Webster Thomas scored the first three goals of the contest and never trailed in their 12-8 victory over Penfield. The Titans were in complete control of the game and led by six at the beginning of the fourth quarter. Thomas also spread out their scoring with five different players scoring two goals each and seven total players making the scorebook. Conversely, Penfield had five of their goals come from junior attackman Max Spaan. Spaan was responsible for 12 of Penfield's 30 total shots with only six total players taking shots in the entire game. Thomas had five players with over four shots with junior midfielder Kevin Hill leading with eight shots.

Junior midfielder Pat LeMoine scored the first goal in the first 40 seconds on an unassisted drive at the cage. A big part of Thomas' success came from face-off midfielder Cam Isaac who finished 12/17 (71%) for the Titans. Isaac scored his first goal with 6:51 remaining with an assist from Travis Ford. Spaan scored his first goal (unassisted) two minutes later. The final two minutes of the quarter had two goals. Thomas scored with 1:56 remaining with Isaac assisting Christian Nairy. Penfield scored the next goal to keep the game within a single goal at the end of the quarter. The final goal of the quarter was the first of five man-up goals during the contest.

The second quarter had Thomas scoring the first two goals to increase their lead and then held it. The first half finished with the score at 7-5. After an injury delay when a Penfield player was hurt in the third quarter, Thomas increased their scoring and won the quarter 4-1. By the end of the third quarter Thomas led 10-5. Entering the fourth quarter Isaac scored his second goal on a face off fast break goal only 0:07 into the quarter to give Thomas their largest lead of the game. Penfield added the final two goals of the game with Jake Sproule assisting Brian Wall and Mitch Standera assisting Ryan Fulton.

Defenseman Jacob O'Connor led the Patriots with three ground balls. In the cage, Liam Guiton finished with seven recorded saves for Penfield. Thomas' goalie Davis Bird finished with five recorded saves.