Walters | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | A/M | |
| Jon Walters | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | D | |
| Wyatt Walters | Penn Yan | 2023 | D | Herkimer |
| Eric Walther | Churchville-Chili | 2009 | D | |
| Kevin Walther | Livonia | 2010 | D | |
| Eavan Walton | Gananda | 2018 | D | |
| Luke Walton | Newark | 2006 | M | |
| Tommy Walton | Fairport | 2025 | A | |
| Brady Wambach | Pittsford | 2023 | M | |
| Conner Wambach | Pittsford | 2025 | M | |
| Austin Wamser | Greece Arc_Oly | 2020 | A/M | |
| Austin Wamser | Greece Storm | 2020 | M | |
| Nick Waples | Spencerport | 2013 | D | |
| Andrew Ward | Hilton | 2023 | A/M | |
| Brandon Ward | Hilton | 2016 | D | |
| Jason Ward | Waterloo | 2006 | D | |
| Matt Ward | Penn Yan | 2017 | M | |
| Shane Ward | Livonia | 2007 | D | |
| Evan Ware | Waterloo | 2022 | M | |
| Justice Ware | East Rochester | 2013 | M | |
| Jahmier Warfield | East United | 2021 | LSM | |
| Jahmier Warfield | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | LSM | |
| Cory Warner | Batavia | 2009 | D | |
| Jacob Warner | Haverling | 2027 | M | |
| Jerry Warner | Fairport | 2011 | M | |
| Jim Warner | Geneva | 2008 | M | |
| Joe Warner | Geneva | 2014 | D | |
| John Warner | Geneva | 2007 | M | SUNY Binghamton |
| Matt Warner | Geneva | 2005 | M | Penn State |
| Mike Warner | Geneva | 2010 | D | Cortland |
| Brock Warren | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | A/M | |
| Christopher Warren | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Donald Warren | Eastridge | 2022 | D | |
| Donald Warren | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | D | |
| Garrett Warren | Irondequoit | 2012 | LSM | VMI |
| Kyle Warren | Brighton | 2006 | A | |
| Levi Warren | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2026 | D | |
| Mitchell Warren | Irondequoit | 2015 | D | |
| Parker Warren | Brighton | 2008 | A | |
| Chris Warrick | Mynderse | 2005 | A | |
| Mike Warrick | Mynderse | 2009 | M | |
| Cody Warshel | Mynderse | 2016 | A | |
| Jake Warshel | Mynderse | 2018 | D | |
| Hunter Warters | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | M | |
| Nick Waseleski | Victor | 2011 | D | Potsdam |
| Kaleb Waters | Geneva | 2021 | M | |
| Justin Watkins | Thomas | 2018 | M | |
| Tyler Watkins | Irondequoit | 2007 | G | |
| Chris Watson | Midlakes | 2005 | M | |
| Luc Watson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | A | |
| Zach Watson | Haverling | 2011 | D | |
| Robert Watt | Rush-Henrietta | 2016 | D | |
| Peyton Watts | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | M | |
| Alex Way | Schroeder | 2015 | M | |
| Justin Way | Schroeder | 2009 | D | |
| Scott Way | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Brandon Wayne | Geneva | 2019 | G | |
| Chashawn Wearen | Brighton | 2024 | M | |
| Jon Weaver | Pal-Mac | 2016 | D | |
| Ryan Weaver | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | D | |
| Tyler Webb | Gates Chili | 2010 | A | |
| Gardy Webber | McQuaid Jesuit | 2012 | A/M | |
| Jake Webber | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2011 | M | |
| Max Webber | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | A/M | |
| Brad Weber | Gates Chili | 2008 | M | Brockport |
| Josh Weber | Batavia | 2015 | M | |
| Josh Weber | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | M | |
| Matthew Weber | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2021 | D | |
| Max Weber | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2009 | M | |
| Zack Weber | Canandaigua | 2015 | D | |
| Ayden Webster | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Bennett Webster | Penfield | 2018 | M | |
| Brady Webster | Haverling | 2020 | M | |
| Edward Webster | Brockport | 2025 | M | |
| Garrett Webster | Penfield | 2022 | G | |
| Troy Webster | Gates Chili | 2017 | G/D | |
| Parker Weeks | Canandaigua | 2010 | M | Geneseo |
| Carter Wegman | Aquinas | 2024 | M | |
| Joe Wegman | Greece Ath_Ody | 2018 | M | |
| Joseph Wegman | Greece Storm | 2018 | M | |
| Kyle Wegman | Aquinas | 2006 | M | |
| Phil Wegman | Aquinas | 2027 | G | |
| Tyler Wegman | Aquinas | 2022 | LSM | |
| Mike Wegner | Aquinas | 2006 | D | |
| Colby Wehner | Irondequoit | 2011 | D | Canisius |
| Tyler Wehner | Pittsford | 2012 | A | |
| Bear Wehrhein | Pittsford | 2029 | G | |
| Wade Weil | Bishop Kearney | 2024 | LSM | |
| Luke Weiler | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | M | |
| Matt Weimer | Newark | 2010 | D | |
| Mitchell Weimer | Newark | 2012 | A | |
| Ryan Weiner | Pittsford | 2018 | D | |
| Matt Weinthaler | Irondequoit | 2014 | M | |
| Jeff Weise | Geneva | 2006 | M | |
| John Weise | Gananda | 2018 | M | |
| Nathan Weise | Gates Chili | 2022 | G | Morrisville |
| Tim Weisensel | Schroeder | 2021 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Rylan Weissinger | Marcus Whitman | 2023 | A | |
| Austin Welch | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | |
| Ben Welch | Thomas | 2021 | D | Potsdam |
| Colton Welch | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2017 | M | |
| Kacin Welch | Fairport | 2014 | M | |
| Schyler Welch | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | A | |
| Scott Welch | Pal-Mac | 2009 | D | |
| Tim Welch | Canandaigua | 2016 | G | |
| Kyle Welker | Penn Yan | 2017 | G | |
| Thomas Welker | Brighton | 2024 | D | |
| Rich Wellington | Brighton | 2009 | M | |
| Brandon Welsch | Schroeder | 2016 | M | |
| Ben Wemesfelder | Wayne | 2017 | A/M | |
| Owen Wendorf | Thomas | 2023 | D | |
| Mike Wentworth | Gates Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Tyler Wenzler | Spencerport | 2019 | D | |
| JT Werkmeister | Victor | 2024 | D | |
| Rob Werner | Greece Arc_Oly | 2007 | A | |
| Parker Werven | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | M | |
| Henry Werzinger | Brighton | 2025 | M/FO | |
| Robert Wesley | Thomas | 2018 | D | |
| Dave Wesolowski | Irondequoit | 2005 | D | |
| Noah West | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | D | |
| Tim West | Penfield | 2005 | D | |
| Kevin Westcott | Penfield | 2009 | M | |
| Jeff Wester | Livonia | 2010 | M | St John Fisher |
| Josh Wester | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | GCC |
| Chandler Westfall | Wayne | 2018 | D | |
| Jamie Westfall | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2024 | D | |
| Jared Westfall | Brighton | 2006 | D | |
| Nic Westfall | Midlakes | 2015 | D | |
| Kyle Weston | Spencerport | 2008 | M | |
| Nick Weston | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2012 | M | Syracuse |
| Nick Weston | Aquinas | 2011 | A/M | |
| R.C. Weston | Midlakes | 2006 | A | |
| Simon Westveer | Greece Ath_Ody | 2018 | D | |
| Owen Weterrings | Livonia-Avon | 2024 | D/LSM | |
| Warren wetherwax | Mynderse | 2026 | D | |
| Shawn Wetterings | Livonia-Avon | 2021 | D | |
| Gunnar Wetzel | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2021 | M | |
| Roth Wetzel | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2018 | M | |
| Ryan Wetzel | Fairport | 2014 | D | |
| Toby Wetzel | Fairport | 2018 | D | |
| Tyler Wetzel | Fairport | 2016 | G | Geneseo |
| Greg Weyl | Pittsford | 2014 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Marc Weyl | Pittsford | 2012 | M | |
| Alex Wezelis | Churchville-Chili | 2010 | D | |
| Austin Wheatcraft | Haverling | 2022 | D | |
| Jason Wheatley | Geneva | 2018 | M | |
| Liam Wheatley | Schroeder | 2012 | M | Utica |
| Dakota Wheaton | Haverling | 2015 | M | |
| Jon Wheaton | Penfield | 2008 | D | |
| Aiden Wheeler | Victor | 2022 | D | St John Fisher |
| Bobby Wheeler | Churchville-Chili | 2012 | D | |
| Colin Wheeler | Victor | 2026 | M | |
| Dustin Wheeler | Livonia | 2009 | M | |
| James Wheeler | Penfield | 2020 | D | Gordon |
| Jared Wheeler | Gates Chili | 2009 | D | |
| Liam Wheeler | Victor | 2023 | M | Jacksonville |
| Max Wheeler | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Shane Wheeler | Midlakes | 2009 | M | |
| Quinn Whipple | Pittsford | 2023 | A | |
| Joshua Whitaker | Mynderse | 2020 | M | |
| Torry Whitcher | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | M | |
| Steven Whitcomb | UPrep | 2018 | A | |
| Noah Whitcome | Batavia-Notre Dame | 2024 | M | |
| AJ White | Avon | 2020 | D | |
| Anthony White | Greece Arc_Oly | 2008 | G | |
| Ben White | Fairport | 2025 | M | |
| Cam White | Brockport | 2018 | G | |
| Connor White | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | G | |
| Dan White | Brighton | 2018 | D | |
| Dennis White | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2018 | D | |
| Dylan White | Brockport | 2009 | G | Lake Erie |
| Jaden White | Spencerport | 2020 | A | |
| Jaiden White | Aquinas | 2024 | M | |
| Jerry White | Penfield | 2019 | DM | |
| John White | Brockport | 2014 | D | |
| Keegan White | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | D | |
| Matai White | McQuaid Jesuit | 2025 | M | |
| Mykel White | Aquinas | 2023 | M | |
| Peter White | Pittsford | 2004 | M | Geneseo |
| Tim White | Pittsford | 2006 | M | |
| Jamison Whitfield | Aquinas | 2014 | M | |
| Kyle Whitford | Livonia | 2009 | G | |
| Dylan Whiting | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2022 | A | |
| Blade Whitman | Eastridge | 2016 | D | |
| Brad Whitney | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | M | |
| Schuyler Whitney | Canandaigua | 2008 | M | FLCC |
| Jeff Whitt | Pal-Mac | 2005 | M | |
| Cody Whittaker | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2025 | M | |
| Carter Whittemore | Irondequoit | 2016 | G | |
| Hayden Whittlesey | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Sean-Paul Whittlesey | Newark | 2017 | M | |
| Robbie Whitwell | Geneva | 2010 | D | |
| Zach Whyte | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M/A | |
| R.J. Wickham | Penn Yan | 2007 | G | Navy |
| Cameron Wicks | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2021 | D | |
| Jordan Wicks | Midlakes-Red Jacket | 2023 | A | |
| Ryan Wicks | Fairport | 2018 | M | |
| Andrew Widanka | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | G | |
| Eric Widanka | Rush-Henrietta | 2011 | M | |
| Shea Widell | Thomas | 2021 | D | |
| Kevin Widzinski | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | A | MCC |
| Robbie Wielandt | Schroeder | 2013 | G | |
| Dylan Wiemer | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Luke Wieser | Victor | 2009 | D | |
| Colin Wightman | Victor | 2025 | M | |
| Micah Wightman | Irondequoit | 2010 | LSM | |
| Pat Wightman | Pal-Mac | 2009 | D | |
| Derrick Wigley | Livonia-Avon | 2022 | A | |
| Ryan Wigley | Livonia | 2019 | A/M | |
| Ryan Wigley | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | D | |
| Baird Wilber | Penn Yan | 2011 | D | RIT |
| Dana Wilber | Penn Yan | 2008 | D | Drexel |
| Colin Wilcox | Thomas | 2025 | D | |
| Brandin Wilder | Hilton | 2021 | G | |
| Jeremiah Wilder | Haverling | 2006 | G | |
| Ben Wildman | Penfield | 2020 | D | |
| Nygel Wiley | East United | 2020 | M/FO | |
| William Wilke | Fairport | 2011 | D | |
| Cody Wilkes | Midlakes | 2011 | A | |
| Kyle Wilkes | Midlakes | 2015 | G | |
| Austin Wilkinson | Batavia | 2012 | M | |
| Drew Williamee | Canandaigua | 2025 | A | |
| Adam Williams | Hilton | 2014 | A | MCC |
| Alex Williams | Penfield | 2010 | D | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Alex Williams | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | A | |
| Brad Williams | Irondequoit | 2007 | M | |
| Brandon Williams | Batavia | 2010 | D | |
| Brandon Williams | Greece Storm | 2021 | D | |
| Brent Williams | Geneva | 2025 | A | |
| Brian Williams | Hilton | 2017 | D | |
| Danny Williams | Batavia-Attica | 2015 | M | |
| Danny Williams | Batavia | 2016 | A | |
| Demar Williams | Gates Chili | 2027 | G | |
| Devin Williams | Fairport | 2016 | M | |
| Duban Williams | Canandaigua | 2017 | M | |
| Edmund Williams | Pal-Mac | 2011 | A | |
| Evan Williams | Churchville-Chili | 2006 | G | |
| George Williams | Waterloo | 2017 | G | |
| Jack Williams | Gates Chili | 2024 | LSM | |
| Jackson Williams | Avon | 2018 | M/D | |
| Jackson Williams | Livonia-Avon | 2019 | G/M | |
| James Williams | Geneva | 2017 | M | |
| JJ Williams | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | D | |
| Jordan Williams | Haverling | 2009 | M | |
| Josh Williams | Newark | 2012 | D | |
| LaShawn Williams | Canandaigua | 2010 | G | |
| Masiah Williams | Churchville-Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Parris Williams | Penfield | 2006 | D | |
| Paul Williams | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2019 | M | |
| Paul Williams | Geneva | 2024 | G | |
| Quinn Williams | Eastridge | 2005 | M | |
| Rich Williams | Waterloo | 2005 | D | |
| Riley Williams | Aquinas | 2022 | M | |
| Riley Williams | Canandaigua | 2022 | G | |
| Robert Williams | Waterloo | 2018 | D | |
| Ryan Williams | McQuaid Jesuit | 2011 | M | Gettysburg |
| Tim Williams | Brighton | 2007 | A | |
| Tyler Williams | Waterloo | 2011 | D | |
| Tyler Williams | Pal-Mac | 2015 | D | |
| Tyler Williams | Thomas | 2021 | D | |
| Xavier Williams | Gates Chili | 2026 | D | |
| Cayden Williamson | Victor | 2013 | M | |
| Timmy Williamson | Wayne | 2018 | G | |
| Andrew Willis | Brockport | 2008 | A | Buffalo |
| Jacob Willis | Livonia | 2014 | D | |
| George Willix | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | A | |
| Max Willix | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2021 | A | |
| Eric Willman | Victor | 2007 | M | |
| Chad Willmes | Schroeder | 2009 | A | |
| Jay Willmes | Schroeder | 2006 | M | Nazareth |
| Ben Wilson | Irondequoit | 2025 | M | |
| Chase Wilson | Hilton | 2024 | A | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Clay Wilson | Marcus Whitman | 2012 | M | |
| Evander Wilson | Penfield | 2005 | LSM | Alfred |
| John Wilson | Livonia | 2016 | D | |
| Jordan Wilson | Brighton | 2019 | M | |
| Kalub Wilson | Brockport | 2026 | D | |
| Kaseefe Wilson | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | D | |
| Matt Wilson | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | M | |
| Matt Wilson | Irondequoit | 2022 | D | |
| Riley Wilson | Fairport | 2020 | D | |
| Robbie Wilson | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | A | |
| Mike Wind | Newark | 2009 | D | |
| John Windover | Canandaigua | 2024 | M | |
| Adam Windus | Newark | 2016 | M | |
| Nick Wing | Gananda | 2021 | D | |
| Adam Wingate | Livonia | 2009 | M | |
| Andy Winslow | Schroeder | 2007 | M | Mercyhurst |
| Tim Winslow | Schroeder | 2007 | D | Mercyhurst |
| Connor Winters | McQuaid Jesuit | 2021 | G | SUNY Binghamton |
| Nathan Wirth | Eastridge | 2008 | D | |
| Ryan Wirth | Eastridge | 2006 | D/M | |
| Jordan Wirthman | Pal-Mac | 2007 | A | |
| Erich Wischmeyer | Hilton | 2012 | G | |
| Erich Wischmeyer | Aquinas | 2012 | G | |
| Jareth Wischmeyer | Hilton | 2010 | G | |
| John Wise | Gates Chili | 2012 | M/A | |
| Mitchell Wise | Hilton | 2024 | A | |
| Steven Wise | Gananda | 2027 | M | |
| Zach Wise | Bishop Kearney | 2023 | D | |
| Patrick Wiseman | Schroeder | 2008 | D | |
| Erik Wisnoski | Gananda | 2024 | D | |
| Michael Witkop | Batavia | 2010 | M | |
| Noah Witmer | Schroeder | 2024 | A | |
| Adam Witscheber | Penfield | 2017 | LSM | |
| Cameron Witthun | Brockport | 2012 | M | |
| Andrew Witzel | Livonia | 2013 | M/A | |
| Zane Witzel | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2005 | A | |
| Sam Wizeman | Pal-Mac | 2021 | M | |
| Christian Woelkers | Newark | 2010 | M | |
| Cody Wohlschlegel | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2019 | D | |
| Paul Wojcik | Spencerport | 2010 | D | |
| Nick Wolak | McQuaid Jesuit | 2010 | M | |
| Nick Wolak | Brighton | 2010 | M | MCC |
| Erich Wolf | Gananda | 2016 | D | |
| Matt Wolf | Waterloo | 2007 | D | |
| Mitchell Wolfanger | Avon | 2015 | A/M | |
| Dan Wolfe | Penn Yan | 2007 | M | MCC |
| Matt Wolfe | Irondequoit | 2011 | M | |
| Tyler Wolfe | Marcus Whitman | 2015 | A | |
| Chris Wolfer | Haverling | 2009 | G | |
| Derek Wolfer | Haverling | 2006 | D | |
| Nick Wolfer | Avon | 2016 | A | |
| Tim Wolfer | Haverling | 2010 | D | |
| Dorian Wolff | Fairport | 2008 | D | |
| Shaun Wolford | Thomas | 2025 | D | |
| Thomas Wolford | Thomas | 2022 | D | Seton Hill |
| Jason Wolk | Greece | 2005 | M | |
| Joseph Wollaston | Eastridge | 2014 | D | |
| Jeremey Wolocki | Eastridge | 2009 | M | |
| Andy Wong | Brighton | 2014 | G | |
| Alex Wood | Hilton | 2007 | A | |
| Alex Wood | Brighton | 2007 | A | |
| Alex Wood | Eastridge | 2021 | D | |
| Alex Wood | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | D | |
| Brandon Wood | Greece Arc_Oly | 2009 | M | |
| Brett Wood | Mynderse | 2011 | A | |
| Caleb Wood | Aquinas | 2026 | D | |
| Collin Wood | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | D | |
| Josh Wood | Brockport | 2022 | D | |
| Nic Wood | Canandaigua | 2011 | A | Alfred |
| Willy Wood | Geneva | 2013 | D | |
| Zac Wood | Livonia-Avon | 2025 | D | |
| Chris Woodard | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Derian Woodard | Midlakes | 2015 | M | |
| Jason Woodard | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | D | |
| Jeff Woodard | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2013 | M | |
| Ryan Woodard | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Ryan Woodard | McQuaid Jesuit | 2024 | A | |
| Chris Woods | Aquinas | 2019 | M | |
| Wyatt Woods | Fairport | 2019 | M | |
| Eagan Woodward | Churchville-Chili | 2023 | A | |
| Jay Woodworth | Canandaigua | 2005 | D | |
| Jory Woodworth | Penfield | 2020 | G | |
| Keiondre Woody | Geneva | 2010 | D | |
| CJ Wool | Brighton | 2011 | A | |
| Matthew Woons | Gates Chili | 2015 | D | |
| Dan Worboys | Hilton | 2007 | M | |
| Mike Worboys | Brockport | 2011 | M | |
| Quinnten Workman | Greece Storm | 2024 | M | |
| Tyler Worthington | Aquinas | 2010 | M | |
| Matt Wowkowych | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | M | |
| Alex Wren | Midlakes | 2019 | A | |
| Andrew Wright | Gates Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Austin Wright | Schroeder | 2025 | D | |
| Chris Wright | Waterloo | 2015 | M | |
| Colby Wright | Livonia | 2013 | M | |
| Daniel Wright | Geneva | 2023 | M | Brockport |
| Eric Wright | McQuaid Jesuit | 2009 | M | |
| Ethan Wright | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | G | |
| Greg Wright | Irondequoit | 2008 | A | Cortland |
| Hunter Wright | Haverling | 2022 | D | |
| Jack Wright | Wayne | 2021 | D | |
| Jacob Wright | Midlakes | 2019 | D | |
| Jared Wright | Brighton | 2017 | M | |
| Kevin Wright | Waterloo | 2008 | D | McDaniel |
| Levi Wright | East United-Eastridge | 2021 | M | |
| Maclain Wright | Haverling | 2025 | M | |
| Mason Wright | Rush-Henrietta | 2024 | A | |
| Mike Wright | Waterloo | 2014 | A/M | |
| Quaron Wright | East United | 2022 | LSM | |
| Quaron Wright | East United-Eastridge | 2022 | D/LSM | |
| Robert Wright | Brockport | 2014 | M | |
| Shawn Wright | Livonia | 2005 | M | |
| Spencer Wright | Fairport | 2010 | D | |
| Tim Wright | Waterloo | 2013 | A/M | Geneseo |
| Adam Wuest | Hilton | 2018 | D | |
| Dave Wychorski | Spencerport | 2008 | D | |
| Trent Wyland | Wayne | 2014 | M | |
| Waquill Wynn | Gates Chili | 2024 | D | |
| Jacob Wynne | Gananda | 2025 | M | |
| Clay Wyzykowski | Greece Ath_Ody | 2011 | A | |
| Phong Xamountry | Rush-Henrietta | 2014 | M | |
| Ben Yacavonis | Victor | 2019 | D | |
| Mike Yacuzzo | East Rochester | 2010 | D | |
| Jon Yaeger | Brockport | 2017 | M | |
| Michael Yaeger | Spencerport | 2015 | D | |
| Zack Yaeger | Spencerport | 2009 | D | |
| Connor Yager | Greece Ath_Ody | 2017 | M | |
| Zach Yager | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2008 | M | |
| Jacob Yakowitz | Gates Chili | 2022 | D | |
| Abeil Yamane | McQuaid Jesuit | 2020 | D | |
| Kody Yancey | Thomas | 2023 | A | |
| Donald Yandow | Greece Ath_Ody | 2018 | G | |
| Donald Yandow | Greece Storm | 2018 | G | |
| Jake Yankloski | Wayne | 2013 | A | |
| Dave Yargeau | Greece Ath_Ody | 2008 | A | |
| Jaron Yarrison | Haverling | 2026 | LSM | |
| Brady Yartym | Haverling | 2022 | LSM | |
| Ali Yaseen | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | M | |
| Ali Yaseen | East United-Eastridge | 2024 | D | |
| Jake Yates | Mynderse | 2012 | M | |
| Logan Yates | Greece Storm | 2021 | M | |
| Dylan Yatteau | Newark | 2015 | M/A | |
| Bryan Yehl | Canandaigua | 2012 | M | |
| Jordan Yehl | Churchville-Chili | 2013 | M | |
| Justin Yehl | Haverling | 2023 | D/LSM | |
| Mike Yehl | Churchville-Chili | 2014 | G | Geneseo |
| Nate Yehl | Haverling | 2020 | M | |
| Zach Yehl | Churchville-Chili | 2010 | M | Geneseo |
| Jacob Yerden | Pal-Mac | 2020 | M | |
| Nick Yerden | Pal-Mac | 2015 | M | |
| Tim Yetter | Penn Yan | 2010 | M | MCC |
| Ben Yonko | Thomas | 2016 | G | |
| Matt Yonko | Thomas | 2018 | G | Clarkson |
| Dylan Yonts | Penn Yan | 2012 | M | St Leo |
| David York | Irondequoit | 2010 | D | |
| David York | Canandaigua | 2016 | D | Geneseo |
| Gavin York | Newark | 2018 | A | |
| Jude York | Canandaigua | 2024 | D | |
| Will York | Canandaigua | 2018 | A | Keuka |
| Abdul Yoruk | Brighton | 2018 | M | MCC |
| Cam Yost | Victor | 2019 | D | Oswego |
| Roger Youmans | Spencerport | 2007 | M | |
| Aaron Young | Eastridge | 2013 | M | |
| Brandon Young | Pal-Mac | 2015 | D | |
| Connor Young | Victor | 2013 | D | |
| Delivan Young | Rush-Henrietta | 2017 | M | |
| Dylan Young | Greece Storm | 2021 | M | MCC |
| Ethan Young | Livonia | 2009 | D | |
| Grant Young | Midlakes | 2015 | D | |
| Jesse Young | Penn Yan | 2023 | M | |
| Jon Young | Mynderse | 2006 | A | |
| Justin Young | Victor | 2015 | G | |
| Miles Young | Eastridge | 2012 | D | |
| Nicholas Young | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | LSM | |
| Nick Young | Mynderse | 2025 | D | |
| Noah Young | Eastridge | 2020 | G | |
| Noah Young | Thomas | 2020 | G | |
| Rashaud Young | Eastridge | 2016 | M | |
| Roy Young | Victor | 2013 | A | |
| Tim Young | Waterloo | 2012 | M | |
| Travis Young | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2012 | M/D | MCC |
| Wally Young | Penn Yan | 2021 | M | |
| Cole Younger | Avon | 2016 | M | |
| Kyle Youngman | Hilton | 2011 | M | MCC |
| Matt Youngs | Geneva | 2013 | M | FLCC |
| Corey Yunker | Churchville-Chili | 2018 | A | SUNY Albany |
| Ryan Yunker | Churchville-Chili | 2011 | A | |
| Farouk Yunus | Gates Chili | 2024 | M/D | |
| Jon Zacharias | Canandaigua | 2007 | D | |
| Johnthan Zajac | Hilton | 2020 | DM | |
| Richie Zajac | Haverling | 2005 | A | |
| Owen Zajic | Fairport | 2025 | D | |
| Zac Zamiara | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | M | |
| Zack Zanghi | Canandaigua | 2007 | D | |
| Jon Zanino | Gananda | 2016 | D | |
| Devon Zaov | Greece Arc_Oly | 2015 | A | |
| Hayden Zapata | Hilton | 2011 | A | |
| Marcus Zappia | Greece Arc_Oly | 2017 | M | |
| Evan Zaryski | Hilton | 2021 | M | |
| Matt Zarzycki | Rush-Henrietta | 2018 | M | |
| Colin Zavacki | Gates Chili | 2018 | M | |
| Andy Zaverella | Mynderse | 2005 | A | |
| Bryan Zavitz | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2006 | D | |
| Brad Zawacki | Thomas | 2010 | D | |
| John Zawacki | Thomas | 2012 | A | |
| Gabe Zawolo | McQuaid Jesuit | 2023 | M | |
| Josh Zeh | Brighton | 2015 | M | |
| Zach Zeh | Brighton | 2012 | M | |
| Alex Zeilke | Thomas | 2015 | D | |
| Meris Zelenjakovic | Bishop Kearney | 2014 | D | |
| Grayson Zenelovic | Wayne | 2019 | D | |
| Ryland Zenelovic | Wayne | 2021 | D | |
| Dominic Zerrillo | Churchville-Chili | 2025 | D | |
| Albert Zhao | Newark | 2009 | M | |
| Leo Ziang | Batavia-Attica-Notre Dame | 2019 | M | |
| Leo Ziang | Batavia | 2020 | M | |
| Andrew Ziccarelli | Rush-Henrietta | 2007 | A | |
| Jake Ziegler | Thomas | 2008 | D | Jacksonville |
| Steven Zielke | Thomas | 2022 | M/FO | |
| Chris Ziemba | Batavia | 2009 | M | |
| Brett Zilliox | Schroeder | 2014 | D | |
| Brandon Zimmer | Irondequoit | 2021 | M | |
| Mike Zimmer | Greece Ath_Ody | 2012 | G | |
| Andrew Zimmerman | Pittsford | 2022 | G | |
| Denis Zimmerman | Fairport | 2006 | D | |
| Jacob Zimmerman | Spencerport | 2021 | M | Roberts Wesleyan |
| Nathan Zimmerman | Marcus Whitman | 2026 | G | |
| Patrick Zimmerman | Fairport | 2007 | D | |
| Ryan Zimmerman | Irondequoit | 2015 | M | |
| Will Zimmerman | Churchville-Chili | 2019 | A | |
| Steve Zink | Brockport | 2013 | D | |
| Nick Zinni | Batavia | 2008 | M | |
| Steve Ziogas | Greece Ath_Ody | 2015 | G | |
| Dylan Zobkiw | Penfield | 2004 | D | Oswego |
| Zack Zollo | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2024 | M | |
| Anthony Zona | Thomas | 2014 | D | |
| Mike Zona | East United | 2018 | LSM | |
| Sebastian Zona | Brockport | 2009 | D | |
| Justin Zonneville | Thomas | 2011 | M | |
| Alex Zuber | Honeoye Falls-Lima | 2022 | D | |
| Drew Zubrzycki | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2010 | M | |
| Ethan Zuck | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2023 | D | |
| Liam Zugner | Victor | 2025 | D | |
| Ayden Zugnoni | Gates Chili | 2023 | M/FO | |
| Blake Zugnoni | Gates Chili | 2021 | M | |
| Parker Zugnoni | Rush-Henrietta | 2027 | M | |
| Ricky Zugnoni | Rush-Henrietta | 2015 | M | |
| Kacin Zuhlke | McQuaid Jesuit | 2014 | M | |
| Alan Zulick | Canandaigua | 2006 | D | |
| Cooper Zurich | Pal-Mac | 2015 | M | |
| Max Zwas | Brighton | 2026 | LSM | |
| Tyler Zweifel | Penfield | 2009 | A | MCC |
| Zach Zweig | Bloomfield-Honeoye | 2016 | D | |
| Curtis Zwickl | Penfield | 2012 | M | |
An asterisk (*) indicates there is no link to the college roster. For players who were recently graduated,
it may mean that they are planning to play at the school but have not yet made the team roster. Also note, that in some cases, a recent graduate who made plans to attend
a specific school changes his mind and does not go to the school. Information on requesting updates or changes is available from a link on the player's individual page.
The Information presented on
this page comes from a variety of sources including game reports, League Chairmen, Coaches and local media. To request a change or to update information, use the
'Submission Form' which is available on each player page.
-
-
Aquinas at Brighton
