|
|||||||
| Date | Home | H Score | Away | A Score | Winner | ||
| 04/04/2024 | West Islip | 10 | Penfield | 9 | West Islip | ||
| 04/07/2018 | West Islip | 7 | Penfield | 9 | Penfield | ||
| 04/19/2017 | West Islip | 8 | Penfield | 7 | West Islip | ||
| 03/30/2015 | West Islip | 15 | Penfield | 5 | West Islip | ||
| 04/14/2014 | West Islip | 8 | Penfield | 5 | West Islip | ||
| 4 wins for West Islip vs 1 win for Penfield | |||||||