Baldwinsville Wins in Overtime Thriller

May 17, 2025 - Canandaigua and Baldwinsville battled through a closely contested non-league matchup, with the Bees securing a 9-8 victory in overtime. Canandaigua led 8-5 after three quarters, powered by Mike Belles (two goals), Ryan Bremer (two goals, one assist), and Will Rheude (two goals). Baldwinsville responded late, with senior midfielder Brady Garcia scoring the tying goal with five seconds left in regulation. Senior midfielder Ignazio LoMedico sealed the win with an outside bounce shot, finding the net with 3:00 left in the first overtime period.

Brady Garcia led Baldwinsville with three goals, while LoMedico and Matthew Niedzialek each contributed two. Dylan Garcia added one goal and two assists, with Oliver Lyman chipping in a goal and an assist. Goaltender John Martoccia made 12 saves while allowing eight goals, helping Baldwinsville remain undefeated against Canandaigua since 2005.

The loss marked the end of Canandaigua’s unbeaten season, dropping their record to 14-1. The Grey Wolves will look to rebound when they face Pittsford on Wednesday for their last game of the regular season.    [ Story and BOX SCORE]