| In College | All Americans | All League | All Current Players | Recruits | Commitments |
All League First Teams for 2021
Links to full lists are available on the 2021 Wrap Up Page.
2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
| Player | Team | Award | |
| DiDomineck, Ian | Hav | Attack (INDY) | |
| Ettinghausen, Maxfield | McQ | Attack (INDY) | |
| McEnerney, Jackson | Liv-Av | Attack (INDY) | |
| O`Neil, Jamie | Hav | Attack (INDY) | |
| Sciortino, Joey | Aq | Attack (INDY) | |
| Skelly, Justin | Liv-Av | Attack (INDY) | |
| Conrad, Curtis | Hav | Defense (INDY) | |
| Miller, A.J. | Liv-Av | Defense (INDY) | |
| Smith, Hunter | McQ | Defense (INDY) | |
| Yartym, Brady | Hav | Defense (INDY) | |
| Conlan, Gavin | Aq | Goalie (INDY) | |
| Winters, Connor | McQ | Goalie (INDY) | |
| Pecora, Luke | McQ | LSM (INDY) | |
| Connor, Matthew | Liv-Av | Midfield (INDY) | |
| Dickson, Brady | Hav | Midfield (INDY) | |
| Hazard, Mike | McQ | Midfield (INDY) | |
| Woodard, Chris | McQ | Midfield (INDY) | |
| Cupp, Hunter | Hav | Midfield/FO (INDY) | |
| Miller, Jack | McQ | Midfield/FO (INDY) | |
| Cross, Harrison | Pit | Attack (MC-d1) | |
| Stuver, Kole | Fpt | Attack (MC-d1) | |
| DeBiase, Charlie | Pit | Defense (MC-d1) | |
| Fundis, Connor | Fpt | Defense (MC-d1) | |
| Knapp, Josh | Fpt | Defense (MC-d1) | |
| Mitchko, Michael | Vic | Defense (MC-d1) | |
| Robbins, Charlie | Vic | Defense (MC-d1) | |
| Wallace, Jack | Pit | Defense (MC-d1) | |
| Ralston, McLean | Fpt | Goalie (MC-d1) | |
| Parton, Alex | Vic | LSM (MC-d1) | |
| Crowley, Rob | Fpt | Midfield (MC-d1) | |
| Lambert, Cal | Vic | Midfield (MC-d1) | |
| Mojsej, Matthew | Hilt | Midfield (MC-d1) | |
| Petschke, Chase | R-H | Midfield (MC-d1) | |
| Callahan, Logan | Vic | Midfield/FO (MC-d1) | |
| Bennett, Sam | CA | Attack (MC-d2) | |
| Cummings, Sam | Pen | Attack (MC-d2) | |
| Russo, Joe | RLT | Attack (MC-d2) | |
| Saulpaugh, Jackson | Pen | Attack (MC-d2) | |
| Adams, Eli | RLT | Defense (MC-d2) | |
| Comella, Brady | CA | Defense (MC-d2) | |
| Platten, Eric | CA | Defense (MC-d2) | |
| Ruller, Ethan | RLT | Goalie (MC-d2) | |
| Nieman, Jackson | CA | LSM (MC-d2) | |
| Grant, Jaxon | CA | Midfield (MC-d2) | |
| Hauman, Nick | Schr | Midfield (MC-d2) | |
| Hoban, Nathan | RLT | Midfield (MC-d2) | |
| Tourangeau, Sam | Bri | Midfield (MC-d2) | |
| Richiusa, John | Pen | Midfield/FO (MC-d2) | |
| Morgan, Elliott | CA | SSDM (MC-d2) | |
| Blythe, Matt | HFL | Attack (MC-d3) | |
| Gibson, Noah | Irond | Attack (MC-d3) | |
| Gostling, Tyler | Spen | Attack (MC-d3) | |
| Hyde, James | Irond | Defense (MC-d3) | |
| Inclima, Anthony | Spen | Defense (MC-d3) | |
| Birkbeck, Adam | Spen | Goalie (MC-d3) | |
| Kane, Ian | HFL | LSM (MC-d3) | |
| MacDonald, Trevor | Spen | LSM (MC-d3) | |
| Wright, Quaron | EU-Eastr | LSM (MC-d3) | |
| Beardsley, Cole | Brkpt | Midfield (MC-d3) | |
| Green, Colt | HFL | Midfield (MC-d3) | |
| Stefano, Yavin | Irond | Midfield (MC-d3) | |
| Zimmerman, Jacob | Spen | Midfield (MC-d3) | |
| Mesh, Connor | Spen | Midfield/FO (MC-d3) | |
| Zimmer, Brandon | Irond | SSDM (MC-d3) | |
| Brown, Ryan | Gen | Attack (FL) | |
| Gerhardt, Devon | PY | Attack (FL) | |
| Herod, Ryan | Whit | Attack (FL) | |
| Nolan, Quinn | P-M | FO (FL) | |
| Poretta, Gino | Myn | Goalie (FL) | |
| Eighmey, Aiden | Gen | Midfield (FL) | |
| Hamel, Andy | Wayn | Midfield (FL) | |
| Royston, Aidan | Whit | Midfield (FL) | |
| Kinslow, Robert | P-M | Defense (FL) | |
| Kuver, Mason | PY | Defense (FL) | |
| Lovejoy, Zack | Whit | Defense (FL) | |
| Lahue, Jordan | Whit | LSM (FL) | |
 The Information presented on this page comes from a variety of sources including game reports, League Chairmen, Coaches and local media. To request a change or to update information, use the "Submission Form" which is available on each player page. |
|||
